Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

why can an umpire ump a baseball game but not know the rules?

who's talking here?

ilovemykids1030 2
likeke27 6
ambergris 1
baseballmom 11
girlsRus 1
RotorHead 3
No Neck Nick 1
d:-] 2
HuntersMommy♥ 1
get_the_lead_out! 10
offroad4by4 6
Strawberry123 1
Iceman 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

dh had 2 run ins with the umpire today. the umpire was NOT going by the rules. if by chance a batter touches the catcher with the bat they get one warning per player and another rule is (in coach pitch) the pitching coach can not coach the runners from the mound. so the umpire told dh that if one of his players hit the catcher with the bat (totally accidentall) again that he will be out. so dh informed the blue that he has to warn each kid. they all get one warning. blue got pissed because dh knew the call. then later the dh told the blue that the other coach can not coach the runners from the mound. so the blue told my dh that you can never hear or see anything can you. guess what happened then?????? dh got kicked out of the game. i can't stand umpires that don't know the rules and get pissed off at a coach that does know them. dh is also a commisioner so he has to know the rule book like the back of his hand. i can't tell you how many times he has read it.....lol. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Put the umpire on notice with the league, and the way USSA used to work is umpire with substantiated complaints were bumped down the priority selection list for available games. Some umpires just have a slow learning curve, and really only learn On-the-Job-Training (learn when calls are contested and go home and read the specific rules) vs study before the games. For fun, ask a random ump what happens to the runner safe on second base if a second base player throws the ball into the other teams dugout, and see what response you get. 

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

why can an umpire ump a baseball game but not know the rules? heck, I want to know why they can ump when they must be blind. We've had the same ump for the last 2 games and she has made really really bad calls. Calls that should have been obvious as they were obvious to both teams what should have happened. They need to have a dang vision test or something before they step onto the field. 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

BBMom, please clarify this statement: if by chance a batter touches the catcher with the bat they get one warning per player I don't know what rules your league operates under, but when a batter swings at a pitch and his bat makes contact the the catcher's mitt the batter should be rewarded first base. Edit: Aren't most umps volunteers? 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

None of the ump positions I was aware of (my family umped since we were old enough) were volunteers, but they only used to be paid wages that amounted to volunteering ($10 to $30 a game many years ago depending on league, and competition levels). 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Children's leagues were the worst to ump for no matter how well you knew the rules, as you quickly become the target of upset parents. However, I did see a lot of umps that only knew the general rules from being a player angle and spent little to no time studying the challenging calls before hand. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

I don't know what rules your league operates under, but when a batter swings at a pitch and his bat makes contact the the catcher's mitt the batter should be rewarded first base. This is true in our league also. But if it's because the batter hits the catcher because he released the bat behind him on the follow-through, then the team gets one warning and not each player. But it might be different rules for different leagues in that regard. Also in our league with coach pitch, you cannot coach from the mound but I'm not quite sure what the penalty is on that. Edit: Aren't most umps volunteers? The umps in our league definitely aren't volunteers. They get paid about $40-$45 a game. Maybe a little less for working a younger team like coach pitch or T-Ball. 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

My point is, if they are paid or not, what type of certifcation do they have to umpire? Edit: Slow on the keyboard. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Still doesn't make sense why your husband was thrown out though. Did he inform/formally protest to the home/lead ump first to determine if the warning was warranted; did he walk onto the field and contest; ? 

girlsRus --- 18 years ago -

This is true in our league also. But if it's because the batter hits the catcher because he released the bat behind him on the follow-through, then the team gets one warning and not each player. But it might be different rules for different leagues in that regard. Also in our league with coach pitch, you cannot coach from the mound but I'm not quite sure what the penalty is on that. When my girls played with emc leagues the team was given one warning when they threw the bat and hit the catcher and then each additional batter would be called out. My daughters played catcher and I would have a problem with each batter getting a warning. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

But just to throw my own gripe in on an ump in our league...One guy is just terrible! In my 7 year old's game, my kid hit the ball off the end of the bat about a foot in front of home plate but I couldn't see whether it was fair or foul. Anyways my kid makes it to 2nd and another kid scores to tie the game up. When the next batter is coming up, the other coach came up and told the ump that it was a foul ball. The ump goes "Um, yea that was a foul ball." What?!? Why did you let the kids run around the bases and let the other team throw it around? We had the same guy at my 10 year old's game next and one of our guys hits it to their shortstop who makes the throw to first. It hits the first baseman in the mitt and the ball immediately pops out and our guy makes it to first before the first baseman picks it up. The ump called out as soon as the ball hit the mitt and turned his back to the play. Our coach argued and the ump looked towards the homeplate ump who signaled that he was safe. Later on in the game we had scored some runs and he was over checking with the scorekeeper to see how many runs we had...only problem was he never let the other ump or anyone know and the game was still going on. Some are there just to make a payday. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

My point is, if they are paid or not, what type of certifcation do they have to umpire? I know is SKSA there is like a two-day class they have to attend. But I think the kid I am griping about has never even played baseball. 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

4X4, as you quickly become the target of upset parents I'll never forget the day I was the 1st base ump for my youngest son. With a runner on first, the batter hit a fly ball towards 2nd base. I immediately called the 'In Field Fly Rule'. The 2nd baseman caught the ball on the grass rather than the dirt. I caught some shit about it, but it is truely amazing how much parents only focus on Johnny. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

I'll never forget the day I was the 1st base ump for my youngest son. With a runner on first, the batter hit a fly ball towards 2nd base. I immediately called the 'In Field Fly Rule'. The 2nd base man caught the ball on the grass rather than the dirt. I caught some shit about it, but it is truely amazing how much parents only focus on Johnny. Good call! You were right! Most people have no idea what that is or what it means. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

True RH. We had one final national tournament game (pony league) where the police had to be called in to escort the umps out after the tournament for their own safety (I was a player not ump on that game). The main issue was stress was high between the two teams, and my friend on the opposing team (he pitched for a team from the other region) started to back the batters off the plate (lefty) with warning pitches if you know what I mean. Two of us rattled his cage with a shot to right field and one straight back at his ankles. His next pitch went a little wild and our batter ducked (two outs and we were still down by one with a runner on 3rd & 1st). Well the ball hit the bat when he ducked, and yep the batter had no clue until it was too late - tournament over. Both teams were hyped but it was a fair great game and the players shooks hands. Three parents went nuts though and part of the stands erupted. Those umps weren't about to leave the field unescorted and the players from both teams were instructed by the two policeman (back when they had two cops per car) to help shield the umps and surround the umps cars until they drove off. I remember shaking my head at the irony (players getting along, parents not so much). By the way, the other team went on to beat Japan. The other pitcher (my father said) went on to pitch for the A's for a brief time until he got hurt and bumped back down to the minors (lost track of him after high school). You could not have paid me enough money to ump that game. 

offroad4by4 --- 18 years ago -

Funny side line & then will go to bed - I also remember a moment when my dad plowed (& cleaned his clock not on purpose) into an ump rounding second. The ump had turned to watch another play I guess and for some odd reason positioned himself right in the line of fire. The ump (fairly plump guy) tried to last minute scramble out of the way, but my dad (fairly big man) had already committed himself to the turn and was too late. They both collided and went down hard. They both got up ok later, but would not have wanted to have been in his shoes nor would my then-stick-frame have survived that blow. 

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

BBMom, please clarify this statement: if by chance a batter touches the catcher with the bat they get one warning per player i haven't read all the comments yet but i will answer this one since that is how far i got...lol. the kid swung the bat and when it came he slung the bat and it hit the catcher. sorry i didn't clarify enough..lol. dh read this thread and told me i didn't explain it enough...lol. 

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

Edit: Aren't most umps volunteers? nope they get pd $35. a game. 

ilovemykids1030 --- 18 years ago -

bbm, which ump? we are having alot of problems with the young one, with the dark hair, with a gotee.. 

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

But if it's because the batter hits the catcher because he released the bat behind him on the follow-through, that is what happened then the team gets one warning and not each player. yes different rules in our league. the rules state per player. dh made sure he was correct before he wrote up his complaint/side of the story. it is one warning per player.Still doesn't make sense why your husband was thrown out though. Did he inform/formally protest to the home/lead ump first to determine if the warning was warranted; did he walk onto the field and contest; ? he left the field to not cause any harm to his team in the future. what i didn't also say is that after the game we stayed to watch our friend play and the blue saw him and told him he was supposed to leave the ball park. so dh went and got a board member. the board member asked blue and he said yes he did and that the report was upstairs. so dh left then got a call from another board member and they informed him that he didn't have to leave the park. the only way you have to leave a park is if you don't get off the field or you keep yelling/harrassing the ump. that never happened and so he didn't have to leave the park. the blue was just an a$$. 

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

bbm, which ump? we are having alot of problems with the young one, with the dark hair, with a gotee.. he and his brother do t-ball and coach pitch. you know who i am talking about. curly hair and real hairy....lol. 

ilovemykids1030 --- 18 years ago -

he and his brother do t-ball and coach pitch. you know who i am talking about. curly hair and real hairy....lol. yeah thats the same one..we are having ALOT of problems with him! he doesnt know his ass from his rule book (if he owns one...). his dad is alright..but the dark and hairy one is an idiot. ur husband is a commissioner, there isnt anything he can do about it??? as a favor to EVERYONE? lol 

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

nope but he was told by a board member to write a letter about his side. they also said that they know what kindof person my husband is and know he has never caused any problems before. we shall see what happens. 

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

update-dh sat out his game last night. he also was told by one of the board members that they can not kick a coach out of the park unless they keep going on and on from the stands. they were also given a lesson in coach pitch rules...lol. dh was also told that it was no big deal and that he had done nothing wrong and things shouldn't have turned out the way they did. but he did his punishment and it may have worked out to be the best thing. he learned that one of the other coaches can pitch (no idea why the guy never said anything). 2 of our coaches are not very aggresive but 2 are. so one unaggresive base coach will now pitch and one will be dugout dad. dh and the other coach will coach bases. this is all going to be better i think. 

HuntersMommy♥ --- 18 years ago -

Did you win last night? 

d:-] --- 18 years ago -

Don't argue with the umpires during the game. If you or your husband has a problem with the umpire's calls then he should take his complaint to the division director or the head umpire. Arguing during the game only wastes everyone's time and it sets a bad example for the kids (the real reason why you're there to begin with). 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

Don't argue with the umpires during the game. If you or your husband has a problem with the umpire's calls then he should take his complaint to the division director or the head umpire. Arguing during the game only wastes everyone's time and it sets a bad example for the kids (the real reason why you're there to begin with). No it doesn't. It is perfectly acceptable to ask for an explanation of a call and his interpretation and implementation of a rule. Otherwise you might be filing complaints on an umpire without a valid reason and that would be unjust to the umpire. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

Sorry, this is a side baseball story because the ump we had last night was awesome! Did a great job of paying attention to all details, giving the coaches on both sides a chance to show the players what they need to correct and interacting with the kids. BUT, there is always a but, talk about poor sportsmanship from the other teams coaches. They didn't fall in line at the end of the game to tell the players and coaches "Good Game". It was strange since there were no incidents at all that I was aware of. Maybe the coaches weren't being sore losers but they were in the dugout packing up their stuff. 

d:-] --- 18 years ago -

No it doesn't. It is perfectly acceptable to ask for an explanation of a call and his interpretation and implementation of a rule. Otherwise you might be filing complaints on an umpire without a valid reason and that would be unjust to the umpire. According to the first post, her husband didn't ask for an explaination of a call. He argued about rule enforcement then was sarcastic with the umpire when told that he could not coach from the mound. I've seen this type of thing over and over. The umpire/ref will always win so it's no point in arguing during the game in front of kids and spectators. Be a good sport and follow the chain of command if there's a problem, otherwise stay home. :) 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

According to the first post, her husband didn't ask for an explaination of a call. He argued about rule enforcement then was sarcastic with the umpire when told that he could not coach from the mound If its the rules the he should insist on the enforcement of the rule and I thought the sarcastic comment was from the ump to the DH. Maybe I am mis-reading it. But I do agree with you that if a coach continues to argue or even berate the umpire action should be enforced on the coach. There is still a game to play. 

No Neck Nick --- 18 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

He argued about rule enforcement then was sarcastic with the umpire when told that he could not coach from the mound. no he was telling the umpire the other coach can not coach from the mound. the umpire told him that "he didn't hear or see the coach doing it". so my husband told him that "you don't hear or see anything do you". why my husband was so mad was because he admitted he had not seen the batter hit the catcher the first time but he made the call anyway. dh was not mad about protecting the player (he is all about kids) he was mad because the ump didn't know the rules. it is in our rule book one warning per kid and the ump gave one warning for the team. so dh told him the correct rule as he did with the coaching off the mound. i hope that makes sense. nonecknick-get lost you fool. when the ump 

Strawberry123 --- 18 years ago -

Just curious what organization do you play at? My dh umpires for Huffman. He has not done any games this year though so I know y'all aren't talking about him LOL!! 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

so the umpire told dh that if one of his players hit the catcher with the bat (totally accidentall) again that he will be out before or after the swing? 

baseballmom --- 18 years ago -

before or after the swing? he told him that after the kid had already hit and made it to base. next batter was coming up to bat. the parents were yelling at the blue that it had happened. then he told dh. dh has no problem with the warning he in no way wants to have a player hurt (the catcher was also a good friend of our family). he just told the ump that in the rules it is not one warning per team but one warning per player. that is the emc ball park rule (coach pitch rule #11). 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

next batter coming ran into the catcher ? 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

But if it's because the batter hits the catcher because he released the bat behind him on the follow-through, that is what happened catcher got hit on the follow-through 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

catcher got hit on the follow-through than it is catchers interference.. catcher would get one warning.. and if it happened again hthe batter will get a free base 

get_the_lead_out! --- 18 years ago -

catcher got hit on the follow-through than it is catchers interference.. catcher would get one warning.. and if it happened again hthe batter will get a free bas Catcher's interference on the beginning of your swing only. Sounds like the kiddo released the bat coming around and hit the catcher. My son had an issue with "throwing the bat" on his swing a couple of years ago. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

Sounds like the kiddo released the bat coming around and hit the catcher. must have missed this part. if he still has the bat in his hands on the follow through it is still catche interference... but if he has let go of the bat than he should get a warning, not the team 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground