Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Were you for or against the bailout plan?

who's talking here?

JDB2 2
NoNameNoLastName 20
donottreadonme 7
R.E.B. 1
Tmans mom 1
~sassy~ 3
clever 5
Forecaster 3
rEVOLution 2
brian* 8
bruiserbetty* 1
bbraz 1
keepinitreal09 3
Warren Peace 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Were you for or against the bailout plan?

Curious to see where people stand on this.

For Vote
 
 35.2% (25)
Against Vote
 
 64.8% (46)
NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Curious to see where people stand on this. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

The way it was presented, I'm against it. History has taught me that anytime government wants to rush something through, as is the case now, there is usually a lot to hide and they are trying to sweep it under the rug. Too many red flags for me. Here's an idea. Take that $700 billion that our government all of a sudden came up with and disperse it evenly amongst everyone who filed a tax return. Watch our economy jump then.... 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Watch our economy jump then.... And let financial institutions go bankrupt? Watch our economy go down the cliff then. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Here is a quick summary of the plan - # The treasury secretary will get $700 billion over time to buy troubled financial assets as he sees fit # The government gets stock warrants in companies getting money # He can hire firms to help manage the assets without competitive bidding # Two oversight bodies will be created to try to minimize cronyism and bad deals # Some kind of industry-funded insurance program will be set up to prevent repetitions of this drama # Corporate tax deductions for executive pay will be limited to $500,000/yr # Golden parachutes for fired executives will be prohibited under certain circumstances # Home owners may get assistance to prevent foreclosure provided it doesn't cost the government # If the government has not recouped its money in 5 years, it may institute a tax on securities transactions It is not a bad plan... 

clever --- 18 years ago -

I am for it..I am thinking of everyone who will suffer if we don't pass this..It's not only the top guys but it's the little people as well.. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

It's not only the top guys but it's the little people as well.. It looks like we agree on something :-) 

clever --- 18 years ago -

It's not only the top guys but it's the little people as well.. It looks like we agree on something :-) Politics aside I have a lot of respect for you.. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

So what the hell has been happening in the last 2 months that has all of a sudden got us in crisis mode?? Our President was just telling us it's "all good". Paulson was saying we had strong economic indicators. It's time to quit playing politics with all this and get this country back on track. Enough finger pointing. Enough executives leading their companies to disaster but parachuting out with $20 mil in their pockets. Enough squeezing average Joe like me who pays his bills on time but I will be the one bailing out the risk takers. Screw them. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

What has happened? It's called politics as usual..The dems are trying to show pubs just how bad they can make the economy right now..The ball is in their court..They have the majority vote and could have passed this without any pubs at all..You have to ask yourself why.. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Our president was trying to keep people optimistic, and I think Paulson thought he could keep things under control by rescuing individual institutions. If you don't like it, send them both a letter telling how you feel. BTW, the plan has provision for golden parachutes - # Corporate tax deductions for executive pay will be limited to $500,000/yr # Golden parachutes for fired executives will be prohibited under certain circumstances 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

I like Dave Ramseys idea of saving the housing market which I posted on the bailout thread. Provided most consumers would pay their mortgage if not for the price being so high then I think it's a win/win situation for all. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

You present your case well, NNNLN. I just feel another middle America screwing coming on. The execs will get richer. The risky lendees will still be able to take out loans, and saps like me will feel the tax burden. Enough already. Enough. Let them take their lumps for awhile. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

You present your case well, NNNLN. I just feel another middle America screwing coming on. The execs will get richer. The risky lendees will still be able to take out loans, and saps like me will feel the tax burden. Enough already. Enough. Let them take their lumps for awhile. While their taking their lumps who do you think will suffer the most..We will..Don't support it if you feel like that but please think of the problem going on and how it will affect us all.. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

If you think about it, the total cost is not $700BB. The government get assets and equity participation in the rescued companies. Over time, as they and the economy improve, the government can sell the stocks and recover part of the money back. Saving individual consumers sounds like a good idea, but it would take too long for liquidity to come back to the market, and other financial institutions would go bankrupt before then - or they would be rescued by the government. As I mentioned on the bailout thread, just so you know, the FDIC is assuming risk on $312BB to "help" Citi buy Wachovia. That's what we need to avoid, and that's why an orderly plan is better. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

I just feel another middle America screwing coming on. The execs will get richer. The risky lendees will still be able to take out loans, and saps like me will feel the tax burden. That's why we need to bring back the regulations that were repealed by Reagan and others after him. After the great depression, regulation was put in place to avoid crisis like this one. We had none until the regulations were lifted. Lehman was leveraging $30 on the dollar before going broke. In other words, for every dollar of their own, they borrowed another 30 to invest. This is ridiculous. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

While their taking their lumps who do you think will suffer the most..We will..Don't support it if you feel like that but please think of the problem going on and how it will affect us all.. The people it affects most are those who work for these institutions and those who are leveraged to their eyeballs. That's what I get for being fiscally responsible. My bad. I'll start charging up to my a** like everyone else because that's what our economy is predicated upon. It's crap. It's "new school" thinking that is fundamentally flawed. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

It's "new school" thinking that is fundamentally flawed. When you let greed regulate the market, that's what happens... 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

Lehman was leveraging $30 on the dollar before going broke. In other words, for every dollar of their own, they borrowed another 30 to invest. This is ridiculous. Agreed. So why shouldn't some financially prudent company be able to purchase them in a free market economy? Just asking. Maybe I don't understand enough here. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

It all comes down to consumer responsibility though. The regulations may have been lifted but even if you have candy in front of you you don't have to take it. My car is financed through Wachovia and I transferred enough money today to pay the balance in full. I will work to pay off all our debt more quickly because I believe only the consumers can help this situation as I feel like Brian and have no faith in our government doing anything beneficial. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

Over time, as they and the economy improve, the government can sell the stocks and recover part of the money back. It will never happen. New agency would be created, instead of selling they will buy more, and it won't look anything like it was designed to be. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

some of the facts you guys have presented in this thread are not completely factual. The comments above mine are a regurgitation of what's on the television. Think this through and put it into perspective. You might see it a little differently in many regards! 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

So why shouldn't some financially prudent company be able to purchase them in a free market economy? Would you? I wouldn't. Nor would any financially prudent company. You buy them, you get their assets and liabilities, along with all the risks. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Think this through and put it into perspective. So, what's your take? I have to go, but I'll pick up the discussion tomorrow. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

Most of us live within our means so to say that is wrong..I don't have credit card debt..I watch the money I spend..I don't need the bailout but I am thinking of the smaller people who will suffer so I don't think..reminding people of the big guys is that good..I know all to well that they shouldn't benefit but if you punish them you are hurting the little guys and I for one will not go for that..I couldn't care less for the corporation execs but I do care about the little guys.. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

It all comes down to consumer responsibility though. Yes, it does. However, we also have laws because responsibility alone is not enough to keep a society working. There is always someone who will try to outsmart the others - like borrowing 30 times more money to make more profits... 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

Absolutely. I'd low ball them just I'd low ball any highly leveraged company in the business I'm in now. I'd get it "on the cheap", repair the flaws, then decide to sell it or keep it as a good asset. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

Think this through and put it into perspective. So, what's your take? I have to go, but I'll pick up the discussion tomorrow. jdb, I'd like to know your thoughts too. I've seen your financial advice on here before and you are exceptionally knowledgeable. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

jdb, I'd like to know your thoughts too. From two perspectives - 1. What is the problem (we know how we got here. I think the problem is liquidity. I would like to hear your opinion). 2. If not the bailout plan, how to fix it. 

bruiserbetty* --- 18 years ago -

honestly, i do not understand it enough to say if i am for or against. it is not that easy of a thing to me. 

bbraz --- 18 years ago -

This is what Ted Poe said and I have to agree with him. Today, I stood victorious with the American people and voted NO to defeat the Wall Street “Fat Cat” bail-out, 228-205. The government has no authority to force American taxpayers to ante up a $700 billion ransom to save the hides of the rich robber barons on Wall Street. I believe in a free-market, capitalistic economy. With this freedom comes the opportunity to succeed, but also to fail. The elites in the financial industry don’t understand that with their vast success also comes the potential for failure. The American people have spoken and their voices were heard. There were no public congressional hearings, no opportunity to question witnesses, nor any opportunities to debate legitimate alternatives. We spent, or wasted, more time and money investigating steroids in baseball. This plan for financial salvation to save us all was discussed by only a few in the shadows of the halls of Congress. I didn’t come to Washington to make backroom deals and I am not going to start now. The irresponsible elites in New York City who caused this financial mess should bear the blame and the cost – not the American taxpayer. The New York City Fat Cats expect Joe Six Pack to buck it up and pay for all this nonsense, but the American taxpayer fought back and won. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

It is a horrible idea for the federal government to buy bad debts from lenders who made terrible choices. Would any of you who support this plan recommend to your kids that they borrow their way out of debt? I doubt it. So why then do some politicians (both Presidential candidates in particular) think that it is wise for the US taxpayer to buy our way out of debt? The people who should feel this are those who made terrible choices. I'm also not convinced the problem is liquidity. We may be talking about a similar issue, but I think solvency is a better descriptor. The other issue that needs fixin is confidence in the market. Here's a better plan to address those concerns: link title 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Here's a better plan to address those concerns: link title And I told you what I think about this plan - you can't fix the economy by changing accounting rules and forcing financial institutions to sell assets nobody wants to buy. This fails to address the root cause of the problem - lack of liquidity. This plan will only accelerate the failure of banks. You are looking only at one side of the problem - solvency. A few banks are in reasonable shape, but they are afraid of lending money to other institutions because they don't know if they will see their money back. This dries up liquidity in the market. By removing the toxic assets from the failed institutions in exchange for equity, we bring confidence and liquidity back to the market. And again, after a few years, the government should be able to sell its participation on those companies, and recover some of the money back. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

The New York City Fat Cats expect Joe Six Pack to buck it up and pay for all this nonsense, but the American taxpayer fought back and won. And because of that I wrote Mr. Poe yesterday that he will never get my vote again. The Dow lost 1.2 trillion dollars yesterday. This is not about rescuing Wall Street - it's about rescuing our economy. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

jdb, you are very quiet... 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

Against, we have lived outside our means for far to long...Myself included... We either tackle the problem now or come back 10yrs from now asking for 7 trillion dollars... Time to tighten the belts yall... 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

What I'd like to know is how things got so bad so fast. How is it NO ONE saw it coming? Or if they did, nothing was done to head it off? JDB, do we buy, buy, buy...sell, or hold? 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

There is a major problem in the way we do business now...Has it ever struck anyone odd that we ceased to produce anything within our own borders now?? The factory town is gone now, which was american as apple pie... Our currency continues to be worth less due to inflation... What happens when the dollar is no longer the world standard when it comes to currency?? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

What I'd like to know is how things got so bad so fast. How is it NO ONE saw it coming? Or if they did, nothing was done to head it off? It was in the makings for many years. Greenspan should have seen it coming. Keeping interest rates too low for too long sparked the problem - although it is easy to point that out today. But someone in Greenspan's position had all information to arrive to this conclusion. A few banks were smart - JPMorgan Chase, for example. They dumped all toxic stuff back in 2007. Last month's Forture magazine has an interesting article about it. do we buy, buy, buy...sell, or hold? I'm sitting tight... This is no time for impulsive actions. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

I'm sitting tight... This is no time for impulsive actions. Us too, havn't sold anything yet, but we sure are about to buy. What and How much is the question. My heart bleeds for those who have lost everything. Who the heck does the little guy put their faith in (besides the almighty, that is.) I mean, who among that bunch of clowns in Washington can we trust to lead us out of this mess? One thing is certain, life as we know it will change on many levels. People will see the wisdom of living within their means and that's a good thing. On the down side, credit will be extended to only the very worthiest....they were talking about that a lot last night. It won't be easy, if at all for a while, for some to buy a home unless there's proof they're financially solid. Living off credit has been the down fall of so many. Easy money, just flash the plastic. Credit cards won't be so easily obtained, which in my book is a great thing. You wouldn't believe the credit card offers our teenagers received upon entering college. wth? Times like these make me glad I've been married to Dave Ramsey's clone for nearly 27 years! 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

Best advice now is to start saving for those car repairs as you may need the money to fix it because you won't be buying a new car any time soon. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground