Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band

who's talking here?

stampin' gal 1
Momof3 1
Fallon 1
ambergris 7
taxi-mom 1
9829LuvLuv9829 1
humbleteacher 2
$AshleyThePrincess$ 1
Smkrman 2
♥ Sam ♥ 1
lemingrebel 1
KYMWHO 1
Wilstar77 5
lovemyboy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

What's the difference between the 2? My kids want one of these for Christmas but I don't know the differences so that I can make a good choice. Can anyone help me out?  

humbleteacher --- 18 years ago -

My girls much prefer Rock Band. All of them can join in. They are updating it for Christmas. 

lovemyboy --- 18 years ago -

my son and his friends prefer Guitar Hero, so do my ears. 

humbleteacher --- 18 years ago -

so do my ears. true enough. 

Smkrman --- 18 years ago -

Rock band is pretty awesome The new guitar hero is going to come out soon and it will have the drums and mic as well but I'm not sure if it will be better then rock band. I believe the new rock band comes out in September and its supposed to blow guitar hero out of the water, but we will just have to wait and see. Right now though Rock Band definitely has my vote! 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

I like Guitar Hero personally. But I think for 2 kids, Rock Band is probably better. I can't see myself at 31 singing in a mic while my wife and kids are asleep. Playing just a plastic Guitar is different. Guitar Hero 4: World Tour will come out before Christmas and will include a Guitar, Mic and Drums. Rock Band 2: Will also come out before Christmas and will include the same stuff. The only difference between the 2 are pretty much what songs will be included. I don't think the Official songs for both systems has come out yet. The ones that have leaked out may not be the real set list. 

9829LuvLuv9829 --- 18 years ago -

What's the difference between the 2? For starters, the price. Rock Band is $169 or so? Guitar Hero is $89. I started out playing Guitar Hero and just played Rock Band for the first time last night. So of course I am used to Hero and compare everything to it. Liked the drums, and could handle the guitar but the singing thing to me, is YUCK. Even someone who can sing sounds like poo. I don't know, I guess it is the songs. Oh, and Rock Band takes up a lot more space for obvious reasons (drums). Everyone can join in on Rock Band but from my observation last night, nobody wants to sing. They fight over the guitar, they fight over the drums. good luck =) 

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

so you have to sing with rockband but not with guitar hero? Is that correct? 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

No, RockBand comes with a Guitar, Drums and Mic. You can choose to play just one thing, all instruments or just a couple. It's up to you. RockBand is $169. Guitar Hero 1,2, 3 and GH: Aerosmith only come with a guitar. Nothing else. Guitar Hero 3 & Aerosmith are $89. Guitar Hero 4: World Tour is coming out before this Christmas and will include Drums, Mic and Guitar. It will probably cost the same as RockBand. 

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

gotcha. Other than price and the accessories are they pretty much the same as far as playing, etc? My kids are 13 and under and they will be the ones that primarily play it. We will have the occasional adult play but it won't be often. 

$AshleyThePrincess$ --- 18 years ago -

We will have the occasional adult play but it won't be often. You say that now.... lol just wait! 

KYMWHO --- 18 years ago -

I like Guitar Hero myself! 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

Kids love the guitar. The drums and mic are fun too but get pretty loud. 

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

any other suggestions or thoughts? This will be a Christmas gift and I think the best reviews come from those who have played the games. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

i have both and while i personally prefer guitar hero (but am tired of the songs), my kids prefer rock band. they can do the drums, guitar, sing, etc. They can both play TOGETHER and dont have to take turns (one on each instrument). 

♥ Sam ♥ --- 18 years ago -

guitar hero 4 is suppose to have a quieter drum set..i dont know if rock band is working to correct that or not, but it's really annoying! I hate how loud it is..I love guitar hero, and I can not wait for guitar hero 4! 

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

I hate how loud it is.. how loud is it? I don't mind some musical noise. I mean, we do have 3 guitars, an accordian, a lap harp, maracas, bongo drums, ukelele, harmonicas, etc in this house. LOL. However, if it is beyond loud and annoying then I might not like it. Is Rockband the only one that more than 1 person can play at a time? That will have to be a big factor to consider because I do not want to hear them whining over whose turn it is to play. 

Momof3 --- 18 years ago -

Guitar Hero is much better for us anyway. We have Rock Band as well but don't play it half as much as GH. 

taxi-mom --- 18 years ago -

We have both, but they play guitar hero much more than rock band. I hate the way the drums sound on rock band. We also have sing star and two people can do that at the same time. 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

Go to Best Buy, they have Rock Band out and you can see how loud the drums are. It sounds like hitting drum sticks on a plastic table. Guitar Hero 3 is also 2 players but you have to buy a second guitar separately. It sounds like your options for Christmas are: a) RockBand2 or b) Guitar Hero 4: World Tour. Both will come with Guitar, Drums and Mic. Both have not come out yet. 

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

It sounds like your options for Christmas are: a) RockBand or b) Guitar Hero 4: World Tour. Both will come with Guitar, Drums and Mic. thanks. This is definitely good useful info. 

lemingrebel --- 18 years ago -

just a thought. IMHO 

Wilstar77 --- 18 years ago -

just a thought. IMHO As a gamer I hear this a lot. So if I like military games, it means I should really join the marines instead of playing the fake stuff? Instead of playing GTA I should just do the real thing and car jack people? Why play chess? Why not be a real king? 

Smkrman --- 18 years ago -

Go to Best Buy, they have Rock Band out and you can see how loud the drums are. It sounds like hitting drum sticks on a plastic table. Very true but they have silencer covers for the drums you can buy at gamestop or maybe even best buy 

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

bump for Fallon 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

Oh thanks! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground