Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Can Someone Explain Something?

who's talking here?

stampin' gal 4
Punkalicious 4
~grandma again~ 3
planemom 8
baseballmom 1
Zionist NightOwl 1
SomeTexasChic 2
$AshleyThePrincess$ 5
justforfun 1
greengirl 1
Forecaster 1
rEVOLution 1
Danielle 3
Wilstar77 6
Big Ben 8
Party Boy!! 1
Squareduck 1
will4u2 1
SiLVERNELLS 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

Please someone explain something to me. How come the popular vote can be 50%/49% but yet there is a landslide in the electoral votes. Whats the point of even voting if the popular doesn't decide the election? Yes, I am admiting my ignorance of the electoral college. Can someone please explain to me how this works. And please no Bull$hit. This is a serious question. 

justforfun --- 18 years ago -

I can't explain because I would like to know. 

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

i have always wondered this also. that is why i had never voted because i felt that the people didn't matter just the electoral. this year i did change that decision. i voted! 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

In most states all the electoral votes go to the winner. That is why the winners of the popular vote and the electoral votes can be different. 

greengirl --- 18 years ago -

Hey, I'm with ya Big Ben. it's C-R-A-Z-Y! But hey, it's America baby and America is G-R-E-A-T, right? :) I'd answer your question honestly but I really do not know "why" it's that way. I just know it is. 

$AshleyThePrincess$ --- 18 years ago -

Please someone explain something to me. How come the popular vote can be 50%/49% but yet there is a landslide in the electoral votes. Whats the point of even voting if the popular doesn't decide the election? Yes, I am admiting my ignorance of the electoral college. I was just discussing this with dh! I think its BS 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

The number of electoral votes each state has is based on the number of seats that state holds in congress. For example: ND has 2 senators and 1 member of the house of representatives, so it has 3 electoral votes. 

$AshleyThePrincess$ --- 18 years ago -

But whats the whole point in voting though for president if OUR vote doesnt really matter? 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

The number of electoral votes each state has is based on the number of seats that state holds in congress. For example: ND has 2 senators and 1 member of the house of representatives, so it has 3 electoral votes. But what decides the electoral votes? Looking online, they are very very close with the popular vote, but its a landslide in the electoral. Seriously, why the hell even vote, if ours doesn't count. 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

The difference between 50% and 49% could be a few million votes. That's a lot. 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

But what decides the electoral votes? Each state gets electoral votes based on that state's population. 

Squareduck --- 18 years ago -

That is why the system is SCREWED UP. The people do not have a voice! 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

If we went with popular vote, Gore would be finishing his second term. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

The electoral system gives smaller states some say in national elections. If it was based only on popular votes than states with larger populations would control each election. 

$AshleyThePrincess$ --- 18 years ago -

Each state gets electoral votes based on that state's population. Ok so lemme take a shot at this... So whoever wins in the popular vote in each state gets the electoral vote? Im confused! Or are the electoral votes a select few people that are the the HOR (like planemom said) that vote and THEIR decision is the one that counts? 

~grandma again~ --- 18 years ago -

The electoral system gives smaller states some say in national elections. If it was based only on popular votes than states with larger populations would control each election. exactly, and it makes perfect sense to me. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

The difference between 50% and 49% could be a few million votes. That's a lot. right now its 200,000. But last time I checked 175/55 is hardly 50%/49%. Sorry, it doesn't make since. Not trying to start a political war here, but i would like an explanation on why the two numbers vary. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Each state gets electoral votes based on that state's population. Kind of. The states population determines the number of members it has in the house of representatives. You add that number to the number of senators (2) and you get the number of electoral votes. When you vote your are not really voting for McCain or Obama. You are voting for the elector (?) who will go to DC in December and cast the official vote. I don't think it has ever happened but the electors do not have to cast their ballots for the person who won in their state. 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

So whoever wins in the popular vote in each state gets the electoral vote? YES. 

$AshleyThePrincess$ --- 18 years ago -

only on popular votes than states with larger populations would control each election. I dont see how that has anything to do with it, not everyone in ONE state is for Mccain/Obama its mixed so I think thats BS (not saying what YOU are saying is BS but the good Ol' USA's method is screwed up) 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Not trying to start a political war here, but i would like an explanation on why the two numbers vary. McCain is losing by very slim margins. All of the electoral votes go the winner. It makes a huge difference in states with large number of electoral votes. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

Basically, I am understanding, our vote doesn't matter and the whole system is a bunch of bs. They say every vote counts, but I am now figuring out, it doesn't. Its kind of like the they are assuming that is what we want. ASS/U/ME 

Party Boy!! --- 18 years ago -

thats just the way the founding fathers decided it should be. It goes back to them wanting more states rights and the electoral vote being based upon the population of each state. i dont agree with it, but it is what it is. At this point Im just hoping McCain pulls off the popular vote and the second time in the history of our country a president will win the electoral vote and not the popular vote and win the election. The last time was with Bush/Gore in 2000 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

Basically, I am understanding, our vote doesn't matter and the whole system is a bunch of bs. They say every vote counts, but I am now figuring out, it doesn't. It's only BS when your guy doesn't win. 

$AshleyThePrincess$ --- 18 years ago -

Sorry my stupid sisters boyfriend was on here AGAIN uuugh 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

i think a fair way to do it would be that each candidate gets a percentage of the electoral votes from their state based on the votes. Example: texas has 34 electoral votes. 10 percent vote democratic So, the democrat gets 3 electoral votes and the other 31 go to the republican candidate. That would seem to me to be more representative of the popular vote AND would still let the smaller states have their say. 

SomeTexasChic --- 18 years ago -

I'm looking on yahoo, and it shows that McCain won the popular vote in Maryland and Minnesota, and Obama ended up winning the state. If I lived there, I would be pissed that my opinion really didn't matter. This is the map I have been looking at tonight. Yahoo Edited to add: Someone goofed on the site, the popular vote has now been adjusted. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I dont see how that has anything to do with it When the founding fathers set up the system they didn't want the areas with the larger populations to be able to run roughshod over lightly populated areas. That is why each state has two senators, giving all states equal power, and the house is based on population, giving greater power to larger states. They did their best to set it up so one part of the country couldn't determine the fate of the country. 

will4u2 --- 18 years ago -

I don't understand the system either, we have the means to count every vote, let the one with the most votes win. I mean each individual vote. That way everyone vote counts. 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

Example: texas has 34 electoral votes. 10 percent vote democratic So, the democrat gets 3 electoral votes and the other 31 go to the republican candidate. Your wrong. Electoral votes don't split. The winner of Texas gets all 34 votes. Only 2 states in the Union split their vote. New Hampshire and North Dakota I think. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

not to say that texas is 90% republican.......it was just an example! :) 

SomeTexasChic --- 18 years ago -

She was saying it would be more fair if the votes were split, not that that is how it is done. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

Your wrong. Electoral votes don't split yes, i realize that. what i said was it would be more FAIR my way. I know they don't split.....thus the problem with a HUGE disparity in electoral votes and so close (relatively) in popular vote. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

It's only BS when your guy doesn't win. If he wins it fair and square because that is what America voted and they went by the popular vote were every single vote counted, then I would not be griping. I know your a hardcore dem and Im a hardcore pub, and personally I have nothing against you. But when your fed that your vote counts and you find out it dont, its a tough pill to swallow. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

Let's hand it to the dems. They managed to elect a man and get duped and are still happy with their selection. Start writing your checks so the lot of them can sit on their duffs and get their free health care and some of our hard earned money. They accomplished something most couldn't do but I still hold firm to my conservative beliefs and those are moral beliefs. 

Punkalicious --- 18 years ago -

I know your a hardcore dem and Im a hardcore pub this is what i dont understand....how can you be a hardcore anything and not even understand the electoral college? 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

this is what i dont understand....how can you be a hardcore anything and not even understand the electoral college? Actually, neither one of us really understand, we both admitted it. Since you here to criticize, do you care to explain? 

~grandma again~ --- 18 years ago -

i don't understand how anyone can graduate from high school and not know this. don't they teach government in school anymore? we had to totally understand it and set up the system before we got credit for government....well, that was many years ago though and many things have changed in schools since then, i guess. i am not being ugly or smart alec about it, i am just wondering. i do hope your children will be taught the importance of understanding how our electoral college works. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

don't understand how anyone can graduate from high school and not know this. don't they teach government in school anymore? we had to totally understand it and set up the system before we got credit for government.... GA I wish I did get to learn it. I went to school in a Small East Texas High School with a govt. and economics teacher who was a year away from retiring. So, I didn't get to learn about this. Like I stated earlier, not trying to start a political war, I just want to know how it works. 

Punkalicious --- 18 years ago -

now that i reread it...i sound like a biatch...sorry (story of my life) i really wasnt trying to be mean i dont do politics...remember about the electoral college from us govt in a college course...but i know i dont know so i dont vote, and i dont complain i just wish more people were educated on what they believe/vote for/etc. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground