Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Toxins in kids' products UPDATE - new PBS video link

who's talking here?

Empty Nest 1
planemom 6
amb07 5
CyberSage 10
NoNameNoLastName 8
CommonSense 1
mamajulie 1
AFWife 1
get_the_lead_out! 2
MxMike 1
onestepforward 12
Nightstorm 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

"Congressional negotiators agreed yesterday to a ban on a family of toxins found in children's products, handing a major victory to parents and health experts who have been clamoring for the government to remove harmful chemicals from toys. The ban, which would take effect in six months, would have significant implications for U.S. consumers, whose homes are filled with hundreds of plastic products designed for children that may be causing dangerous health effects. The rare action by Congress reflects a growing body of scientific research showing that children ingest the toxins by acts as simple as chewing on a rubber duck. Used for decades in plastic production, the chemicals are now thought to act as hormones and cause reproductive problems, especially in boys. -snip- White House spokesman Tony Fratto said that President Bush opposes the ban but that it is too early to say whether he will veto the measure, which is part of popular legislation to reform the Consumer Product Safety Commission. Among other things, the legislation would ban lead in children's products and would give consumers access to a new database of complaints or accident reports for goods. The measure also allows stiffer fines for violations and enhanced enforcement of consumer safety laws. - snip- The measure had wide support in the Senate, but it bogged down in the House, where the chemical industry waged a costly battle to defeat it. The campaign was led by Exxon Mobil, which manufacturers diisononyl phthalate, or DINP, the phthalate most frequently found in children's toys. The company spent a chunk of its $22 million lobbying budget in the past 18 months to try to prevent any ban. -snip- The European Union banned six phthalates from children's products in 1999 and more than a dozen other countries have done the same. California's ban has been followed by legislation in Washington state and Vermont." full story  

mamajulie --- 18 years ago -

Here we go again. Same ole, same ole. What ever happened to the concept of protecting the American people; not just the corporations, but the actual people. But this is the Republican way folks. Remember that on election day. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

Europeans MAKE their governments work for them. They pay attention to what is going on and they will take to the streets and protest in a heartbeat, thus they have much greater consumer protections in place than we do. There are so many poisons and toxins that our government allows, that have been banned in other countries, sometimes for decades. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

the chemicals are now thought to act as hormones and cause reproductive problems, especially in boys. The key word in that sentence is thought. They don't know for sure. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

the chemicals are now thought to act as hormones and cause reproductive problems, especially in boys. I wouldn't want to subject a child (or adult) to any chemicals that were even slightly questionable. Would you? Apparently there is enough evidence to ban these chemicals in other countries... 9 years ago. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

The European Union banned six phthalates from children's products in 1999 and more than a dozen other countries have done the same. This is exactly why I try to buy products made in Europe. They use common sense. The FDA is a joke. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

This is exactly why I try to buy products made in Europe. Me too, especially cosmetic products. Japan also has higher consumer protection standards. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

I wouldn't want to subject a child (or adult) to any chemicals that were even slightly questionable. Would you? Apparently there is enough evidence to ban these chemicals in other countries... 9 years ago. I wouldn't. Of course I was the kind of mom who purchased BPA free bottles and pacifiers a year ago when everyone thought I was nuts. And I feed my family as much organic food as I possibly can. And I won't even get started on the chemicals that are placed on playgrounds and sports fields. Why take a risk with your child? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

The key word in that sentence is thought. They don't know for sure. And if you are not sure, which way do you think we should err? On the safe side or on the corporation side? Give me a break... 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

My next question is: If they are so dangerous why does the ban only include toys? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

My next question is: If they are so dangerous why does the ban only include toys? You are contradicting yourself. Are you against the ban or not? If you are against it, don't try to extend it. If you are not and you feel strongly that the ban should be extended, write to our useless representatives - at least annoy them a bit. Answering your question now, I gave up chewing rubber duckies a long time ago. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I could really careless one way or the other. I just find it odd that if these toxins are dangerous the ban only includes toys. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

I would love to give each of you a basic chemistry lesson about phthalate esters, what percentages they are present in different consumer products, how the different ones are made, and how they leach out of products. But you would rather remain ignorant, praise the EU for its ability to crush commerce, and blame Bush for wanting lead in toys. I've been following this phthalate debate for 10 years. You just don't know what you're talking about. You people think that chemicals are bad, that "organic" somehow means "better," and that plastic is a public enemy. It's a shame that our education system has done this. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

I could really careless one way or the other. I just find it odd that if these toxins are dangerous the ban only includes toys. Do you have small kids? After learning that, will you let them chew on their toys? And perhaps if more people cared we would be in a much better situation. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

I just find it odd that if these toxins are dangerous the ban only includes toys. Phthalates are present in a variety of consumer products. The reason that toys are singled out is because children chew on them, and the phthalates leach out. However, phthalates are also what gives a car the "new car smell," as they leach out of the plastic. Some phthalates are worse than others. Their ability to leach depends on their chain length, their degree of branching, and the medium (typically PVC) in which they are blended. Fishing lures contain up to 40% phthalate plasticizer. Before you ban a product that is a foundation in the medical industry, toys, etc., the proper homework needs to be done. It's called public health. I'm sorry, but just because a few people may have gotten cancer, that doesn't mean that you ban something, especially if it's IV bags or something that benefits millions. Now, it is also true that ExxonMobil, as one of the largest producers of phthalates in the world, has a conflict of interest. However, the studies I've read show that DINP simply doesn't need to be banned. It ws probably a good idea to ban DEHP or DOP, but I can't even explain why because nobody knows enough chemistry to even understand the explanation. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

Do you have small kids? After learning that, will you let them chew on their toys? Yes, and as a Ph.D. chemist who has kept up with the plasticizer debate, I continue to let my kids have Barbie dolls, pacifiers, etc. Phthalates are healthier for them than sugar. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

So you are saying that the scientific research that was used as basis for the ban is all wrong, and you are right? 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

So, as a chemist, you have done research on the effects these such chemicals have on the human body? So you don't believe chemicals cause cancer and other health problems. You are right, what has our education system come to when someone who believes such crap has a PhD. Do you by any chance work for one of these companies? 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

So, as a chemist, you have done research on the effects these such chemicals have on the human body? So you don't believe chemicals cause cancer and other health problems. You are right, what has our education system come to when someone who believes such crap has a PhD. Do you by any chance work for one of these companies? What silliness - you don't even know what a chemical is. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

What silliness - you don't even know what a chemical is. The question was legitimate - have you done any studies of how those chemicals affect the human body? Or you just happen to work for Exxon? 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

No, I do not work for Exxon. And I could possibly benefit enormously if phthalate esters were to be banned. But I don't think the studies in my file cabinet support a ban of all phthalates. Feel free to respond by typing your answer with your keyboard that is made of petrochemicals. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

So you don't believe chemicals cause cancer and other health problems. The question was legitimate How so? That wasn't really a question was it? That was just a hyperbolic paroxysm. So, as a chemist, you have done research on the effects these such chemicals have on the human body? Well now, that was a question...but not a very legitimate one. Again, how do I explain? One person doesn't carry out this kind of research. They have this thing called JOURNALS. They are peer-reviewed (look up what that means). The results are summarized and explained in major trade journals, so people who don't work in that area can understand the implications of the results. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

The results are summarized and explained in major trade journals, so people who don't work in that area can understand the implications of the results. Bottom line, are those chemicals harmful or not? If there is a CHANCE they may be harmful, they should be banned until proven otherwise. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

If there is a CHANCE they may be harmful, they should be banned until proven otherwise. I'm sorry, but this shows no knowledge of public health. If I walked through your house, I could point out virtually everything in your home and tell you why there's a chance that the chemicals in it could be harmful. There's a chance that there could be Cr(VI) in your milk jugs or other HDPE sources. The plastics in your car may leach harmful chemicals. The fluoride in your toothpaste may be harmful. The Scotch Gard in your fabric or cookware may be harmful. The pipes taking water to your house, or the paint on the walls may be harmful. The manure that grew your organic vegetables, or the unpasteurized apple-foods may be harmful. The gas that you use in your car is extremely toxic, and possibly carcinogenic. Your statement just shows the typical ignorance people have toward chemicals. This type of ignorance persuades politicians to act in knee-jerk manner to buy the votes of their ignorant constituents. Science education in America is dead. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

has anyone seen the jar that's in just about everyone's pantry?...you know the one that if you have kids you use it all the time. The one that you can make a great sandwich with! That's right! Peanut Butter can kill some people. It would take a lot less peanut butter than the lead in paint to kill some people. Should we make peanut butter illegal to sell or consume? 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

Taking up for Bush no matter what, gtlo and cyber? Even a risk of toxins to children? Amazing. Like I've said a thousand times... repub. party trumps over America and Americans every time. Got to be loyal to the party... at all costs. Being ugly to other people and insulting them doesn't distract, has much as you would like it to, from the facts about Bush and Exxon keeping these chemicals on the market when they are clearly banned, for years, in other civilized nations. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

what? I point out the hypocrisy and you just throw political rah-rah at me? How about vaccinations? Some kids are thought to have adverse side effects. Should these be banned also? In the case of vaccinations, I think it should be up to the parents to decide. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

A few decades ago, should it have been "left up to the parents" to remove lead from paint and gasoline? This article was specifically about phthalates in childrens' products, not about lead or peanut butter. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

That's right! Peanut Butter can kill some people. Yeah, that's an allergy. Apples and Oranges here. But since you bring it up, they do put warnings in foods that may contain/are made in the same facilities as those containing peanuts. Before you ban a product that is a foundation in the medical industry, toys, etc., the proper homework needs to be done. It's called public health. I'm sorry, but just because a few people may have gotten cancer, that doesn't mean that you ban something, especially if it's IV bags or something that benefits millions. Nobody is saying get rid of IV bags, just take them out of toys like the EU did and replace them with something that is not as potentially problematic. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

If I walked through your house, I could point out virtually everything in your home and tell you why there's a chance that the chemicals in it could be harmful. And I would balance the risks and benefits for each one of them. The fluoride in your toothpaste may be harmful. My toothpaste has no fluoride, thank you. The gas that you use in your car is extremely toxic, and possibly carcinogenic. That's one of the reasons why I support alternative sources of energy. Your statement just shows the typical ignorance people have toward chemicals. Why? Just because I would like something that is potentially harmful to be banned until proven otherwise? Do you work for Exxon? 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

Do you work for Exxon? No. Would you like for me to answer it a 3rd time? And I would balance the risks and benefits for each one of them. Based on what? Your statement just shows the typical ignorance people have toward chemicals. Why? Just because I would like something that is potentially harmful to be banned until proven otherwise? Ignorant. You probably don't even know what phase 3 and phase 4 clinical trials are. The fluoride in your toothpaste may be harmful. My toothpaste has no fluoride, thank you. Ignorant - do you even know what "fluoride is" The gas that you use in your car is extremely toxic, and possibly carcinogenic. That's one of the reasons why I support alternative sources of energy. Ignorant, as if I don't. Which non-toxic form of energy do you prefer? This oughtta be good... Spare me the ignorant anecdotes. Ignorant. ........ Perhaps DINP should be banned. I don't think so. I thought that DOP/DEHP should have been. But none of this merited accusations about the President wanting to poison children. That's just ignorant. Ignorant, ignorant, ignorant. Ignorant outcries from an uneducated public. Quit buying the stuff if you don't like it. Taking up for Bush no matter what, gtlo and cyber? Even a risk of toxins to children? Ignorant. Bush is a grown man. He doesn't need me to "take up for him." Neither does ExxonMobil. Science in America is dead, swallowed up in postmodern relativism, proud mediocrity, the welfare state, the liberalization of the education system, and the death of rational thought. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

research commissioned by the European Union’s own executive branch, the European Commission, had already concluded that the chance of a child exceeding the recommended limits through exposure to such products was ‘so rare that the statistical likelihood cannot be estimated.’ Here is the source. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Here is a chart that might provide some useful information. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

I think cybersage is one angry scientist. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

I think cybersage is one angry scientist. Ditto... if he/she even is one. All the scientists and doctors I know don't have to insult to inform and are confident enough not to have to brag or belittle. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Yes, most people who are competent in their profession, thrive on the opportunity to educate other, not insult people. I think you hit the nail on the head. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

research commissioned by the European Union’s own executive branch, the European Commission, had already concluded that the chance of a child exceeding the recommended limits through exposure to such products was ‘so rare that the statistical likelihood cannot be estimated.’ Here is the source. Planemom, I do appreciate you citing your source, but I have to tell you that this website is: "The Phthalate Esters Panel (the Panel) of the American Chemistry Council is composed of all major manufacturers and some users of the primary phthalate esters in commerce in the United States. Panel members include: BASF Corporation, Eastman Chemical Company, ExxonMobil Chemical Company, and Ferro Corporation. Teknor Apex Company, a major user of the materials, is an associate member." This is from the same website. There would definately be a conflict of interest. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

Here is a little more information from the European Union website, Europa.org: Brussels, 10 November 1999 Ban of phthalates in childcare articles and toys The placing on the European market of childcare articles and toys in soft PVC containing phthalates which are intended to be put in the mouth by babies under 3 years should be banned immediately. The European Commission has approved a package of legislative proposals to ban the use of phthalates in soft toys: firstly, an immediate ban on these products because the phthalates released when babies put them in their mouth pose a serious risk to child health. Secondly, the Commission proposes a permanent measure to confirm the ban for this particular use of phthalates in the longer term on a permanent basis. This will take the form of an amendment to the legislation on the marketing of dangerous substances, which for procedural reasons can only be applied by Member States several years from now. In addition, this second measure will require, as a matter of precaution, that other soft PVC toys for the under three's which could be placed in a child's mouth even when this is not intended by the manufacturer, should carry a warning label if they contain phthalates, in order to ensure their safe use under all circumstances. Recent scientific evidence has shown that checks of phthalates release from such products in soft PVC are not a reliable way to ensure that babies do not absorb dangerous quantities of phthalates. There is therefore a need for a ban with immediate effect. The ban will be enforced within ten days from its final adoption by the Commission, after consultation of the Emergency Committee, composed of Member State representatives and set up under the General Product Safety Directive (92/59/EEC). This procedure is expected to be completed in two weeks. Phthalates are chemical substances used to plasticize, or soften, PVC. They have been shown to be liable to cause liver, kidney and testicular damage.(1) The phthalates are released in dangerous quantities when soft PVC teethers or dummies, rattles and other toys for young children are sucked and chewed over extended periods by babies, in particular in their "teething" age. source Again, I just don't think it is worth the risk. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

Bush and Exxon FIGHT to keep toxins in kids' products This headline serves no purpose toward the goal of enacting good legislation regarding chemical safety. All it does is incite hysteria, panicked calls to legislators who are terrified of offending their constituents by waiting for enough information to make good public health decisions. What should we replace phthalates with? Will it be even more toxic? Will it upset the balance of another critical product stream? Nobody knows, but darned if that's gonna stop some fearful legislator from pulling the trigger. If that's not consistent with the definition of "ignorant," then please let me know. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/ignorant 

MxMike --- 18 years ago -

This is exactly why I try to buy products made in Europe. They use common sense. The FDA is a joke. Not just the FDA, its the entire system that has rotten through. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground