Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Potty Training with Underwear

who's talking here?

MomofTwins 2
cmi 6
QueenCassie 3
Dentalgal 2
La_Guerita 2
Sue 1
chappers 1
chunksNbones 1
"AmysAngels" 1
bidingmytime 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

cmi --- 18 years ago -

I know there are a zillion potty training threads, but I want specific info here. My 3 year old won't sit on the potty. But, he also freaks out without a diaper on, saying he might poop on the floor. So, I think I am going to try potty training by just putting him straight in underwear. He is all game for it, or so he says! Several people have told me in the past that this is how they trained their kid and it only took a week. Has anyone ever done it under these circumstances, where the kid currently won't even sit on the potty. He has a few times, but stopped and won't sit anymore. He knows he's not a big boy until he starts wearing underwear and going in the potty, and he REALLY wants to be a big boy! LOL 

QueenCassie --- 18 years ago -

I am going through the exact same thing with my 3 yr old DD. Refused to even sit on the potty for poo. We have been using Pull-ups for quite awhile, with no luck. I guess it jsut feels like a diaper to her so she forgets and pees/poos in her Pull-ups.I started using regular panties 3 days ago and today she voluntarily came and told us she had to poo-poo on the toilet! And she did :) So I would say yes, go straight to regular underwear, it is working great for us. 

MomofTwins --- 18 years ago -

This method WILL work if he is ready for potty training and if you are willing to stick with it. If I remember correctly, Valentine on KU told her twins they no longer made diapers in their size, and went straight to underwear (I hope I'm remembering that correctly!). It might be a mess; prepare yourself for it if it is. I threw out all poop filled underwear - I never had the patience or desire to clean it. If he won't even sit on the potty, you are going to have to tell him, that in order to have the underwear he's going to HAVE TO sit on the potty. Make a sticker chart; add one sticker for each time he just sits on it; add another if he pees or 2 more if he poops. Make it fun and good luck! 

La_Guerita --- 18 years ago -

It's not going to be fun, but if he's ready, stick with it. If he won't even sit on the potty, you are going to have to tell him, that in order to have the underwear he's going to HAVE TO sit on the potty. This is how my daughter was trained at daycare and we did the same at home at night. Consistency is the KEY! 

QueenCassie --- 18 years ago -

As an added note- we were also having probs with her peeing in the toilet, she would go sit but still had so many accidents. For the past 3 days I have set a timer for 30 minutes, and when it goes off she knows it is time to go sit on the potty. It has worked so far, no accidents for 2 days! 

La_Guerita --- 18 years ago -

For the past 3 days I have set a timer for 30 minutes, and when it goes off she knows it is time to go sit on the potty. This is really good advice 

MomofTwins --- 18 years ago -

The timer is a great idea, as you don't have to nag all of the time. Set some ground rules and all should go fairly smoothly. 

QueenCassie --- 18 years ago -

This is really good advice The timer is a great idea, Thank you! I am so smart ;) Lol.. But really, it is for her & for me- when I get busy I tend to not realize how much time has gone past since she sat on the potty. Every 30 minutes seems to be the perfect amount of time for her. And now when she hears it beep, she gets up and says 'time for potty,Mommy!". 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

Thanks for all the advice so far. Another part I'm worried about is that he does NOT have predictable bowel movements. He poops when he poops, and it's several times a day. He has started telling us when he needs to poop and has sat a few times on the toilet, only to go in his diaper a few minutes later. Our older son had one bowel movement at the same time every day, so that part was easy. 

"AmysAngels" --- 18 years ago -

Several people have told me in the past that this is how they trained their kid and it only took a week. YES! I did this with my daughter and she really didn't like sitting on the potty. She is 2 1/2 and fully potty trained even to swim and travel with!! She still wears night time diapers to sleep in. But we are getting there. 

Dentalgal --- 18 years ago -

I am starting tomorrow to potty train my dd. I am trying a completely different way then I trained my son. It is a 3 Day potty training.com, I downloaded a book and you also get menotoring advice. It is great (or a guess I will see) you watch them and when they go you take them to the potty rather than spending the day in the bathroom, which didn't work for my dd, it scared her when she finally went. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

Okay, so now for the million dollar question.....how do I get DH on board? He's like eeewwwwwww about it. He kinda has to be on board b/c I work until 12:00. 

Dentalgal --- 18 years ago -

I have a treat for my dd if she goes, gummy bear, small chocolate, or sticker. You will be amazed when you put him in underwear how quickly it clicks. 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

The best way to potty train is to put the little tyke in big boy/girl undies. This is supposed to make them more aware of the discomfort of being wet or messy in their pants if they have an accident. A reward for successful pottying is good, but also, the fact that your child does not want to be in underware that is soiled is supposed to be the greatest incentive. No shame required, just logic that "hey, everyone has to potty and it's time for you to do it like mommie and daddie" With boys you put them on the potty backwards (because that makes their penis naturally point down) and float a cheerios in the toilet and tell them to make bubbles trying to hit the cheerio. (a game, a competitive game, goes their natural nature. tee hee) girls, I believe care more about not being wet in thier panties. This I read in Dr. Spock's book years ago. The child needs to be made to wear their own underpants and they need to be taken to the potty (regardless if they have to go) every couple of hours. The ritual is the whole point. If they go, great, they get a reward, if they don't go they try again. Dads need to do it exactly how you do or it won't work. Tell them this, simply. If they want their kid potty trained they need to get on board and do it the same way as you do.' Good luck! My 24, 17, and 14 all trained just fine this way... 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

Whew at 24, 17, and 14 I'd hope they'd be potty trained!! :-P I need to start potty training also, but mine is only going to be 2 next month....I think I'm going to get him those Gerber training pants...kinda like underwear, just thicker so less mess....Pull Ups wouldn't work on mine, he just uses them like a diaper Good luck to you! 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

They invent the coolest things for kids today!! You moms are so lucky! My sister had a 1 and a half year old and I just love seeing all the new kind of kids stuff now. It's awesome! Strollers are like cadillacs now, there are new bottles, when my sister was little we used glass bottles. Isn't innovation cool! 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

If they want their kid potty trained they need to get on board and do it the same way as you do.' He thinks pull ups will do just fine, but I am trying to tell him that the little one will just use them as a diaper. It's tough b/c he's the "stay at home" parent (works here), so technically it should be his choice. I just kind of sprung this on him. I think if I start it on the weekend, he'll be okay with it. He just doesn't like icky stuff and thinks he'll have to clean poopy underwear. I told him he can just throw those ones away. I'm hoping to share some success stories from KU with him! 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

Well, we started in the morning yesterday with a 45 minute potty stand off. He finally went and I put his BIG BOY underwear on him with a vinyl cover. We went to a playgroup. After about 15 minutes, I went outside to get him to potty. He was soaking wet. So, vinyl pants don't work! I put him in a diaper until we got home. Then, back to the underwear. No accidents since! He even woke up dry. So far, I'd go with the opinion that straight to underwear works. We'll see! 

Sue --- 18 years ago -

I used to swear by Dr. Spock with my three. I used to take them to the potty ever so many minutes to start to get them used to it. Back then they used to have heavy white cotton training pants, but I guess they don't make those anymore, and just have those pullups that you throw away.. 

chappers --- 18 years ago -

They DO still make those thick cotton undies, and they're a lifesaver! Often saves from having to chance actual clothing, just underwear. You can get them at Target, Walmart, both near the baby stuff (NOT in the toddler/big kid undies section). I highly recommend them!! 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

I have the padded training underwear. He would just treat the pull up like a diaper. I only used a pull up for sleeping last night. He was pissed when he woke up in a "diaper" instead of his big boy underwear! LOL 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground