Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Obama/McCain tax comparison - CHART

who's talking here?

JDB2 2
smartypants 2
JUNIPER 1
CoralReef 1
brian* 3
n_sider 10
onestepforward 6
bubble28 1
Nightstorm 1
sandanista 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

link  

n_sider --- 18 years ago -

i love how you found this at the washington post. :-) So an American family earning $3 million next year must pay nearly 1/3 of their income to the government? How is this something anyone can support? I love the high percentage cut for the lowest brackets, but give me a break. Tax cuts should be equal across the board, and no one deserves a tax hike (regardless of income). Obama makes the FairTax look better and better. 

n_sider --- 18 years ago -

Why start now? Bush gave the big tax cuts to the wealthy. I'm not a huge fan of the Bush tax cuts either, but at least it was a small step in the right direction. The "tax the rich" philosophy has failed generation after generation. Only when the government returns our entire paycheck will our tax system be on the road to recovery. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

I like this chart alot. It shows very clearly the different plans. I'm not a huge fan of the Bush tax cuts either, but at least it was a small step in the right direction. Can you please tell me how Bush's tax cuts have helped with our economy in the shape it is in now? Are you "O.K." with our economy? 

n_sider --- 18 years ago -

Absolutely not. However, I do believe that taxing income is terribly unconstitutional. Our nation survived and prospered for over 100 years without an income tax. The only tax should be on consumption. Raise our sales tax to around 20%, but eliminate income taxes (and the IRS) and reduce taxes on real estate and investments. 

n_sider --- 18 years ago -

Are you "O.K." with our economy? Again, I'm very disappointed in the Bush tax cuts. With some many citizens in debt up to their necks giving them a small government check does little to stimulate anything. Bush and our next president owe us a lot more than a 2% or .3% tax cut. Raising the taxes of the most wealthy Americans 11% is absurd. They should not owe the government anymore than anyone else. 

n_sider --- 18 years ago -

May sound good in theory but dream on. Contrary, economist agree that a consumption tax would benefit the economy on a much greater scale than increased income tax. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

With some many citizens in debt up to their necks giving them a small government check does little to stimulate anything. I so agree with you here. Raising the taxes of the most wealthy Americans 11% is absurd. Warren Buffett disagrees with this one. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

"Warren Buffett, the third-richest man in the world, has criticised the US tax system for allowing him to pay a lower rate than his secretary and his cleaner. Speaking at a $4,600-a-seat fundraiser in New York for Senator Hillary Clinton, Mr Buffett, who is worth an estimated $52 billion (£26 billion), said: “The 400 of us [here] pay a lower part of our income in taxes than our receptionists do, or our cleaning ladies, for that matter. If you’re in the luckiest 1 per cent of humanity, you owe it to the rest of humanity to think about the other 99 per cent.” Mr Buffett said that he was taxed at 17.7 per cent on the $46 million he made last year, without trying to avoid paying higher taxes, while his secretary, who earned $60,000, was taxed at 30 per cent. Mr Buffett told his audience, which included John Mack, the chairman of Morgan Stanley, and Alan Patricof, the founder of the US branch of Apax Partners, that US government policy had accentuated a disparity of wealth that hurt the economy by stifling opportunity and motivation." He isn't the only wealthy person who feels this way. link 

bubble28 --- 18 years ago -

Good informative chart onestepfoward. It is stark when you look at the plans. Obviously, if you make alot of money you will pay more. That is how our government is suppose to work. The Bush/McCain tax plan is only for the wealthy. Funny thing is that most of wealthy people that have brains don't mind paying more. ex. (Buffett is only one guy that sees the insanity of his tax plan. Most in the entertainment business like actors and musicians support Obama. It is the greedy people like the oil men(BUSH) and corporate big wigs(McCain's),(GRAMM) that don't want to pay. Bush has been a dream for these people! 

n_sider --- 18 years ago -

Bush has been a dream for these people! How has Bush been a dream for anyone? His tax cuts were never expanded, and his promises to lead as a conservative Republican were never fulfilled. Under Bush we have seen our taxes soar (poor or wealthy) and energy costs spiral out of control. If anything Bush has been a horrible disappointment for the wealthy. 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

If anything Bush has been a horrible disappointment for the wealthy. The gap between rich and poor is vastly widening, so much so that I am sincerely worried about America's middle class shrinking dramatically. The rich are getting wealthier. High-end, luxury businesses are booming. I do understand that Bush has to be a disipointment to true Republicans, but I really don't think so for the wealthy. Could you tell me why you think this? 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

It is the greedy people like the oil men(BUSH) and corporate big wigs(McCain's),(GRAMM) that don't want to pay It seems that way. I would like to know what a person making millions in income would have to give up if their taxes increased. And surely someone making 20K or less would appreciate a little more in their pocket to help pay for necessities. Waitresses and other minimum wage people work hard; I think they deserve to keep more of their income. 

n_sider --- 18 years ago -

I would like to know what a person making millions in income would have to give up if their taxes increased. Why should they have to give up anything? The money would be much better spent in the market than given to some free spending politician. Lower income people need a few extra bucks for sure, but we should not give the government the rite to continually raise taxes Americans. This hurts people of all income brackets. Our government spends money wastefully and does not always have the interest of the people in mind. They cannot be trusted with any additional tax dollars from anyone. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

The gap between rich and poor is vastly widening why does that matter though? Why are we not all rich? If we were, would we think the same way? If you start your own business with your own capital and sweat equity, are you going to be willing to give a bigger piece of your income to your favorite uncle? Wouldn't you rather give it to your kids or your family? 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

I would like to see McCain's tax cuts but in an inverse percentage. I'm fine with the lowest earners paying a smaller percentage. They need every penny they can keep. What I really want to see is where these guys are planning to spend this tax money. 

n_sider --- 18 years ago -

Could you tell me why you think this? Supporters of big government have been concerned about the fate of the middle class for years. Yet capitalism always prevails and the middle class continues to live more comfortable than the previous generation. Luxury businesses succeed because we are a growing economy (despite the recent slump). My comment regarding disappointed wealthy Americans simply stems from the fact that Bush has not been the Republican we thought he would be. You would think after 8 years of a "conservative Republican" we would have lower taxes across the board and responsible government spending. That hasn't happened and we should all be outraged. 

CoralReef --- 18 years ago -

You would think after 8 years of a "conservative Republican" we would have lower taxes across the board and responsible government spending. That hasn't happened and we should all be outraged. I am. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

I am too, Coral Reef. I'm exceptionally disappointed our government has been so fiscally irresponsible. 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

capitalism always prevails and the middle class continues to live more comfortable than the previous generation Disagree. People of my parents generation were able to support their families on one income. My father worked a blue collar job, paid off his mortgage early, and sent two kids to college. 

JUNIPER --- 18 years ago -

I know our children will have a much harder time than we had making it into prosperity. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

I know our children will have a much harder time than we had making it into prosperity. Only if we don't teach them financial responsibility and educate them about money. Financial Peace University should be required reading much like The Great Gatsby and other literary works. 

n_sider --- 18 years ago -

Disagree. People of my parents generation were able to support their families on one income. My father worked a blue collar job, paid off his mortgage early, and sent two kids to college. My response to this should be predictable. Our parents and grandparents did not live in a country where it was considered necessary to have two cars, a 3000 square foot home, multiple cell phones, and new applainces and furniture every few years. If we could cut down on the expenses we consider imperative we could easily make it one hard working income. However, I'm glad we have all these things and I hope my kids have even more. If I'm able to teach them responsible money management I have no doubts they will. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

My father worked a blue collar job, paid off his mortgage early, and sent two kids to college. and how are you doing? Do you make sure you spend less than you make? I know our children will have a much harder time than we had making it into prosperity. they don't have to. They can have an easier time making it. Only if we don't teach them financial responsibility and educate them about money. Financial Peace University should be required I agree! My response to this should be predictable. Our parents and grandparents did not live in a country where it was considered necessary to have two cars, a 3000 square foot home, multiple cell phones, and new applainces and furniture every few years. If we could cut down on the expenses we consider imperative we could easily make it one hard working income. very well said! 

onestepforward --- 18 years ago -

I graduated from highschool in the early 80s and was working full-time. Minimum wage was $3.25/hr and I was making $3.65/hr. I was able to support myself with that... modest apartment, modest car payment and even a few college coarses at the city college. There is no way that an 18 year old, right out of highschool, could do that today, so I see both points of view here. Kids do need to be taught financial responsibility and have a basic financial knowledge, for sure. I also think that the widening gap between rich and poor needs to be looked at also. Thanks for the civil discussion. I thought it was interesting! 

sandanista --- 18 years ago -

How has Bush been a dream for anyone? His tax cuts were never expanded, and his promises to lead as a conservative Republican were never fulfilled. Under Bush we have seen our taxes soar (poor or wealthy) and energy costs spiral out of control. If anything Bush has been a horrible disappointment for the wealthy. You're right. He hasn't done SQUAT for anyone! -c THE REVOLUTION STARTS NOW 

Nightstorm --- 18 years ago -

You would think after 8 years of a "conservative Republican" we would have lower taxes across the board and responsible government spending. That hasn't happened and we should all be outraged. That's only what you would think when you think of the traditional republican and what they stood for. So many here still squawk those values however the repub party hasn't practiced them in forever now. Yes, they preach them but they are the epitome of hypocrites. Small government, fiscal responsibility....all that jazz...it's all illusion. Go take a gander at Bush's budget online. WAKE UP, PEOPLE! 

n_sider --- 18 years ago -

Thanks for the civil discussion. I thought it was interesting! Thank you. That's what I came here looking for. Small government, fiscal responsibility....all that jazz...it's all illusion. Go take a gander at Bush's budget online. WAKE UP, PEOPLE! Those values live on in our local conservative politicians. Unfortunately, the high profile Republicans (Bush, Perry, McCain) have not represented those values too well. We nominated McCain (by far the weakest candidate in a strong GOP primary feild) and as a result we most likely will have to endure at least four years of even greater government intrusion into our lives and higher taxes on business and trade. It has been a sad year at the national level, but we can still keep conservative polictics in Harris/Montgomery counties. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground