Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is being humiliated by Target worth 3 Million?

who's talking here?

Miss T 2
Melanie 1
JDB2 3
randyjet 2
sunshine1881 2
Fancy 1
planemom 7
steinhoister 3
Mabbers 1
★ † 12 Stones † ★ 1
*Vanessa* 1
Angela 2
KayCat 1
~sassy~ 1
Perfection 2
OH SNAP! 1
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 2
GTV3 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Or is the humiliation of spending over 100 bucks in Target bad enough? I don't agree that the actions of an employee in Target are right - but to be awarded 3.1 Million for it? That's just as wrong. Woman awarded 3 Million  

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 18 years ago -

well, at least she got to clear the taint. edited to add....no one likes a messy taint. 

★ † 12 Stones † ★ --- 18 years ago -

it is ridiculous. people cannot accept "sorry " anymore. yes of course being humiliated like this is terrible but please! 

*Vanessa* --- 18 years ago -

OMG that is crazy!!! If her child has died in Target I bet she wouldn't have won that much. 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

Umm, they sent an email to other retailers containing her picture and making false allegations about it. It ruined her reputation. She deserves every penny of it. She did nothing wrong. It's not her fault they were stupid and didn't recognize or real bill. 

Miss T --- 18 years ago -

But a store employee sent out an e-mail to dozens of other retailers and law enforement agencies warning them that Cantrell was a shoplifter who tried to spend bogus cash. The e-mail also included Cantrell's picture. that was a little excessive, don't you think? 

Miss T --- 18 years ago -

If it was just that the one store did not want the bills, ok, but to send out an email like that? I hope that employee was fired! 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

She did what she needed to in order to clear her name. How many e-mails were sent out? Would she have had to explain this false accusation over and over again every time she went to one of the businesses that received the false e-mail? The punitive damages might seem excessive but the article doesn't say how they arrived at the $3.1 million figure. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

and making false allegations "without substantial proof of wrongdoing." Doesn't exactly mean the allegations were false... 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

The bill was real, police said. 

sunshine1881 --- 18 years ago -

The bill was real, police said. Obviously the allegations were false. 

GTV3 --- 18 years ago -

that was a little excessive, don't you think? I normally hate these kinds of lawsuits, like the McDonalds coffee one, but this one I agree with. Fine.. if you think she is using fake bills, call a manager, refuse her sale and send her home, whatever, but this is WAY overboard. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Target must have changed their policy. DHDSC (used to be Targets parent company) used to say to take the bill and call security and let security handle it. That was 20 years ago though. 

GTV3 --- 18 years ago -

Target must have changed their policy. DHDSC (used to be Targets parent company) used to say to take the bill and call security and let security handle it. That was 20 years ago though. That is a much better way to handle. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Federal agents showed up at her workplace? Mass e-mail with her picture? Oh hell no. I'd take the three million without a stinkin' doubt. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

The bill was real, police said. Obviously the allegations were false. hope you guys aren't on a jury anytime soon...this particular bill was good. The story does not answer weather the woman was a shoplifter that used fake bills. It states that this particular bill was good...and that she knew the e-mail existed. Don't you think that if she knew the e-mail had been sent that she would then only bring a good bill? The bottom line is that none of us have all of the facts. Juries have done worse and theives have won many times. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

But a store employee sent out an e-mail to dozens of other retailers and law enforement agencies warning them that Cantrell was a shoplifter who tried to spend bogus cash. The e-mail also included Cantrell's picture Yeah, I tend to believe she got what she deserved. They branded her a shop lifter on top of everything else. Besides 3 mil is pocket change to Target 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

hope you guys aren't on a jury anytime soon...this particular bill was good. The story does not answer weather the woman was a shoplifter that used fake bills. It states that this particular bill was good...and that she knew the e-mail existed. Don't you think that if she knew the e-mail had been sent that she would then only bring a good bill? I believe the e-mail was sent out AFTER they thought her real bill was fake. and I would've sued too. Her employer and her fellow employees, and everyone who got that e-mail knows about this. 

steinhoister --- 18 years ago -

hope you guys aren't on a jury anytime soon...this particular bill was good. The story does not answer weather the woman was a shoplifter that used fake bills. It states that this particular bill was good... You don't think a judge would have reviewed all the facts before taking it to trial? WE may not have them but I would be sure that the judge did. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

You don't think a judge would have reviewed all the facts before taking it to trial? different motivation though. Remember various Walmart cases? The OJ trial? Maybe this woman was substantially wronged and maybe Target is to blame....maybe the person that sent the e-mail is to blame but Target has deeper pockets.... I'd like to think that if I were wronged I would come up with a creative solution that would actually solve a problem...like a public retraction with equal time, or at least something equitable. What is $3M going to do? 

steinhoister --- 18 years ago -

What is $3M going to do? If you did something that cost you $3M chances are you wouldn't do it again... 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

If you did something that cost you $3M chances are you wouldn't do it again... But the person who sent the email isn't responsible for the $3M. The store did not direct them to send the email. The store did not play a part in this problem. Why should they pay? Why didn't she sue the person individually for slander if she was so concerned about the email? 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 18 years ago -

Why should they pay? because they are responsible for the actions of their employees!! 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

The $3M is enough to get Targets attention. An employee of theirs screwed up and the judge wants Target to ensure it doesn't happen again. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Why didn't she sue the person individually for slander if she was so concerned about the email? The name Target probably appeared on all of the faxes and e-mails sent. Target is responsible for the actions of all of their employees. 

steinhoister --- 18 years ago -

But the person who sent the email isn't responsible for the $3M. The store did not direct them to send the email. The store did not play a part in this problem. Why should they pay? The employee was in an official target capacity, the actions of the employee ARE the ations of Target. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I wonder what was left out of the article? How big was the confrontation between the employee and the lady? What happened to piss off the employee to the point of sending out faxes and emails? 

randyjet --- 18 years ago -

In Texas the all Republican Supreme Court would overturn the entire verdict and force the woman to pay the court expenses for Target. The GOP judges have no respect for the rights of the individual against the corporations and throw out verdicts against corporations 87% of the time. The GOP has also taken away our rights to recover damages for most things as well. The Court of Criminal Appeals is even worse if possible. We had a guy in Porter who was convicted of kidnapping, raping and killing a woman on the sole testimony that he told a co-worker that he forced a woman to have oral sex with him. There was no evidence against him, his employer said that he could not have had time to do anything other than work, given the amount of trees he had cut down. The judge let the trial go forward, and when the jury found him guilty with no evidence, overturned the verdict. The state appealed, won, and he served 9years in prison. DNA evidence was then shown to NOT be his, and the Court of Criminal Appeals basically said, it does NOT matter. They agreed with Supreme Court Justice Scalia, who famously said, "Innocence is NO bar to conviction." Bush finally did a decent thing, and granted a petition that I signed to grant him a pardon, and he was released. The FACT is that the Republicans have taken and will continue to take away all of our rights if you vote for them in judicial races. 

KayCat --- 18 years ago -

Back in my retail management days I always carried a counterfeit detector pen for $100 bills ... I see that they're still being sold. You'd think that a large corporation like Target would provide them to their cashiers & managers. I think that they would be a lot cheaper than a $3 million lawsuit. 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

that was a little excessive, don't you think? A lot excessive! 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

Don't you think that if she knew the e-mail had been sent that she would then only bring a good bill? The email was sent after she tried to use the $100 bill. 

Angela --- 18 years ago -

The email was sent after she tried to use the $100 bill. I think what he was saying was...If you knew that the e-mail was sent out and knew they would be questioning you. Wouldn't you be carrying around a real one at this point. Just in case. And not the original if it was indeed fake. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

.If you knew that the e-mail was sent out and knew they would be questioning you. Wouldn't you be carrying around a real one at this point. Just in case. And not the original if it was indeed fake. Most criminals aren't that smart. I tend to believe the woman was wronged. 

randyjet --- 18 years ago -

A lot excessive! The jury heard the case and the award was mostly for punitive damages. She was only awarded $100,000 for actual damages which seems about right to me. They obviously heard some evidence that made them think that such an award was needed. 

Angela --- 18 years ago -

Most criminals aren't that smart. I tend to believe the woman was wronged. I didn't say that she wasn't wronged. What I was trying to do was explain what I thought that jbd was saying. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground