Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I have a question....

who's talking here?

mugglemom 1
bbjones 1
samigale 3
♥SATex♥ 1
toot 1
browneyes 1
TXamanda 1
Superwitch 1
Rubicon 1
ghostpost 1
Fin and Feather 3
pamperedpaws 1
JHMO'S Mom 3
Someone2Know 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

samigale --- 18 years ago -

When you are on life support and brain dead, is your spirit still with you or have you already went on to heaven? Someone was asking me and I wasn't sure. Just wondering if anyone knew. 

TXamanda --- 18 years ago -

WOW! that is a good question, but i don't know the answer really:( but i intend to talk it over with dh over dinner, can't wait to see the answers KU comes up with:) 

samigale --- 18 years ago -

WOW! that is a good question, but i don't know the answer really:( but i intend to talk it over with dh over dinner, can't wait to see the answers KU comes up with:) I thought so to! I have never really thought about it. 

Rubicon --- 18 years ago -

That's deep. 

ghostpost --- 18 years ago -

I have no idea because I'm not one of the religious scholars on here. But when my father was on life support and we knew we needed to say goodbye, one of my family members said "It's time to release him so he can go home to heaven." That was very comforting to me at the time when faced with letting go. 

Superwitch --- 18 years ago -

When my mom was on a ventalater, I know she knew when we were there. She would kinda spark..ya know. 

browneyes --- 18 years ago -

I do not have anything to back this up but I do think the soul is still there. Sometimes when people are taken off life support it takes a while for them to die. My grandma passed minutes after her children told her it was ok to let go. 

Fin and Feather --- 18 years ago -

The body is merely a vessel for the spirit, so I think it’s there till the end 

♥SATex♥ --- 18 years ago -

I too think they are still with us. My MIL was in icu for 5 weeks, I did not leave the hospital for the whole time. When her bloodpressure or anything would change, they would come and get me to go set with her and talk. It would be just minutes after that she would make a change. When her organs were starting to shut down and we had to make the call to take her off we could tell how tired she was. We did tell her is was time to rest and if she was ready to let go. It was about 20 min. after that she just had a calm look and she passed. 

toot --- 18 years ago -

I have thought about this also. When my mom's body was alive during her last few days I felt that her spirit was already gone. She was basically comatose during that time and reacted to nothing. I know we can't really know the answer to your question and probably we don't need to know. I was with her when she passed as well as with my grandpa when he passed. Although their deaths were alike in many ways it seemed to me that his spirit departed his body when he breathed his last breath. So to me your question probably has many answers and each person is different. 

mugglemom --- 18 years ago -

i believe that the spirit remains until the body is dead. 

JHMO'S Mom --- 18 years ago -

The body is merely a vessel for the spirit, so I think it’s there till the end The spirit is still there. It is there till the end. The second the body is gone the soul leaves. 

JHMO'S Mom --- 18 years ago -

There is a book called Summerland that will explain alot. When my Father was in that state I read that book. It really helped alot when it was time to let him go. 

Someone2Know --- 18 years ago -

I think I would have said, "it is a case by case basis, and either way it is in Gods hands. Pray for the intended outcome because noone know s better than God." Well, if it was a child that asked me :) 

Fin and Feather --- 18 years ago -

So the spirit and soul not in cahoots 

JHMO'S Mom --- 18 years ago -

So the spirit and soul not in cahoots My belief is they are the same JMO 

Fin and Feather --- 18 years ago -

This was my understanding also.. Not sure how but I misread first time.. sorry 

samigale --- 18 years ago -

I was just wondering what everyones thought were because dh was asking me yesterday when we were talking about his co-worker. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

So the spirit and soul not in cahoots My belief is they are the same JMO It is clear from the Bible that man is composed of three distinct parts: spirit, soul, and body. "And the very God of peace sanctify you wholly; and I pray God your whole spirit and soul and body be preserved blameless unto the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ." (1 Thessalonians 5:23) 

pamperedpaws --- 18 years ago -

well, I have a truly amazing story about being on "life support" My grandma was recently in the hospital, they had her on a basic life support with oxygen and everything, she couldn't live without it, but they lost her one night and were able to "bring her back". They prepared us for having to put her on life support, they did the surgery to insert the ventillator (which we were told she probably wouldn't make it through-they thought they'd have to insert it through a tracheotomoy) She made it throught that great! She was placed on temporary life support and they never thought she'd live, they told us they could only leave the tube in for about 3 days, so they'd need to wean her off to see if she could breathe on her own, then they would have to put her on a more permanent life support system....our family was preparing everything to be able to take her off in case it came down to that b/c that was her wishes. She would open her eyes every now and then and look at us with a blank stare like she had no idea what was going on. We didn't see g'ma when she looked at us, hard to explain, but even some family members commented on how you could see death in her eyes. Everytime they would try to wean her off the ventillator, they would lose her, we did this for 3 days. They talked to us about how she wasn't responding and what they were going to have to do. All of our family was there with her, they let the little grandkids go in and see her for a few minutes....then they decided to try one more time. She was able to breathe on her own, her doctors are still amazed. Long story short....I can tell you that she is back with us completely and was able to move into a nursing home last week. She will never be able to live on her own again, but she is so excited as we are for her....she is going thru a rehab program now and she calls us everyday to tell us how many steps she's taken by herself, she took 65 yesterday. And to think that weeks ago the doctors were preparing us for the worse. But now she is laughing and talking with us and you know, she remembers EVERYTHING from her stay in ICU while on life support. We have had several conversations about what was going on in her mind and if she was aware of her surroundings. She said it was all like a dream but she knew we were there...I think in her situation, our love brought her back, we weren't ready to let her go. ALL our family flew in to see her and it was amazing how she responded to us all being there. She would respond to our touch, she would try to sqeeze her hand when we held it. When she came to and was able to focus on us, she was very upset, she knew something bad was going on b/c she hadn't seen some of us in years. I never gave up on her, I sat on her bed in ICU and held her hand and told her over and over how much we loved her and needed her. I am sure everyone who deals with life support has very different stories about how the person could respond or not. But I know that my grandma was with us, even though she didn't seem like it. And now that she is back with us, I know that she never really left. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground