Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Does a President Need to be Experienced?

who's talking here?

smartypants 3
planemom 1
My 3 and Me 1
rose8304 1
NoNameNoLastName 5
CommonSense 4
eldiablo 1
Mabbers 1
mamajulie 1
ZITA 1
haroldoftherocks 1
david 1
~sassy~ 1
clever 2
CoralReef 1
rEVOLution 3
lulu 1
hrlydad 1
bubble28 4
Nightstorm 4
Spawn_of_Santa 1
Agent of Change 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Okay, I was doing some reading and decided to pose y'all a novel question: Suppose you had to choose between two Presidential candidates, one of whom had spent 20 years in Congress plus had considerable other relevant experience and the other of whom had about half a dozen years in the Illinois state legislature and 2 years in Congress. Which one do you think would make a better President? If you chose #1, congratulations, you picked James Buchanan over Abraham Lincoln. Most historians see Lincoln as the greatest President ever and Buchanan as the second worst ever (better only than Warren "Teapot Dome" Harding). Both served in what was probably the most difficult period in American history. 

hrlydad --- 18 years ago -

was Lincoln a "social communist"? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Buchanan as the second worst ever Soon to be 3rd, Bush will take the first place... 

rose8304 --- 18 years ago -

I always think its funny when people say that experience is so important. I think that new ideas and a "fresh eye" are more important. It's not like the president is all by himself. He has experienced advisors and other people helping him out. 

eldiablo --- 18 years ago -

He has experienced advisers and other people helping him out In Obama's corner, you will have people like Reverend Wright and Tony Rezko...that inspires confidence! 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

I always think its funny when people say that experience is so important. Bush was governor before being president, and look at the results... 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

Nixon had years and years of experience. That makes me think ethics might be more important. 

Spawn_of_Santa --- 18 years ago -

Reverend Wright and Tony Rezko No, I doubt it. More likely you'll have a lot of Bill Clinton's people and maybe even Bill and Hilary. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

 

ZITA --- 18 years ago -

After Bush, I'm just looking forward to someone who can speak in full sentences. 

lulu --- 18 years ago -

Bush inherited a lot of problems from Bill and Hillary. If you look at history, the Democrats get us into a lot of hot water and the Republicans have to get us out and on dry land. Bill and Hillary had their 8 years, and you are right- Obama will use a lot of Bill's people and we will be back in hot water. Better look twice at history!!! 

Nightstorm --- 18 years ago -

I always think its funny when people say that experience is so important. I think that new ideas and a "fresh eye" are more important. It's not like the president is all by himself. He has experienced advisors and other people helping him out. Not to mention, no one has experience being president except incumbents. Nothing but on the job training for each and every one of them. 

Nightstorm --- 18 years ago -

was Lincoln a "social communist"? There are other ways to word what you said so that others won't find it so offensive.....or derogatory which was your presumed intent. Forget about Lincoln. Let's review the facts.....regarding Texas. Texas was a Republican state until Lincoln, a Republican, signed the Emancipation Proclamation. Outraged about that, Texas turned blue or Democratic. Texas remained Democratic until Johnson, a native son, signed the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Texas, angry again, became Republican where it has remained ever since. Pretty sad. 

Nightstorm --- 18 years ago -

Bush inherited a lot of problems from Bill and Hillary. If you look at history, the Democrats get us into a lot of hot water and the Republicans have to get us out and on dry land. Bill and Hillary had their 8 years, and you are right- Obama will use a lot of Bill's people and we will be back in hot water. Better look twice at history!!! Guess what? Surprise! The Dems see it the other way around. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Guess what? Surprise! The Dems see it the other way around. The facts see it the other way around. What world does one have to be in to see the mess we are in now and completely miss how prosperous the 90's were? Who ran a surplus? Under who was I paying $0.99/gallon? Who had inflation under control? I could go on and on. And if I remember correctly Bill got put in there due to Bush Sr's incompetence forcing him to go back on his "I will not raise taxes" promise, among other major gaffes. No bid contracts, lying to go to war, breaking the law and our constitutional rights, attorney firings, forcing generals into retirement, out of control spending, a republican congress that did nothing, etc... I miss the days when the worst thing our president did was go to third base with an intern. This goes back to the same tired old Republican argument. Bill was unfit because he did such an immoral thing and (gasps) tried to cover it up. Obama will be unfit because he lacks experience. In the real world those accusing Bill were doing much worse things themselves, Bill did a fine job, and Obama's experience in Congress is twice that of Lincoln's. 

mamajulie --- 18 years ago -

and we will be back in hot water and what part of government now is NOT in hot water. Goodness, how in the world can you believe that. Just the fact that the wars are costing 12 billion each and every month should be enough to wake everyone up to the mess we have now. And this money is not, has never been part of the deficit budge. We as a country are more than broke, we are almost destitute. Why do you think the dollar has fallen so much in the world market. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Just the fact that the wars are costing 12 billion each and every month should be enough to wake everyone up to the mess we have now. And the not so funny thing is that we cut taxes during a time of war, issued T-Bills to pay for it (only republicans think the war was self sustained...), and those were bought massively by the Chinese government using the dollars we sent them importing their stuff, which also helped cut American jobs. 8 years of Bush, and the Chinese own a trillion dollars of the American government. If that's not hot water - caused by the republicans alone - I don't know what hot water is... 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

And one more comment - all this mess created by an "experienced" president... I'll take the one with no experience at all... 

My 3 and Me --- 18 years ago -

Would you want to go to a surgeon that had no experience? Umm, No! 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

Bush inherited a lot of problems from Bill and Hillary. ...who inherited problems from Bush and Reagan, who inherited problems from Carter, etc etc. At least Clinton took the problems he inherited and made things better. Bush took the ropes and put us in debt and now he's getting out scott free. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

I don't like Obama because I disagree with his ideology. I feel the only reason he is doing as well as he is, is because he doesn't have a track record. 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

Would you want to go to a surgeon that had no experience? Umm, No! Did you even read the original post? I don't like Obama because I disagree with his ideology. I feel the only reason he is doing as well as he is, is because he doesn't have a track record. I created this topic to put a definite end to anyone saying Obama's lack of experience makes him unfit to lead. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Would you want to go to a surgeon that had no experience? Would you go to a surgeon with a track record similar to Bush as president? Be honest... 

CoralReef --- 18 years ago -

Would you go to a surgeon with a track record similar to Bush as president? Be honest... Good one, LOL> HELL NO!!! 

clever --- 18 years ago -

Would you go to a surgeon with a track record similar to Bush as president? Would you go to a surgeon like Obama and his teachers were Wright or Farrakhan? Oh heck no. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Does a President Need to be Experienced? Nah...go for it. 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

end to anyone saying Obama's lack of experience makes him unfit to lead. I have stated before that the only true way to judge a politician is to view his or her voting history. I know for a fact that my candidate stands firmly behind what he says he will do because he has a proven decade of voting that way. You can't just watch Faux news or go to a rally and listen to a candidate recite the speech that was prepared for him and believe that he or she is the candidate that best supports your own views. If they don't have a proven voting history to be judged by they probably can not honestly produce all that they have promised. 

bubble28 --- 18 years ago -

Would you go to a surgeon like Obama and his teachers were Wright or Farrakhan? Oh heck no. Hagee,Falwell,Robertson,Parsley, I feel better, don't all of you? Ignorance is Bliss, everyone has moved on the Rev. Wright,even Fox is running that one out. Keep up, what else do you actually have??? His judgement on the war? Oh wait, he made the right choice. You guys just can't deal right now. McCain has been having some bad days, he will spring back. Maybe , spring wasn't the right choice of words! 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

I would go to a surgeon like Ron Paul, not that it should matter but his military record and professional record are far better than McCain's or Obama's. Where does your candidate rank? To simplify the ranking, each candidate will be graded from 1 to 5 on each of the 20 criteria. The 20 criteria are listed below, along with a short description for each. How does your candidate rank? 1. Liberty-based Voting Record - Ron Paul is the standard bearer of a true liberty and constitutional based voting record not equaled by any candidate. It should be virtually impossible for a candidate to get a perfect score of 5 here. For candidates that do not have voting records the default score should be a 3. 2. The Federal Reserve and Monetary Policy - Most candidates don’t even discuss this. If a candidate wishes to abolish the Fed à la Ron Paul they should get a 4. If they also want to legalize competing currencies then they should get a 5. 3. Foreign Policy and Iraq - A candidate advocating a non-interventionist foreign policy and returning our troops from Iraq deserve a 4. If that candidate also wants to bring our troops home from bases overseas that deserves a 5. 4. Taxes - Abolishing the income tax and replacing it with nothing earns the candidate a 5. Advocating for a low flat tax or a consumption tax should get a 3. If that candidate also wishes to repeal the 16th amendment it should earn a 4. 5. Government Spending - Earmark reform is a drop in the bucket and should earn a 2. Advocating reducing the debt brings that up to a 4. Requiring a yearly balanced budget brings that up to a 5. 6. Privacy and Civil Liberties - Voting or speaking out against the recent FISA bill gives a candidate a 2. Also advocating for leaving same sex marriage up to the states brings it up to a 3. Advocating for repealing the Patriot Act as well brings the score to a 4. Also advocating against the Real ID Act brings the score up to a 5. 7. Immigration - Advocacy for no amnesty gives a candidate a 3. Advocating for no border fence as well gives a candidate a 4. Treating the problem by reducing the welfare incentive brings the score up to a 5. 8. Gun Control and Second Amendment - Having a pro-Second-Amendment voting record gives a candidate a 3. Lauding the latest DC Gun Ban Supreme Court decision as a big win for the Second amendment brings it to a 4. Completely rejecting any form of obstruction to the free ownership of any type of firearm (to include background checks and waiting periods) brings the score up to a perfect 5. 9. Internet Regulation - Being against Net Neutrality is a 3 since, as Ron Paul says, it is regulation even if you may agree with the goal. Advocating the for Internet gambling and protecting freedom of speech on the Internet brings the score up to a 5. 10. Adherence To The Constitution - How well do the programs (or voting record) a candidate supports match the Constitution? This could be considered a fairly subjective one. 11. Religion vs. Public Policy - Ron Paul walks the religion vs. public policy line very well. He very rarely ever mentions his religious beliefs on the campaign trail. The more a candidate wears religion on his sleeve the lower the score should be for this one. 12. Environment - If the candidate believes that the jury is still out about man made global warming her gets a 4. If he also advocates allowing the free market and court system to handle environmental problems and disputes he gets a 5. 13. Energy Policy - Advocating drilling in ANWR gives the candidate a 3. Also advocating drilling off of our coast lines gives the candidate a 4. Also advocating for more Nuclear power brings the score up to a 5. 14. U.S. Sovereignty - Speaking out against the North American Union (NAU) gives the candidate a 5. Most candidates don’t even mention it. Those that don’t get a zero. 15. War On Drugs - Advocating ending the war on drugs gives the candidate a 3. Also advocating leaving medicinal marijuana use up to the states brings that up to a 4. Adding to that the order to free all non-violent drug offenders from prisons brings the score up to a 5. 16. Education - Advocating getting rid of the Department of Education scores a 4. Advocating for home schooling as well brings this score up to a 5. 17. Welfare Programs - Wanting to gracefully rid ourselves of the Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid programs earns a 5. 18. Abortion - Being personally against abortion, wanting to overturn Roe v. Wade, but leaving the legality of abortion up to the states earns a 5. 19. Health Care - Advocating for any kind of socialized national health care system earns zero points. Leaving it up to the free market, putting health care decisions back into the patients and doctors hands earns a 5. 20. Ability To Spread The Liberty Message - This is, for the most part, the ability to get media attention/appearances on main stream media outlets. The more people hear the sweet liberty message the better. Keep in mind some candidates have the ability to spread the liberty message but don’t actually have a liberty message, and should get downgraded. 

bubble28 --- 18 years ago -

BUSH/CHENEY!! 

david --- 18 years ago -

i wouldnt say experience but real solutions on how to solve issues not "change" 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

He has experienced advisers and other people helping him out In Obama's corner, you will have people like Reverend Wright and Tony Rezko...that inspires confidence! Imagine a president who sat under a preacher of hate for 20 plus years. Imagine what a guy like this will do to - and for - our country. Plum scary folks. 

bubble28 --- 18 years ago -

Plum scary folks. You mean John McCain's relationship with Hagee, Falwell, Robertson and Parsley? Yeah, I agree that is plum scary folks!! I mean at every level all 4 of these scary folks should not be embraced by a presidential candidate. 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

My vote is for the guy with the lengthy voting record on issues I agree with, that wants to fire most of congress, and wants to fire the federal reserve and IRS. 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

What has John McCain accomplished during his 2+ decades in the Senate besides no earmarks? Anything else? 

CommonSense --- 18 years ago -

What has John McCain accomplished during his 2+ decades in the Senate besides no earmarks? Anything else? It doesn't matter what he's accomplished, he's completely flip-flopped on everything he stood for. 

Nightstorm --- 18 years ago -

I don't like Obama because I disagree with his ideology. I feel the only reason he is doing as well as he is, is because he doesn't have a track record. planemom, I'm glad you said you "feel" because all you stated above can only be a feeling you have as opposed to something based on fact. 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

i> the only true way to judge a politician is to view his or her voting history According to Congressional Quarterly, McCain voted with Bush 100 percent of the time so far this year, 95 percent of the time in 2007, and around 90 percent since Bush took office. Experienced or not, a vote for McCain is more or less a vote for a third term of Bush. (Don't count on health care for the kiddos being any easier to afford.) 

bubble28 --- 18 years ago -

Obama and his teachers were Wright or Farrakhan? This is what you always go to when you have nothing intelligent to say! I think Phil Gramm and Hagee and Robertson and Bush are really great role models for McCain. McCain will be glad to hang his hat with these guys. We should all feel warm and fuzzy with his past relationships. 

Agent of Change --- 18 years ago -

According to Congressional Quarterly, McCain voted with Bush 100 percent of the time so far this year, 95 percent of the time in 2007, and around 90 percent since Bush took office. And he's maintaining that track record in this Congressional year. If you like Bush - vote for McSame 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground