Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Letting kids cry it out to sleep by themselves

who's talking here?

blessed 1
outermaga 1
cmi 4
mocha_mama 1
QueenCassie 1
Fancy 1
ambergris 1
Firewoman ;-) 1
FishinKim 4
*Annie* 2
Zionist NightOwl 4
Mabbers 4
I Kissed Frogs 14
buckey♥ 1
Flower Child 1
goldfishdust 1
christina 1
Sue 4
chappers 1
RX8LVR 1
ghostpost 1
Tootsieboo 2
chunksNbones 1
Setta 1
txlady67 1
mamamiaow 1
luvmylars 1
Forecaster 1
momof5 1
Buttercup:) 1
JET 5
Betty 2
NYCGIRL 1
Unichic™ 4
Sally Hardesty 2
Rhea 2
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 2
Paige Paige 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

I know all the books say to let babies cry themselves to sleep and after a few nights they are okay being left alone to sleep. Well what about when they are 10? Due to a previous medical condition my son is very afraid of the dark and wants to sleep with someone. His brother is in the same room but doesn't want to sleep in the same bed. I am honestly tired of sleeping in there too - he has a twin size bed so not comfy for both of us. The only relief we had was antianxiety drugs but they eventally started keeping him awake at night so we had to stop. Am I a horrible mom for making him cry himself to sleep? His doctor says he will never be able to control his fears with out drugs but I have a hard time buying that. Anyone else have older kids that are scared to sleep by themselves? 

blessed --- 18 years ago -

Oh bless your son's heart! Wow. I have no advice. I feel so bad for you both. What a hard call for you as a mom. I will say a prayer for you both. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

It's funny this came up b/c I was talking about it today at TCH. My son is only 5 and the neuropsychologist told me it wouldn't be a good idea to just make him cry it out when he has been sleeping with us for so long. This is how I felt, but everyone else seems to think I should just throw him in his bed and make him deal with it. I think I'll go with the expert! She said that it would be a whole process that she would lay out for us. Maybe the dr. can help you transition him. 

QueenCassie --- 18 years ago -

Ditto to what Blessed said! I had such a hard time doing that with my 3 yr old, I just can't imagine with a 10 yr old. Wish I had some good advice for you :( 

buckey♥ --- 18 years ago -

IKF, I was very afraid of the dark at that age. My mom would leave a lamp on or a hallway light on so that I was not totally in the dark. Also, maybe have a radio or even a t.v on so that he has something to listen to, and help him to fall asleep. That stuff helped me. I pray that he can overcome his fear. Poor guy! 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

With babies they cry and it breaks your heart. With him being 10 he can say things like "I am so scared, how come no one will sleep with me?" "I am afraid something will get me", etc. He has a light on in the room and I am 2 rooms away and keep reenforcing I am just down the hall and his brother is in the same room. He just isn't buying it tonight and I know part of it is because his brother had a sleep over last night so he got to sleep in our bed last night (two parents - joy). Well that can't happen every night because he kicks and my husband is complaining about me sleeping with him all the time and not being there for him at night. I wish I had a cloning machine! *** I am not sure if that made any sense, lol. I am rambling because I am so frustrated. I have spent more money on sound machines, sleep enducing scents, etc - waste of money*** 

christina --- 18 years ago -

Well my first 2 always slept with me when it was just us, but after getting remarried and having acouple more I had to make them sleep in their own room. It was REALLY hard and some nights I wondered who cried more me or them. But they adjusted and after a week or two it got easier. Good luck, just try to stay strong and remember it's better for them in the long run :) 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

my husband is complaining about me sleeping with him all the time and not being there for him at night. Ummmm...tell him you'll be there for him when you're done being there for your son. Sorry if that sounds rude, but if that really is a driving force here, I don't agree with your husband. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

Problem is my son wakes up many times during the night to make sure I am still there. And if I am not he starts to freak out. It got to the point I was so sleep deprived I would just stay in there all night. I can't just be there until he fails asleep because he will not stay asleep. 

Tootsieboo --- 18 years ago -

Here is what helped ours and they are around the same age. Leave a light on. Go tuck them in and say prayers with them but put them to bed at least 30 min to 1 hour before you go to bed. This makes mine feel safer knowing someone is still awake in the house. If that doesn't work I would try just sitting on the floor until he falls asleep. You will need to set some rules and maybe some rewards. Hope this helps. 

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

I don't really have any suggestions other than maybe a long body pillow. Do you suppose it would help if you got one of those for him to hug and hold onto at night. Maybe you can slip one of your shirts over it even so it has your scent and then keep a nightlight on. I'd even give him his own flashlight for when he gets really scared. They sell the wind up kind at BB&B so that you are not constantly replacing batteries. I bought those for my oldest 2 since they would occasionally get scared at night. I hope you find a solution that will work for both of you. 

goldfishdust --- 18 years ago -

Poor kiddo and poor suffering Mommy! This may only help a little bit, but thought I'd throw it in.... My friend's son dearly loved sleeping in Mommy and Daddy's bed, so much so that he would fake being scared or sick sometimes, just so they would bring him to their bed. Her brilliant idea was to designate Friday night as "HIS Night". Every Friday he was allowed to sleep in their bed, and they made a big deal about it, like a party of sorts, with a special before-bed snack, etc. So on other nights when he would ask to sleep there, they'd say, "Sorry, it's not Friday yet", and it worked amazingly well! Good luck with your son. 

luvmylars --- 18 years ago -

Your husband is going to have to sacrifice for a while... you've developed a habit for your son, and habits take a while to break. First, you will let him fall asleep with you in the bed, then sleep in the same room (obviously, you'll need another bed!). Once he is comfortable with that, you'll have him fall asleep in bed by himself, sleeping in the extra bed by yourself all the time reassuring him that you are there. After he is comfortable with that, you can start sleeping in your bed (hopefully on the same floor, preferably in the next room), and he will know that you are right there if he needs anything. But make sure he isn't allowed to come to you for small things he can do himself - getting a drink of water, going to the bathroom, etc. In time, he will be completely broken of his habit without much emotional breakage on his part. ;) I've done this successfully a couple of times with my son, who was diagnosed with Autism and never was able to sleep without my holding him as a baby. He would have literally screamed for hours if I had let it get to that point if I had listened to the "experts" who tell us to "let them cry it out". I am one who firmly believes that is only damaging to the relationship between mother and child. Your child should know that any time they are hurting (emotionally or physically), you are going to be there for them. You are the one who teaches them to trust. 

FishinKim --- 18 years ago -

I'm one of those mean moms who just doesn't sleep w/ kids in the bed. I don't have much advice for your situation because it sounds like maybe his past is causing him more than just the manipulative "I need to sleep w/ you". I will say that once my oldest, at about age 4, decided she had bugs in her room and she would not sleep in there....cried for hours. She ended up sleeping on the breezeway between the 2 sides of the house. For me it was a point of no return...I told her she wasn't sleeping w/ us every night, but she put on a huge show every night and lost. We even filled up squirt bottles to spray the bugs, opened windows, etc. Nothing worked except sticking to our guns. Now, it was a miserable week or maybe even 2 (I've forgotten it) but it worked. 

Sally Hardesty --- 18 years ago -

Yes you are a horrible mom for letting him cry when you know he has special 'issues'. (sorry but you *did* ask) If you aren't willing to nurture him thru this traumatic time, I recommend at least trying one of those electronic teddy bears they sell at Babies R Us that mimicks a heartbeat and womb-noises. Kids are so simple; I hate it when people act like there is some other solution other than just sucking it up and being what they are supposed to be for their kids. >:( I have one a-hole of a toddler; difficult 9-kinda-ways. Oh well. Was dealt it; I'll be damned if I just ignore it and let him feel as confused and un-loved as I did growing up. (guess you could say I remember having issues, too----but also am stuck with real bad memories of never being understood) 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

I'm with Luvmylars. This sounds alot like the conversation I had with the dr. today! 

Rhea --- 18 years ago -

I can tell you from personal experience that if your son has anxieties there is nothing you can do but help him feel secure. I had alot of anxieties when I was a child and had these same sorts of issues and nothing could console me when I started to freak out. It's such a comfort and someday he will grow out of it. Just buy a bigger bed or sleep in the floor on an air mattress. I actually have a degree in developemental psychology and sometimes brains are just wired differently. I also know my 10 year old son deals with these EXACT same issues that I did which I find amazing since I had never mentioned them to him. He still sleeps with his little brother and half of the time they both sleep downstairs because the upstairs is so far away. Needless to say I don't think making him cry himself to sleep at this stage of the game is a good idea at all. I let my little ones cry it out but at his age it's a much more complicated situation. You need to help him cope by a slow transition that you can both live with. I still live with my anxiety's today and I do take something to calm them down but if my parents hadn't been patient with me I think I'd be a real mess now. Anxiety is so complicated and frustrating for all involved. I know you want to just tell him to get over it but he can't. He will work it out on his own as he matures. 

Tootsieboo --- 18 years ago -

How about a baby monitor in his room so he can hear you breathing? That might make him know you are there without him having to get up. Or walkie talkies so you can talk to him without getting up. I know your pain. It hurts your heart but you both need to sleep. I hope you find something that works soon. I know I had to try several things before mine would stay out of our bed. We did have to use some tough love at times when we thought they were just waking up and coming into our room rather than being really scared. 

chappers --- 18 years ago -

Just a thought ...what about sleeping pills? Are the OK for kids of that age? I'm so sorry you are going through this, it must be so difficult. Best wishes to you. 

Sally Hardesty --- 18 years ago -

Just a thought ...what about sleeping pills? Yet another selfish way out. This pisses me off, you have no idea. Your JOB, once you decided to spawn, is to nurture/handle/protect/teach/guide/etc.... There are no easy ways out. Medication???????Wow I hope the broad that brought up sleeping pills for an apparently distressed child doesn't have any kids of her own. >:-( 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

I take melatonin (the sleep hormaone w/ the vitamins at the store) to sleep at night. It keeps me asleep through the entire night. I started taking it when I had so much anxiety about James when he was first diagnosed. Anyways, it worked for that anxiety. You should see if it's safe for kids. 

Rhea --- 18 years ago -

I just thought of what my husband did to get my kids to quit coming downstairs all night telling me that they couldn't sleep or that they had a bad dream. One night when they came down, before I could say anything, he asked them why they kept coming downstairs to tell us they couldn't sleep. He said from now on, everytime he couldn't sleep he was going to go upstairs and wake them up! I just died laughing at that and so did they. They giggled their way upstairs and the next night my husband spent the entire night waking them up telling them that he couldn't sleep. They got really mad! I don't know why it worked but they don't come down unless they have a REALLY bad dream. We still laugh about it. 

FishinKim --- 18 years ago -

Just a thought ...what about sleeping pills? Yet another selfish way out. This pisses me off, you have no idea. Not to get my panties in a wad...but Chappers is a wonderful mom who has certainly been in a horrible position this year not by her choice. Read some of her past posts and you would know she always has the best interest of hers and other peoples kids at heart. Her top priority is being the best mom she can be to her kids. 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

awww! I don't think I have any good advice, I only have a 2 year old, and I let him cry it out to get him to sleep by himself when he was about 6 months old I do know that I used to be very anxious about everything when I was a kid (still am!) and the thing that helped me was leaving my tv on a sleep timer for about an hour until I could fall asleep...Then if I woke up, so did the tv :) 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

I think a child being 10 years old is a little different than a 4 year old that's crying. You can reason with a 10 year old much easier, and listen to what their fears are. To say that you're a horrible parent for letting him cry himself to sleep, I don't think so at all. As long as he knows you're there, you love him, and you care, that's what matters. He needs to learn to self soothe a bit, there's nothing wrong with that. I don't know what his past troubles were, but hopefully, this is something that you will be able to work out quickly...for everyone's sanity. I don't know what your past issues are Sally, but I think you're being a little harsh with people and their suggestions. 

mocha_mama --- 18 years ago -

I am so sorry that you are going through this with your son. Prayers for him. I wish I had some advice for you but I don't. I am having the same issue with my 6 y/o son. Both he and my 5 y/o dd sleep with us....EVERY NIGHT. I've tried several times transitioning them to their own rooms, but ds has nightmares and dd is...well...just spoiled. I'll keep you guys in my thoughts. 

*Annie* --- 18 years ago -

I've only skimmed some of the responses since I'm tired but thought I'd offer this - The way my mom lured me into sleeping alone in my own room was to get me a puppy. The logic was there wasn't ample room for everyone and the dog in the bed. The dog "needed" to share the bed with me in my own room. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

Well he has been asleep 3 times tonight already and keeps waking up. He fell asleep the first time on his own, the second time with me sitting a the foot of his bed and the last time with me lying beside him. He is snoring this time so hopefully in a deeper sleep that will last longer. Regarding Melatonia, this was suggested in the past and did not work. It is natural but it is a hormone and I have had several people tell me since that they would not give a hormone to anyone under the age of 18 so I haven't tried it again. Has anyone used weighted blankets with their kids or other family members before? And Sally, I know I asked for opinions and I definately got yours and unfortunately so did someone else that was trying to help me. Please remember that the best of people get frustrated and tired from time to time and your comments are harsh when we are trying to brainstorm ideas that will work for everyone best interest in my family. I have tried and will continue to try many different things until I find something that works. Yes my main job is caring for my son but I also realize that if we don't get some decent sleep consistantly I will not be any good to him in the long run. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

Funny you mentioned a puppy Annie. I have tried everything posted on this thread including a puppy. Even the dog only wants to sleep with me, lol. I must give off good sleep energy or something. 

*Annie* --- 18 years ago -

I would do anything and everything to keep the dog in his room. If your son tosses & turns alot, perhaps a dog bed at the foot of his bed. If you wanted to play dirty, you could make your room seem less desirable to the dog - noise or scent can help deter. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

IKF, our pediatrician recommended Dr. Richard Ferber's book "Solve Your Child's Sleep Problems" when DS was 3. The library should have a copy; it was a best seller. Although he does recommend the "crying it out", it is done in a very loving way. First, you're gradually moving out of the room, not just all at once. E.g., you might sit in a chair in the room with him, and then inch it closer to the hallway. Also, you let him cry for a short time in the beginning, and then slowly build up the time intervals between checking on him. Although it may not be for everyone, it worked great for us when our kids were 2-3. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

Thanks Nightowl. I keep getting pictures of Good Night Moon in my head and I will be the old bunny in the red chair knitting away. How on earth do you remember stuff for all the books you read? I have read so many they all run together and you always know the name and the author. Your brain amazes me. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

lol. That book actually worked so well for us that we used it on E, too. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

Thanks for listening to me tonight ladies. He is still snoring so I am going to try and go down to my bed and get some sleep. Good night everyone. 

FishinKim --- 18 years ago -

Ferber is a controversial figure for many. I agree with his concept of a schedule...but don't agree w/ his schedule. I hope you can find a way to make this work for all of you. It has to be exhausting. 

Sue --- 18 years ago -

Your marriage might suffer sometime in the furure, unfortunately, if this doesn't stop. How old is his brother? What is he afraid of? I truly think, at this age, he knows how to work you and you give in. On what else with him do you give in? I'd say,if he awakens, just let him lie there for awhile and don't rush in, as he knows you will. Tell him you're tired, and you're sleeping in your own bed. 

Sue --- 18 years ago -

 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

Ferber is a controversial figure for many Yes, he is; that's why I said it's not for everyone. I just know it worked great for us. The first 2 nights were awful (power struggle for about an hour); the 3rd night was a shorter struggle; and by the 4th night, barely any resistance at all to getting in bed and staying there. Good luck with whatever you end up trying. 

txlady67 --- 18 years ago -

when i was 10 years old i was scared of the dark. my parents kept a lamp on in my room. i also had my blankie that i slept with. 

FishinKim --- 18 years ago -

Ferber is a controversial figure for many Yes, he is; that's why I said it's not for everyone. I just know it worked great for us. Exactly why I didn't bash him. I ended up being a VERY modified Ferber person. I probably would have developed our style even w/ out reading his books. I had a severely colickly 1st baby and was up for anything. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground