Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Sarah Palin's Alaskonomics

who's talking here?

maverick 1
CommonSense 6
Mabbers 1
clever 3
indisguise 1
traveller! 4
bruiserbetty* 1
PHSMOMOF2 1
biding*my*time 5
Warren Peace 7
steven 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

I was going to post this TIME article, but a little wind blew through, and well... It was still open so what the heck! They make a good point on the Windfall Profits tax. http://www.time.com/time/politics/article/0,8599,1839724,00.html Sarah Palin thinks she is a better American than you because she comes from a small town, and a superior human being because she isn't a journalist and has never lived in Washington and likes to watch her kids play hockey. Although Palin praised John McCain in her acceptance speech as a man who puts the good of his country ahead of partisan politics, McCain pretty much proved the opposite with his selection of a running mate whose main asset is her ability to reignite the culture wars. So maybe Governor Palin does represent everything that is good and fine about America, as she herself maintains. But spare us, please, any talk about how she is a tough fiscal conservative. Palin has continued to repeat the already exposed lie that she said "No, thanks" to the famous "bridge to nowhere" (McCain's favorite example of wasteful federal spending). In fact, she said "Yes, please" until the project became a symbol and political albatross. Back to reality. Of the 50 states, Alaska ranks No. 1 in taxes per resident and No. 1 in spending per resident. Its tax burden per resident is 2 1/2 times the national average; its spending, more than double. The trick is that Alaska's government spends money on its own citizens and taxes the rest of us to pay for it. Although Palin, like McCain, talks about liberating ourselves from dependence on foreign oil, there is no evidence that being dependent on Alaskan oil would be any more pleasant to the pocketbook. Alaska is, in essence, an adjunct member of OPEC. It has four different taxes on oil, which produce more than 89% of the state's unrestricted revenue. On average, three-quarters of the value of a barrel of oil is taken by the state government before that oil is permitted to leave the state. Alaska residents each get a yearly check for about $2,000 from oil revenues, plus an additional $1,200 pushed through by Palin last year to take advantage of rising oil prices. Any sympathy the governor of Alaska expresses for folks in the lower 48 who are suffering from high gas prices or can't afford to heat their homes is strictly crocodile tears. As if it couldn't support itself, Alaska also ranks No. 1, year after year, in money it sucks in from Washington. In 2005 (the most recent figures), according to the Tax Foundation, Alaska ranked 18th in federal taxes paid per resident ($5,434) but first in federal spending received per resident ($13,950). Its ratio of federal spending received to federal taxes paid ranks third among the 50 states, and in the absolute amount it receives from Washington over and above the amount it sends to Washington, Alaska ranks No. 1. Under the state constitution, the governor of Alaska has unusually strong powers to shape the state budget. At the Republican National Convention, Palin bragged that she had vetoed "nearly $500 million" in state spending during her two years as governor. This amounts to less than 2% of the proposed budget. That's how much this warrior for you (the people) against it (the government) could find in wasteful spending under her control. One thing Barack Obama and McCain disagree on is an oil windfall–profits tax. McCain is against it, on the theory that it is a tax and therefore bad, and also that it would discourage domestic production. Obama is for it, on the theory that if oil companies can make a nice profit when oil sells for $50 per bbl., they can still make a nice profit when it sells for more than $100, even if the government takes a bit and spreads the money around to those who are hurting from higher oil prices. Although Palin's words side with McCain in this dispute, her actions side with Obama. Her major legislative accomplishment has been to revamp Alaska's windfall-profits tax in order to increase the state's take. Alaska calls it a "clear and equitable share" tax. The state assumes that extracting oil from the tundra costs about $25 per bbl. and takes as much as 75% of the difference between that and the sale price. Why is a windfall-profits tax good for Alaska but not for the U.S.? Well, it's obvious, isn't it? People in Alaska are better than people in the rest of the U.S. They're more American. Although there are small towns and farms and high school hockey teams in the lower 48, there are fewer down here, per capita, than in Alaska. And there are many more journalists and pollsters and city dwellers and other undesirables who might benefit if every American had the same right to leech off the government as do the good citizens of Sarah Palin's Alaska. 

indisguise --- 18 years ago -

Have you ever thought about saying something nice about your candidate? What's the matter can't find anything nice to say? I see you people on here daily and you never talk about your candidate but you are good at finding fault with the other one.Talk about your man or isn't there anything about him worth a discussion? 

biding*my*time --- 18 years ago -

Commonsense has posted many good threads about his candidate. Some people like to read articles about all the candidates. One can agree with the content or not agree. There is no need to care one way or another why someone posts something. Is there? 

traveller! --- 18 years ago -

I find William Ayers / Barck Obama more interesting. 

biding*my*time --- 18 years ago -

I don't know who William Ayers is. 

traveller! --- 18 years ago -

You can google Ayers, he is a terrorist and a former member of the Weathermen and an associate of Barack Obama. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

You can google Ayers, he is a terrorist and a former member of the Weathermen and an associate of Barack Obama. Yes he is..How is it people can be so in love with Obama and yet they never check him out?...Look up Ayers.. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

I find William Ayers / Barck Obama more interesting. As Obama said: "the notion that somehow as a consequence of me knowing somebody who engaged in detestable acts 40 years ago when I was 8 years old, somehow reflects on me and my values, doesn't make much sense..." From now on anytime anyone mentions Ayers and I see it I will donate $25 to my choice of campaign, moveon.org, DailyKos Orange-to-Blue operation or Brave New PAC (run by Howard Dean's brother). Seriously people, go to FactCheck and get it right, and for goodness' sakes throw that Jerome Corsi book in the trash. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

As Obama said: "the notion that somehow as a consequence of me knowing somebody who engaged in detestable acts 40 years ago when I was 8 years old, somehow reflects on me and my values, doesn't make much sense..." Oh so you believe anything Obama tells you? I see.. 

traveller! --- 18 years ago -

You can also google Alexi Giannouli, and Tony Rezko. I think everyone knows who Reverend Wright is. 

biding*my*time --- 18 years ago -

Hey, hey, now. I don't know Ayers... but he is NOT Barack Obama. George Bush's family has been intimately involved with the Bin Laden family. So...it's the candidate, not his associates. That is a mute point really. Each and every candidate can probably be claimed to have ties to disreputable people or acts. These are the things that I don't feel are worth discussing. The issues of the country and how each candidate plans to address it are what is important. But, I am not getting into any political talk today. Nope. 

traveller! --- 18 years ago -

I'm not a Bush fan either. I just get tired of all the negative posts about the "other" candidates. I would much rather read something positve about who you are supporting. 

biding*my*time --- 18 years ago -

Then why post on a thread that you don't like the content? Others may like it. Don't you perpetuate the very negative that you say you don't like. Obviously people of opposing sides will post articles or info that they feel are prudent for enlightening other people. So what.. again, I'm just saying that the ugliness starts this way that's all... 

clever --- 18 years ago -

I'm not a Bush fan either. I just get tired of all the negative posts about the "other" candidates. I would much rather read something positve about who you are supporting. Me too..Is there anything? 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Me too..Is there anything? Yup. More wedding guests mean more gifts. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Why is a windfall-profits tax good for Alaska but not for the U.S.? 

biding*my*time --- 18 years ago -

I don't think that you are going to get serious discussion right now CS, but good luck and don't help to let this get ugly ok? 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

I don't think that you are going to get serious discussion right now CS I have a hard time ever getting a serious discussion. 

bruiserbetty* --- 18 years ago -

palin=gimmick 

steven --- 18 years ago -

the above article on Palin is a waste. It's filled with ridiculous comments like "she thinks she is a better American than you.." Seriously, is that supposed to help people make a rational decision about who to vote for? After reading a number of the responses, I am happy to see that most people don't really get caught up in the 'school yard' name calling when it comes to something as important as presidential selections. We need a P/VP ticket that will get us out of this ridiculous mess we are in. Unfortunately, our issues in Iraq and the massive financial crisis are products of both parties. Personally, I think the financial crisis is the uglier of the two. God help us. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Still, care to comment on why her windfall profits tax is a good idea but Obama's isn't? 

steven --- 18 years ago -

I don't have a good feeling about windfall profit taxes. My suspicion is they cost the consumer more in the long run. Let's say you own a business and your cost structure goes up by 10 to 20%. Are you going to suck up the costs or are you going to find a way to recoup it? Windfall taxes will not be taken lying down the oil companies or anyone else. The costs will be passed on to the consumer in the form of higher energy prices and/or it could result in layoffs. Reagonomics says, "make it easy for the organizations who employ people to make money. Take away the barriers and the economy will grow". While it is more complex than that, the point is that we only hurt ourselves in the long run by overtaxing the very organizations that employ us and put goods/services on our table. Again, companies won't just pay higher taxes and move on, they will get it back. Who will pay, the very consumer they were trying to protect. My 2 cents, but I am a poor cajun boy from louisiana, I don't claim to know much. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

I just bothered to look at this link and I'm amazed. I'm amazed at what's become of a once respectable news mag. Sadly, this is no exception and a perfect example of what's become of our once distinguished news media. The web page isn't even labeled an opinion piece nor an edititorial. Yet the first line reads, "Sarah Palin thinks she is a better American than you because she comes from a small town, and a superior human being " Really? This is journalism? Telling us what someone thinks without a single quote? I've heard a few of her speeches and have seen snippets of her interviews and never once heard anything about being superior. I'd love to take the time to pick apart more of this. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

Ugh, the whole tax commentary is a mess too. Taxes per resident? Without listing the tax rates? Someone is hiding something. Let's take a look at some of Alaska's tax rates. Well, no sales tax. What? That's right. Can anyone name another state that has no state sales tax? What about income tax? None. No state income tax. Property tax? Per capita property tax is $1,228 in 2007. All of the above can be easily found at this credible source. So that begs the question: Where does Alaska's tax revenue come from? The answer is disguised in this article. But first, does it now make sense why the author of this article phrased the observation as "taxes per resident" rather than taxes paid by residents? If I need to answer it for you, it is precisely because the truth does not meet this author's (and presumably Time Magazine's) agenda. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 18 years ago -

Do some of you think the way the economy is right now that people are aware that it is at its worse and may sway their votes from Jurassic JOhn and Pitbull to the democrats? 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

In 2005 (the most recent figures), according to the Tax Foundation, Alaska ranked 18th in federal taxes paid per resident ($5,434) but first in federal spending received per resident ($13,950). Its ratio of federal spending received to federal taxes paid ranks third among the 50 states, and in the absolute amount it receives from Washington over and above the amount it sends to Washington, Alaska ranks No. 1. How can this even be included in this hit piece? Didn't her term start in 2006? And don't congressmen solicit funding? If she tried to ween Alaska from the gov't tete with her influence, perhaps this article should have compared Alaska's numbers from 2005 through the current fiscal year. Perhaps the author knows what those numbers look like and decided it wouldn't be a good fit for this high school editorial. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

At the Republican National Convention, Palin bragged that she had vetoed "nearly $500 million" in state spending during her two years as governor. This amounts to less than 2% of the proposed budget. That's how much this warrior for you (the people) against it (the government) could find in wasteful spending under her control. So now the author gets back to finances under Palin's control. Vetoing $500 million sounds impressive to me. Perhaps it's low as a percentage of the State's budget, but perhaps it also happens to be higher than most State Governers. Perhaps also this author knows that would have been helpful information for readers to have to draw conclusions about her performance. Its omission from this hit piece is glaring. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

The author and our own "Common Sense" have fallen short on accuracy (surprise) on characterizing the oil tax as a "windfall profits" tax. I'm certain they share a common agenda and the truth hasn't made that agenda. What is a windfall profits tax? According to Obama, it is a tax on corporate income (I'm guessing revenue above expenses) that kicks in above a certain percentage. Anyone is welcome to set me straight on that, but this is my understanding of what Obama is interested in. So what is it that critics of Palin are calling Alaska's windfall profits tax? It's called the Alaska Permanent Fund and it is not Sara Palin's doing. It was established in 1976 and the Alaskan Constitution had to be amended to get it done. That's right. The Governor cannot do anything about it but work with it. So what is it? It is something rare in any government agency. It is a government savings fund that allows the State (and its citizens) to grow their savings and receive dividends. Every citizen of Alaska receives an annual check from this fund as long as they file for it by providing proof of residency. Oil companies do not pay it as a result of property taxes nor corporate income taxes. The language of their Constitution reads, "At least 25 percent of all mineral lease rentals, royalties, royalty sales proceeds, federal mineral revenue-sharing payments and bonuses received by the state be placed in a permanent fund, the principal of which may only be used for income-producing investments" So it is mineral resource revenue that funds it. Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't all States have this? The only difference seems to be that Alaska directs these funds toward future earnings while other States do not. That is clearly not a windfall profits tax folks. Oh, one more thing. Sara Palin's role in this appears to be that she led the legislature into granting the citizens of Alaska a larger dividend in 2008. She didn't raise taxes. 

maverick --- 18 years ago -

So more BS from the left. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Well, no sales tax. What? That's right. Can anyone name another state that has no state sales tax? Except in Wasilla, thanks to Sarah Palin. Granted she lowered other taxes (which she more than takes credit for) but she instituted a sales tax in a state with no sales tax. Not only that but keep in mind a sales tax shifts the tax burden down. Not that most on here care. Vetoing $500 million sounds impressive to me She never set a clear direction for state spending, which is part of the governor's job in Alaska. This is part of why she had so many vetoes. She is not a fiscal conservaive like she claims to be, and was even targeted by John McCain's group back when she was Mayor. That is clearly not a windfall profits tax folks. She increased the tax rate on oil companies due to higher oil prices. That's a windfall profits tax if I ever heard of one. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

Except in Wasilla, thanks to Sarah Palin. Granted she lowered other taxes (which she more than takes credit for) but she instituted a sales tax in a state with no sales tax. Not only that but keep in mind a sales tax shifts the tax burden down. Not that most on here care. I guess the truth you meant to report is that when Palin first ran for city council in 1992, Wasilla had just passed a 2% sales tax. Anchorage Daily News Fortunately, a sales tax is a consumption tax rather than a tax on productivity (like income). I'm all for it. The municipal tax in Wasilla (that doesn't seem to be Palin's doing) still seems lower than other municipal or state sales taxes. Just curious, but what led you to believe that Palin instituted a sales tax? 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

She increased the tax rate on oil companies due to higher oil prices. That's a windfall profits tax if I ever heard of one. No. Oil prices are not the same as oil profits. With the lack of State revenue coming from sources other than oil, I don't see any reason for an Alaska Governor to tinker with their State's solvency by objecting to their constituency's wishes. So I'd say the difference is that Obama has proposed a tax because oil profits seem obscene to him. The Fed Gov't has a rather diverse number of revenue sources that Alaska doesn't have. It may be wise for Alaska's next Governor (or Palin if she ends up keeping her current job) to consider instituting a state sales tax comparable to the Flat Tax, but at a lower rate. I just don't see how Alaska can continue to operate its government by being so dependent on oil. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground