Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Nat gas generators

who's talking here?

Momoftwo 1
Bows and More Galore 1
AuthorMan 1
I Kissed Frogs 1
David 4
Donkey Hodie 1
Marthax2 1
Fin and Feather 2
offroad4by4 6
Dinojo 1
AllenVanAllen 2
Lorralei 1
BearBranchBroad 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Fin and Feather --- 18 years ago -

Is it cheaper? I am looking at getting a multi fuel conversion to keep from fighting gas lines. Conversion is not cheap looks like $185 ish. http://www.propane-generators.com/a-c_kit_list.htm  

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Be careful on the conversion. Be sure to consider the higher heating value of the natural gas (NG) and 10 to 20% power out reduction (strongly dependant on your fuel system layout). 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

NG runs much hotter and the original rings aren't built to handle the heat long term. You can add a larger oil cooler to help dissapate some of the heat, but the seals can't handle the heat for very long. It might be better to sell your old system and buy a tri-fuel system. However, if you are determined to convert it, add an additional oil loop below off of the drain plug and attach a fan to blow across it when the generator part of the kit is turned on. Natural gas is the way to go for fuel availability, safety, long term maintenance (compared to liquid fuel clogging up the fuel ports), and cost. Have you checked to see what the gas company will need to change for the piping (i.e. line pressure adjustment up or down, line size, etc..)? Someone at work told me the gas company had to run an additional tap for his generator, but I think his was one of those huge 15 kW systems (~$80/day fulltime run). http://www2.northerntool.com/generators/portable-generators/item-165938.htm 

Fin and Feather --- 18 years ago -

Humm, I didn’t think about it like that, thanks 

AllenVanAllen --- 18 years ago -

There were a few mansions I worked in that had natural gas generators, and they were big! They seamlessly switched on when power was lost and they would run the home's entire electrical load. They were very impressive. I can't even imagine what they cost. They were the size of a truck! Good luck with the generator Fin. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Fin - If you get a natural gas system, would you be willing to PM me what the gas company has to change and I'll do likewise? Link to installation manual Check out page 4 and page 14 of the pdf file link above. 

Marthax2 --- 18 years ago -

My husband would prefer to get a nat gas one over the other. He just doesn't want to take up our yard with it in there. 

AuthorMan --- 18 years ago -

Conversion is not cheap looks like $185 ish Dang- I figured all I would need is a straw and some tacos. lol 

BearBranchBroad --- 18 years ago -

my husband is a natural gas generator... i make him sleep in the shed most nights... 

Lorralei --- 18 years ago -

When I do it, NG will be the way I go. NG is cheaper than gasoline, too... lol. 

David --- 18 years ago -

We have a natural gas generator. It was tied to the main gas line at the back of the lot and a meter and presssure regulator added by Centerpoint for $550 about two years ago. It ran full time and was shut down each day to check and add oil. I expect an average daily bill of $50 for natural gas, which is cheaper than a gasoling generator yielding the same power, without the storage problem or the trial of finding gasoline after a storm. It will also work with propane with better efficiency than with natural gas. Conversion is a minor adjustment to the unit at no additional costs. 

Donkey Hodie --- 18 years ago -

Has anybody had any experience with Guardian Generators? 

David --- 18 years ago -

Yes, I have a Generac Guardian standby generator and am very happy with it. However, there are several issues that you need to be aware of. First, make sure that the installer obtains a city permit for the installation. Second, plan on some oil use and have plenty of oil on hand before any extended operations. Also, have extra oil filters and an air filter on hand because they have been very hard to find post hurricane. They have a very poor support network when it comes to consumable parts. Mechanically it has been very good. My last piece of advice is to get the estimate of install costs absolutely tied down before buying. If it is estimated by some third party seller such as Home Depot don't accept that without a commitment from the company that will actually do the install. 

Bows and More Galore --- 18 years ago -

Great advice David, and thanks fin for asking the question. My DH and I are looking into getting a natural gas generator to run the first floor of our home. I am sending my Dh a link to this thread as we speak. My concern was/is the cost of running it. Your $50/day est really helps. Also, does anyone out there know what it will do for the value of your home? I don't mind the initial cost if I know when the day comes that we sell our home that cost can be recooped. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

David - do you have to pay the Centerpoint minimum monthly fee for the new/additional meter, or do they charge only per gas use? How often do they read your 2nd meter? 

David --- 18 years ago -

No, you only pay for the gas. The initial charge of $550 covered the installation, meter and pressure regulator. Monthly you will use a small amount of gas due to the weekly test run of 20 minutes of so. that will be in the range of $10 to $15. One more important note - the battery is small so I strongly recommend that you replace it every year of no more than 18 months. It is easy to take out and it is a standard battery that you can get from O'Reilly's for about $60 as I recall. You don't want to be at the end of your battery life when the next Ike visits. Also, as I mentioned earlier, keep plenty of oil on hand and check your oil every day. It is easy to add oil. The unit has low oil and high temperature shutdowns to protect the engine. It is essentially the same maintenance as for a car engine - 30 hp in my case. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

We have had a Guardian (Generac) since right after Rita and have never changed the battery and haven't had a problem with it. I should probably have my husband check it now since the hurricane. We didn't run ours continously because the installer scared me to death about the cost of running it all the time during a power outage. I think he was wrong though because I have tried to manually figure the bill myself and it will be about $25/ day but that is with me turning it off some times during the day. It is very easy to turn off/on (just flip 2 switches) I did however blow a fuse on ours. I plugged in the leaf blower forgetting that my husband had hooked up our neighbors freezer. It blew a little fuse that was very easy to change. It did take a lot more oil than I expected though but still easier than waiting in gas lines. Home Depot really screwed up our install and didn't have it inspected by the City. They sent someone out to look at the install before calling the city out (2-1/2 years later) and said it is completely installed wrong and offered to buy it back. However, I think we will keep it after the hurricane. We will probably have to move it though to comply with an inspection. As far as recooping the money for resale I called the agent that sold us the house and she said not to count on it but this was before the hurricane and people might appreciate it now. We just figured we would take it with us if we wouldn't receive value in a resale. 

AllenVanAllen --- 18 years ago -

Thanks for the great information guys! 

David --- 18 years ago -

Be careful about the new install. the city code changed between the time you had it installed and now. You will not be able to have as many circuits connected as you probably have now. They assume that you will be using every circuit to its max amps all at the same time. 

Momoftwo --- 18 years ago -

I also will lead my dh to this thread. We are thinking about a natural gas generator as well. My dad was telling me that the natural gas generators just don't last as long as the others and have more mechanical problems. He is a project manager in the construction industry and has to rent generators/welding machine for his jobs. He said the natural gas/propane ones just don't run for long and break down often. He said the rental company confirmed they aren't as good. Any thoughts? I would hate to invest the $ on a natural gas generator if it's not going to hold up many years. Our gasoline generator is 8 years old and going strong. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

I work in an area where 90% of our equipment is natural gas fueled, and can state that natural gas equipment does run a higher temperature than other fuels, but if you buy a system built for natural gas they will last longer due to running dry gas which translates to a cleaner system for carbon build up and fuel "storage". The issue with NG units having more problems might have to do with rental (portable) units that are moved around on a trailer or back of trucks (knocked around) a lot and abused (not maintained per manufacturer). Natural gas unit are better suited for stationary or occasional portable situations due to the design of gas tight fittings and parts. Liquid fuel generators are better suited for true portable (rental type) units. Look for a system with stainless or other steel piston "sleeves" that you can change out if needed, and low and high oil pressure shutdowns and you are probably on the right track to a well designed system. Because it does run hotter, you will need to change out the oil a little more frequently but that amounts to pennies on the dollar difference. Water cooled generators would be a nice OPTION as well, but that's a plus not an essential. You must complete your routine maintenance like mentioned above (unfortunately some manufactures suggest running 30 minutes a month to keep it primed, but a minimum 10 to 15 minutes a week is crucial) if you want a long lasting system. The $10 to $15 a month fee the gas company is charging sounds like they are uncluding/charging you the minimum meter read fee (used to be $12 per monthly reading). 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Also, if you are going to invest in a larger natural gas unit, go ahead and invest in a cheaper natural gas sniffer to check for leaks and a CO detector to check your unit periodically. 

Dinojo --- 18 years ago -

Anyone know anything about Gap Plumbing. Just called them to get an estimate on the gas generator. They are not listed on BBB. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground