Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Do you give back the ring?

who's talking here?

Miss T 1
Carla 1
GCan 2
Lilteapot 1
randyjet 1
FishinKim 1
Ashley ... 1
auntmarsa 1
cowboyswife 1
Deltadawn 2
yesIcan 2
Clown Vomit 1
Mabbers 2
KWMommaX3..now 4! 1
Rachel 2
$AshleyThePrincess$ 1
txdaddy 4
HsMommy 1
*Vanessa* 2
2girlygirls 1
I ♥ My Thông 1
Louisiana Proud 1
Carole 1
cuckoo'snest 2
~sassy~ 2
Diamom 2
Perfection 1
Lillabeth 1
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 1
Peace out 1
TheBatsMeow 1
Danabug 1
PHSMOMOF2 4
Yosamitesa 2
Party Boy!! 1
Nickie 3
Veronica 1
moltobella 1
tamsy 1
~*~ 1
Give Peace A Chance 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you give back the ring?

My BFF's little sister is in college and has been dating a boy for a couple of years. They recently got engaged and planned a wedding for July 2009. This past week, the boy told her he loves her but is not in love with her. Thus, he does not want to get married and wants his ring back. She just ordered and paid for a $1000 wedding gown. My bff says he should buy the gown from her parents and then he could have the ring. I think she should keep both & sell both. He broke it off.

keep the ring. it is hers Vote
 
 72.2% (65)
give it back. he bought it Vote
 
 14.4% (13)
give it back IF he pays for the dress Vote
 
 10.0% (9)
other - please explain Vote
 
 3.3% (3)
Diamom --- 18 years ago -

My BFF's little sister is in college and has been dating a boy for a couple of years. They recently got engaged and planned a wedding for July 2009. This past week, the boy told her he loves her but is not in love with her. Thus, he does not want to get married and wants his ring back. She just ordered and paid for a $1000 wedding gown. My bff says he should buy the gown from her parents and then he could have the ring. I think she should keep both & sell both. He broke it off.  

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

I have heard on Judge Wapner (lol) or something that if HE breaks it off, she gets to keep the ring. If SHE breaks it off, should give it back. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

I broke off my marriage and not only did I keep my rings I kept his also and traded them in for some jewelery I really liked. 

TheBatsMeow --- 18 years ago -

if HE breaks it off, she gets to keep the ring. If SHE breaks it off, should give it back. I agree. I would keep it if I were her. He's too scared to get married, that's not her fault. I just think it's tacky he's asking for it back, I feel it should be her choice to give it back or not. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 18 years ago -

Depends on the laws there, and I'm pretty sure in the state of Texas...she gets to keep the ring because they apply fault to the break up. And she could probably make him responsible for the dress as well. 

Deltadawn --- 18 years ago -

If the ring is a 'family' ring, not one he purchased for her, it would be nice if she gave it back. It isn't his family's fault that he is a chicken butt. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

If the ring is a 'family' ring, not one he purchased for her, it would be nice if she gave it back. It isn't his family's fault that is a chicken butt. I would give it back in that case out of respect for the family. 

HsMommy --- 18 years ago -

If he broke it off then she is should get to keep the ring. Like someone mentioned before if its his familys ring I would give it back. 

tamsy --- 18 years ago -

I agree that if is it a family ring it should be returned.if he is unwilling to help pay for the dress then I would keep it . 

moltobella --- 18 years ago -

f HE breaks it off, she gets to keep the ring. If SHE breaks it off, should give it back. Agreed unless its a family ring. 

Give Peace A Chance --- 18 years ago -

Ok, here's my input as a man. Boys of the world. Grow up. Now's the time you start paying a price for an invaluable lesson that hopefully you will carry out with you for the remaining years on this earth. Sucks, but you will foster in some serious knowledge and maturity if you start owning up to your mistakes now. 1) A woman's heart, although complex, is tender. Once you break it or abuse it then get ready for some wrath be it subtle or full steam. Breaking a woman's heart and withdrawing your promise comes with a price. Sorry, but someone has to pay that price. Be clear about the words that fall out of your mouth for a woman will use them to create a home or use them to wreck your world. Think about what you do because it will follow you for a long long time. 2) Don't be a jerk. Be honest and if you need to break up then do so and get it over with. Don't be fickle. Again, women need emotional security. If you're wishy washy about providing it, do her a favor and get lost. No one wants a bum lingering for an undetermined time frame without ever knowing which way he is going or coming from. Marriage and the INTENTION of marriage is serious. If you're not sure, then DO NOT. Don't destroy someone else's heart while you are still trying to sow yours. 3) It's really NOT about the money. If you have intended on marrying someone but change your mind then remove yourself altogether but do so empty handed. Don't ask for the ring back. It just makes you look like a bigger a$$ and shoves the knife deeper into an already wounded heart. Best thing to do if you feel the need to ask for your promise gift back is find the nearest cliff and leap. 4) Have some sense of honor. Most women dream of a future. If you are the kind of man that cannot see past his penis or tomorrow then DO NOT promise a woman anything unless you can promise her that you'll jump off that cliff. A woman's nature is to live each day filled with sincere promises. Be truthful, loving, considerate, and above all, grow up. Cut your lessons learned and move on WITHOUT the ring. In Texas, you'll be lucky you escaped without a lynching. 

Louisiana Proud --- 18 years ago -

Tell her to keep it, pawn it, and send the little bastard the receipt, along with copies of the bills for her expenses. We had the same thing happen. 

Carole --- 18 years ago -

Wow, I am happily married but I think I love GPAC! Heya if you are around 25 I have a neice I want ya to meet!! LOL 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 18 years ago -

I would give it back, I would not want a reminder of what was. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

Unless I am mistaken, the ring is given in contemplation of marriage. If no marriage takes place, Judge Judy says the ring goes back....lol 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

I would give it back, I would not want a reminder of what was. Or if she's really pissed she could sell it and take all her girlfreinds drinkin! 

Lillabeth --- 18 years ago -

I would give it back, I would not want a reminder of what was. Agreed. Plus it's in comtemplation of marriage. Since a wedding didn't happen by law she has to give it back. 

Yosamitesa --- 18 years ago -

From what I've been told (went through something similar) by my attorney is that the ring is a sign of a contract. If the contract is unfullfilled for ANY reason, the ring goes back to the buyer of the ring. By not giving it back and if she sells it, he can take her to court and the courts will rule in his favor. Sorry!!! I had the dress too and ended up being able to return it to the bridal shop, but I had to pay a restocking fee. I explained the situation and they were VERY sympathetic. Hope that helps! 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

I'm not sure of the laws here in Texas, but normaly the laws say the engagement is represents a contract of marraige, and if marraige does not happen the ring should be returned. She should be happy he had the wisdom to break things off now, and not go through with something that would inevitably bring them both misery. He should pay for the gown though. 

Clown Vomit --- 18 years ago -

I'd take it back, finger and all if I had to. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

Isn't the ring given as a promise to fullfil a contract? He's defaulted on the promise. It's like a deposit on a banquet hall. You back out, you're out your deposit. If she had backed out though, I would have expected her to return the ring. 

Yosamitesa --- 18 years ago -

I'd contact an attorney and ask. If they can't help you then contact legal aid. They will be able to help you. Don't want you to get sued over it... 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 18 years ago -

My goodness its a ring, give the thing back. It represents nothing if no relationship or marriage took place. I dont see a need for lawyers and court, it will take more to pay for the courts time if you do that. Dont be spiteful , there are plenty of fish in the sea, give it back and be done with it. Elizabeth-here we go again agreeing, cant believe that. hope you are well. Take care sweetie. 

Veronica --- 18 years ago -

He gave her the ring! Gave..you dont ask for something back, once you have given it back, especially if HE called off the wedding. Poor girl! She needs to keep that ring. 

Deltadawn --- 18 years ago -

Helpful info This was supposed to be stated as a question - sorry about that. 

*Vanessa* --- 18 years ago -

As long as it's not a family ring I would also keep it. BUT if he is not in love with her then it's a good thing he called it off now. I know she is hurt and upset now but if he married her and then they had kids it would be 100x worse. 

2girlygirls --- 18 years ago -

I wouldn't want to keep it. I broke off an engagement (mutually) and I gave the ring back. Keeping it would be bad karma. Kind of like holding on to your bitterness over the breakup. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 18 years ago -

It doesnt matter if he gave it to her. He gave it to her with the intent of marrying the girl, now that he has broken it off she should give it back because they are not getting married, two its a RING not an organ. 

~*~ --- 18 years ago -

I have heard on Judge Wapner (lol) or something that if HE breaks it off, she gets to keep the ring. If SHE breaks it off, should give it back. I agree with this. Maybe she can return the dresss???? 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 18 years ago -

Better that he broke it off now then be married a few years and want a divorce. Look break ups happen all the damn time. Some more severe than others, Its only a ring that bears no symbol other than an engagement, a promise to a marrigage. Since niether will continue why keep the ring? why hold on to something that will not be there? 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

I think the fact he's demanding it would make me keep it. LOL. 

Ashley ... --- 18 years ago -

When Dh & I got engaged he said if you break up with me I get the ring back but if he was the heartbreaker I could keep the ring. (He was just being silly) Most places will not let you return a wedding dress. If she wants the ring she should keep it unless it's a family ring. I don't think I would want the ring it would just be a reminder of what a jerk he was! A gift is a gift though. 

Give Peace A Chance --- 18 years ago -

Wow, I am happily married but I think I love GPAC! Heya if you are around 25 I have a neice I want ya to meet!! LOL 40. 2 kids. Locked in. :) 

Miss T --- 18 years ago -

if HE breaks it off, she gets to keep the ring. If SHE breaks it off, should give it back. I think I go with Judge Wapner on this one.. 

yesIcan --- 18 years ago -

Better that he broke it off now then be married a few years and want a divorce. So true!! But I would keep it and have it melted down into something else. Or sell it to help pay for the dress. 

GCan --- 18 years ago -

My dad got his ring back after calling off his engagement. Initially his girlfriend refused and then she sent him a letter with the enclosed ring. He gave then gave it to my mom. She didn't care that it had belonged to someone else. Dad bought mom her own ring a few months later but she ended up giving that ring to my grandmother. Mom wore the first fiancee's ring for the remainder of her life and resisted numerous attempts to buy her another one. 

Nickie --- 18 years ago -

I wouldn't give it back if he broke it off unless it was a family ring. It could help pay for the dress that you know he isn't gonna fork over money for. However, if I had been the one to break it off, I would give it back. 

cowboyswife --- 18 years ago -

I would give it back, I would not want a reminder of what was. Agreed. Plus it's in comtemplation of marriage. Since a wedding didn't happen by law she has to give it back. Agreed. 

yesIcan --- 18 years ago -

I wouldn't give it back if he broke it off unless it was a family ring. Family ring, that's a good point. 

*Vanessa* --- 18 years ago -

I had a friend whos dad loved to be engaged but would never marry them. Once the girl got a clue and left him he would take the ring and give it to the next girl he met. I was many or women wear that ring.....It was so sad. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground