Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

How Stuff Works - What happened to the World Trade Center Towers

who's talking here?

Fallon 1
bbjones 1
RotorHead 1
Tyrus 4
Zionist NightOwl 1
Renace 5
R.E.B. 1
haroldoftherocks 1
carmineskeeper 1
Fin and Feather 1
Forecaster 2
willie wierdie 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Tyrus --- 18 years ago -

by Tom Harris September 11th, 2001 On the morning of September 11, 2001, immediately after terrorists struck the Twin Towers, it looked as though the buildings might remain standing. While the plane crashes had taken huge chunks out of both towers, the overall structure seemed to be intact, at least to the observers on the ground and the millions of Americans watching the catastrophe on television. But within an hour, World Trade Center 2 had collapsed, followed by World Trade Center 1 only 40 minutes later. In the weeks after the attacks, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the Structural Engineering Institute of the American Society of Civil Engineers (SEI/ASCE) assembled a team of scientists and engineers to investigate exactly how the buildings collapsed. Based on video, eyewitness accounts and debris analysis, the team formed a likely hypothesis of what happened, which they made public in April 2002. In August 2002, the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), an agency in the U.S. Commerce Department, announced it would launch its own two-year, $16 million study of the collapse. The following is a summary of the FEMA evaluation teams' findings, which were largely along the same lines as the numerous media evaluations in the weeks after the attacks. You can read the entire report at the FEMA Web site. When the planes hit the two towers, the collisions damaged each building in two major ways: * In each case, the force of the speeding plane knocked out a number of vertical columns around the building perimeter, damaged large sections of floor, sent furniture and plane wreckage flying through the offices and presumably damaged support columns in each building's core. Most likely, the initial impact also destroyed the sprinkler system on those floors. The evaluation team estimates that the first plane -- a 395,000-pound (180,000-kg) Boeing 767-200ER going about 470 miles per hour (756 kph) -- fractured as many as 36 perimeter support columns over a four-story area of WTC 1's north face. The connected floors partially collapsed, and the central core suffered undefined damage. The second plane, a Boeing 767-200ER flying at about 590 miles per hour (950 kph), inflicted similar damage on WTC 2. The collision fractured as many as 32 perimeter columns over a five-story area, collapsing sections of connected floor and damaging the central core. * In each attack, the crash ignited the plane's' fuel supply, causing a massive fireball -- an expanding area of burning gas. While the ignited fuel didn't really explode, the fireball did spread fire down the side of the building, throughout the nearby floors and down interior shafts to lower floors. The investigators hypothesized that nearly all of the jet fuel was consumed in the initial fireball and first few minutes of the building fire, but it ignited enough office equipment, paper and building materials to keep the fire raging until the collapse. Amazingly, the initial damage to the support structure was not enough to topple the building. The report, as well as a number of prominent engineers, have claimed that the majority of skyscrapers on the planet would have collapsed within seconds of such a collision. But the collisions did divert the entire vertical load of the buildings to the remaining columns, significantly increasing the structure's stress level. Without any additional loads on the support structure, the report claims, the towers could have stayed up indefinitely. But the extreme heat of the fire, which might have been in excess of 2,000 degrees Fahrenheit (1,090 C) at some points, exerted tremendous stress on the perimeter columns, the core columns, and the floor trusses in between them. The main factor was really the size of the fire -- the total area it covered. Building fires typically start with a small fire -- say a burning cigarette on a stack of papers -- which gradually spreads through a larger area. In that situation, the fire is most intense where it has the most fuel (stuff that can burn), and it significantly weakens the support structure only at those most intense points. If a fire starts in the northwest corner of a skyscraper floor, by the time the fire reaches the southeast corner, the starting fire at the starting point will have burned through most of the fuel, and the fire will not be as intense. The result is the fire doesn't put maximum strain on the total support structure all at once. It strains different parts of the support structure in turn, over time. In the case of the World Trade Center, the burning jet fuel spread the fire across several floors in a matter of seconds. This massive fire put exceptional strain on the structure at nearly all points on those floors. Additionally, the report suggests that the force of the collision removed much of the fire-resistant material sprayed on the steel, making the structure more susceptible to heat damage. The heat expanded, twisted and buckled the steel support structure, gradually reducing the building's stability. Any number of things could have happened during this period. For example, connections between vertical columns and floor trusses probably broke, dropping sections of floor on lower levels and breaking connections between the core and the perimeter wall, possibly causing columns along the perimeter to buckle outward. Every broken connection or buckled length of steel added to the force acting on connected steel segments, until the entire structure was weakened to the point that it couldn't hold the upper section of the building. When this happened, the top part of each building collapsed onto the lower part of the building. Essentially, this was like dropping a 20-story building on top of another building. Before the crash, this upper structure exerted a constant downward force -- its weight -- on the superstructure below. Obviously, the lower superstructure was strong enough to support this weight. But when the columns collapsed, the upper part of the building started moving -- the downward force of gravity accelerated it. The momentum of an object -- the quantity of its motion -- is equal to its mass multiplied by its velocity. So when you increase the velocity of an object with a set mass, you increase its momentum. This increases the total force that the object can exert on another object. To understand how this works, think of a hammer. Resting in your hand, it doesn't hurt you at all. But if you drop it on your foot, it can do some damage. Similarly, if you swing the hammer forward, you can apply enough force to drive nails into a wall. When the upper structure of each tower fell down, its velocity -- and therefore its momentum -- increased sharply. This greater momentum resulted in an impact force that exceeded the structural integrity of the columns immediately underneath the destroyed area. Those support columns gave way, and the whole mass fell on the floors even farther down. In this way, the force of the falling building structure broke apart the superstructure underneath, crushing the building from the top, one floor at a time. To put it another way, the potential energy of the building mass, the energy of position it had due to its height and the pull of gravity, was converted into kinetic energy, or energy of motion (the report puts the total potential energy for WTC 1 at 4*10^11 joules). This is the same basic principle that professional demolition blasters use to bring down unoccupied buildings. WTC 2, the second tower hit, actually collapsed before WTC 1. This was most likely due to two different factors. First, WTC 2 probably suffered greater immediate damage -- the second plane to hit was going faster than the first. Secondly, the plane that hit WTC 2 crashed lower on the building than the plane that hit WTC 1. Consequently, the strained support columns in WTC 2 had a greater load pressing down on them than the strained columns in WTC 1, so it would make sense that they reached the buckling point more quickly. While the towers' support structure ultimately couldn't withstand the raging fire, it was strong enough to save thousands of people's lives. Around 99 percent of the people below the impact in each tower were able to evacuate before the buildings collapsed. If the towers hadn't been built with redundant structural stability, the death toll would have easily been in the tens of thousands.  

Renace --- 18 years ago -

Gee, something that you and I appear to be in agreement on. I've read and viewed so much on the four 9/11 planes and there isn't really anything from an engineering and physics standpoint that disputes the official explanations. Those who are still harboring suspicions need to read some of the articles that get into what actually happened. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

Gee, something that you and I appear to be in agreement on. Big smiles!!!!! 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

exactly W, but don't hold your breath. Some people will read and study this and still blame the government. Yet they are the same folks who want the government to take care of them from cradle to grave. 

Renace --- 18 years ago -

Some people will read and study this and still blame the government. Yet they are the same folks who want the government to take care of them from cradle to grave. You get carried away, Fallon. I believe that the official explanation covers what happened to the planes that day. I also believe that the jury is still out on what government actually did or neglected to do that did have or might have had an impact on what happened that day. I also believe that the jury may always remain out on that. 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

WTC-7 

willie wierdie --- 18 years ago -

exactly W, but don't hold your breath. Some people will read and study this and still blame the government. Yet they are the same folks who want the government to take care of them from cradle to grave. excuse me but the president was given intelligence that there were terrorists that were going to strike in the US by hijacking planes and Bush ignored this evidence. I blame the government for ignoring the intelligence that was reported by the CIA. Oh and I do not depend on the government to take care of me thank you very much. 

Renace --- 18 years ago -

excuse me but the president was given intelligence that there were terrorists that were going to strike in the US by hijacking planes and Bush ignored this evidence. I blame the government for ignoring the intelligence that was reported by the CIA. Oh and I do not depend on the government to take care of me thank you very much. Exactly, ww, but don't hold your breath. Some people will read and study the record of the events that preceded 9/11 and still feel that the government shares no blame. Yet they are the same folks who have defended the government as it has sent 4,000 of those serving in Iraq to early graves. 

R.E.B. --- 18 years ago -

Exactly, ww, but don't hold your breath. Some people will read and study the record of the events that preceded 9/11 and still feel that the government shares no blame. Yep...they were planned while Clinton was president. Bush had only been President about 8 months when it happened. By then, the ball had been rolling for a couple of years. 

willie wierdie --- 18 years ago -

By then, the ball had been rolling for a couple of years. and the intelligence was ignored by President Bush a month before the attacks. 

carmineskeeper --- 18 years ago -

We dont know anything, we never will know anything so why invade your brians with such trash? Truth is in the eye of the beholder right... 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

I blame the government for ignoring the intelligence that was reported by the CIA. Is that the same CIA that provided the Iraq WMD intelligence? 

Renace --- 18 years ago -

and the intelligence was ignored by President Bush a month before the attacks. Yep...they were planned while Clinton was president. Bush had only been President about 8 months when it happened. By then, the ball had been rolling for a couple of years. Exactly, ww AND R.E.B. That's just one of the great tragedies. Intelligence that, as R.E.B. agrees, had been accumulating for a couple of years, was ignored by Bush and those closest to him. He'd deserve more slack if he hadn't been handed some well developed data and given 8 months to act on it. 

Tyrus --- 18 years ago -

and the intelligence was ignored by President Bush a month before the attacks. How about citing a source for your accusation. And how about the intelligence reports that were given to Clinton? 

Renace --- 18 years ago -

the ball had been rolling for a couple of years. How rare to find so much agreement on a largely political thread on KU. Most of us agree that the events on 9/11 happened substantially as the official report describes, that it is doubtful that our government was directly involved in those events, and that, in the months before 9/11, there was intelligence provided to the President and those closest to him that such an attack might occur. What are we gonna do with all this harmony? 

Tyrus --- 18 years ago -

there was intelligence provided to the President and those closest to him that such an attack might occur. I don't believe that most agree on that. Good attempt at spin however. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

How Stuff Works - What happened to the World Trade Center Towers I predict they fell down. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

I predict they fell down. LOL. It is not a prediction if it has already happened. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

LOL. It is not a prediction if it has already happened. Poetic license. 

Fin and Feather --- 18 years ago -

The part that I’ve never understood is the physics don’t add up on the heat ratio’s it takes weaken the structure, given when kero burns its hot and fast and at when atomized it will not sustain a flame long with out being replenished. So within lets say 20 min the only thing left to burn / smolder is class A materials, paper wood, etc, that yield verry small heat factors. So what caused the still molten mass discovered weeks later under the rubble? I’ve always felt there was another unidentified source on the lower portion of the building. 

Tyrus --- 18 years ago -

So what caused the still molten mass discovered weeks later under the rubble? Go read this and maybe it will help you understand. An informative article. A brief synopsis is: "But Professor Jones obviously does not comprehend that the hot, red-hot and molten IRON IS COMBUSTIBLE matter. Here, Jones clearly missed it, when he wrote: "At these temperatures, steel will melt, and aluminum materials from the buildings should continue to undergo exothermic oxidation reactions with materials also entrained in the molten metal pools including metal oxides which will then keep the pools molten and even growing for weeks despite radiative and conductive losses. ... The government reports admit that the building fires were insufficient to melt steel beams -- then where did the molten metal pools come from?" http://www.physics.byu.edu/research/energy/htm7.html Jones has no clue because he has conception of Steel Burning (iron oxidation) in air. The Truth is that: HOT STEEL WILL CONTINUE TO UNDERGO EXOTHERMIC OXIDATION REACTIONS WHILE EXPOSED TO AIR, CAUSING IRON TO INCREASE ITS TEMPERATURE UNTIL IT MELTS, FORMING POOLS OF MOLTEN IRON. Professor Jones' comments and conjectures about the origin of the alleged molten iron found within the three huge piles of combustible matter burning after the collapse of the WTC towers, distinctly prove that Professor Jones is oblivious of the fact that Iron Burns in air." 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground