Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

do you know anything about the movie The Golden Compass.

who's talking here?

OneHotMama 2
gking 3
thekat 2
wayward1 1
Deltadawn 1
eldiablo 4
momof5 1
Natu 5
allofus 8
doodlelab 1
flyonthewall 3
pollyanna 5
bruiserbetty* 3
Bluesky!! 1
sunnymunchkins@hotmail.com 1
KU-kid 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

thekat --- 18 years ago -

My kids and I were going to watch it on PPV but they are telling me their dad said they couldn't watch it. THey can't really tell me why and I was just wondering if anyone knew why he wouldn't want them to see it. 

Natu --- 18 years ago -

in short, the books are written by an open atheist. While the movie isn't too terrible, the series of books is like the opposite to the Chronicles of Narnia. At the end of the series of books, the children end up killing "God". There are some old threads here. Do a search and you should find them. 

thekat --- 18 years ago -

ok thanks....I guess that makes sense considering they are Catholic. 

Natu --- 18 years ago -

Here's one of the old threads. Golden Compass 

Natu --- 18 years ago -

I watched the movie on the flight to India. The thing that bothered me about it was that each human has an animal that is attached to them. It could be a cat, dog, lion, bird, whatever. So as the person moved, the animal was always somewhere nearby. They called these animals demons and so the whole movie, it was where's your demon, or so and so's demon. I just wish they would have chosen another word. That bothered me. 

bruiserbetty* --- 18 years ago -

i loved the movie. 

KU-kid --- 18 years ago -

First of all, the word wasn't demon. It was Daemon. And second of all, The book isn't completely about killing God. In fact there are a myriad of Christian symbols in the books. 

Bluesky!! --- 18 years ago -

I would have a bird or a cat daemon.....or a transvestite midget, hard choice. 

doodlelab --- 18 years ago -

I would have a bird or a cat daemon.....or a transvestite midget, hard choice. okay, this just cracked me up. 

OneHotMama --- 18 years ago -

I give your kids' father credit for being in touch enough to know that the movie has many themes that are against their beliefs and for sharing that with your children. And good for your kids for sharing that with you. Good for you for listening to them and for respecting their father's wishes. 

flyonthewall --- 18 years ago -

What a coincidence! My husband and I are about to watch it. We rented it. I have heard it is an ant-religious allegory of sorts. I have also heard the books were great. I will watch it purely for entertainment value...no movie is going to change my mind about the existence of God. 

OneHotMama --- 18 years ago -

from what I read regarding reviews of the movie, the anti-God themes are "snuck" into the movie to make it entertaining to children. that is scary to me. 

bruiserbetty* --- 18 years ago -

..no movie is going to change my mind about the existence of God. yeah...that would be ludacris 

Deltadawn --- 18 years ago -

no movie is going to change my mind about the existence of God. Couldn't agree with you more. I saw the movie and enjoyed. 

momof5 --- 18 years ago -

no movie is going to change my mind about the existence of God. Exactly. Regardless of the views of the writer, the movie was meant to entertain. Take it for that and nothing else and enjoy it. 

wayward1 --- 18 years ago -

I think the chances of this movie turning you against God is as likely has watching the lion on Narnia and coming to Jesus. 

Natu --- 18 years ago -

First of all, the word wasn't demon. It was Daemon. ok, but what 9 year old kid knows that? the word sounds like demon and it bothered me. 

bruiserbetty* --- 18 years ago -

I think the chances of this movie turning you against God is as likely has watching the lion on Narnia and coming to Jesus. lol 

flyonthewall --- 18 years ago -

ok, but what 9 year old kid knows that? the word sounds like demon and it bothered me. Yeah...it sounded like demon to me too....unless that was just their British accent! 

gking --- 18 years ago -

Exactly. Regardless of the views of the writer, the movie was meant to entertain. Take it for that and nothing else and enjoy it. Again - consider the audience. An adult is way more prepared to extract only the entertainment portion, whereas children are still very impressionable. Now is the time for parents to make the impressions they feel are most important in the formation of their belief system, etc. It certainly is admirable that this parent is actually active in this regard instead of lazying out like so many other parents do. Then before you know it, you don't even know your own kids any more. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

demons a if you read the book it is not a demon... it is a daemon whoops didnt read the whole thing 

eldiablo --- 18 years ago -

One problem is that all of Pullman's stories are "about destroying God" (his quote by the way). A 2nd problem is that his stories are written for children so that they reach the widest audience. Jesus taught with parables (stories) to make his points. Stories do affect us on several levels, and to different extents depending on how grounded we are. On a side-note, the "myriad" of Christian symbols another poster mentioned just means that Pullman wishes to mask his intentions. The Devil is not going to come at you with a pitchfork and red union suit...he will distract you with any means possible to get you off a narrow path...even if he has to pretend to be Jesus to accomplish that. He may even look like Tom Cruise :-) 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

i read this book as a young teenager. My father brought the first in the trilogy home from him when he visited scotland one time then i found the rest over here. Phillip pullman is an excellent writer. I wish i still had the whole trilogy instead of just the third book. I am a very advanced reader and i got that is was in no way real. It is all a mythological type book. heck who believes you can walk on the milky way... etc. I in no way correlated this to killing God. I am also a catholic. I also dont believe you should read too much into a book. Some things are written as total FICTION not to be confused with fact. Anyone who is taught anything about literature should understand this. Do you read macbeth and believe there are truly witches. Or take shakespeare at his word. Do you believe a raven can talk or think that Poe is just a sadistic B*stard laying bricks to hole someone up in a room.. No you see it as what it is wonderful literature. You cant look for someone trying to corrupt your children in everything they read. A person should read as much as possible in a varying genre in order to be as knowledgeable as possible. You should not put a limit on what good literature should be written about, what about books on Faeries. Are those not to be read because they are mythological. What about norse and greek mythology. What about the dragonwyck novels. Or anne rice... or better yet the ogre novel. I read all of those as a child. I personally consider myself to be well read. And I have read a variety. I do not believe in limiting reading due to content. What is next book burnings? 

eldiablo --- 18 years ago -

What is next book burnings? No book burnings...adults should read and watch whatever they want...just do not ignore the agenda of a writer who definitely has expressed an agenda in his interviews...that would be naive. 

eldiablo --- 18 years ago -

Do you read macbeth and believe there are truly witches No...I believe that Shakespeare believed that his audience would know what a witch is. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

just do not ignore the agenda of a writer who definitely has expressed an agenda in his interviews as a parent we teach our children morals and values. We also teach them to separate fact from fiction. This is a work of fiction. If your child believes it then who it to blame. I think that a book is just that a fantasy if we are taught correctly in no way should it cross our mind as fact. One thing brought up was narnia. I watched that. The idea of a lion talking and a kingdom in the closet is about as ridiculous as a parallel universe where our souls are manifested as animals and the goal is to walk on the aurora aborialus. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

No...I believe that Shakespeare believed that his audience would know what a witch is. and if Shakespeare gave us as much credit shouldnt that be transferred to other works of fiction Have you read this book? Judged for yourself? or are you just spouting what you have heard. 

eldiablo --- 18 years ago -

if Shakespeare gave us as much credit shouldnt that be transferred to other works of fiction It does not matter if the Good Samaritan is fact or fiction...it illustrates a point that is understandable. Pullman's work also illustrates and raises points that are understandable. Pullman's story may be enjoyable and well-told, but the message may not support the parent's instruction to their children who are not as advanced on many levels. The messages are there, but those messages are not in Shakespeare or Poe's work. They told great stories, but did not have the agenda that Pullman admits he has. 

pollyanna --- 18 years ago -

Just thought you might find this interesting.... Although he did not set out to do so, in the process of writing his fantasy works, Lewis (an adult convert to Christianity) found himself incorporating Christian theological concepts into his stories. As he wrote in Of Other Worlds: Some people seem to think that I began by asking myself how I could say something about Christianity to children; then fixed on the fairy tale as an instrument, then collected information about child psychology and decided what age group I’d write for; then drew up a list of basic Christian truths and hammered out ‘allegories’ to embody them. This is all pure moonshine. I couldn’t write in that way. It all began with images; a faun carrying an umbrella, a queen on a sledge, a magnificent lion. At first there wasn’t anything Christian about them; that element pushed itself in of its own accord. And yet.... Lewis has also received criticism from Christians and Christian organizations who feel that The Chronicles of Narnia promotes "soft-sell paganism and occultism", because of the recurring pagan themes and the supposedly heretical depictions of Christ as an anthropomorphic lion. The Greek god Bacchus and the Maenads are depicted in a positive light, although they are generally considered distinctly pagan motifs. Even an animistic "River god" is portrayed in a positive light (Chattaway 2005), (Berit 2005). According to Josh Hurst of Christianity Today, "not only was Lewis hesitant to call his books Christian allegory, but the stories borrow just as much from pagan mythology as they do the Bible" (Hurst 2005). Lewis himself believed that pagan mythology could act as a preparation for Christianity, both in history and in the imaginative life of an individual, and even suggested that modern man was in such a lamentable state that perhaps it was necessary "first to make people good pagans, and after that to make them Christians" (Lewis, Calabria & Moynihan 1998). He also argued that imaginative enjoyment of (as opposed to belief in) classical mythology has been a feature of Christian culture through much of its history, and that European literature has always had three themes: the natural, the supernatural believed to be true (practiced religion) and the supernatural known to be imaginary (mythology). 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

Pullman's story may be enjoyable and well-told, but the message may not support the parent's instruction to their children who are not as advanced on many levels. So would not this be a good learning tool. The books are advanced books. Made for a child or teen more likely who is already taught right from wrong etc. If you are letting your young child watch this. then wouldnt it be something you could use as a teaching tool. Also from the look of the previews a child under the age of 8 wouldnt understand the movie at all it is geared towards a little older crowd who should already be taught. As I said i read pullmans stories as a young teen. they were obvious in that they are fiction. even a child of five understands that people do not have an animal following them around. This story is a basic story of good versus evil. That I will give you. But if I remember correctly in the 3rd book, good triumphs. Good always triumphs. There were three tools... the compass.. the knife and I forget the third it has been awhile. The children battle many imaginary creatures and one wicked witch type person. it is literature. simply literature. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

pollyanna. That is the most intelligent thing I have read and it is true. People always set out to destroy what they themselves do not understand 

Natu --- 18 years ago -

demons a if you read the book it is not a demon... it is a daemon whoops didnt read the whole thing exactly, not all kids that watch the movie, or all adults for that matter, will have read the books. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

exactly, not all kids that watch the movie, or all adults for that matter, will have read the books which is quite the problem with making a book into a movie. A lot gets lost in translation. 

pollyanna --- 18 years ago -

pollyanna. That is the most intelligent thing I have read and it is true. People always set out to destroy what they themselves do not understand well, I would love to take credit, but I have to thank ol' Wikipedia for that one. It just goes to show that you can never make everyone happy, lol. The same group that holds him up as a great example of a Christian author for children also criticized him for trying to incorporate paganism in his books.Go figure. 

allofus --- 18 years ago -

no you cant make everyone happy. But if you read his (CSLewis') books and let yourself get absorbed into them he really makes the books; i cant really explain it well, like draw you in and make you feel like you can see feel taste smell everything. I love to lose myself in a book and become someone else for awhile. Heck when I am reading a book the real world all but ceases to exist. Unfortunately it also makes me say yes to anything to make the person go away.. or puts me at my most aggravated when I am interrupted of course that being said only while I am reading is it "real" to me. When I put it down and examine it in my mind I examine it as fiction 

pollyanna --- 18 years ago -

lol...I teach reading and try to convey that to the kids everyday. I tell them to imagine what it would be like to watch television, with no commercials-ever, you can take the tv with you where ever you go, and if your mom needs you to do some chores, you can turn it back on exactly where you left off. I am an avid reader...I always have a book in my hand. And whether it is C.S. Lewis or Phillip Pullman, I can always find a reason to appreciate it, if nothing else it makes me question the status quo, why I believe what I believe and I become a better person for it. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

Some things are written as total FICTION not to be confused with fact. Unless you read L. Ron Hubbard's crap. Plenty seem to confuse his fiction for fact. 

pollyanna --- 18 years ago -

When I worked at Barnes and Noble, his books were in the self-help section. Never knew if that meant his books provided self-help or you needed help if you purchased them. lol 

gking --- 18 years ago -

When I worked at Barnes and Noble, his books were in the self-help section. Who's? Pullman's? 

pollyanna --- 18 years ago -

Hubbard's 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground