Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

How much is too much for one kid?

who's talking here?

GCan 3
Fallon 2
QueenCassie 2
I Love Horses 1
ambergris 2
jklucas03 1
CyberSage 1
Deltadawn 1
Pet Lover 1
Mygirl01 1
Clown Vomit 1
d:-] 1
2girlygirls 3
Vedette 6
Buttercup:) 3
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 1
ladybughomeschool 2
PHSMOMOF2 1
SueRDH 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Vedette --- 17 years ago -

Right now I have DD in Karate and the church's choir. She's been asking me for horseback riding lessions and piano lessons as well. My mom has expressed interest in getting her the horseback riding lessons and my dad (they're divorced) is bringing me my grandmother's piano and so that's extremely convenient for piano lessons. DD is five and I don't want to stretch her or myself too thin. Where would you draw the line on extracurricular activities and how would you decide which to keep and which to ditch? 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

IMO, she's very young to have karate, choir, horseback riding and piano lessons. I only permit my kids to do one thing at any given time and that seems to work for now. 

Clown Vomit --- 17 years ago -

All "activities" should be free, like mowing and raking the yard, cleaning the gutters, repairing toilets, changing the oil in my truck, rotating my tires, etc. I don't believe in paying to keep a kid busy. 

Buttercup:) --- 17 years ago -

My 5 year old was doing horse riding lessons, ballet, and t ball! IT WAS KILLING ME! We are taking a break from horse riding lessons and fall ball is over. And boy what a nice break! In the day she also has spanish twice a week and art once but I dont consider that extra activity it is part of her schooling. 

Vedette --- 17 years ago -

one thing at any given time I kind of want to draw the line at 2. Something sporty and something artsy, if that makes sense. We put her in karate with the intention of never letting her quit (lol) and I'm not sure if choir even counts since it is right after school and I just have to make sure she shows up at the correct Mass when the angel choir sings. So she's learning a little extra and it's not out of our way or anything. I think learning piano is something educational too since knowing music is tied to math skills. The horseback riding would teach her discipline and responsibility. She's also obsessed with horses so she'd absolutely be thrilled. I just don't know where to draw the line! I want her to do and learn the things she wants but I don't want her "hobby hopping" like my little sister did when she was little. (first it was ballet then piano then horseback riding then softball then basketball then theatre. She finally decided on theatre...I hope...she's majoring in it now) AHHHHHHhhhhhh!! 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

IT WAS KILLING ME! That's why I refuse to do it. I knew one mom that spent all her time in her vehicle driving her children all over the city for multiple events. Always eating on the run and frazzled beyond belief. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

karate could go. Church choir is just one day a week right? I would not get her horse ridding lessons until she is a bit older. I would start the piano lessons, just because you will have a piano, and that is one thing I have always wanted to - to learn to play the piano. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

Something sporty and something artsy, if that makes sense. That I can make an exception for. But there are some parents that have kids in multiple or back to back sports. Kids don't have a break. Then we wonder how come kids are getting sports injuries at such young ages, etc. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

I would start the piano lessons, just because you will have a piano, and that is one thing I have always wanted to - to learn to play the piano. and the younger the better....and you'll be able to tell right away if she has an ear for it!! plus the piano is like the "gateway" (LOL) instrument. we only do one at a time...its supposed to be extracurricular, not all-consuming. and......i'm a lazy mom! 

2girlygirls --- 17 years ago -

After figuring out that our quality family time was mostly spend in the car shuttling kids to and from activities, we've limited it to one activity per kid at any given time. 

ambergris --- 17 years ago -

I don't want her "hobby hopping" like my little sister did when she was little. (first it was ballet then piano then horseback riding then softball then basketball then theatre. She finally decided on theatre... Why not? That's the only way she will really decide what she likes. I let my kids dabble in everything until they find the one thing that fits and that they love. Oh, but only 1 thing at a time. I don't want to spend every night doing something. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

my oldest wants to do Karate, but no way I am going 4 days a week. Why the heck can't you find something in Kingwood that is one day a week? 

Vedette --- 17 years ago -

karate could go. No, like I said we put her in with the intention of never letting her quit. Karate is the one thing DH and I agreed would be the best activity for both physical activity/coordination training as well as discipline and responsibility. That particular one is the only constant I'm refusing to let go of. my oldest wants to do Karate, but no way I am going 4 days a week. DD's karate classes are only 2 nights a week... 

2girlygirls --- 17 years ago -

Why not? That's the only way she will really decide what she likes. I let my kids dabble in everything until they find the one thing that fits and that they love. Oh, but only 1 thing at a time. I don't want to spend every night doing something. That's our philosophy as well. We just don't let them quit in the middle of an activity. They have to stick with it until the end. Then on to different things. 

Buttercup:) --- 17 years ago -

That's our philosophy as well. We just don't let them quit in the middle of an activity. They have to stick with it until the end. Then on to different things. Same here. right now my DD wants to quit ballet and do gymnastics but I told her she had to finish ballet until her recital. 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

I wouldn't really count choir since it does not really take much out of your schedule. The piano lessons would be great since you will have one in your home. You will be able to tell pretty quickly if it is something she has a talent for and will be interested in keeping up. 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

Maybe start the piano lessons now, and make a deal with her to give it 6 mnths and see how your schedule looks then for introducing horseback riding? 

SueRDH --- 17 years ago -

Why not? That's the only way she will really decide what she likes. I let my kids dabble in everything until they find the one thing that fits and that they love. I totally agree. How else will they know what they like? 

ambergris --- 17 years ago -

That's our philosophy as well. We just don't let them quit in the middle of an activity. They have to stick with it until the end. Then on to different things. same here. If you sign up then you will finish it whether you like it or not. AFter it is over then you can choose something else that you would like to do. 

Vedette --- 17 years ago -

Why not? That's the only way she will really decide what she likes. I let my kids dabble in everything until they find the one thing that fits and that they love. My personal problem with that is that sometimes these activities require hard work and sacrifice. Not wanting to work is not a good reason to find another activity. I did ballet for 9 years and sometimes it sucked and sometimes it was awesome but if I had quit after the first time I was "tired" of it or if I'd moved on to something else, I never would have learned what I did. I understand what you are saying about letting them find what they love, but sometimes something you love really sucks and that's not a good reason to quit, IMO. I would never force her to stay in karate if she had hated it from the beginning. She loves it now but if she hates it a year from now I'm not letting her give up on it or on herself. There are about a million activities that DD would love but she just plain can't do them all and trying out a little of everything is not going to teach her anything concrete at all. And don't think I'm wanting her to be the best at any one thing, I just want her to do her best at what she's doing, whether she likes it at the moment or not. This is a personal decision we've made as parents and I totally respect that some of you may disagree with it. 

Deltadawn --- 17 years ago -

You need to look at how much time does she need both inside and outside the class time for each activity. Piano, like any other instrument requires practice, and you get to hear it too. There are only so many hours in a day, and part of that needs to be unstructured. 

2girlygirls --- 17 years ago -

She's only 5 right? Homework is right around the corner too. I'd take that into consideration because your school commitment is going to increase. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

my oldest wants to do Karate, but no way I am going 4 days a week. DD's karate classes are only 2 nights a week... I had to chime in on this one too, since my dd goes to the karate class after your dd's karate class. The basic karate at our particular school is 2 nights a week and sparring every Friday, but most of the kids don't do the Friday night class. So it would be at the most three nights and the classes are short 45 minutes to an hour, and you can always switch a night if you needed. Now, as they advance the whole thing can change. My dd is 7 (today) and she has been at this karate school for 3 years next month. She goes to the regular karate class (2X per week), she goes to competition team practice (2X per week), she goes to Weapons class (1X per week) and then she does the Gymnastic class on Friday night, so even though she is on a team at the school we are only there 4 nights per week. DON'T QUIT KARATE, girls these days need to know defense and she is learning that there. For us, Karate is year round, so we only add Swim Team in the Summer and that is great for us. Next year at school B will have homework and test's almost daily so I would wait until you get that pattern down to start adding to many more things for her to do. 

Vedette --- 17 years ago -

Next year at school B will have homework and test's almost daily so I would wait until you get that pattern down to start adding to many more things for her to do. I had thought about that. We probably won't be getting the piano for a few months and will probably not want to get into another activity until next fall anyway. I talked to DH and we're definitely not doing the horseback riding now. So adding piano will have to happen in the fall and only if we can fit it in with everything else plus homework. I feel a little less frazzled now that we have a plan. lol 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

I have three to cart around to activities. I allow each child 1 or 2 activities based on expense and their ability/willingness to take care of academic and family obligations. My 13 yo ds is in Karate 2 nights a week and homeschool band 1 day a week. He actually just got his Jr Black Belt a few weeks ago. My 12yo ds has homeschool band 1 day a week. He is eligible for another activity but would rather spend more time learning with Dad. My 6 yo dd is in Homeschool Choir 1 day a week and girl scouts every other week. One plus is that the boys are in band on the same day and same place. We are considering allowing my 6 yo dd to enter Karate because it is such a good activity. I just do not think my poor schedule can take it. I might have to wait until the oldest can drive ! 

CyberSage --- 17 years ago -

How much is too much for one kid? Like you don't know the answer... No, like I said we put her in with the intention of never letting her quit. Back off - she's 5. My kids go to Bible study - it's one day a week. My goodness, a 5 year old doesn't need karate any more than a 7 year old needs tackle football. It's all about the parents. My advice: Find something YOU like to do. Next, fit your kid's schedule around it. Selfish? - nope, it's called "healthy." Sorry to be so blunt, but maybe someday when you're an empty nester, you'll still want to be married. 

Vedette --- 17 years ago -

ladybughomeschool I bow to your mothering awesomeness. lol 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

I bow to your mothering awesomeness. lol It's not awesomness. I think it is a mental disorder of some sort. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

My boys are into everything, they have basketball practice everyday to include some saturdays. They play three times a week in all different places around texas. We work full time and we love it. It keeps them busy. They also have tournaments in between as well. On the weekends they fit in other things as well and we shuffle them back and forth and we do not complain one bit. As long as they keep up the grades they can keep up with the sports. 

jklucas03 --- 17 years ago -

we are going to start our little boy in karate, he is 5 

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

Drop down to one exc. activity and find something else that you and your five year old can do together. That'll be more valuable to her in the long run. 

I Love Horses --- 17 years ago -

We tried to do football and baseball for one child, didnt work out! Neither coach would give on him missing one practice to go to another! Now i just have 3 boys in baseball and one that alternates between baseball and football since he is in middle school. It gets a bit overwelming at times. 

Buttercup:) --- 17 years ago -

ladybughomeschool I bow to your mothering awesomeness. lol Ditto! 

Pet Lover --- 17 years ago -

Camille, Do what you can, but don't overload yourself or your dd. Some kids (and parents) are able to do more...Some aren't. Just make sure she has time to play and be a kid with other kids, and has good Mommy and Daddy time, too! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground