Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Moore: Automakers never listened to workers, consumers

who's talking here?

Carla 2
CMGs 6
JDB2 1
planemom 3
Sandyr9111 3
maverick 1
justforfun 1
Perfection 9
*maryc 3
JetMan 1
JohnLynch 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

Moore: Automakers never listened to workers, consumers (CNN) -- Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid reversed plans Wednesday to hold a test vote on an automakers' bailout bill on Thursday. Reid had planned to move on legislation that would have taken $25 billion from the $700 billion already approved for Wall Street and diverted it to the big three automakers. CNN's Larry King talked Wednesday with Michael Moore, a filmmaker with deep ties to the auto industry. Moore's father worked for General Motors for 35 years. In 1989, Moore became an international figure for his film, "Roger and Me," which centered on the declining auto industry in his hometown of Flint, Michigan and the ripple effect on the town's residents. The following is an edited version of the interview. Larry King: Michael, was (the movie) prophetic? Michael Moore: When I made that film, there were still 50,000 people working at General Motors in Flint. I mean they had eliminated 30,000 jobs, but there were still some jobs there. Today, I think there's less than 12,000 working in the area, so it has devastated Flint. Flint was one of the first towns to go. When I made that movie almost 20 years ago, I hoped that the film would be a warning to other cities that this corporation was intent upon removing jobs from this country and taking them to Mexico and Brazil and other places. When I made that movie that year, General Motors made a profit of over $4 billion, and they were still laying off people simply to make a bit more money, the people who helped to build the company, the workers in their hometown of Flint, Michigan, they just forgot about them and took the money and ran. King: Since the principle was, 'We'll have the cars built elsewhere and many of the cars are built elsewhere now,' what went wrong if they were paying less out of the country to build them? Moore: Well, what really went wrong is that General Motors has had this philosophy from the beginning that what's good for General Motors is good for the country. So, their attitude was we'll build it and you buy it. We'll tell you what to buy. You just buy it. Eventually, the consumer got smart and said, 'You know what, I'd like a car that gets a little better gas mileage. I'd like a car that's safer on the road,' so they started to buy other cars. General Motors still wouldn't change. They still kept building the wrong cars, and more and more people stopped buying them. Watch how Moore feels about auto bailout » At a certain point, you know, General Motors lost such a large part of the market share that there probably was a point of no return. Now, here we are on the verge of this collapse. If General Motors collapses, then there goes hundreds of thousands of jobs, if not millions of jobs of the ripple effect of this. King: And the same is true of Ford and Chrysler? Moore: Absolutely. I'll tell you, it was hilarious just watching these CEOs there (Tuesday) and (Wednesday) testifying in Congress, saying that, you know, that the problem wasn't theirs, you know, the cars they were building. It was the financial situation that we're in now. Watch automakers get grilled on Capitol Hill » The problem is the cars they've been building. They've never listened to the consumers. They've just gone about it their own wrong way. I'll tell you, you know, I'm of mixed mind about this bailout, Larry, because I don't think these companies, with these management people, should be given a dime, because that's just going to be money going up in smoke or off to other countries. GM is currently building a $300 million factory in Russia right now to build SUVs, right outside of St. Petersburg. That's where your money's going to go, no matter what they say. King: Why (do you have) mixed feelings? Moore: Well, because we can't let all these people lose their jobs because of the bad decisions, the stupid decisions made by the management of these auto companies. I think what has to happen here is that Congress needs to pass some legislation, and our president-elect needs to do what Roosevelt did. When Roosevelt came in and when World War II faced the country, Roosevelt said to General Motors and Ford, you're not going to build cars anymore. You're going to build airplanes and tanks and guns and the things that we need for this war because we have a national crisis. General Motors had to do what Roosevelt told them they had to do. King: What do you want them to do now? Moore: President-Elect Obama has to say to them, yes, we're going to use this money to save these jobs, but we're not going to build these gas-guzzling, unsafe vehicles any longer. We're going to put the companies into some sort of receivership and we, the government, are going to hold the reigns on these companies. They're to build mass transit. They're to build hybrid cars. They're to build cars that use little or no gasoline. We're facing a national crisis, not just an economic crisis, but a crisis of the polar ice caps are melting. There's only so much oil left under the Earth. We're going to run out of that, if not in our children's time, our grandchildren's time. There's got to be a plan set out to find other ways to transport ourselves in other ways than using fossil fuels.  

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

why does anybody talk to or listen to michael moore? 

*maryc --- 18 years ago -

jdb, I only listen to michael moore for a laugh. Surely no one takes him seriously....except himself, of course. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

I watched some of the Senate thing last night and i was LOL when one of those senators asked those CEOs about why didnt they fly first class or "jet pool" on their private jets to save money instead of each one flying their own private jet up? He said its like yall are standing in the soup line with tuxedos on! 

JetMan --- 18 years ago -

jdb, I only listen to michael moore for a laugh. Funny, I only read your posts for a laugh!!! 

*maryc --- 18 years ago -

JetMan, Happy that you are entertained. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

I watched some of the Senate thing last night and i was LOL when one of those senators asked those CEOs about why didnt they fly first class or "jet pool" on their private jets to save money instead of each one flying their own private jet up? That is standard practice and it really accomplished nothing other than to waste a lot of time that should be spent discussing the issues. How many Senators sitting at that table asking the questions are wasting our taxpayer money themselves on their own perks? How many of them are giving up anything for US? That is a question that needs to be asked as well. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Reid had planned to move on legislation that would have taken $25 billion from the $700 billion already approved for Wall Street and diverted it to the big three automakers. If Congress wants to give the automakers money why don't they give up some of the $100 billion in pork that was attached to the $700 billion Wall Street bail out? 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

If Congress wants to give the automakers money why don't they give up some of the $100 billion in pork that was attached to the $700 billion Wall Street bail out? Because Congress will NEVER lead by example. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

So then, you guys all think we ought to hand over the money with no strings? I'm curious if you read what he said, because like him or not, he has a good point about giving the money to save the jobs, but to control what they build to better suit the demands of the people. (His first movie, almost 20 years ago, was about the auto industry's problems.) About the private jet issues, what's scary is that they still see no problem with it, as they are defending the use of private jets. It's not just the private jets, it's an entire mentality of spending. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

So then, you guys all think we ought to hand over the money with no strings? I think we should NOT hand over any money. This is a capitalistic society. If they fail, they should be allowed to fail. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

So then, you guys all think we ought to hand over the money with no strings? Definitely not! 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

There should not be bailouts for any companies. The marketplace does not require 7 options for the same type of vehicle or any other product. Just look in any mall - how many similar stores are there with the same products? What we are going to see happen is that these companies also experience natural selection and survival of the fitest. If you provide a good product at a good price with good value then you will be successful. If you do nothing that differentiates you from the competition you will not survive. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

There should not be bailouts for any companies. I agree. They should have to make cut backs and try to survive on their own. I cant imagine how they all could fail that quick. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

I'm iffy about the bailout. My dh's family is from MI, and they've been hurting badly for years. I definitely think that, should we give the money, there should be strings, not just a blank check. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

I cant imagine how they all could fail that quick. It hasn't. In the interview I posted, he specifically points to this coming, at least, for the last 20 years. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

I'm iffy about the bailout. My dh's family is from MI, and they've been hurting badly for years. I definitely think that, should we give the money, there should be strings, not just a blank check. The people who worked there KNEW this was coming. Many of them chose to stay because they were "union" workers who knew they would not make 50-60 per hour anywhere else. By having these high labor prices the auto makers could not afford to sell the cars for any less. It was a vicious cycle that the companies AND the unions created. However many people did leave MI and went to work in other parts of the country. It was their chocie. 

*maryc --- 18 years ago -

Toyota, Nissan.......they are not asking for a bailout...... Maybe the Big 3 should look at the differences. Of course we know the UAW is a problem also. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Maybe the Big 3 should look at the differences. Of course we know the UAW is a problem also. Bingo. The workers had as big a hand in this as the management which is why now both are suffering. If only 3 or 4 auto makers survive that's fine. We really do not need 7 different auto makers do we? 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

How come everybody assumes they entire industry is going to fold if there isn't a bailout? What about bankruptcy? This would give them a chance to reorganize and restructure and hopefully come out stronger. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

Well CH, I disagree. The domestic cars are cheaper than say Honda or Toyota. I think the point that MM makes in the article, more fuel efficient cars, is a main reason why the US automakers are suffering. As for people leaving MI, several members of my dh's family ran into trying to sell their homes. In the past few years, they have watched their homes value go lower than what the paid for it, so instead of taking a hit, to the tune of 25K, one has just walked away. The others are still managing to make their house notes and surviving. They probably should have done like the others and walked away and found another job. Again, what we're experiencing now, nationwide, has been going on for a long time in MI. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Here is another question: Are the Toyotas that are being made in the US still considered foreign cars? 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Again, what we're experiencing now, nationwide, has been going on for a long time in MI. And again, that isn't a bad thing. It is part of what happens in a capitalistic society, there are those that succeed and those that don't. It has to happen that way in order to work. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Here is another question: Are the Toyotas that are being made in the US still considered foreign cars? The unions consider them foreign cars because they are not produced with union labor. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

And again, that isn't a bad thing. It is part of what happens in a capitalistic society, there are those that succeed and those that don't. It has to happen that way in order to work. Of course I agree with you on how this all works, and I'm not agreeing with these automakers, that they are just a casualty of the financial crisis. They have not remained competetive and they will go under, for the most part, without the bailout money. A big issue now, is do we want to see more jobs gone, more people on unemployment, therefore more government spending on those employees, etc. If we don't want to loose jobs and lost wages for the government on those peoples income taxes, we should give the money, but with restrictions. They should not be allowed to continue down a path already proven to fail. Of course, for those that believe we just need to go further into recession, and into a depression to correct our inflated economy, which is a very valid point, this bailout is nuts. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Of course, for those that believe we just need to go further into recession, and into a depression to correct our inflated economy, which is a very valid point, this bailout is nuts. It will not reach a depression. It is a correction and one that is necessary. 

maverick --- 18 years ago -

Here is another question: Are the Toyotas that are being made in the US still considered foreign cars? The unions consider them foreign cars because they are not produced with union labor. They are foreign because the money from their sale still leaves the country. That being said, the CEOs of the US companies are so out of touch with reality, they must be replaced before any real change and recovery can be made in the industry. 

Carla --- 18 years ago -

We're going to put the companies into some sort of receivership and we, the government, are going to hold the reigns on these companies. Socialism . . . great! I don't think the auto industry should be bailed out. It isn't like the writing hasn't been on the wall for a long time. The current financial crisis has just brought to a head sooner what would have come about eventually. The auto industry has had 30 YEARS since the last oil crisis to create more fuel efficient cars. Other car manufacturers have done it . . . our three haven't. And the labor unions are as much to blame as the management. Do you know why they are building plants in other countries? So they don't have to pay assembly line workers $100k+ a year. The ironic part of this to me is that the unions made such a huge push to get Obama elected with extreme one on one pressure with their members because they wanted unions protected. At least in the case of the UAW, there may not be anything left to protect. They may have managed to negotiate themselves out of business. 

Carla --- 18 years ago -

Taking multi-million dollar "bonuses" when you business is tanking is ridiculous, but this is as well (and this was three years ago.) According to the National Review: Massive job cuts at General Motors, America's largest carmaker — coupled with the bankruptcy of Delphi, America's biggest autoparts maker — have provoked predictable handwringing from liberal pundits who worry that America is "losing its manufacturing base." But the wrenching change now buffeting the auto industry defies the usual press formulas. Just listen to Steve Miller a turnaround specialist who is steering Delphi's restructuring process. He exploded the myth of America's "endangered" union manufacturing jobs at his October press conference announcing Delphi's move into Chapter 11: "We cannot continue to pay $65 an hour for someone to cut the grass and remain competitive." Take grass cutting. As defined by the current United Auto Worker contract negotiated with the "Big Five" (GM, Ford, Chrysler, and top parts makers Delphi and Visteon), an auto "production worker" is a job description that covers anything from mowing grass to cleaning the toilets. In the real world, these jobs would be outsourced to $8 an hour, no-benefit wage earners, but on Planet Big Five, these jobs get the same wages as any auto line-worker: an average $26 an hour ($60,000 a year) plus benefits that bring the company's total cost per worker to a staggering $65 an hour. But at least the grass cutters are working for their pay. The UAW contract also guarantees that 12,000 autoworkers get full wage for doing nothing. On the heels of Miller's straight-talk, the Detroit News reported that "12,000 American autoworkers, instead of bending sheet metal, spend their days counting the hours in a jobs bank." These aren't jobs. And they certainly aren't being "lost" to China. "We just go in (to Ford's Michigan Truck Plant) and play crossword puzzles, watch videos that someone brings in or read the newspaper," The News quoted one UAW worker as saying. "Otherwise, I've just sat." The coming months will be painful for many American autoworkers. Accustomed to a certain lifestyle, they will see their wages cut in half, jeopardizing second homes, college tuitions, and car payments. One blue-collar Delphi worker interviewed by the Detroit News makes $103,000 a year operating a forklift and fears the consequences if his pay is drastically reduced. But many Americans will ask how a forklift operator felt entitled to a six-figure income in the first place (according to Bureau of Labor Statistics, the average forklift operator wage in the U.S. is $26,000). It is an opportune time for political leadership to step to the plate and speak with candor, but the signs are not encouraging. - November 29, 2005, Labor Pains, Detroit needs to play by market rules. By Henry Payne 

justforfun --- 18 years ago -

I think some of you are missing the point in all of this. Lets see, others are saying the auto workers are making 65 to 90 dollars an hour. In a sense that is true but in the same sense it's a lie. The worker probably makes 25 to 28 an hour if that much. The worker's insurance and pension is averaged into that 65 to 90 dollars and hour. I can't believe we are arguing over what isn't the truth. I am assuming this is what the stink is all about. 

JohnLynch --- 18 years ago -

I think some of you are missing the point in all of this. Lets see, others are saying the auto workers are making 65 to 90 dollars an hour. In a sense that is true but in the same sense it's a lie. The worker probably makes 25 to 28 an hour if that much. The worker's insurance and pension is averaged into that 65 to 90 dollars and hour. I can't believe we are arguing over what isn't the truth. I am assuming this is what the stink is all about. The truth is that it costs 65 to 90 dollars an hour for the "Big 3" to employ those workers whereas it costs their competitors about 40 to 50 dollars an hour to employ their workers. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground