Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Censorship

who's talking here?

Carla 2
stampin' gal 1
~grandma again~ 5
smartypants 4
randyjet 6
planemom 3
NoNameNoLastName 1
ladybeachbum 1
Mabbers 1
Queen Aeval 1
Katie D. 1
ghostpost 5
justforfun 4
Scarlet 3
JUNIPER 1
Bruiser Billy 2
LiveOak 1
KwdFoodie 1
momof5 7
Perfection 10
MxMike 2
Nightstorm 8
*maryc 2
TakeTheGlovesOff 2
voice of reason 1
MAllyn 1
burbchick 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Are we being censored? The economic stimulus bill was kept from us after being promised that we could read it with ample time. Now even our local message board has gone censorship crazy. Civil questions, yes on tough topics have been flagged. People having disagreements have been iced. People who post thoughts out of the mainstream have had them removed and then iced. What are we teaching our childrene? That is is ok to bury your head in the sand and not have difficult conversations? Are we being honest and adult? Come on, this is a PUBLIC board, not a PRIVATE board. If it is pornographic, yes, by all means delete it, if it is child abuse, delete it. If it is conversations about difficult subjects, do not delete, embrace them and allow others the RIGHT and the opportunity to learn and grow from others. Shame on you for putting Slim Jim, sassygirl, PutOnYourBigGirlPanties and others in the icebox. Shame on you for turning Bruiser Billy's topics red. Shame on you for deleting comments because you disagree with them. Shame......... Life does not happen in a bubble. You need to grow up and realize that. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

A friend of mine would say our freedom of speech is decreasing. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Your friend might very well be right. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

I am in full agreement. It isn't enough the government is talking our freedoms slowly but now we aren't allowed thoughts and ideas of our own because someone somewhere might find it offensive. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Do you feel our right to protest is disappearing? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

hmm, great question planemom. I don't know if it is disappearing as much as we are not using it to its fullest potential. We have become afraid of being different or outside the norm. We are afraid of being judged. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

My friend honestly believes if she went to DC to protest against abortion she would be arrested. Not because she was causing problems but because of her anti-abortion stance. I disagree with her but feel sad that she feels this way. I still believe we have the right to protest and voice our opinions. However, getting a minority voice heard has always been difficult. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I still believe we have the right to protest and voice our opinions. However, getting a minority voice heard has always been difficult. Well said. Now what used to be the majority is the minority and the new majority is ready to rub some serious noses in it. 

Katie D. --- 17 years ago -

So...everyone wanted mods. Now that you have them, what do you think? There are pros and cons to both scenarios. If there was someone watching the mods to ensure they were being fair, it would make the situation better. I 100% agree that a mod should only be taking action in extreme cases. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Katie D. Should the mods have to have a vote (they could email) before they could take action so that at least a majority of them agree. Could that lessen the personality issues that occur? Are the moderators here simply a microcism of what is happening in the country today? 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Are the moderators here simply a microcism of what is happening in the country today? Yes. People will regret what's happening but it will take time. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

What are we teaching our childrene? That is is ok to bury your head in the sand and not have difficult conversations? My children don't learn about life from the happenings on KU. Do yours Chunky? I agree that the deleting and icing is ridiculous. I think personal, below the belt attacks that have nothing to do with the topic of conversation are unnecessary, people do it all the time, doesn't make it right, but it happens. KU is what it is, if you don't like it, there are MANY OTHER forums out there to choose from. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

momof5, this is about something far greater than KU. KU is but an example of the larger issue that is affecting everyone's lives. Seeing how people respond on KU is indicative of how society reacts to opportunities and issues. The ability to converse in a manner that is both civil and ethical is important and that is the value that should demonstrated in our lives. If we cannot do that here, what confidence does anyone have that it can be done anywhere? 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

I think some people set the bar really low here, as far as their conduct. Because it's a cyberspace forum and they are anonymous, standards of civility towards others are deemed unnecessary. There's little stock placed in netiquette. Some think vulgarity is amusing. Then you have trolls, bullies, and anyone with an axe to grind abusing the flagging feature. Once I started a discussion and said political bias is okay, just be civil when expressing yourself. THAT comment was "kindly deleted". I don't have a problem with anyone stating their view if it is done respectfully and factually. Whining, however, is immature and annoying, and I'm never sorry to see those posts (or posters) go. Flaming and flamers, same thing. Learning to use a message board/public forum properly makes the site more enjoyable for the most people. 

~grandma again~ --- 17 years ago -

chunky, i basically agree with you, however, if rules are being broken how do you call that censorship? my momma always taught me if you are going to play the game, you have to follow the rules. she also taught me if you can not say something nice, then don't say anything at all. i have no idea why slim was sent to the icebox. i can only think why sassy and POYBGP were iced was most likely because of name calling and personal attacks, which are against the rules. disagreeing is different from being ugly and calling others names. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

momof5, this is about something far greater than KU. Really? I don't experience censorship outside of KU, do you? I am able to have civil conversations with people I meet and it never resorts into someone calling me a "bony windbag" when they don't like what I have to say. If you're talking about Political Correctness in society, well, better to be politically correct than downright rude and insensitive. Different strokes for different folks. I've never felt I couldn't say what I wanted at any time. There's always more than one way to say something, and it's up to you how you want to be perceived. 

TakeTheGlovesOff --- 17 years ago -

Do the censoring Mods send PMs and or an emails to the 'Iced' persons stating what the offending issue was that caused them being sent to the 'Ice Box'? Maybe KU needs to institute better Mod policies for example: - Mod sends a notice to the offending poster by PM or email with a warning stating what the perceived offending issue was. Then if the offense is repeated, off to the 'Ice Box'. - For situations when it's the same Mod enforcing their censorship repeatedly where the perceived offense is clearly the Mod's personality at work, have Adam suspend the Mod's privileges for three days.. kinda like a Mod 'Ice Box'. - institute a Mod committee hearing process if there is a complaint related to Mod abuse. Surely Adam et al, want KU to be inviting and fair to sincere KU posters and be a place attractive to business advertisers to keep KU a viable business. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Really? I don't experience censorship outside of KU, do you? Yes. 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

"Maybe KU needs to institute better Mod policies for example" KU is full of adults. As long as they act like adults, they don't have to worry about being iced! 

Bruiser Billy --- 17 years ago -

This morning I posted about a matter that is impacting this country and changing the way many americans think about scripture and it goes red in about 5 mins. SOMEBODY explain to me why we can't discuss a topic such as homosexuality and how it is affecting this generation and many to come w/o a handful of wack jobs (and I don't know who they are so don't send me to the ice box for an all expense paid vacation for insulting) on here flagging it? Am I the only one that believes this is a problem? 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

Maybe KU needs to institute better Mod policies No "maybe". I think the board would be better if policies were improved, guidelines and offenses more clearly defined. Surely Adam et al, want KU to be inviting and fair to sincere KU posters and be a place attractive to business advertisers to keep KU a viable business I hope so, but I don't really know how much time Adam wants to spend insuring this. It will take some effort on his part. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

Really? I don't experience censorship outside of KU, do you? Yes. Wow. What are you saying that you feel is getting censored? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Really? I don't experience censorship outside of KU, do you? Yes. That fairly well adequately answers the question. 

TakeTheGlovesOff --- 17 years ago -

I hope so, but I don't really know how much time Adam wants to spend insuring this. It will take some effort on his part. If so, then perhaps Adam could find a and delegate to a '2nd in command' 'super Mod'. Anyone know about the Mod vetting process? 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

Really? I don't experience censorship outside of KU, do you? Yes. That fairly well adequately answers the question You're always digging for deeper, more meaningful answers from folks on KU. I'm surprised you don't have one. Bummer. Sorry you feel censored, I would hate feeling that way. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

You're always digging for deeper, more meaningful answers from folks on KU. I'm surprised you don't have one. Bummer. Sorry you feel censored, I would hate feeling that way. Thank you. I do have answers that pertain to me, however I am looking broader than that. I am capable of dealing with the issues that affect me and my family, I am concerned however on those issues that affect more than my little circle. Censorship of any kind is wrong. Bruiser Billy brought up a difficult subject today only to see it turned red. Now I am sure that Bruiser Billy and I would see their question from different perspectives however that discussion was removed to a "danger" topic because some people who did not choose to participate in the discussion wanted to keep others from that same opportunity. That is wrong. 

Queen Aeval --- 17 years ago -

That is wrong. It was wrong... and the discussion was civil too. 

burbchick --- 17 years ago -

No "maybe". I think the board would be better if policies were improved, guidelines and offenses more clearly defined. In defense of the mods, they do enforce the rules. I see individual referees make calls all game long without having to 'ref huddle' for each call. Not everyone on this forum is nice, and some get a 'penalty'. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

I see individual referees make calls all game long without having to 'ref huddle' for each call. ok, that is funny......can you imagine the mods having to do a 'mod huddle' every time something seemed questionable? lol. that just makes me giggle :) 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I agree that this icing and deleting needs to stop. It seems like it goes in waves. Once one side starts, the other retaliates. Let's try and be adults please. As for more censorship outside in the USA, I can tell you that it is MUCH better than when I came to Houston in the early 70s. THAT is when Houston was a police state. If you handed out anti-war leaflets you were arrested. If you had unpopular views, your house was shot up, your cars were vandalized, your bookstore or headquarters were bombed and shot up. The police were the ones who were actually promoting this. Many people were framed and sent to prison for as long as 30 years. That is only the local authorities. Then the Federal government pursued those it did not like, and Nixon had his dirty tricks teams up and about,not to mention all the illegal activities of the FBI. People were fired from their jobs, were afraid to speack out at all, so I can tell you I DO know what a police state is like since I LIVED it here in Houston. So I have to laugh at those poeple whow say that we have no freedom to protest or are afraid. It is FAR better now than it was. 

~grandma again~ --- 17 years ago -

i think lots of issues come from different individual standards. for example: some people think the "F Bomb" is perfectly acceptable in todays living, while some do not. also, some people have argumentative personalities and some do not. it all pretty much levels everything out until things get out of control. that is when a mod steps in...most of the time. however, remember we do not have mods on line 100% of the time. things do fall through the cracks, causing some to think they have been treated unfairly. 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

I lived in Houston in the 70's, randyjet.........what on earth are you talking about.......police state??? 

~grandma again~ --- 17 years ago -

As for more censorship outside in the USA, I can tell you that it is MUCH better than when I came to Houston in the early 70s. THAT is when Houston was a police state. If you handed out anti-war leaflets you were arrested. If you had unpopular views, your house was shot up, your cars were vandalized, your bookstore or headquarters were bombed and shot up. The police were the ones who were actually promoting this. Many people were framed and sent to prison for as long as 30 years. WOW! 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

Nothing is going to be perfect. Sometimes there is only one mod online--there isn't another mod for them to conference with even if such a rule was in place. Sometimes there are not any mods on KU..it is a volunteer assignment not a hired position. Yes, sometimes things get testy on here. It is the nature of forums. Usually, it is the same people going at each other and I think that is when the mods step in a little faster..they know by history where the thread is going to go and they put a stop to it. However, I notice they usually let the fur fly for a bit before they do anything, so I think everyone got to make their point..even when the point is only that they don't like each other. It isn't perfect and it isn't a democracy..it is a privately owned forum. Adam chooses to close KYS on Sundays. It is his belief system that business should not be conducted on Sundays. I may not agree with his belief system, but this is his business to conduct as he pleases. Is it censorship that I can't sell my floral bedspread on a Sunday? No, it is just the policy of a private business. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

You have a floral bedspread for sale? 

Nightstorm --- 17 years ago -

Adam chooses to close KYS on Sundays. It is his belief system that business should not be conducted on Sundays. It's not about his belief system. Did you see the article on him in one of the community newspapers? KYS takes constant monitoring for it to run smoothly. He just wants the day off. Since Party Boy!! and his 27 accounts have been obliterated by Adam (amazing that they were all one person!), things have been quieter with that vulgarity removed. Munky fuk, for example, was shown to send threatening PMs which needed to be reined in. I agree with Chunky's position here. While I think that those iced may not have been playing nice, I don't think anyone in the icebox deserved it. I think we should have the ability to turn topics red for the purpose of showing there is "danger if you enter", I don't think they should be invisible on the front page. I also don't think people's comments should ever be deleted. Leave the words out there for all to see....then everyone could form their own opinion if someone is a racist or not, for example. While some of the mods may be fair, the view from here has shown many to be not; to show favoritism and also to advance their own private agendas. That's BS in my opinion. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

I don't think they should be invisible on the front page. I also don't think people's comments should ever be deleted. Leave the words out there for all to see. Absolutely. Mark the threads and the comments in red to show what people think of them, but don't make them invisible. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

I think the board would be better if policies were improved, guidelines and offenses more clearly defined. In defense of the mods, they do enforce the rules. I see individual referees make calls all game long without having to 'ref huddle' for each call I don't think they should have to call for a "ref huddle" either. That's why having clearly defined rules is important. Example: Why do we have flagging at all? To keep the site clear of offensive material, pornography, vulgarity, hate language, and everything else unseemly. What exactly is "offensive"? Is starting a thread on homosexuality automatically offensive? Personally, I find name-calling offensive, but it's done all the time with no penalty. 

Scarlet --- 17 years ago -

I learn something new everyday. I did not know that red threads do not show up on the first page. I posted a question on one of the red threads about which tv program was being protested. I could not find my post anywhere. That explains it. I guess I will have to wait a while for my answer. 

Nightstorm --- 17 years ago -

Personally, I find name-calling offensive Me, too. Those that can't debate with facts and choose to use name-calling instead (MORON, IDIOT, etc.) need to grow up. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground