Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: 20/20 Special About is College Worth It?

who's talking here?

Miss T 1
freshhell 1
cmi 1
planemom 2
needrnr 1
jjfingrainalready 3
cowboyswife 1
path 3
BaylorMom 1
Your Neighbor 1
donottreadonme 1
nodoubt 5
I Kissed Frogs 1
Rachel 1
ghostpost 2
NellieGurl 2
~sassy~ 3
Forecaster 1
Perfection 3
Nightstorm 2
Danielle 1
itsmagic 1
*maryc 1
Ogre1 1
♥kerry♥ 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: 20/20 Special About is College Worth It?

They are showing people that have approximately $100K in student loan debt and can only find jobs making $10-$11 and hour. That is scary! They are stating that for kids graduating today a Bachelor's Degree is about the equivalent to a High School Diploma for their parents. And that unless you are going to school to be a doctor, lawyer, or other specialized field that it may not be worth it to go to college. So I am just curious if you went to college and if you feel it helped you.

Yes I have a degree - The field I am in REQUIRES a degree Vote
 
 66.1% (37)
Yes, I have a degree – it was not required for the job I have but I feel I am paid better than my co-workers because I have a degree (work ethics being equal otherwise) Vote
 
 1.8% (1)
Yes, I have a degree – I do not feel it has really helped me at all. I have co-workers w/o a degree making the same or more than me Vote
 
 3.6% (2)
No, I do not have a degree – but make more than co-workers that do because my company pays for work ethic rather than a piece of paper Vote
 
 25.0% (14)
No, I do not have a degree – and have a dead end job because of the lack of one Vote
 
 1.8% (1)
Other, please explain Vote
 
 1.8% (1)
I Kissed Frogs --- 17 years ago -

They are showing people that have approximately $100K in student loan debt and can only find jobs making $10-$11 and hour. That is scary! They are stating that for kids graduating today a Bachelor's Degree is about the equivalent to a High School Diploma for their parents. And that unless you are going to school to be a doctor, lawyer, or other specialized field that it may not be worth it to go to college. So I am just curious if you went to college and if you feel it helped you.  

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

We could NEVER have achieved what we have without dh's Petroleum Engineering degree. His first degree (both from UT) is in Radio, Television and Film) and while interesting and fun, it paid nada. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

We paid off his student loans, what few we chose to take out, in 6 months. 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

A degree puts you at a higher pay and benefits scale in most jobs. I consider a Masters Degree essential to any professional. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

A degree puts you at a higher pay and benefits scale in most jobs. I consider a Masters Degree essential to any professional. Generally speaking U R probably correct, however, there R some who just jump to the head of the ranks on sheer smarts w/o the master's Degree. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

Some fields it is required, like teaching. For other fields it gets your foot in the door but after you have made a good name for yourself, the degree is not important. But in a tight job market, applicants with degrees will often be given priority over those without, even if it is not a necessity. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

They are showing people that have approximately $100K in student loan debt and can only find jobs making $10-$11 and hour Why did they spend so much on college to get a minimum wage job? Does that loan include only tuition or all their expenses for four years? If it's all of their expenses, why didn't they get a part time job so they didn't have such a huge debt when they graduated? Was that for a Bachelors degree or does it include a masters or phd? I guess after watching people work their butts off in college to graduate with little or no debt I have very little sympathy for those that do graduate with that kind of debt. I do not think you need a college degree to be successful, Bill Gates proved that. However, there are many fields where you won't get looked at unless you have a 4 year degree. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

only find jobs making $10-$11 and hour That's sheer laziness on their part. BEFORE I got my degree I was making more than that on a GED. I haven't held a regular job yet since I've graduated (I went straight to Law School) but I expect I'll be making a bit more than $10.00 an hour when I get done. And I don't even want to talk about my debt load.. it's depressing. Sadly, I have four friends who have graduated from Law School... one is doing exactly what she wanted and loving it. One is doing document review...ugh..total grunt work, pays cr@p. One is doing speeding tickets, hates her life (it doesn't help that she sucks as an attorney), and another has taken the bar four times so far.... Me? I've already got two cases under my belt and I expect I will have a good paying litigation job waiting for me when I graduate in 2011. This job thing is all about personality though. If I started looking on ...Tuesday I guess, I'd have an O.K. to Good job by the end of the month. I don't know anyone who is as proficient at finding work as I am. 

Nightstorm --- 17 years ago -

His first degree (both from UT) is in Radio, Television and Film) and while interesting and fun, it paid nada. I've a couple of friends with that degree that have done rather well. I guess it just depends on what you do with it. One manages a radio station in Houston and the other is a political reporter for a local TV news station. 

Nightstorm --- 17 years ago -

This job thing is all about personality though. I agree. Confidence and determination. 

itsmagic --- 17 years ago -

I am glad I went to college. In terms of the degree, I've done nothing with it, but I paid as I went so there was no debt. What I can say is that my college experience gave me a work ethic that I didn't have prior and my student organization experience propelled me into being a leader at most things I do. I am the organizer for my 15th reunion this year. That would have never happened prior to college because I was too shy and timid to stand up and lead. College was worth the money to me for the knowledge and skills I acquired during that time. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

College does not guarantee you a job. You have to show work ethic, determination and a willingness to learn. Those are the SKILLS any employer is looking for regardless of the job. Honestly, if they have that much in student loans, that shows me they don't have a work ethic nor can they budget time OR money nor do they demonstrate determination. If they have that much in student loans, they did not hold a job (any job) while in school, spent more than they could afford (on items other than books/tuition). Nor did they do internships or work in the field of their studies while in school. When people tell me they are going to school AND working full time - I have a ton of respect for them and I am more willing as a hiring authority to give them a second look. They are showing me drive, determination, budgeting skills and DESIRE. You come to me right after college with a blank resume........... you get blank. It's that simple. 

BaylorMom --- 17 years ago -

Well I hope my son who graduates this year from Baylor finds a decent paying job. Baylor is very expensive, he does have some debt, but most of it is paid off. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

College was worth the money to me for the knowledge and skills I acquired during that time. itsmagic, congrats on building those skills. That is what college is about. Learning to do all those intangibles that employers look for. No employer wants someone who can simply spit out the same outdated information. They need people who can think, plan, organize. Kudos! 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

My granddaughter will start college on the 20th. I truly hope it gives her a brighter future than she would have without it. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

My granddaughter will start college on the 20th. I truly hope it gives her a brighter future than she would have without it. maryc, it will - just encourage her to be active in various organizations, become involved, do internships - get the full experience. 

Your Neighbor --- 17 years ago -

I was a corporate recruiter for about 8 years and I will say that having a degree is generally a must to get your foot in the door in any type of corporate job besides clerical and customer service. In my experience, most of those college graduates with fresh business or acct or marketing degrees come out of college w/o any work experince and expect to be making 50k to start and have a mid-level position. The reality is that a college degree in those fields is just a foundation to build on. You need to work your way up to get those upper level, higher paying jobs. Those that understand that and apply themselves more than 100% are the ones that move up. The ones that come in with an attitude that the entry level job is beneath them and that they are biding their time are the ones that don't advance because managers won't promote them. Many times we couldn't even look at applicants who didn't have a college degree because that was "minimum job requirement". The equivalent of that in HR's eyes is 8 years experience in the field. So, yes, a college degree is "worth it". However, I would say that getting a degree that costs $100k in student loans is not worth it. Go to community college for 2 years, then transfer to a university while doing some work to support the cost. Unless you are interviewing with wall street or a large law firm, most employers don't care where your degree is from. 

Danielle --- 17 years ago -

The school in which I work out was the one that was featured on the special! 

cmi --- 17 years ago -

I didn't see the special, but the people who had 100K in loans, was it all for the actual degree, or did they take the max to be able to pay bills and get the degree? There is a difference there. My husband took the max for 2 years so that he could stay at home and go to school, rather than putting the kid in daycare and working and going to school. He probably would not have finished if he had worked and done school full time. Does he use the degree now? Nope....he runs his own business. Oh, and his degree is in Religious Studies and Philosophy. Was it worth it? Yes, because if he ever wants to teach he can, or if he ever decides to go further in his education he can. Can I go and say his degree cost such and such amount? He did not take near $100K. I think the max for undergrad is somewhere around $40K, so the people on the show must have gone beyond the undergrad. No, I don't think it would be fair to include the extra he took. Yes, I know that's part of the "expense," but I know we did it so that he could focus on school. Does any of what I'm saying make sense? And does anyone that saw the special know if they were showing people who took the max all through grad school and never worked, paying bills with it instead? Or did they actually take $100K for tuition? 

path --- 17 years ago -

College is expensive now adays....my son is looking at A&M and for his aerospace engineering degree, it will cost nearly $100,000K for 5 years (projected cost of everything incl books,tuition, fees, room board, misc. expenses) 

Miss T --- 17 years ago -

today a Bachelor's Degree is about the equivalent to a High School Diploma This is exactly true. Some jobs it doesn't even matter what your degree is in, just as long as you have one. It shows employers that you have discipline enough to finish a task. 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

I have worked for a VERY large integrated oil and gas company for over 20 years and one of the fun things that I get to do is return to the university that I graduated from once or twice year and recruit students. The company does this with about 60 schools across the nation. I interface with the recruiters dozens of other corporations such as IBM, Dell, Walmaert, General Electric, Shell, Bank of America, Microsoft, etc., ect. at career fairs, information nights, dinners and so forth. I can assure you that the one common theme across most, if not all of these major corporations is that you must have a college degree (most of them demanding a high GPA) to even talk with a recruiter for all the reasons Your Neighbor stated above. At my company we only hire new grads, very rarely hiring experienced individuals. 

path --- 17 years ago -

Nodoubt....does your company hire business majors? My DD will be graduating in Aug and is scared she will not find a job? Where is your company based? 

cowboyswife --- 17 years ago -

I do not have a college degree and I am making more than a couple of my friends that DO hae degrees. Granted they are only bachelor's degrees but nonetheless.. 

Rachel --- 17 years ago -

I do not have a college degree and I am making more than a couple of my friends that DO hae degrees. Granted they are only bachelor's degrees but nonetheless.. Me too. I actually make more than a friend of mine who has a masters degree! 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

path - what is his major? (MIS, Accounting, General Business ...) What school is he going to? We are in over 180 countries with main offices in Houston, Dallas, and the northeast. Most business majors end up in Houston for their first assignment. 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

Oh - and I am talking about exempt (or professional) positions. We do recruit lots of hourly jobs (which make lots of money - especially off shore) where experience is king! 

path --- 17 years ago -

My dd will have a bachelor's in finance from Texas State if she gets her last class this summer. We are from here and she is gathering all her contacts and starting to make them this semester. She never did intern so I do not know if that will hurt her or not. She started out in acct but could not quite make those high grades so switched to finance and loves it. But she will have enough acct classes to start out in an entry level position if she had to. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

so not worth it unless you are going to graduate school. I have found many areas to definitely be a "who you know", not "what you know" business. And yes, my DH and I are both educated. Biggest waste of $ ever. 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

I could agree on a degree not being "worth it" under certain circumstances. Depends on what the degree is in (Social Behavior of Indiguious Tribes of the Alginates vs Chemical Engineering or Computer Science), GPA, personality, work ethic, and, somewhat what school you go to ... not necessarily the most expensive ones. And yes it sometimes makes it easier if you "know someone" but not as often as you might think - especially in the bigger corporations. I can assure you that there are some jobs that you will not qualify for and CANNOT get without one. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

Well obviously you can't talk or fake your way into engineering or something like that, so yes a degree is absolutely essential in certain areas. I have seen and experienced the "who you know", and it will blow your mind to see people NOT worthy by any means (ethics, education, common sense) move on up b/c of who they know or who their spouse knows. I myself have been offered several positions that I did not seek out. A few offers were from people that did not even know me and just cold called and offered b/c they were asking around and I have a good rep at work and my name came up. But would I have ever received an interview for those positions by going through the "proper" channels.....probably not. 

nodoubt --- 17 years ago -

Sure - once you get into your first job lots of other things take effect such as past history with indivual managers or office politics, but I am talking about getting your foot in the door and first job out of school. I fully agree with you that once you are in, the game changes..... 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

but I am talking about getting your foot in the door and first job out of school I am talking about this too. For me and DH, totally not worth it. For some people it will be. You never know. But if my kids decide not to go, or at least not to go right away, I will not be upset, b/c I have nothing great to say about it. Waste of time and $ and me and DH could have both been further along in our careers if we had not stopped for college! 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

it will cost nearly $100,000K for 5 years (projected cost of everything incl books,tuition, fees, room board, misc. expenses) I guess I don't consider living expenses as part of the cost of going to college. You have to live and eat even if you don't go to college. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

His first degree (both from UT) is in Radio, Television and Film) and while interesting and fun, it paid nada. I've a couple of friends with that degree that have done rather well. I guess it just depends on what you do with it. I agree. My son has the same degree from the same university. He will be in the CNN booth in Washing DC covering the inauguration...not too shabby for a 29 year old. He has traveled the world and has met many world leaders because of the field he chose. BTW- money isn't the only measure of success. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

I think one of the best and economical paths to a college degree is to start at the community college level and live at home for two years. Many students are not ready for the complete move away from home at age 18 anyway, so this is a good transition. After 2 years of community college and getting a good GPA, it is much easier to get into a "namebrand" 4 year university and you are ready to go directly into your major course work, having gotten the prerequisites out of the way. So many kids make the mistake of declaring their major too soon anyway, and waste time and money with course work that doesn't give them credit toward graduation. 

donottreadonme --- 17 years ago -

If College is required to get a decent job, than it should be provided like 1 to 12. But not required if someone doesn't want to go, they don't have to be forced. Of course private can cost more like it does now, but state run should be mostly free, they make enough off tax funding and sports that they can run the college. College is mostly a class separator, when too many people have a BS than they will require an MS and so on. I have a BS and am not any smarter or more capable than other people I know that don't have one. But, having my degree also got me my job over others that did not. 

NellieGurl --- 17 years ago -

My son graduated in 2004 from A&M and 21,000. in loans. I paid his cell phone his dad paid his auto insurance and his dad and I paid his share of the rent. He had 3 roommates, drove a grand am, worked part time, volunteered part time and went to school full time. They would send him huge loans....he used only what he needed for books & tuition and returned the rest. He graduated and wanted to work for a specific company soooo bad but couldn't get his foot in the door. He finally got in thru a temp agency doing data entry working Thur-Mon nights 7pm-3am. While all his friends were out having a good time he was proving himself. End result. He now works in their corporate office making good money, drives a new vehicle and purchased a new home. A degree and determination will get you a long way. 

Forecaster --- 17 years ago -

Went to college and got a job with an engineering firm. I made six figures within five years of starting the job but that's more to do with my ambition to not be the low pay scale guy. Now I make around ten dollars an hour to keep the old business going and to make sure my guys get competitive pay. I had to give up on ambition for myself when taking over this business and only care about others futures and ambitions. 

needrnr --- 17 years ago -

many of the people i work with do not have a degree. we may be at the highest rung in the ladder at this point, but we have job security, and make as much or more than people with degrees in other fields of work. many of us had to start in positions most people would never want to be in. many of us transferred to areas no one wanted to be in. we sacrificed living in high cost of living areas so to gain the work experience then we transferred to areas of our choice good example houston. it took me almost 2 years to get my foot in the door. i encourage the kids to go to college. my job will not be available to them with out a degree later. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground