Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Question on Obama's Tax Claims

who's talking here?

Carla 1
Fallon 1
randyjet 1
Justwatching72 2
Sandyr9111 1
NoNameNoLastName 23
donottreadonme 1
R.E.B. 1
david 10
Dynomite 2
bruiserbetty* 8
onestepforward 1
OH SNAP! 11
jmbtx78 23
Party Boy!! 1
razumikhin 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

I have a serious question here. I have yet to read every last detail of Obama's tax plan, so I'm hoping one of his supporters can give me a nutshell answer of this question. If he's going to cut taxes to 95% of people, but 33 percent already have no tax liability, is he just going to be giving those 33% some "free" money? If so, where is this "free" money going to come from? Please let me know how this is going to work.  

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

Bueller....? Bueller.....? Anyone? 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

is he just going to be giving those 33% some "free" money? no other way to explain it. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

If he's going to cut taxes to 95% of people, Dont know how the hell he thinks he can do this when our country is drowning in debt. He can talk big all he wants but wont happen. 

razumikhin --- 18 years ago -

The issue to try and understand (which I haven't read enough to know) is does Obama's plan give any new refundable tax credits. This is the code words for what you refer to as "free money". I just don't know, but doubt it as conservatives would likely be highlighting this. On the other hand, I find it interesting that your link indicates that the proportion of those w/ no tax liability will increase under both McCain's and Obama's plans to about the same number (33% now to 43% for McCain and 44% for Obama). Didn't know this and wouldn't have guessed it. 

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

On the other hand, I find it interesting that your link indicates that the proportion of those w/ no tax liability will increase under both McCain's and Obama's plans to about the same number (33% now to 43% for McCain and 44% for Obama). Didn't know this and wouldn't have guessed it. Yeah, that was quite surprising to me as well. The issue to try and understand (which I haven't read enough to know) is does Obama's plan give any new refundable tax credits. This is the code words for what you refer to as "free money". I just don't know, but doubt it as conservatives would likely be highlighting this. There's a ton of stuff conservatives need to be highlighting more - but that's a different topic. If he's not giving them refundable tax credits, then he's lying about cutting taxes to 95% of people in this country. If you're not giving them the money, then you can't reduce zero tax any lower. That's what I'm trying to figure out. 

R.E.B. --- 18 years ago -

Obama will eliminate Bush's tax cuts. McCain will not. That will be an automatic tax increase under Obama. Then you throw in spending. McCain is planning on going in and cutting government spending line by line. Obama is planning on increasing it. 

Party Boy!! --- 18 years ago -

Then you throw in spending. McCain is planning on going in and cutting government spending line by line. Obama is planning on increasing it. After bailing out AIG and the like so they can go have a luxury resort getaway, Im thinking more government spending is not the answer. 

donottreadonme --- 18 years ago -

He can talk big all he wants but wont happen. Bingo Sandy People need to quite voting for miracle workers ain't no such thing and you just set yourself up for disappointment. Rather to go with the devil you know than the devil you don't know. ;) 

Dynomite --- 18 years ago -

If Obama eliminates Bush's Tax plan Obama will be raising taxes on everyone.He can call it anything he wants but he will cut Bush's tax plan when in reality will raise everyone's taxes.How hard is this to understand? He can use the excuse I didn't raise your taxes but if he eliminates Bush's tax plan then our taxes go up so yes he is raising everyone's taxes without coming out and saying that. This will mean more of a tax increase on any business that make over 250 thousand.In the long run these corporations will either close their doors or start cutting the work force.Is this really what anyone wants? 

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

Well, he has mentioned that he will likely renew the tax cuts for the middle class only. So he's not entirely eliminating the Bush cuts - and we all know we'll get taxed even more via various other methods, but none of that applies to my question. He's so adament that 95% of us are going to see cuts - that is literally his #1 talking point that I've seen. He obviously has to have a plan to make that happen and I'm looking for an Obama supporter to explain how he plans to do it. 

Dynomite --- 18 years ago -

I can only add to you comment that he can only tax 55 percent because 40 percent of the people do not work so yet again Obama lies and double talks around the issue. 

razumikhin --- 18 years ago -

Agree that to answer this question, you have to define what he means by "people". I don't think it is the same as your definition since 40% seems like a rather large number. If you are including children (who are usually dependents on tax returns) and non-working spouses (who are usually covered by joint tax returns) and retirees (who don't work, but usually do pay taxes on SS and pension benefits) then your 40% number may be plausible. I think he is really meaning something closer to "taxpayers" as his basis when he says 95%. 

razumikhin --- 18 years ago -

On second thought, maybe "tax filers" would be a better definition than "taxpayers". 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

undefined 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

onestep, we have seen the chart.... continually reposting it still does not answer the questions posed. see jbm...they CAN'T answer it because they dont, because obama does not know. 

randyjet --- 18 years ago -

I find it interesting that McCain makes sure that HE and his wife get the biggest tax cuts under his plan. Would that be considered a conflict of interest? McCain also loves the idea of increasing taxes on our health benefits that companies pay. So he is actually INCREASING taxes on the middle class. That is not mentioned in the chart. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

continually reposting it still does not answer the questions posed. It doesn't if you are a McCain supporter... For everyone else, the chart is pretty clear. 

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

Uh - thanks, but this doesn't help address the question at all. 

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

It doesn't if you are a McCain supporter... For everyone else, the chart is pretty clear Again, the question is: how do you cut taxes to 95% of taxpayers, when 33% of them already pay no tax? It's a pretty straightforward question. How do you cut tax on those who already don't pay any? 

david --- 18 years ago -

show me a chart that takes into account everything and see what it shows, example dividend tax, windfall tax, tax on retirement and lets see how those numbers really compare! 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

how do you cut taxes to 95% of taxpayers, when 33% of them already pay no tax? If you pay no taxes, are you a taxpayer? 

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

how do you cut taxes to 95% of taxpayers, when 33% of them already pay no tax? If you pay no taxes, are you a taxpayer? Yes, you are. You pay and are re-imbursed by the government - thus zeroing out your tax liability. Plus, if you want to use your chart above, it takes into consideration those making under the thresholds for tax liability (which vary by filing status), and shows their taxes going down. Again - how is that possible? 

david --- 18 years ago -

is there a chart avaialble that figures in the increased taxes that obama wants to do so we can match apples to apples? 

Justwatching72 --- 18 years ago -

Plus, if you want to use your chart above, it takes into consideration those making under the thresholds for tax liability (which vary by filing status), and shows their taxes going down. Again - how is that possible? They will NEVER give you a straight answer jmb, they don't know. It doesn't if you are a McCain supporter... For everyone else, the chart is pretty clear. Quit following me around little puppy dog , here is a treat for you..now shooo *pat*pat*pat* 

razumikhin --- 18 years ago -

There do appear to be some refundable tax credits in Obama's plan. Again, my understanding of these is that you get a check even if your tax liability is less than the credit. 1) a $1000 "Making Work Pay" tax credit. 2) a $4000 tax credit for college education 3) universal mortgage interest tax credit for "low and middle class homeowners" 4) expansion of existing health care, earned income, and child care tax credit This would seem to provide the vehicles needed to deliver "tax cuts" to a the "non-paying" taxpayers. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Yes, you are. You pay and are re-imbursed by the government You pay taxes, you are reimbursed, if you pay less taxes, but your reimbursement is the same (for example, credit for children under 18), then if you are really poor you are actually receiving an incentive. What's the difficulty here? I don't get it. Is this the best you guys can do to attack Obama? No wonder your campaign is in the sh!tter... 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Quit following me around little puppy dog , here is a treat for you..now shooo *pat*pat*pat* Oh, I thought you were going to ignore me... You can't resist, can you? 

david --- 18 years ago -

So I see your avoiding the ? About a real chart that covers every aspect of the candidates plan once again higher taxes on retirement,dividend,and windfalls. You know this will show obama actually with a higher tax per $ then mccain 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

So I see your avoiding the ? About a real chart that covers every aspect of the candidates plan once again higher taxes on retirement,dividend,and windfalls. The question was about 95% vs. 33%. That was answered. Now you are changing topics. Since you seem to know that for certain, you must have real data to prove it. Care to share? Or are you just pulling this out of you know where? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Since we are changing topics and checking on the candidates' promises, how can McCain claim to support veterans and take care of them when he has a 20% score and Obama has 80%? Source. 

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

You pay taxes, you are reimbursed, if you pay less taxes, but your reimbursement is the same (for example, credit for children under 18), then if you are really poor you are actually receiving an incentive. What's the difficulty here? I don't get it. I'm just looking to discuss this issue. I don't take Obama at face value - and am looking for a good solid debate on his #1 talking point. Based on your answer, as well as Raz's post above, having to pay zero taxes to the government isn't good enough - you will be getting more on top of that, correct? In your words: then if you are really poor you are actually receiving an incentive. If so - then we'll put aside the fact that it appears being "poor" will become more adventageous, and move on to the next question. Keep in mind, this is something Obama already has as his plan that he pushes to anyone who listens to him talk. How does he intend to fund these "extras"? Based on your chart above (which I've used twice now - maybe it does apply here - my apologies), is it a solid assumption to make that it will be funded by the significant tax increases on the top percentage of tax payers? 

OH SNAP! --- 18 years ago -

Obama will eliminate Bush's tax cuts. McCain will not. That will be an automatic tax increase under Obama. Then you throw in spending. McCain is planning on going in and cutting government spending line by line. Obama is planning on increasing it. OK, first of all, the Bush tax cuts were a joke. As I stated in another thread, what good does a slight decrease in taxes do us when his disastrous economic policies have now caused the cost of living to go through the roof and the unemployment rate to rise significantly? As far as increasing government spending, Obama and McCain were both very clear on their stances during the debate. Both support decreasing government spending, and both have said they will take a thorough look at where money is being wasted and do away with those programs. Obama took it a step further and said he would also retool the programs that are working to make them even more efficient. Again, the economy is not JUST about taxes and decreasing government spending. Obama is focused on alleviating some of the burden on the middle class, which is what separates us from the rest of the world, which is slowly but surely being eroded. The poor are getting poorer and the rich are getting richer. The gap between the wealthiest and the poorest has never been higher. The only solution is to bolster the middle class and Obama seems to have a much better understanding of that than McCain does. 

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

Since we are changing topics and checking on the candidates' promises David - avoid changing the subject in this thread - we're close to the answer here and I don't want to stray from the main debate. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

being "poor" will become more adventageous So you are saying it is better to make $19K a year so you can make an extra $600? What's the advantage of being poor? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

we're close to the answer here Wasn't your original question answered? 

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

So you are saying it is better to make $19K a year so you can make an extra $600? What's the advantage of being poor? I said "putting that aside" - ignore it and answer the main question please. 

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

Wasn't your original question answered? One of two - yes. read the whole first post. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Look at the chart. It tells you where the money is coming from, plus ending the war in Iraq, closing corporate loopholes, etc. Go to Obama's site for details. McCain is cutting taxes for everyone - including those who make more money than they can spend (isn't that the definition of "rich"?). Where is the money coming from? We all know that pork barrel alone won't do it. 

jmbtx78 --- 18 years ago -

Look at the chart. It tells you where the money is coming from, plus ending the war in Iraq, closing corporate loopholes, etc. Go to Obama's site for details. Ok, that's what I thought. He's taking it from those who have it, and redistributing it to those who don't. Isn't that called socialism? 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground