Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The real problem with government assistance

who's talking here?

smartypants 5
AuthorMan 5
NoNameNoLastName 1
crrc 1
BaylorMom 2
txdaddy 1
HsMommy 10
ghostpost 5
david 1
justforfun 24
~sassy~ 37
ExLady In Blue 3
momof5 4
Perfection 21
MxMike 1
MomTimesFive 1
OH SNAP! 20
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 2
Nightstorm 1
Allimama 31
itsmagic 4
Hiro Protagonist 6
PHSMOMOF2 1
clockwatcher. 1
hopscotch 2
Polly Ester 5
Shenanigans 3
zombie slayer 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

I've been thinking about this a lot, and I'd like several viewpoints to serve as a sounding board for my thoughts here. It seems that the real problem of government assistance is that makes all of us unaccountable for our fellow man. I realize that this seems counterintuitive, but stay with me. For a society to work, two of the most important virtues to hold are accountability and responsibility. Every person must be responsible and accountable for him/her self, and for each person within his/her sphere of influence. In a perfect world, this would mean that first, one must do everything he/she can to take care of him/herself and family, then at the point that he/she is not able, charity of others steps in. The problem with government assistance is that the charity is impersonal. No one is inserting his/herself into the lives of the other person. Money is given to take care of immediate needs, but the forces that created the lack of money are not addressed. When people give charitably, they give out of an understanding of "being my brother's keeper". They give out of love, out of friendship, and out of a desire to make society better for all. People are responsible for giving more than money, they must also give of their time, social resources, educational resources, etc. However, the government takes away the need to be accountable to each other. We never even see the money that gets taken away. It's not out of charity, but out of cooercion. We aren't personally invested in the lives that the money goes to, nor are we able to see the effects of the money on their lives. We have no opportunity to offer our education, time, morals and values, and social resources. It seems that it lets us off the hook--we don't need to do anything, welfare will take care of them--which further isolates those in poverty from those who know how to escape from poverty. It not only robs us of our paycheck, but it robs us of the opportunity to be personally invested in the people who need our help. What do you think about this?  

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

Would I have gotten more people to answer to me if I had said, "poor people suck and liberals are bad!"? 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, I guess I used the wrong word there. Substitute "obligation" for "opportunity" and read it again. How is personal, charitable giving considered anarchy? 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

You have a very interesting point. On the other hand, there is only so far peoples' hand can reach. Even if good people had every intention of making sure no child went hungry or without a clean pair of clothes, it would be impossible to get to them all. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

I dont have a problem with people being on assistance if they need it and do something productive with their lives while on it. I have a huge problem when they just sit and collect and take advantage of it. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

You have a very interesting point. On the other hand, there is only so far peoples' hand can reach. Even if good people had every intention of making sure no child went hungry or without a clean pair of clothes, it would be impossible to get to them all. Yes, but not if we truly helped people out of their poverty. That way, we would be creating more people with a desire to help those around them. If we helped build communities, rather than giving money here and there, then we would be teaching them to fish. Then, they could help those in their own community learn to fish. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

Wouldn't we, in effect, be creating wealth rather than redistributing it? 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

I dont have a problem with people being on assistance if they need it and do something productive with their lives while on it. I have a huge problem when they just sit and collect and take advantage of it. SE, thank you so much for this. I guess I am in the siutaion that fits both of these situation. I depend on medicade to keep my DD healthy while I am finishing school. She has a "father" that is supposed to be providing medical care but he doesn't. He would rather work jobs being paid under the table so he doesn't have to "help" with his children. So yes Allimana, there is a "real problem" with government assistance. 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

I fully believe that if the system was ran correctly, then we would have to pay as much to help it run. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

I think you should look at countries that don't have much, or any gov't assistance programs, and see how people end up living. In India they have many very wealthy people and it is a fast developing nation. It does not have much in the way of a welfare system and they have a huge section of their society that lives in squalor and overwhelming poverty. In a perfect world everyone would take care of themselves and those that can't. In the real world, that would not happen. You would have massive, crippling poverty, and the crime and filth that go with it. If you think the crime and gangs are bad now, what do you think would happen if there was no assistance programs? It would be the quickest way to make this country a second rate or quasi-3rd world place. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

I think you should look at countries that don't have much, or any gov't assistance programs, and see how people end up living. In India they have many very wealthy people and it is a fast developing nation. It does not have much in the way of a welfare system and they have a huge section of their society that lives in squalor and overwhelming poverty. In a perfect world everyone would take care of themselves and those that can't. In the real world, that would not happen. You would have massive, crippling poverty, and the crime and filth that go with it. If you think the crime and gangs are bad now, what do you think would happen if there was no assistance programs? It would be the quickest way to make this country a second rate or quasi-3rd world place. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

What do you think about this? The problem is assuming the 'entitlement' people have the same ethics as you do. If they did, the numbers that really needed help would be manageable. When I was young, extended family took care of the needs of the financially and health challenged members of the family. That is rare today. In my opinion, too many able bodied people do not make the effort required to succeed in this system. And now, it appears the system is ready to change to accommodate the slackers. This may sound harsh to some, but that is where I think this wonderful country is headed. I miss the 'old days and old ways'. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Yes, but not if we truly helped people out of their poverty. That way, we would be creating more people with a desire to help those around them. If we helped build communities, rather than giving money here and there, then we would be teaching them to fish. Then, they could help those in their own community learn to fish. In a perfect world, sure. But I'm going to have to agree with Marcellus. In countries that do not have any support for their poorest citizens, you see poverty on an unfathomable level and the gap between the rich and the poor is almost incomprehensible. People are greedy by nature. The more money people have, the more obsessed with it they tend to be. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

This I am in agreement with to the extent that humans in America are not living the way it was intended we live and that went to wayside with our killing off of the Native Americans. Their way of life was taking care of each others within their tribal community. Slim, this is a poor example of 'taking care of each other'. Wasn't it many indian tribes who left the old and infirmed at the top of a cliff, with one purpose? FictionWriter what year are you referencing We had one uncle spend the last year of his life in our house starting in 1953. We had another do the same in 1958. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

FictionWriter what year are you referencing I believe that slim was trying to say there is no such thing as the "good ol days," and I would have to agree. The "good ol days" were great as long as you were white and male, for everyone else they pretty much sucked. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

Really, I don't think that welfare does much more than put a bandaid on the problem. I know that to truly make a difference, we all need to reinvest in our communities. The problem that I run into is finding a way to do this safely, and finding a way to keep my child safe and happy while I give of my time and other resources other than money. In Humble, we need free tutoring offered to schools, we need free or reduced childcare offered to single mothers who need to work, we need job training and education for those who are short on skills for the workforce. I know my church used to offer free English lessons. Does anyone know of any churches that are fulfilling some of these needs? With enough local help, we wouldn't need the govt. to do this. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

The "good ol days" were great as long as you were white and male, for everyone else they pretty much sucked. Back then, we were too busy trying to make a living to be concerned with your 'white and male' thing. 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

In Humble, we need free tutoring offered to schools, we need free or reduced childcare offered to single mothers who need to work, we need job training and education for those who are short on skills for the workforce. This is all offered via the government, but once again we are at the place it is being abused and those that really need it can not get a spot because of those that are abusing it. I completely understand wehre you are coming from Allimama and i think it would be great, but IF the system was used correctly then it would help solve the problems. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Back then, we were too busy trying to make a living to be concerned with your 'white and male' thing. LOL. Um, what? 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, some of it is offered through the govt., but I think that is part of the problem. When it is someone's job to do these things, it is handled differently than if someone has a passion for people and offers it out of free will. I think that the people being helped recognize that as well. The whole problem is that the help is impersonal. The people need to be loved, not just provided for. Real life example, how many of you know a family who buys everything for their child, but doesn't spend time with them or really invest in the child? How does that child turn out? It's the same concept. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

completely understand wehre you are coming from Allimama and i think it would be great, but IF the system was used correctly then it would help solve the problems. An example: How many 'Rita' evacuees are still on the government rolls? How long has it been? 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Alli...great post! 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

An example: How many 'Rita' evacuees are still on the government rolls? How long has it been? DING DING DING DING BINGO! 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

AM...it's a generational thing. Many deny it even exists. Duh! 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

AM...it's a generational thing. Many deny it even exists. Duh! You have to wonder why. Does denying it make it go away or does it make it better? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

Back then, we were too busy trying to make a living to be concerned with your 'white and male' thing Becuase you are white and male that is all you had to worry about. I don't know about you but I wouldn't want to go back to the 50's and be black in the south would you? Hell, just being a woman in the work place wouldn't have been a picnic either. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Becuase you are white and male that is all you had to worry about. I don't know about you but I wouldn't want to go back to the 50's and be black in the south would you? Hell, just being a woman in the work place wouldn't have been a picnic either. I would like to go back to when we had peaceful times if that's possible. Now everyone is so consumed with telling others they aren't doing enough to take care of their brothers and sisters. Maybe it's time to stop giving people an excuse to stay down. Give them an incentive instead of an excuse. You'd be be surprised how differently things would be. be. Help but please stop with the excuses. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

I would like to go back to when we had peaceful times if that's possible. BAHAHAHAHAHA!!! when exactly WAS that? 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

Becuase you are white and male that is all you had to worry about. hmmmmm....so no white males worried about it? i think more to the point though is the spirit of the saying (to take something from another thread you posted)...saying one misses the 'good old days' should not automatically make another presume that they missed the bad things of the good old days. why can't we presume that AM meant he missed there being more responsibility, less divorce, more kids with both parents, simpler, not as fast paced....? i think it is unfair to presume when someone says they miss the good old days that they must be talking about civil liberties. there were a lot of good things about the good old days as well. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

I would like to go back to when we had peaceful times if that's possible. BAHAHAHAHAHA!!! when exactly WAS that? There you have me but I'm sure they did exist. Maybe before we had internet and everyone wanted to tell the others how awful they were for working and not giving more than they kept. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

I agree justforfun, which is why I think that charity HAS to be personal. Giving from anything other than love creates entitlement. The giving has to be from love, and it has to be with the intent of getting the person to stand on their own. Basically, the people in poverty need to be parented. We love them unconditionally, but the giving comes with expectations. Most importantly, we have to stand with them as they try to break free of the behavior patterns that have caused the economic gap in the first place. They need much much more than our money. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

The government has the power to tie education to welfare but they won't, and until they make it mandatory, generational welfare will exist, even thrive. For able bodied, mentally fit persons who lack their GED, I'd put money into providing free education, even beyond a GED, within reason, for those wishing for such a thing. If they refuse to better themselves by taking advantage of this, I'd kick their lazy azzez to the curb. The alternative should not be acceptable. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

think it is unfair to presume when someone says they miss the good old days that they must be talking about civil liberties. there were a lot of good things about the good old days as well. Here! here! 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Basically, the people in poverty need to be parented. We love them unconditionally, but the giving comes with expectations. Most importantly, we have to stand with them as they try to break free of the behavior patterns Must you always make such good sense? you're making some of us look foolish in comparrison :D 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

i think it is unfair to presume when someone says they miss the good old days that they must be talking about civil liberties. there were a lot of good things about the good old days as well This is certainly true, my point is people always look back at times passed through a cloud of sentementality, and fail to see that the old days had just as many or more problems than today. My main point is, today really isn't as bad as people think. 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

For able bodied, mentally fit persons who lack their GED, I'd put money into providing free education, even beyond a GED, within reason, for those wishing for such a thing. If they refuse to better themselves by taking advantage of this, I'd kick their lazy azzez to the curb. The alternative should not be acceptable. EXACTLY, This not being done as you stated is the reason why the whole government assitance thing is NOT working. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

In Humble, we need free tutoring offered to schools, we need free or reduced childcare offered to single mothers who need to work, we need job training and education for those who are short on skills for the workforce. I know my church used to offer free English lessons. Does anyone know of any churches that are fulfilling some of these needs? With enough local help, we wouldn't need the govt. to do this. See, I can completely understand what you are writing about. I think gov't programs are full of bureaucracy and are expensive and inefficient (having worked for many, I know what I'm talking about). I have often thought that two of our most vulnerable populations--children and the elderly could be assisted effectively if day care centers were housed in /or near retirement homes. What a wonderful thing it would be to see a toddler being told a story by a grandmother--both needs being met. Unfortunately, only charitable groups and the private sector views the needs of our citizens in creative ways. I understand what a huge undertaking it would be for the government to look at assistance through different eyes, but it frustrates me to see the vast sums of money thrown at inefficient, ineffective, and corrupt programs. 

HsMommy --- 17 years ago -

Yesterday, today, tomorrow---none is perfect. 

itsmagic --- 17 years ago -

Libertarian stance: "We should eliminate the entire social welfare system. This includes eliminating AFDC, food stamps, subsidized housing, and all the rest. Individuals who are unable to fully support themselves and their families through the job market must, once again, learn to rely on supportive family, church, community, or private charity to bridge the gap." 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

For able bodied, mentally fit persons who lack their GED, I'd put money into providing free education, even beyond a GED, within reason, for those wishing for such a thing. If they refuse to better themselves by taking advantage of this, I'd kick their lazy azzez to the curb. The alternative should not be acceptable. EXACTLY, This not being done as you stated is the reason why the whole government assitance thing is NOT working. What is so wrong with expecting people who receive assistance to help themselves while they receive it? Stop trying to be so excusing of bad behavior, hold people accountable for not making an effort. As long as we make excuses for them nothing will ever improve. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground