Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Auto bailout - DEAD

who's talking here?

RoseSr 1
RRay 1
randyjet 6
planemom 1
likeke27 2
AuthorMan 1
CommonSense 1
eldiablo 4
Fin and Feather 1
cuckoo'snest 2
Forecaster 2
Perfection 6
JET 1
keepinitreal09 1
WaldenDad 2
Big Ben 1
oneyedman 5
*maryc 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Thank goodness that common sense has prevailed. Interesting how it was the UAW who killed this bailout by refusing to accept wage concessions to begin immediately (they offered 2011 concessions). GM has retained bankruptcy counsel - perhaps now by reorganizing they can come out from under the burden of those union contracts and start being able to run their company again. 

RoseSr --- 17 years ago -

perhaps now by reorganizing they can come out from under the burden of those union contracts and start being able to run their company again. My thoughts exactly. 

Fin and Feather --- 17 years ago -

You don’t run form a problem, you work it out and keep your head up. My cookie tonight said: courage comes from suffering , and somehow I found it worth noting 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

I sure am glad the UAW lacks cranial capacity. :-) 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Interesting how it was the UAW who killed this bailout by refusing to accept wage concessions to begin immediately (they offered 2011 concessions). And some people think it is only corporate greed that has led to our current economic situation. 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

i hope it stays dead! 

Big Ben --- 17 years ago -

Wow! So instead of a paycut, workers would just prefer to be without a job all together? Im not for the bailout, but personally, I believe the UAW just screwed their members on that one. 

eldiablo --- 17 years ago -

It sure would be nice if 10% of the scrutiny being put upon the auto companies was placed upon AIG before they were given billions! Those bastards make a helluva lot more than the union guys ever could and are still paying out bonuses to the nimrod management teams! I am not defending the union, because they screw things up plenty. I am just saying that as of 2004, new UAW employees already make comparable $ and benefits to the Jap auto companies. The American auto companies have 100 years of retirements on their books, and Toyota and the rest could easily have similar problems if they were in business during the same era. You should also look up how much the CEO of Toyota makes in a good year compared to how much the Big 3 executives make in a bad year. It is pretty interesting how different the company cultures are. Rest assured, the guys making 25 million in bonuses will still get their money as the companies decommission American plants and open operations in Juarez. I am glad the bailout was shut down this time because that money would have only paid for the cost of closing facilities down in Michigan. An even bigger bailout will be approved shortly though, because UAW and Big 3 are some of the biggest contributors to political campaigns...you may recognize the names of other top contributors: Fannie May, Freddie Mac, Citigroup. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I find it interesting that eldiablo seems to think that just because the UAW and the Big 3 give many donations to political campaigns that this would sail through. This is from today's Houston Chronicle. Note how it is the UAW donations to the Democrats that did work, but the Republicans who receive donations from "the Big 3" can seperate donations from what is best for the country. Big donations to GOP don't help auto companies By KEN BENSINGER Los Angeles Times Dec. 12, 2008, By standing in the way of an auto industry bailout, GOP senators appear to have bitten the hand that fed them. Over the last decade, General Motors has given $1.50 to Republican candidates for every $1 it has given to Democrats. That same pattern has been followed by Chrysler and Ford, which year after year have favored the right side of the aisle, sometimes by more than a 3-to-1 ratio in dollar terms. Since 1990, the auto industry as a whole -- including suppliers, dealers and manufacturers -- has cut $100 million in checks to Republicans, compared with just $34 million to Democrats. On Thursday night, the carmakers discovered just how little loyalty that investment strategy had bought them. Efforts to get through even a watered-down version of the $14 billion aid package were stymied by Republican senators, many of whom contend that GM and Chrysler -- the most troubled U.S. automakers -- should simply go bankrupt. "Carmakers have always leaned Republican," said Larry Sabato, director of the University of Virginia's Center for Politics. "But it'll be interesting to see whether what happened this week changes that pattern." Political giving from the auto industry as a whole -- including carmakers, dealers and suppliers -- has long backed candidates that favor less regulation, lower taxes and looser labor rules, among other key issues. This year, for the first time on record, Detroit's spending slightly favored Democrats. But since 2000, overall spending by the Big Three has steered 61 percent of contributions, or $7.2 million, to Republicans, according to Federal Election Commission data compiled by the Center for Responsible Politics. Democrats, meanwhile, have looked to the United Auto Workers for support. Since 2000, the union has given $12.5 million to Democrats compared with only $94,540 to Republicans. GM, the only carmaker that could be reached for comment, downplayed the role that money may have played in the current debate. "It's highly doubtful that political giving ever played a factor in an individual member's position," GM spokesman Greg Martin said. But on Capitol Hill, the cold calculus of money is never too far from any issue. A study released Thursday by the Center for Responsive Politics suggested that in the House of Representatives, where the bailout passed this week, there was a direct correlation between votes and campaign cash: Those who voted in favor of the plan received, on average, 8 percent more money from the auto industry than those who did not. In the Senate, other forces may have been at play. Some of the loudest opponents to helping Detroit were senators whose states are home to car factories of foreign brands, including Sen. Richard C. Shelby, D-Ala., who has Mercedes, Hyundai and Honda plants in his state but no Big Three facilities. At the 11th hour, Sen. Bob Corker, R-Tenn., put forth a bill that sought to wrest new concessions from the United Auto Workers as well as from corporate bondholders. He has received $234,860 from the auto industry throughout his career, but Tennessee is also home to several Nissan plants and the Japanese automaker's U.S. headquarters. "A part of this is certainly the old adage 'Where you stand is where you sit,' " said Norm Orenstein, resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research. Representatives of the two senators could not be reached for comment. Labor was another issue underlying the tense negotiations. An action alert circulated among Senate Republicans on Wednesday called for Republicans to "stand firm and take their first shot against organized labor." In doing so, analysts said, Republicans were planting the seeds for a fundraising appeal to big business -- other than the Big Three, of course -- as they gear up for a major political fight next year over expected legislation that would make it easier for unions to organize. "They may lose money from the auto industry, but a union fight will get them a lot of money from the rest of the business community," Sabato said. A final issue was ideological, experts say. For many conservatives in Congress, the idea of government rescuing any industry is simply unpalatable -- and that trumps any contributions from Detroit. "The tension for Republicans is that it's an industry that's been staunchly in their camp for many years, but this is legislation calling for billions of dollars of government spending," said Massie Ritsch, spokesman for the Center for Responsive Politics. "It's a conflict between their principles and their longtime supporters." 

cuckoo'snest --- 17 years ago -

Wow! So instead of a paycut, workers would just prefer to be without a job all together? Im not for the bailout, but personally, I believe the UAW just screwed their members on that one ALL of the work will be shipped to foreign countries, wonder if that was the whole idea in the first place...in my best scandalous voice... "Sorry Charlie we didn't get the money so good bye to you American worker we can find the labor to be done cheaper in a foreign country and import the product in for less while still charging our own people more money. (Heck we have been doing it for awhile)Instead of having the finger pointed to us for abandoning our country and moving our manufacturing else were we will place the blame on the GOV for not bailing us out." Think about it. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

"Sorry Charlie we didn't get the money so good bye to you American worker we can find the labor to be done cheaper in a foreign country and import the product in for less while still charging our own people more money. (Heck we have been doing it for awhile)Instead of having the finger pointed to us for abandoning our country and moving our manufacturing else were we will place the blame on the GOV for not bailing us out." Think about it. The same work is being done in THIS country by NON-UNION workers in Tennessee and Alabama. It can and IS being done and those workers are producing cars we actually WANT to buy and have better quality. 

cuckoo'snest --- 17 years ago -

I agree to leave the work to be done here. I believe product can be produced here that would be desirable. I believe the big 3 really don't want to keep the work here I don't believe the bail out would have helped the regular auto industry worker. It would have been a bandaid. GM has retained bankruptcy counsel - perhaps now by reorganizing they can come out from under the burden of those union contracts and start being able to run their company again You don’t run form a problem, you work it out and keep your head up. I am sure they will run... 

eldiablo --- 17 years ago -

First, I never said the bailout bill would sail through. I just expressed that the automakers and the UAW will get some big money before this is done. If Bush does not act or coerce the Treasury to intervene, then Obama will "take charge" and make something happen in January. Most of the opponents in Congress oppose the auto bailout because many citizens are tired of bailing business out, and elected officials know this...they will use their firm opposition votes to bolster a re-election campaign. There are a few congressmen (of southern states mostly) who have constituents who work at Nissan, Toyota or Honda plants, so they have to oppose the Big 3 bailout. As to the quality arguments, try driving a Malibu or Ford Fusion and they are very nice, and a bit cheaper on purchase and maintenance from what I can tell. If you are comparing modern Toyotas to Chrysler K cars of the 80s, well, that is not really a valid argument anymore. 

eldiablo --- 17 years ago -

By the way, I am not pro-union at all. However, I do recognize that without organized labor in the history of our country, none of us would have paid time off in any form, we would all be working 65 hours + for less pay, and would be subject to our bosses. If you do not believe this, look up the history of the NLRA. At the other extreme, when the unions have had too much power or are outside of the acceptable labor supply/demand curves, management simply decides to close the US plant and move that to another country. The bottom line for today's situation is that the top people in the UAW and the top people of the Big 3 do not care about the future of this country or its citizens, only their paychecks, because the business is not sustainable in its current form. I still hold that 15Billion is chump-change compared to the Fannie/Freddie, AIG, Citigroup charity fund our government approved without any standards. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I agree that back in the day, unions did a TON for workers. However they have outlived their purpose and now exist solely to make those who are at the upper levels rich and powerful. Comparing the auto bailout to the financial sector bailout is like comparing apples to oranges. You will never make sense with that arguement. Now if you would like to debate the validity of that bailout individually and not in comparison to another, that is a great topic and one worthy of discussion. 

WaldenDad --- 17 years ago -

An e-mail I received just this morning ... The car makers: The cost per employee (salary + benefits) at the big three automakers - Ford, Chevy & Chrysler - is $78 per hour. Toyota, (a non-union US manufacturer) on the other hand - is $48 per hour. While the average American worker comes in at $28 per hour. So let me get this straight......... The $28 per hour worker needs to bail out the $78 per hour worker whose company is going bankrupt ? 

JET --- 17 years ago -

The $28 per hour worker needs to bail out the $78 per hour worker whose company is going bankrupt ? That's the entire argument. The big 3 (management and union employee's) have priced themselves out of business. Both need pay cuts and less bonuses. The jobs bank that supports the unemployed union worker needs to be cut off and the unemployed needs to get unemployment until he finds another job. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

Ok so now Bush wants to give the Big 3 the money anyway using the Wall Street $700 billion already approved..... So our elected officials turn down the bailout, then Bush goes ahead and give the money anyway... DO WE LIVE IN A DEMOCRACY ANYMORE??? 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

He says it would be "irresponsible" to allow Detroit to fail..... Gee, perhaps it is a bit "irresponsible" to ignore the will of the People and act like a friggin King... FU Bush! 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Actually President Bush did exactly what Congress wanted AND what needed to be done. The money given to them did not need to be NEW money, but money that had already been approved. Now they need to be RESPONSIBLE. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

Actually President Bush did exactly what Congress wanted AND what needed to be done. The money given to them did not need to be NEW money, but money that had already been approved. Now they need to be RESPONSIBLE. What does any of this mean? Congress failed to approve money for Detroit. PERIOD. The approved monies were NOT for the Big 3. Who needs to be responsible? Bush? Congress? The Big 3? The Treasury? WHO? And why would any of them start now? They have dupped us all into funding everything they want without their "responsibility" up to now... 

WaldenDad --- 17 years ago -

DO WE LIVE IN A DEMOCRACY ANYMORE??? NO WE DO NOT ONEEYE!!!! That will change on January 20!!! Meaning we'll return to Democracy or begin a period of Socialism? 

Forecaster --- 17 years ago -

The money given to them did not need to be NEW money, but money that had already been approved. The 700 billion relief fund still has fifteen billion of released money, of the first half and president Bush can give that as a loan to the big 3. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

UnbBush has no business using money approved for Paulson's Pet Project and spending it elsewhere. NO BUSINESS OMG Mr. Slim of the Jim and I agree... Surely not a good sign. 

Forecaster --- 17 years ago -

Bush and congress had no business giving away my tax dollars to companies such as AIG when I'm not in debt to them and owe them nothing but what are you going to do? I didn't agree with the first bail out and don't agree with any to come but according to Bush and congress I have no say in the matter. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

according to Bush and congress I have no say in the matter. YES!! Does anyone TRUST our government anymore? 

keepinitreal09 --- 17 years ago -

Does anyone TRUST our government anymore? They shouldnt...Isnt it funny though that this 35 billion is like a drop in the bucket compared to the 8 trillion we have spent already... Would of been nice if we stopped all these bailouts....Not just the small ones... 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I agree that back in the day, unions did a TON for workers. However they have outlived their purpose and now exist solely to make those who are at the upper levels rich and powerful. Actually they STILL do tons for workers. If you can be vested in any retirement plan at ten years you can thank the UNIONS for that. If you have insurance for your pension plan and cannot have it taken away by corporate raiders, you can thank UNIONS for that. If you can have notice as to what hazards exist on your job, you can thank UNIONS for that. ALL of those things came about rather recently too by the way. I never knew any union worker who was rich and powerful. That is funny! 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

The $28 per hour worker needs to bail out the $78 per hour worker whose company is going bankrupt ? The figures are NOT accurate at all since the $70s figure includes ALL pensioned workers health care costs, which the UAW modified so that the auto makers do NOT have to bear those costs any more, pensions, benefits etc.. The average wage for UAW workers in their plants is about $26-8/hr. 

likeke27 --- 17 years ago -

which the UAW modified so that the auto makers do NOT have to bear those costs any more, pensions, benefits etc.. which, by the way, wouldn't take effect until 2011 

RRay --- 17 years ago -

So let me get this straight......... The $28 per hour worker needs to bail out the $78 per hour worker whose company is going bankrupt ? Walden dad hit the nail on the head here...... 

likeke27 --- 17 years ago -

well, if that is not going to happen, i guess this will not either... extras for the bailout 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

which, by the way, wouldn't take effect until 2011 NO the UAW takes over responsibility next year for the health care plan for ALL its workers, thus about half of that so called 73dollar/ hour goes away. 

eldiablo --- 17 years ago -

NO the UAW takes over responsibility next year for the health care plan for ALL its workers, thus about half of that so called 73dollar/ hour goes away I think this is only true if and when that plan gets funded by the auto companies. If the Big 3 do not have the cash or go bankrupt before that funding check is cashed by the UAW, those retirement commitments of the Big 3 become arguable in court or arbitration during the reorganization process. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I think this is only true if and when that plan gets funded by the auto companies. If the Big 3 do not have the cash or go bankrupt before that funding check is cashed by the UAW That is quite true, but I think that they have already made a half payment. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

If the GOP Senators want to control the wages of workers, I wonder why they did NOT do the same for the Wall Street execs? I guess it depends on whether or not they will run into the people at the country club. They don't have to worry about running into any auto workers there and causing a scene. IT would also make sense then for them to insist that the health care costs be paid at the SAME rate as those plants down south too. Also, they need to cut the insurance premiums that are being charged to the automakers. Since almost HALF of the costs quote for labor are those for health care insurance, THAT would go a LOT further than cutting wages only. Again, though, the Senators would run into irate insurance execs who would give them a HARD time. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Now if this had passed, people would be upset, saying the Republican Senators had been bought off by the Big 3 in campaign contributions. But now, those very same Senators have turned their backs on those who make donations and fought for every one of us taxpayers and fought to protect capitalism. It proves who has integrity. The UAW on the other hand donated over 90% of their campaign contributions to Democrats - why aren't these same people arguing that the Democrats are not supporting you and I but rather the lobbyists who donated/bought them? That also shows integrity. 

CommonSense --- 17 years ago -

STOP SAYING IT'S $78 I PROVED IN THE OTHER THREAD IT'S INCORRECT 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

You think Republicans CARE about truth? That is beyond funny! They accused Rep. Frank of the exact OPPOSITE of what he did and still get away with it. You should see his letter to the WSJ, it answers all the lies about him. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground