Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Teen suspended from school for taking a call from his dad who is in iraq...

who's talking here?

Wildcat 1
stampin' gal 3
JDB2 1
cmi 3
Fallon 1
Fancy 6
planemom 1
Justwatching72 7
Sandyr9111 1
likeke27 2
kjones0125 1
lilmommy 5
amb07 1
Puppy again 1
rose8304 1
cowboyswife 9
BrookleighPhotography 15
TXamanda 2
Brian 1
amyfromsa 1
txdaddy 1
Brennan 1
Caro ♥ 1
Blynda~JAM 3
haroldoftherocks 1
Sue 1
get_the_lead_out! 1
cuckoo'snest 2
Pumpkin 1
The 834 Guy 3
pamperedpaws 1
shortfuse 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

What are your thoughts on this issue???
Date: 14 Apr 2008, 07:26 AM


School Suspends Teen for Taking Call From Dad Serving in Iraq
.. 

amyfromsa --- 18 years ago -

I can't get it to play..but jeez, you would think they could give the kid a break to talk to his father! 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

did he break a rule at the school? 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

yes likeke the no cell phone policy. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

ok. 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

Well i have a different oppinion on the matter then. I think that with a call like that it should be aloud, do people not see phone calls are kept to a BARE MINIMUM while they are there FIGHTING FOR OUR COUNTRY and the times are 8 hours diff. So when he is able to make a call to his CHILD which is not often, i would hope it would be ok that he does so. Especially since he lives in a military town where over HALF the school has one of there parents serving. I guess being someone who has been through this, it hits close to home. For heavens sake the boy misses his father!!!!! 

TXamanda --- 18 years ago -

This is why i hate zero tolerence rules. In the schools defense, he could have gave his teacher a heads up, hey mu dad is going to call from IRAQ today, can i please take his call. I mena if all of the trops from Ft. Hood are deployed the adminsitation can surely make an exception. I mean geez he wasn't making a booty call!!! Shame on that school, run your own school how you see fit, not what some yuppie wrote in a handbook, you went to college to be a leader (principle) be one, lead!!! ok off my small soapbox!!! 

Puppy again --- 18 years ago -

I think they should make allowances for these kids. They should be allowed to immediately leave class and take the call! 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

I think they should make allowances for these kids. They should be allowed to immediately leave class and take the call! AGREED 100% he wasnt taking a call from his dang gf. It was his father who is serving our country risking his life EVERYDAY for our freedom. That's the least they could do. 

pamperedpaws --- 18 years ago -

I think the kids should be able to talk to their parents that are serving whenever their parents are available to make a phone call. These families are going thru alot and I can only imagine how badly the kids want to see and at least be able to talk to their parents. I know the schools have rules they have to abide by, but I do believe in a case like this, there needs to be special rules. Like this kid explained, there is a time difference and it's not easy getting ahold of soldiers when you are able to talk...it's pretty much if they are available and able to talk or if they have access to a phone. I am sure that some of these kids do not get to talk very often, so when they are able to....they should be allowed to. 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

I think they should make allowances for these kids. They should be allowed to immediately leave class and take the call! Ditto. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

wow. normally, i am a "the policy is known prior to the infraction, deal with the punishment"...but this seems to be a situation that should be really considered to be allowed. i mean, it would have be nice if he would have let the admin and teachers know ahead of time if that were possible. although, to be honest, if i was his dad and this happened while his mom was serving...i would be ready to accept the suspension. i would not be happy about it, but i would know going in that it would happen and tell him to take the call anyway. we'll deal with the repurcussions aftewards. 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

Let me guess this school is in Austin? This is so crazy. I wonder if the teacher feels like a moron? 

Caro ♥ --- 18 years ago -

ok suspended for taking a phone call, regardless of WHO it is... seems like a little much... i didnt listen to it or read a story on it... but here they take ur phone and you get like a saturday class or something 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

It's at Fort Hood. This makes me so mad lol. 

kjones0125 --- 18 years ago -

I cannot believe that. The mom did say that the principal has changed the policy at that school. Fox News also got his dad on the phone and the 2 got to talk on TV. I started crying. What a story... 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

Ok, but what happens if they let this child take a call and leave the classroom? Then what happens if the next time a cell phone rings and the child claims it's his/her military parent? Why couldn't the father have called the school and why did the boy have his cell phone on during class or school for that matter? 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

lilmommy, you can't be serious? :( Wouldn't you wanna talk to your child if this was you in this situation. It's not like they can call anytime they want. This whole thing really upsets me. I guess you never know what it's like unless you experience it first hand. Unless you are the one who waits on the calls morning noon and night with the phone by your head in hopes that he might call that night. A call you try and look for everyday but really you never know when you will get it. 

TXamanda --- 18 years ago -

Ok, but what happens if they let this child take a call and leave the classroom? Then what happens if the next time a cell phone rings and the child claims it's his/her military parent? Why couldn't the father have called the school and why did the boy have his cell phone on during class or school for that matter? oh, the teacher can fix that real fast, NAME, RANK, SERIAL NUMBER to whomever is on the other end!!!LOL i mean seriously, it must not happen very often if they are just now having the problem. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

I'm dead serious. What happens when class is disrupted and these kids take advantage of the situation because they can get away with it? Don't think for a second they wouldn't do it. Why couldn't the father call the main office? He would have done less disruption to the class. Rules are rules and while I agree he needs to speak to his father how do you pick and choose who is important enough to allow phone calls? What happens when a parent is a doctor and been at the hospital for a few days and calls their child? Do you not think they'd be mad if the school let the one boy talk to his dad being in the military and the doctors child couldn't? There has to be a line drawn somewhere because unfortunately everyone feels they are important. Now if this was me and my son and his father was overseas, I'd gladly take the suspension and not complain. Who cares? Talking to his father is important. 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

there is ways around the whole "anyone would take calls and claim it is such and such" Ie: talking to the father when the call is recieved etc. Maybe he did not have the school phone number. He is in iraq, and it might not be something he had on hand. And like i said this is a school in a military town. These people know these kids parents are out. There should be a policy for things like this. and i never said they shouldnt be aloud to talk to there parent if he/she is really sick and in the hospital. Like i said there should be rules. And talking to a parent who is in the military should definetly be one of them and aloud!!!!!! I'm glad the school took action and is now changing that policy, good for them they should. 

lilmommy --- 18 years ago -

talking to the father when the call is recieved etc Look, if it were my child I'd expect him to take the call but rules are rules and I'd gladly stand behind him. Talking to someone every time the phone rings in a class would disrupt the classroom which any parent, I would assume, would agree that it's not the best thing to do. My point is what about the traveling father? What about a mother in jail? You get my picture. If they allow it even one time then others will want the rules bent for them. I'm certain this phone call disrupted class for a few minutes. And what parent doesn't have their child's school number memorized, written down or at least in a cell phone or something. 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

A mother in jail? I'm sorry girl but that is NO COMPARRISON. She is in jail for a reason that is obviously not a good one. That really cannot compare i'm sorry lol. So don't answer the phone in class walk out into the hall and take the call. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

There are a million good reasons that can be given for a kid to be allowed to tske a call. The rule is usually "cell phones POWERED OFF." It wouldn't be an issue if the phone was off to begin with. I agree that the father should have called the school, not the cell phone during school hours. Lead by example. On the other hand, as the teacher, I would have bought the story (even if it had been a lie) and let the kid slide. 

rose8304 --- 18 years ago -

Rules are rules and while I agree he needs to speak to his father how do you pick and choose who is important enough to allow phone calls? I agree. He and his parents knew the rule. If he chose to break it, fine, but he should deal with the consequences. That's life. You know the rules, you make choices, you deal with the consequences. 

The 834 Guy --- 18 years ago -

Why couldn't the father have called the school and why did the boy have his cell phone on during class or school for that matter? Are you NUTS? Have you EVER been in the field under military operations? Do you think they have TIME to call and ask permission to talk to their kids back in the States? I'm sure the father thought the school had good sense to let his kid talk to him. But shame on him for assuming so. If rules should be rules then that should apply to deaths in the family. You shouldn't hear about them until AFTER school and AFTER business hours when you shift is over. Gimme a break. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

Rules are rules and while I agree he needs to speak to his father how do you pick and choose who is important enough to allow phone calls? agreed 100%. Unfortunately, these 'no tolerance' policies were created because kids AND PARENTS tried to get around the rules in a million different ways and there was no way to 'use common sense' and be seen as fair. Can't you hear it now? "well, she got to talk to her dad who is heading to war, why can't I talk to my mom that is ......". Unfortunately, the rules are the rules. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

taking the call is worth suspension. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

taking the call is worth suspension. absolutely! 

The 834 Guy --- 18 years ago -

Unfortunately, the rules are the rules. Sorry dad, I can't talk to you because my school set rules up. I know you might be killed in action soon without ever seeing us in person again. But rules are rules. Yes, I love you too but dad, RULES ARE RULES! And most of the people back home have no sense of what kind of environment you are working in to instill our freedom. Sorry, rules are rules. Good luck with that war thing and all. (I say BUCK the system. If your principal can't handle this kind of exception, you shouldn't be sitting in class playing by those rules) 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

I would take my suspension with pride. Imagine how bad the child would have felt if his father did not get through, left a message, and died the next day. The child's actions may have made him a "bad" student, but they make him a great son. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

You shouldn't hear about them until AFTER school and AFTER business hours when you shift is over. Actually, most people would follow the proper procedure if there were a death and they would go through the office. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

I would have taken the call. and, I would have taken the suspension and not said a word about it. 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

I would have taken the call. and, I would have taken the suspension and not said a word about it. Me too. 

The 834 Guy --- 18 years ago -

Actually, most people would follow the proper procedure if there were a death and they would go through the office. In this time of war, perhaps the person placing the call would have turned out the be THE death in the family. I would have taken the call. and, I would have taken the suspension and not said a word about it. Ditto. Sorry, but I was in the military and so was my father. When I was in college, my father called from Kuwait. I did not ask my professor for permission to walk out of class to talk to my dad on the front lines. I simply did so. And I expected full consequence for my actions. I think that if we say we support our troops then we should go the extra mile and make exceptions to the rule that servicemen DO matter. Some people can only dream of talking to their loved ones in the military. Here a kid has his chance and he's disciplined for doing so. When "I" was in the Gulf War my mother walked out of her job to talk to me on the phone. She made a stand placing family first. Life is too damned short to play by every single rule. 

Wildcat --- 18 years ago -

I too think that there should be an exception to the rule in this case. His father isn't over there protecting only his son, he is helping to protect this country! 

Sue --- 18 years ago -

The boy said he'd been having some kind of problems and needed to talk with his Dad, his best friend that he went to for everything. The Mother said the suspensions are happening in other states, also. I don't know the answer, but these kids need to talk, somehow, someway to their parent in Iraq or Afghanistan. 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

Why couldn't the father have called the school and why did the boy have his cell phone on during class or school for that matter? Are you NUTS? Have you EVER been in the field under military operations? Do you think they have TIME to call and ask permission to talk to their kids back in the States? I'm sure the father thought the school had good sense to let his kid talk to him. But shame on him for assuming so. If rules should be rules then that should apply to deaths in the family. You shouldn't hear about them until AFTER school and AFTER business hours when you shift is over. Gimme a break. Thank you. This subject really gets to me and i CANNOT believe people think this is ok. HOW DO YOU KNOW THE DAD EVEN HAS THE # TO THE SCHOOL? remember where he is IRAQ, do you really think he was sitting infront of a computer with internet sipping a cup of coffee? I highly doubt that, i'm sure his sons # is a # he knows by heart and he made the call to his son. Remember where he is and why he is there. Remember what he is doing over there not just for his family but for mine and yours. He is risking his life EVERY DAMN DAY for each and everyone of us, the LEAST he should get is a dang phone call to his son. How do you know that will not be his LAST phone call he ever makes, how do you know he will be here tomorrow?? You don't. Put yourself in this familys shoes and maybe you will have a different look on the situation. Like i stated above, you NEVER KNOW WHAT IT'S LIKE UNTIL YOU ACTUALLY HAVE TO GO THROUGH IT YOURSELF, until you have to wait everyday for that phone call morning noon and night and never knowing when it will come or if it will EVER come. Wondering daily if you will get that horrible phone call nobody ever wants to recieve. :( 

Pumpkin --- 18 years ago -

MW- I agree with you. 100%! These kids need and should be able to talk to their parents when they are fighting for us. These schools she be ashamed of themselves. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

why did the boy have his cell phone on during class or school for that matter? That's what I was thinking too. Yes the school could have made an exception, and should in this case just to be nice and patriotic, etc..., but the kid broke the rule the second he had his cellphone on in class. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

rant


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground