Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Parents with 529s for their children

who's talking here?

JDB2 24
MissT 1
*JR* 3
FishinKim 1
amb07 11
JDaddy 2
RotorHead 4
I Kissed Frogs 1
AmysAngels 5
TwoCrazyKids 2
~sassy~ 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

We just got our statements for our 529s. They went down 10% in the first quarter of this year. Is this on par or are ours doing really bad? I don't want to put any money in them this year (do a money market instead) and my husband thinks I am overreacting. What are other parents doing? 

AmysAngels --- 18 years ago -

Have you talked to JDB?? Both of my daughters are in 529 American Funds (I believe) and they are both doing really well. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 18 years ago -

Ours went down but I haven't done the math yet to figure percentages. 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

A money market fund will bearly, if at all keep up with inflation. Do you know what the fund invests in? Conventional wisdom suggests that the stock market is the best place to be for long term investing. The fund should been diversified with domestic, foreign, real estate (etc.) investments. 

*JR* --- 18 years ago -

When you put money in when the market is down, you are able to buy more shares at the bargain prices. When the prices go back up, your share value will go up. If you skip making your conributions when the market is low, then you are only buying shares when the prices are high. 

*JR* --- 18 years ago -

I meant contributions. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

I know it is in stocks, I don't know much more than that. My frustration is that we put a lot in in November and it has gone down before ever really going up. Amy- do you have a recent statement showing how they did in the past quarter? If you skip making your contributions when the market is low, then you are only buying shares when the prices are high. I am just thinking we should diversify things a bit more, 10% in one quarter seems like a lot to me, I didn't think things were THAT bad (but I really don't know much about it all) 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

amb07, most of the worlds economies are not doing very well right now. There has been a great run up in the markets over the past 6 yrs.,but our economy is cycling towards a recession. JR is right, down markets are the best time to purchase stocks. I understand this is a rough ride if your tolerance for pain is low. Hang in there. 

AmysAngels --- 18 years ago -

Amy- do you have a recent statement showing how they did in the past quarter? I don't know how to read them.... JDB told me last night that we were doing good and I am looking online and we have more then we have put in. 

*JR* --- 18 years ago -

I know my 401K was down 15% a few months ago, and has gone back up to minus 5%. I haven't looked at the 529 statements. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Conventional wisdom suggests that the stock market is the best place to be for long term investing. The fund should been diversified with domestic, foreign, real estate (etc.) investments. amb07 - how old are you kids? What investments do you hold? Have you completed a risk tolerance analysis? The stock market has done poorly this year. Some investments have done worse than others. Are you an investor or a saver? Big difference between the two and part of the answer depends on how much money you save and how old your children are. Fax a statement to me and I'll give you some analysis on what you have and what might be good alternatives if necessary. 10% in the first quarter means you are probably in pretty aggressive funds or pretty crappy funds. I'd be happy to give you a qualified (and free) opinion! 

AmysAngels --- 18 years ago -

This is what we have. CIRAX CP INC BLDR 529A CWIAX CAP WRLD GR 529A CIRAX CP INC BLDR 529A CNWAX NEW WORLD 529A CWIAX CAP WRLD GR 529A 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

you are getting some good advice here. If I called you today and told you that Kohl's had a sale and everything was 20% off, would you tell me that you would rather wait until prices were 105% before buying? The key is high quality investments in diversified portfolios. 

TwoCrazyKids --- 18 years ago -

jdb - what 529 plan do you recomment? With what state? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

if your kids are young, your advisor may have taken some additional risk....or your advisor may not know how to properly build a portfolio. Keep in mind that every person/investor is different and has different thoughts and feelings. Amy's allocation is a great one based on her situation. It may or may not be right for you! Thanks again Amy!!! 

TwoCrazyKids --- 18 years ago -

sorry, "recommend" 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

jdb - what 529 plan do you recomment? I use American Funds. Without state income tax, the state doesn't have an impact for us. You need great funds with a long track record and low expenses. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

JR is right, down markets are the best time to purchase stocks. I understand this is a rough ride if your tolerance for pain is low. Hang in there. I am just completely ignorant on this stuff. I am much more science oriented and I don't understand economics at all (other than spend less than you make, LOL) 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

amb07 - how old are you kids? What investments do you hold? Have you completed a risk tolerance analysis? 4 and 5 months. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Okay I am looking at the statement and under fund name it says collegeadv growth A. Does that mean anything to you? LOL 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Vanguard is good. The expenses are very low. Some of their best funds are index funds and with index funds you get more than 100% of the downside and less than 100% of the upside. Also, if you have an advisor, you most likely pay a fee for allocation advise. That offsets the lower expense ratio. If you don't have an advisor, how do you manage the allocation decisions? Of course, I will be happy to take a look and make sure you are in the best ones and allocated appropriately. If anyone else wants help, let me know. No cost, no obligation. Money is a very important part of your life and you want to make the best decisions. I'd be happy to help! 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

4 and 5 months. do you use an advisor or did the company make a selection for you? With very young kids, you can afford to take some risk. If you are losing sleep, you shouldn't take as much risk as you are currently even if I would. We should make sure you have good funds and a good allocation. If you'd like to come by the office, I'll help you out. It won't take long, won't cost you anything and you will sleep much better being more familiar with where your money is going and what is doing while you're sleeping! 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

collegeadv growth Is that Smith Barney? Do you see a 5 character ticker? The A means you are paying a commission. Hopefully you have an advisor that is earning that commission. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

I have NO idea! I am more of a low risk kind of person, my husband is the high risk one, LOL 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Putnam? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Putnam? they are currently falling apart. It's a bit of an unexpected "anomoly" so to speak, but if you are with Putnam, most of their funds are doing worse than the broad market. 

FishinKim --- 18 years ago -

I know it is in stocks, I don't know much more than that. My frustration is that we put a lot in in November and it has gone down before ever really going up. You have to remember how volatile everything is right now. We invested a buttload of money (finally) in December...it has only gone down so far, but that's ok because we are looking at LONG term. It doesn't make me feel any better thought when I look at the numbers. 

AmysAngels --- 18 years ago -

JDB ROCKS. I am very happy with the decision my husband and I have made to switch to Edward Jones and more importantly, Jonathan. He takes time to get to know your situation and what will work best for YOU! He worries about you and your family's financial future! 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Crap, do you think it will get better? 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

Edit: Sorry, not 529 related. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

You have to remember how volatile everything is right now. We invested a buttload of money (finally) in December...it has only gone down so far, but that's ok because we are looking at LONG term. That is the key, but you must make sure that you are allocated properly and that you diversify across asset classes. Putnam may not come back. They don't always and if you use relevant benchmarks, you can tell frequently what is wrong with a fund company. The Putnam Advantage Large Cap Growth: Voyager Option has performed less than half as well as the Russell 1000 Growth. I haven't analyzed whether that is an appropriate benchmark, but it is the one Putnam uses, so it should be somewhat appropriate. By the way, to get less than half of the performance in every measuring point, you are taking more risk most likely (than the benchmark) and you are paying 1.53% versus around 0.69% with American Funds. Every fund is different and has a different purpose and nobody can guarantee any performance, but we can learn quite a bit from historical analytics. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Putnam may not come back. They don't always and if you use relevant benchmarks, you can tell frequently what is wrong with a fund company. At this point I don't care if it performs amazingly as I probably won't put anymore in, but just want it to be positive. Do you think that will happen in the next 14 years, LOL? 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

BeeDubYa, I use Vanguard for my retirement investments. Key here is low cost. They don't hit a lot of home runs but for the most part the funds have low volatilty. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

At this point I don't care if it performs amazingly as I probably won't put anymore in, but just want it to be positive. Do you think that will happen in the next 14 years, LOL? You might consider transferring what you have to a better plan. I can't tell you what Putnam is going to do. I'm not ever sure what you currently have. You have to keep investing for your kids though. In 14 years, you'd be suprised how much money you can accumulate. Don't quit investing, just get more information and decide a better way to get it done. Putnam may come back. The funds hold many of the same stocks other funds hold. They just seem to make poor buy/sell decisions amongst other poor decisions. Don't do what they are doing. Buy what you know and hold it through down times -- if it's good stuff, buy more. Listen to Amy...she is brilliant!!! 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

They don't hit a lot of home runs but for the most part the funds have low volatilty. VG is who AIG uses for the 401k. They are good, but you can do better with less risk if you have the option, especially if you are paying a fee overlay in non-401k investments. In a 401k, you have to deal with the fund lineup given to you. Outside of the 401k, you have options. VG is good though! 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

Some food for thought here parents....if you put money away in your childs name, when they turn 18 (and are aware the money exists) you legally have to turn over every dime to them IF they ask for it. We were doing this until a friend of a friends twit teenage daughter demanded the money her parents had been saving for her education. She took that 33,000.00 and ran off with her boyfriend and in six months the boyfriend and the money were gone. From what I've seen, the benefits of saving in your kids name no longer outweigh the risk. 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Oh, so you can switch them????? see how stupid I am with this!!!!!!!! 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Some food for thought here parents....if you put money away in your childs name, when they turn 18 (and are aware the money exists) you legally have to turn over every dime to them IF they ask for it. if you use and UTMA, UGMA or savings account. In a 529, this is not true. The parent/grandparent is the owner and the child is the beneficiary....no legal obligation to give the money and you can change the beneficiary any time you wish! 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

????? see how stupid I am with this!!!!!!!! Stupid is a bad word amb....I have worked in the industry for over the past decade. Investing can be confusing and you don't exactly have a full work week to dedicate to it. Any time you have financial questions, PM me or start a thread. I try not to miss money threads... 

amb07 --- 18 years ago -

Thanks! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground