Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Mini van or Suburban?

who's talking here?

Momof3 1
RRay 1
Fancy 3
planemom 1
airline*brat 1
jklucas03 1
ET 1
willow10 1
ladybeachbum 1
BeadQueen 1
KayCat 1
chunksNbones 1
justforfun 1
offroad4by4 1
Diamom 1
brian* 1
Atasca Mom 3
picasso1 1
Lillabeth 2
ilovepugs 1
Dana 1
Big Ben 1
Rubiconpete 1
jtcitrus 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

airline*brat --- 18 years ago -

I have an Odessey now that I really like but am thinking of getting a suburban. Does a suburban hold more than a mini van? Is it roomier inside or just holds more cargo? Thanks!!! 

ET --- 18 years ago -

Holds more gas... 

KayCat --- 18 years ago -

what's the mpg comparison? 

BeadQueen --- 18 years ago -

Suburbans are bigger inside but I don't think the ride is as smooth and quiet. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Suburbans seat 8 or 9 depending on the configuration. They do hold more cargo. However, mpg will be lower on a suburban. We have an Excursion and a mini-van. I like the van for driving around town but prefer the Excursion on longer trips. 

Diamom --- 18 years ago -

We have owned a suburban and now an extended Expedition (like a burb). My husband is tall and likes the bigger vehicle. That said, I had a rental mini-van for a week recently and secretly loved it. The doors were fabulous, especially in the garage. The back cargo area wasn't deep horizontally but dropped down deep so that it could still hold a lot. I think if you're kiddos are younger go with the van. I love my expedition EL for the room on trips, etc but sometimes it is a bit clunky. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

Well, my opinion, if you want your husband to like driving it, get the suburban. Not to manys guy will admit to liking driving a mini van. 

picasso1 --- 18 years ago -

I rented a mini-van when we flew to Florida a couple of years ago. The other men in our group were relentless in making fun of my DH in the red minivan. He was not too happy with me-it sure held a lot of people and luggage though. I love my suburban! 

Rubiconpete --- 18 years ago -

Dont get a suburban. I have one at work - those things are way huge. Get a cross over vehicle. Those are almost as roomy as suburbans but probably get better gas mileage. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

Suburbans are gas hogs. Mini-vans are dorky. :0) 

Atasca Mom --- 18 years ago -

Mini-vans are dorky I have a Nissan Quest and I dont think it is dorky. I love love love it. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

I agree that mini-vans are roomy and practical and loaded with all kinds of neat stuff, I have seen my friends vans, but they are so not cool. 

Atasca Mom --- 18 years ago -

they are so not cool. I am a busy 35 year old mom. "Practical" outweighs "cool" these days :o) 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

"Practical" outweighs "cool" these days :o) I hear you. Unless you have self esteem issues go with the mini van. 

Lillabeth --- 18 years ago -

Practical" outweighs "cool" these days :o) No kidding. We have an Expedition, a Sport Trac, and a Mini Van. I really like my van. I love how I can push a button and the doors open and close. Very easy to get the kids in and out. Plus it holds more than the Expedition. 

Momof3 --- 18 years ago -

I have a love hate relationship with my mini-van. I do think they're pretty uncool but you just can't beat those sliding doors in parking lots and in the garage. The cargo area is very flexible and not too high up to load into. It's also great to be able to change the seating in my Odyssey. I used to have a Nissan Armada and I don't miss pulling out and feeling that the hood of the car was sticking out too far into the next lane. The mini vans definitely serve their purpose. I would move to a crossover vehicle like the GMC Acadia but the luggage space is nothing like the Odyssey. 

Lillabeth --- 18 years ago -

but the luggage space is nothing like the Odyssey. I couldn't believe how much that van holds. We have an Odyssey. The only problem I'm having is with the stupid nav. system. Although I thinks its operator error. Oh, and you gotta go with the back up camera!! 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

I am a busy 35 year old mom. "Practical" outweighs "cool" these days :o) I agree. Thank goodness I only have one kiddo to tote around. Unless you have self esteem issues go with the mini van. I have self esteem issues when it comes to mini vans, lol. 

Atasca Mom --- 18 years ago -

Think about this-- You stop in front of the school in the morning.. push 2 buttons and everyone gets OUT! Push em again, the doors close and you roll out! Love it!! 

jtcitrus --- 18 years ago -

My dad had a suburban my entire life. It's hard to beat for utility. Sure you can fit 8-9 people w/ room for luggage left over. I had 8 fraternity brothers and luggage on a 24 hr road trip and we did just fine. Plus: JD-Power rated the suburban the most reliable SUV on the road. Just be good about the regular maintenance and it will last forever. However, the fuel economy is terrible. It get's in the teens. The only good mileage on a REAL SUV is on the Tahoe/Yukon hybrid ~(20/26) 

ladybeachbum --- 18 years ago -

I am a long time owner of Suburbans, but my very favorite auto with children was my custom van. That thing was pure luxury driving with a family! I still drool when I see one. The gas was not great but I am telling you we could bring everything and then shop on vacation and still have room. I now have the Yukon hybrid and I love it when driving but I miss the room of the suburban. It just doesn't have it. I am considering selling it because I need the space going back and forth hauling junk to the beach. It does get great milage 20/22 for an SUV. If you drive 25 you are only on battery and not using gas.. I did rent a minivan in Florida and loved the doors, but no way did we have the same space as the suburban. Some are extended versions though and this was just a normal mini. Also, when I bought furniture for the houses, I could get a couch, loveseat and a chair in the back of my suburban and I do not think any other car can do that. Good luck on whatever you decide. 

willow10 --- 18 years ago -

Whatever you buy - think about parking in a parking garage. Some vehicles (like mine) are too tall. Also, if you have any difficulty parking or manuevering in tight spaces stick with the mini van. Some people can drive huge vehicles and put it in whatever space they want - I'm not one of those people and I wish I would have known that beforehand. 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

no question SUBURBAN. ITS Also AMERICAN made, Keep your money HOME! 

jklucas03 --- 18 years ago -

I just got a suburban, love it so far 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

I have a sweet ride :) Crossover. American Made. Look into them :) 

ilovepugs --- 18 years ago -

Suburbans are bigger inside but I don't think the ride is as smooth and quiet. Gas mileage does suck but my rides like a caddy! Smooth as a baby's butt! no question SUBURBAN. ITS Also AMERICAN made, Keep your money HOME! What Ray said. I so want a Tahoe with that blue/slate color but once the salesman pulled up the back door my mouth dropped! So much more room in the back of a 'burb! 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

The Suburbans and Odyssey's get about the same mpg. My Odyssey gets ~ 15 mpg in town, and have also run out of room. We have been looking at the Suburban/Tahoe/Yukon. Just be sure to price the active cylinder management feature for mpg increase. 

justforfun --- 18 years ago -

Suburban. 

Dana --- 18 years ago -

Suburban. Ditto 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground