Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Who has a Tankless Water Heater installed in their home?

who's talking here?

Fallon 2
ambergris 2
Pixel Giggles 3
Aviator 9
ShookUpRamen 1
nodoubt 9
Nightstorm 2
zapper007 1
TakeTheGlovesOff 1
Ogre1 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Aviator --- 17 years ago -

Our hot water tank is dying a slow death and I’ll have to replace it soon, but I’m considering a tankless water heater over the traditional tank type. The cost to replace the existing tank with a similar tank is well over a $1000.00. Broken down; a 50 gallon tank cost approximately $550, plus $125 to carry it up to the attic and bring the old one down, followed by another $245 to install the new one and an additional $45 in permit fees (yep, the city wants a piece of the action). A tankless water heater, suitable for our needs, cost in the neighborhood of $650 but I have no idea of the cost to install it, not to mention any accessories I’d need to complete the installation. I stopped by Lowes, and they sell them, however; the salesman told me they don’t offer installation services for the tankless models. If you've got one and you don’t mind my asking, what did it cost to have it installed? Also, do you recommend it over the traditional type? 

ambergris --- 17 years ago -

I have family members with the tankless kind and they love love love it. They all tell me they will never go back to the traditional water heater. DH says that when our current one goes out we will replace it with a tankless. He works in the plumbing industry and he has heard nothing but good things about them. 

Nightstorm --- 17 years ago -

I need to replace my water heater soon, too, and have been wondering about these myself. I grew up without a water heater. They didn't call it "tankless" then and it probably isn't exactly like the one you're talking about. This was up in NY where we have oil burners to heat the houses. The water went through some kind of a coil that was heated by the oil burner. The negative was that the water had to be run slow to be kept real hot (maybe only when it was very cold out but who remembers?) I do remember running it very slow to fill up a bathtub to take a hot bath. I'm sure the new technology is state of the art and much improved. What does the water run through in these new models that heats it up and if a lot of water is being used at once (say a shower and washing machine), does it maintain the hot temp? 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

I have one - and love it - but do not buy those crappy ones at Lowes - I have one of those in the trash heap after about 4 months of hell(just long enough for the warranty to run out) - never got any money back from that thousand dollar mistake. Replaced it with a commercial grade Reni over 2 years ago and have never had a problem - endless hot water! Long showers! The biggest expense is rerouting the gas lines (mine is gas) and plumbing. If gas - there is also the vent work, and making sure you have enough gas pressure to feed the burner. But once they are installed, the gas models are less expensive to run and more reliable. Even the gas ones need to have electrical to run the blowers - but just a regular 15-20 amp plug. 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

With mine I have no problem running 2 showers and a washing machine at the same time. 

Pixel Giggles --- 17 years ago -

IF anyone would like a quote from my DH for a complete installation including unit, or installation alone, or for that matter anything plumbing...lol Please call his office Quality Plumbing @ 281-858-9898 ask for Michael and tell them that I sent you from KU. He has MANY rating both here on KU...search plumber or plumbing, and at: ratekingwood.com. Thank you, and my PERSONAL opinion IF I could have one I would :-) 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

I agree with Pixel - this is not a DYI weekend project - I learned that the hard way from my first install of the Lowes tankless.... There are gas and water lines to re-route as well as specific venting requirements (much different than the old water tanks. But IMO they are worth the extra effort. Once you have one you will wonder how you lived without one! 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

And you also don't have a pressure tank filled with 30 gallons of hot water sitting above your head.... thats worth something! 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

I think Ashley the Princess, on here, works for a company that installs them too. This is the one we will get next. Our house had a brand new one, and we have only been here 5 years. So not sure how long they last, but when it goes, I want the tankless too. 

Nightstorm --- 17 years ago -

So do you recommend we all get commerical grade ones? What will that cost with installation, re-routing, etc? I don't want to wait until my current one leaks all over. 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

Up to you. My experience - I bought a Bosch tankless (still laying in my garage, I can't bring myself to throw it away it was only used for a few months)with the intent of having it installed by my plumber while I was having renovations done to my house - a new room add on that was going to displace my hot water tank in my attic. The plumber advised against purchasing those types of systems at the time but I thought he was just trying to make some extra bucks selling his Reni's. During the Bosch purchase I discovered that you also had to buy some special custom stainless steel venting with special connections due to the heat of the vent pipes (extra $100 plus - which BTY Lowes does not sell). After installation the burners would not consistently light up, factory said not enough gas pressure, plumber fixed that, still didn't work, factory said needs new computer board, plumber installed that, worked for awhile then problems again. Factory said water line not feeding fast enough, fixed that, still had inconsistent problems, factory said gas pipes not big enough ... see a pattern? By the time I said enough is enough the warranty was out and the factory would not honor due to the different "supposed" issues. I tucked my tail between my legs and went back to the plumber to admit he was right and to help get me out of this mess (we were pretty close by this time and he was getting tired of spending weekends at my house). He gave me the commercial grade system for the his price which was about the same as the home version. It was installed with the same gas lines, etc. and has had no problems. The main difference with the commerical one is that it will heat the water to a higher temp at a bit higer volume, but the regular Reni puts out plenty - I keep mine at about 130 degrees. I don't know if Reni is the best, I just suggest that you do your research. If you are blessed with a good plumber that you trust and they have experience with this kind of stuff, listen to him/her. The initial install is going to be more expensive than replacing a tank, but the long term benefits are so much better - and at the time I got a tax break, don't know if that is still the case. 

Aviator --- 17 years ago -

It's the Bosch from Lowes that I was considering, but perhaps I should research the Reni. I don't mind a little extra expense upfront if it's going to save me money down the road. Thanks for all the excellent advice. Everyone's been a big help with making my decision. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Is it Reni or Rennai???? 

Aviator --- 17 years ago -

Is it Reni or Rennai???? You were close, I Googled it and the correct spelling is "Rinnai". 

ambergris --- 17 years ago -

I asked DH and he said to go with the Rinnai. 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

Sorry - it was late - mine is a Rinnai. They seem to be one of the better rated ones all of the folks in the plumbing industry that I have run into recommend them. 

Aviator --- 17 years ago -

Sorry - it was late - mine is a Rinnai. They seem to be one of the better rated ones all of the folks in the plumbing industry that I have run into recommend them. I sent you a PM. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

If I am not being too nosy can one of ya'll pm me what you paid for the Rinnai, and for installation. Thanks! Need to know if this is a possible option now, or do I need to save for a bit:) 

Aviator --- 17 years ago -

If I am not being too nosy can one of ya'll pm me what you paid for the Rinnai, and for installation. Hi Fallon, I sent you a PM. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Oh heck Av post for all to see. I'm thinking about do the same thing myself. 

Aviator --- 17 years ago -

Oh heck Av post for all to see. I'm thinking about do the same thing myself. Since I have Ogre1's permission, here is his PM to me describing his experience and costs: It would be hard to separate because of all the original work that was done for the Bosch system as well as the stuff that were done as part of the house renovation. One of my problems was that I didn't have enough room above my load bearing wall to put another water tank, so really tankless was the only way I could go - but it was a great decision. That being said, I would estimate that starting from scratch it would have probably cost around $2000. The units are a bit more expensive than the Bosch (around $1200 - $1400 or so with the vents), and the plumber did have to do a bunch of work with the gas and water lines. But I would not recommend the Bosch. Like I said on the board - it cost me over a thousand dollars for absolutely nothing - it is setting on the floor of my garage. The Rinnai is built so much better and has been trouble free. Good luck 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

Aviator - that was not Ogre1's PM to you - it was mine .. but that's OK... 

Aviator --- 17 years ago -

Aviator - that was not Ogre1's PM to you - it was mine .. but that's OK... I'm sorry, I hate it when that happens. Blame it on a Senior Moment. 

zapper007 --- 17 years ago -

Cost $400-$1800, save $70/year. Will not pay for themselves in 20 years, but do save energy. Sometimes may not ignite yielding, if you are in a hurry, making it a very cold shower... http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/appliances/heating-cooling-and-air/water-heaters/tankless-water-heaters/overview/tankless-water-heaters-ov.htm 

Aviator --- 17 years ago -

From Consumer Reports.Com: Thanks Zap, that's good information. Welcome home ... 

TakeTheGlovesOff --- 17 years ago -

Cost $400-$1800, save $70/year. Will not pay for themselves in 20 years, but do save energy. Sometimes may not ignite yielding, if you are in a hurry, making it a very cold shower... Yes, requires electrical power too to fire-up for the on-demand. Some installers offer a battery back-up option for these situations. What I've heard on various AM radio home improvement talk shows and read is that the typical gas lines in existing homes do not allow the required cubic-foot gas flow to meet the BTU of the tankless requirements. So the costs could easily be above $1800. Also, there are street water pressure and flow requirements. 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

Once again - my experience - I did have a problem with gas pressure when installing the Bosch but not an issue with Rinnai. The pressure can be checked by a plumber and can be adjusted somewhat by contacting your gas provider. A lot depends on the distance of the unit from your meter. Electrical - during the hurricane I ran a extension cord up to the unit and plugged it in - no problems. Have never had a problem with street water pressure or ignition. One thing that is often misunderstood is the way these systems advertise "hot water on demand". That DOES NOT mean hot water as soon as you turn on the faucet. There continues to be cold water in the house hot water pipes that needs to run through before you get hot water to the faucet, just like with a hot water tank. The only way that you can get instant hot water is by installing a closed loop hot water circulating system which can be done with tankless systems (but in my opinion an expensive and wasteful option). To be honest, I didn't put this in to save money, as stated above, it was really my only option due to space and weight requirements. 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

I should clarify that during the hurricane I plugged it into a generator... lol 

Aviator --- 17 years ago -

A lot depends on the distance of the unit from your meter. Makes sense. One of the fellows I work with told me this too, so he had his installed outside next to the meter. I'm putting the Rinnai at the top of my "want list". Thanks again, nodoubt (hey, I got it right this time). 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Blame it on a Senior Moment. Dude! Sorry about the confusion. But thanks! 

Pixel Giggles --- 17 years ago -

If you are blessed with a good plumber that you trust and they have experience with this kind of stuff, listen to him/her. The initial install is going to be more expensive than replacing a tank, but the long term benefits are so much better - and at the time I got a tax break, don't know if that is still the case. I second this comment!! ANY questions that you have.... feel free to call my DH's company (info on my comment above) and he will be happy to come out to your home for FREE, and give you ALL the information that you need, a quote on price for unit, installation, etc, and answer ANY and ALL questions that you have. In MY opinion this is the BEST way for you to get the correct information on YOUR home, because he is there to see your home, and answer everything from your personal situation. Everyone has a different situation and questions and this is a no risk way to answer them. Thank you all....and lots of good comments and experiences on this thread..great thread! :-) 

ShookUpRamen --- 17 years ago -

I have the largest Takagi you can get for homes. It is gas, with an electrical control panel. A plumber had to install the gas line, and an electrician installed a 120 outlet, which was a piece of cake. The total job was $2500, vs $1400 for the tank variety - so, I paid an extra ~$1000, but I no longer have the liability in my attic. I've been very pleased thus far. I repeat, this is not a DIY project. 

Pixel Giggles --- 17 years ago -

I am glad that you are happy with your purchase shookupramen....many that go with tankless are...like you said IF you have it done correctly :-) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
services


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground