Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Don't know what to do? Advice on skipping your child a grade!

who's talking here?

Melissa 1
Miss T 1
whatchamacallit 1
stampin' gal 5
ProudNana 1
Momof3 2
Bows and More Galore 1
My 3 and Me 2
BaylorMom 1
Rachel 1
HsMommy 9
Sue 1
chunksNbones 5
rEVOLution 1
momof5 2
4boys 1
slinky 1
Paige Paige 1
ladybughomeschool 3
clockwatcher. 2
lucky2337 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

DD is in a pre-k program now, she rides the bus to my cousin and aunts school and comes home with them. The principle has noticed/gotten word about how bright my DD is and asked my aunt if she was going to be put in kindergarten or first grade. I don't know what to do, really I don't! 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

I know there are pro's and con's to skipping a grade and my DD is ready for first, but I don't want her to miss out on the fun stuff in kindergarten either. On the otherhand, I don't want her to be bored, she already is bored in pre-k! 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

I don't think it's that easy to advance a grade--especially just by casual conversation...there are formal assessments and evaluations before any suggestion of grade advancement. 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

I don't think it's that easy to advance a grade--especially just by casual conversation...there are formal assessments and evaluations before any suggestion of grade advancement I was asked to skip a grade in junior high and there was a test for that. I've never heard of skipping kinder though. 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

I don't think it's that easy to advance a grade--especially just by casual conversation...there are formal assessments and evaluations before any suggestion of grade advancement. I know its not that easy, the principle also mentioned that in the conversation, that if we decide to do it she will need to be tested....etc. I just don't know if I should. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

My Mom skipped a grade in school and hated it. She was in highschool so she always felt funny about not being with her class, but I really don't see a reason not to do it at this young age, other than her being so much younger than the other kids. Is she at the older end of the spectrum for pre-K? Do you think she is more mature than her current classmates? Are there any classes she might be able to take, either at school or otherwise, to help prevent her being bored, now and next year, if you don't skip her? Music or some other interest? Sorry, you got more questions than answers from me! 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

I will be able to put her in more extra afterschool activities next year, due to me being done with school and actually having more time with her. She is very mature for her age, will be five in April. She is already complaining about being bored at school and she is only 4. 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

You don't want your child bored...it will be a year wasted...if your child is capable, mature, does well on the assessments..I'd say, go for it... 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

IMO-I wouldn't skip her ahead until she is older if at all. 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

IMO-I wouldn't skip her ahead until she is older if at all. I'm not questioning your advice, just asking why you think that? That may sound rude the way I worded it, but please don't take it that way. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

Is she at the older end of the spectrum for pre-K? Do you think she is more mature than her current classmates? I was going to ask these same questions. It was offered to us to have our son skip mid year 2nd and go into 3rd, but we decided against it for two reasons. 1st, he wasn't mature enough and 2nd, it was mid year, and we worried about him going from the top of the class to possibly struggling since the other kids had already had 4 months of 3rd grade. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

My oldest ds had the opportunity to skip a grade. We decided to homeschool him instead. Now he is 13 and working a tenth grade curriculum. We were faced with him starting college at 16. My dh and I have decided after much prayer that our son has the right to be a teenager and he has the right to be with young people his own age. We see no benefit to having him do this. Their are so many more things in this world to do and learn. He was also very bored at school. he spent a good deal of time in the library alone. He was in GT but it was only 2 hours a week. There is no easy answer but I have always found it better to expand a childs knowledge base on rather than push them forward. Childhood is a gift that should be savored not moved through as fast as possible. 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

I'm not questioning your advice, just asking why you think that? That may sound rude the way I worded it, but please don't take it that way. I just think that's too young. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

I don't think it's that easy to advance a grade--especially just by casual conversation...there are formal assessments and evaluations before any suggestion of grade advancement. I had a friend that wanted her dd to skip kindergarten. her child had to take AND PASS the 3rd grade TAKS test to skip into 1st grade. she was extremely bright, but needless to say, did NOT pass. If she is 6 before sept 1st, she can go straight into 1st grade, because she will be old enough. otherwise, she will have to pass some form of testing to skip (i would guess). really.....there is no need to skip a grade IMO. i think a lot of kids are bored in pre-k, lol. I have a child that is extremely bright (as in reading the harry potter books at age 5) and mature as well. we wouldn't consider him skipping a grade. some years he is challeged, some years not so much.....depends on the teacher. we just add stuff at home to challenge him. 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

Childhood is a gift that should be savored not moved through as fast as possible. LBHS put it best IMO 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

Childhood is a gift that should be savored not moved through as fast as possible. This is very true and a great way to think about it. I am just looking at it this way, if she is put in first grade and she is on level there, why not just keep her at that level and let her grow from there? I just think that's too young. Fair enough, just curious as to why you thought what you did :) 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

i just saw that your dd will be 5 in april. even going into kindergarten, she will be on the VERY young end of the spectrum. many of the kids will be turning 6 in early fall. i can't imagine putting my child into a first grade class at barely 5 years old, when most of the kids are 7 (or almost 7). but, that is just my opinion! :) 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

BTW-I didn't skip a grade till high school, and I have to say....if I could go back and do it all over again, I'd stay with my class. There are just some experiences you can't get back. Even as young as 4 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

but, that is just my opinion! :) Thats why I posted this, I don't know what the best option is and why I posted this. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

i'm with you momof1. the fact is, even skipping a grade, my sons teachers have told me he wouldn't be challenged in a regular classroom. we just accept that we have to add things at home. there is so much more to school than being smart.......lots of important factors. academics is just a small piece of it. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

is she reading already? like really really reading? not just the cat in the hat, short vowels, etc. like can she pick up a book like frog and toad and make her way through 95% without help? 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

BTW-I didn't skip a grade till high school, and I have to say....if I could go back and do it all over again, I'd stay with my class there you go, from someone that's actually been through it. I agree, she's amongst the younger kids in her regular class, she'd be almost 2 years younger if you put her ahead a grade. 2 years is a HUGE difference when you're 5 and 7. you can buy all sorts of workbooks and computer software to challenge her at home. Trips to the library and "field" trips with the family...she'll be fine if she stays right where she is. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

why not just keep her at that level and let her grow from there? That is an option but kinder to first is a big jump as far as what is expected. My ds did pass the 3rd grade TAKS in 1st grade and we still did not want him to skip. If you can at all afford it why not a private school that lets them work at that own pace in a small classroom. as in reading the harry potter books at age 5 thats funny my ds read his first one in between K and 1st grade 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

as in reading the harry potter books at age 5 thats funny my ds read his first one in between K and 1st grade yep, people didn't believe me, but he could tell people all about them at age 5 and I personally have never even opened one, lol. 

Melissa --- 17 years ago -

IMO I would not skip a grade. I would think you would want her to experience being a kid, recess, parties. She will miss out on a lot of fun stuff, crafts, etc. Plus every grade has is a building block for the next grade. IMO kids start school WAY too early! :) 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

yep, people didn't believe me, but he could tell people all about them at age 5 and I personally have never even opened one, lol. I made mine do a Geometry test right smack in front of me Friday because I found it hard to beleive that he is making straight 100's on all his tests. He was not cheating he was making perfect scores. 

Sue --- 17 years ago -

I believe that, at that age, she belongs in Kindergarten, not first grade.She may be mature but is still young. What has her pre-K teacher said, if anything? 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

While it might be debatable on this site I turned out OK and my parents held me back in the third grade. 

lucky2337 --- 17 years ago -

Leave her in her grade. If she is gifted and talented, they have programs for that. 

Rachel --- 17 years ago -

My daughter is an August baby and the second youngest in her class. At 15 she still complains about being the youngest....we considered moving her up a grade and are very happy that we didn't. There is something about being with kids near your age that the KIDS like. Even one year will make the difference of liking Barbies to Hannah Montana if that makes any sense. 

BaylorMom --- 17 years ago -

I put my son in a K-4 program when he should of gone to kindergarten. He was a summer baby and after talking alot to teachers I felt like he would benefit the most. Especially boys since they seam to be more immature. It worked great, He would turn say 6 in July, then the rest of his class would turn 6 that year. So he never felt like he was much older than the rest. He got better grades and was more mature to handle things. Best decision we made. Now skipping a grade, that is a hard decision and only has a parent who knows her child can make. 

ProudNana --- 17 years ago -

Would you rather give her an extra year of childhood, or an extra year of being an adult? That was the advice given to my daughter in a similar situation that helped to resolve the issue. Thinking in that perspective made the decision easy! 

4boys --- 17 years ago -

I was told, "when in doubt, wait it out" and it was great advice for us. I have boys so I know that is different BUT to me social maturity is much more a consideration than intellectual ability in deciding to skip a grade. Are you sure she will still be socially mature enough in a few years? In high school? 

Bows and More Galore --- 17 years ago -

I was advanced past 2nd grade straight to third as a child. Emotionally I was not ready. It was the worst school year of my life. I say keep her with kids her age. She can do advanced placement things, such as spice. She can get straight A's and feel good about herself. For me, it was awful. My parents still regret that decision. 

Momof3 --- 17 years ago -

I think the maturity factor is a big issue. There are not just many Fall birthday kids in a grade, but quite a few parents hold their kids back a grade too. They delay putting them into Kindergarten if they aren't mature enough yet. I know quite a few kids whose parents did this. So if you advance a child who has an April birthday there will be kids in her school year not just potentially up to 19 months older than her, but even older than this. Just IMO I think that in Kindergarten/1st grade this is too much of an age gap. 

My 3 and Me --- 17 years ago -

My advice is to keep H in Kinder. Her reading skills are VERY advanced, she could travel to 1st (GT) for reading. I think Kindergarten is an experience all little ones should have. There is not use in making her grow up too fast. =) (Plus- I want her in MY room!!!) 

My 3 and Me --- 17 years ago -

I will talk to you more at lunch today. There are many cons to putting her straight to 1st. 

Paige Paige --- 17 years ago -

Wow! April is a VERY young 5 to be going into first. I bet she is a total smarty, but some of those firest graders will be turning 7 right after and months after school starts. I think it is a bad idea. Right now she may do fine, but think later down the road. In 7th grade when she is only 11 and the other kids are 13. 

Momof3 --- 17 years ago -

In 7th grade when she is only 11 and the other kids are 13. I totally agree with you. As the mom of an 11 yr old girl I wouldn't want her in class with 13 yr olds! 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

Thank you all again for the advice. As of right now I am leaning on keeping her with her grade level. I just don't want her to hate school because she is bored. I will feel better if she does indeed get placed in my cousins classroom, because my cousin knows where she is at....etc. Also she will be able start more afterschool activites next year, due to me being finished with college. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground