Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Guns aren't only thing to blame in tragedies

who's talking here?

JDB2 5
planemom 1
likeke27 1
funmom 1
NoNameNoLastName 3
ditsterz 1
Loblolly 1
accent_ 5
Tylers Journey 2
txdaddy 1
Sue 1
romper room 3
Reverend X 1
notreallyhere 1
dreamer 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Guns aren't only thing to blame in tragedies 08:50 PM CST on Monday, February 18, 2008 Dallas Morning News With clockwork predictability, we zeroed in on the source of the weapons used by the gunman in last week's appalling slaughter in an Illinois campus classroom. Where did he buy the guns? Why were they so easy to get? Can't we do more to keep guns away from people who are potentially disturbed? All reasonable questions, albeit politically difficult to answer. Here are some other questions, though, that perhaps should also be asked: Why did he stop taking his medicine? Wasn't he being monitored? Can't we do more to make people stay on the drugs that keep them sane and stable? I'm not saying these questions, which go to the heart of privacy and civil liberty, are any easier to resolve than the intractable and shopworn battle over firearms. But somebody, at least, ought to be asking. Graduate student Stephen Kazmierczak reportedly quit taking psychotropic medicine not long before last Thursday, when he massacred five people in a lecture hall at Northern Illinois University, then killed himself. Last March, a teenager with bipolar disorder had gone off his medicine shortly before he shot his girlfriend and then himself outside a Midland, Mich., high school. A man diagnosed with schizophrenia had quit his meds not long before he stormed the U.S. Capitol building and killed two police officers in 1998. The suspect in the gruesome meat cleaver murder of a Manhattan psychiatrist last week had, according to his family, frequently stopped taking his anti-psychotic medication. A Haltom City mother had gone off the drugs prescribed to control her bipolar disorder not long before she poured gasoline over her three little girls and set them on fire last September. And on and on, a drearily familiar scenario of a notorious and bloody crime committed by somebody with a documented history of serious mental trouble who would not take the drugs they needed to keep their demons under control. Most people with serious mental illness, of course, do not pose a danger to anybody, or if they do, it's only to themselves. But mental disorders are frequently part of the equation in the murky psychology of crime. For a lot of patients, sticking with the drugs can mean the difference between stability and chaos. "One of the main goals of our program is to convince them to stay on their meds," said Dallas County court appellate judge Kristin Wade, who oversees a special program that offers selected minor offenders strict supervision in lieu of jail time. "I'd say 90 percent of them do not want to." The reasons are varied: Some don't like the side effects; some simply don't have the wherewithal to keep up with doctor visits and pharmacy refills. Many people just quit taking their medicine in the perverse belief that, because it makes them feel better, they don't need it any more. "I always analogize it to antibiotics," Judge Wade said. "And then, there's some part of your brain that's in denial about the reality of mental illness." Courts can make keeping up with medicine a condition of bond or probation, but there are no guarantees. Some anti-psychotic medicine can be administered by monthly injection, Judge Wade said, which can help patients stay on track. But, by and large, we expect people to maintain their own health. If they neglect their medicine and get sick – well, that's their lookout, right? Perhaps. Yet last week, a New York truck driver was charged with manslaughter for running down two people after he suffered a seizure behind the wheel because he didn't take his medication. In that case, there were serious legal consequences for his neglect. I'm not suggesting that someone could have followed around Steve Kazmierczak to make sure he took his pills, and I'm certainly not intimating that people with diagnosed mental illness don't deserve our compassion. We need to recognize, though, that many people with severe mental illness need these drugs to function in society. It's more than a minor issue of personal preference to unilaterally decide to stop taking them. Mr. Kazmierczak's case, perhaps understandably, set off a fresh round of gun-control debate. If he had stayed on his meds, he might not have gone looking for guns in the first place.  

Tylers Journey --- 18 years ago -

Great article, thanks for posting it. I think that if someone needs meds to function in society, that they should be monitored in a safe hospital with people that know how to handle them. Allow them a time on the meds and then allow them time off the meds. If at any point with or without these meds they act in manner harmful to others, then they do not get released. I think that so often now days people are given these meds in hopes that it will simply get them by or get them off the doctors back. When the reality is they need to be in a facility that is safer for them. 

Reverend X --- 18 years ago -

Great article, but unfortunately it is impossible to make sure people keep taking their medicine. One point that I was telling my buddies the other night, is when a convicted felon tries to buy a firearm, a red flag is waved and that felon is immeadiately arrested. It is a federal offense for a convicted felon to handle any firearm or weapon but not for a paranoid schizophrenic or someone displaying signs of psychosis. There is a database that is checked when someone with a felonious past tries to buy a firearm, but not a database that is checked for someone that has proven to be a threat to themselves and others. 

Tylers Journey --- 18 years ago -

At least most felon's have a target in mind when they go to buy a weapon. Psychotics tend to want to kill everyone as the majority feel let down and belittled by society. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

A lot of seemingly conflicting concerns in this case. Extended hospital stays come up against the rising costs of health care. Doctor client privilege and other privacy concerns hamper flagging of those with a diagnosed mental illness. The vast majority of those with histories like this grad student's present no danger, so whom do we watch? Whom do we flag? Private individuals who sell guns aren't required to check any data base. Those with mental illness aren't criminals, and there wouldn't be funds for it anyway, but I could imagine a system like probation for mental health patients, where they are required to check in with a health professional regularly and an alarm would go up if they don't, but that sounds draconian to me, and, again, the vast majority of those with diagnoses similar to that of this grad student. I'm absolutelt for a more comprehensive screening of gun purchases by ALL sellers, but am not sure that that would have worked here. I'm for a waiting period in ALL gun sales. Still, 6 died in this incident, but 8 died in the drag racing one, and we won't be putting more controls on car purchases. 

dreamer --- 18 years ago -

Maybe over prescribed medicine as a child has a very big impact on kids. Teach kids to deal with life. We are starting to see that the blame is still being shifted to the medicine the person was or wasn't on. Does it matter he did or didn't take medicine? Looks like it is cop out, another excuse why medicine should be banned until it is used correctly. 

Sue --- 18 years ago -

It sounded like he was just able to go in and buy the guns. There must be no waiting period in Illinois. When my husband worked at Walmart in Fl in sporting goods a long time ago, there was a three day waiting period, even for shotguns. 

Loblolly --- 18 years ago -

Good article. One point that I was telling my buddies the other night, is when a convicted felon tries to buy a firearm, a red flag is waved and that felon is immeadiately arrested. This is unfortunately not true. I do background checks for a gun dealer - this is not a true statement. A red flag is waved in the fact that they get denied - but they are not arrested. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Looks like it is cop out, another excuse why medicine should be banned until it is used correctly. It's not always a copout. Mental illness is a terrifying reality for many, and a tiny fraction of that number can be dangerous to themselves and to others. That many can be treated with medication and live productive lives is a wonderful thing, and a vast improvement over the treatment of mental illness 50, 40, or even 30 years ago. If, though, through medication, we can allow some, who would otherwise be institutionalized indefinitely, to lead more normal lives, there needs to be some way to insure that the meds are taken. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Is it the under lying psychotic disorder that makes the people violent or is it the changes caused by going on medication and then quitting the medication that makes them violent? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Is it the under lying psychotic disorder that makes the people violent or is it the changes caused by going on medication and then quitting the medication that makes them violent? That is probably specific to the case (Is there a mental health professional in the house?) There are, of course, some psychotics who are homicidal, but I understand that suddenly coming off some meds, with some underlying conditions, can be a shock to an already taxed individual. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

When my husband worked at Walmart in Fl in sporting goods a long time ago, there was a three day waiting period, even for shotguns. Are there any background checks when you buy guns in gun shows? I'm under the impression the answer is no. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Guns aren't EVER to blame. They are inanimate objects. 

romper room --- 18 years ago -

Guns are safe. People are not. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

People are not. Guns are handled by people, therefore... 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

When my husband worked at Walmart in Fl in sporting goods a long time ago, there was a three day waiting period, even for shotguns. CHICAGO (AP) -- Federal officials say the shotgun-wielding graduate student who killed five people at Northern Illinois University yesterday bought all four of his guns legally. Thomas Ahern of the bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms says Steven Kazmierczak purchased them from a federally licensed firearms dealer in Champaign. Kazmierczak was a graduate student in social work at the University of Illinois in Urbana-Champaign, but he'd previously been enrolled at NIU. That's where authorities say he killed five people before killing himself yesterday. ATF officials say Kazmierczak picked up two of the guns on February 9th after both the criminal background check and waiting period required by state law. Authorities say he got the others in December and August of last year. Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.) APTV 02-15-08 1642CST 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Guns are handled by people, therefore... everything is dangerous and should be banned...your car, your bicycle, your utensils in your home, your sporting equipment.... 

ditsterz --- 18 years ago -

In my opinion schizophrenics should always be in a mental facility. He stopped taking his medicine like a million other mentally unstable people. That is no surprise. Schizophrenics tend to be violent and the majority will act out violently which is why they should all be locked up. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

Guns aren't EVER to blame. They are inanimate objects. yep. never saw a gun lying on the table jump up and shoot anyone. people need to stop blaming everything except what is to blame...the PERSON WHO CHOOSES TO SHOOT SOMEONE 

romper room --- 18 years ago -

Don't blame the guns. Don't blame the person using the gun. Don't blame the medicine. Don't blame the media. Don't blame bad parenting. Don't blame video games. Don't blame society. Don't blame anyone. Who's left to blame 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I realize that mental illness exists and that it is horrible. I believe there are many folks that go it alone meaning they don't have anyone that cares about them. However, most of the mentally ill people we see in the news have been diagnosed previously. We have this afterthought that "oops, I didn't think..." or "my ds/dd would never..." If my DW or my kids were diagnosed with some of these illnesses, why would I not take responsibility for them? I am responsible for my kids now, why would that change if they could not assume responsibility for themselves when they reach 18? If they cannot and I am unable, why wouldn't the state take the risk off the table? Again, assuming the diagnosis has been made, why risk it? If a person is known to stop taking their meds, someone should force them to take the meds or someone should take responsibility for the individual. 

romper room --- 18 years ago -

My point is, why look for something or someone to blame? The guy did it. Who knows why? The blame is his and his alone. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

My point is, why look for something or someone to blame? The guy did it. Who knows why? The blame is his and his alone. you and I are on the same page. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

One gun, one person trained how to use it and willing to do so could have stopped most of this: DEKALB, Ill. - Another person shot when a gunman opened fire at a lecture hall at Northern Illinois University has died, bringing the toll to seven, including the gunman, a coroner said Friday. Investigators and school officials did not immediately know why the man indiscriminately fired into the crowd with a shotgun and two handguns Thursday, wounding 15 people and sending panicked students fleeing for the exits before killing himself. “We have no motive and I have no way of knowing what the motive was,” University Police Chief Donald Grady said. At one time I was very against arming teachers or allowing qualified students to carry on campus. I’m not any more. These maniacs go to those schools KNOWING that their’s will be the only gun there - until police arrive. And that can take minutes. If you know anything about guns, or ever fire on a range, take any semi-automatic pistol with, say, two extra loaded magazines, and see how long it will take you to fire every single round in those magazines. It doesn’t take but a few seconds. Then imagine firing into a crowded room filled with unarmed people. Like shooting fish in a barrel. This one, like some others before him, even stopped to reload. One gun. That’s all it would have taken. But that campus, like all the others, is a “gun free zone”. To everyone except the killer.  

funmom --- 18 years ago -

i belive ever person is responsible for their own actions. wether they are mentally ill or not.. i dont own a gun cause i dont want to, i have nothing against them i just choose not to.. it is like someone that chooses to drink and drive they choose to get behind the wheel.. each person chooses the path their life takes. if i choose to go down the wrong path is it my mom or dad's fault NO it is mine.. if my son chooses to do anything illegal is it my fault NO i raised him right and i cannot tell him what to do when he moves out and is on his own.. mentally ill people need their meds, but i take meds for my health and if i choose not to take them that is my choice i know the consequenses, the effects that is has on my body.. if i choose an all sugar diet i will kill myself but that is my choice not my dr's or anyone else's.. if you have a mentally ill family memeber the best you can do is support them but you cannot force them to take their meds.. the blame that everyone puts on people that commits crime all boils down to they decided to commit that crime.. no one put the gun in their hand walked them into the building and pointed the weapon.. it is all about personal responsibility.. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

.. it is all about personal responsibility.. I used more words in an attempt to say the same thing. If you are unable to be responsible for yourself, someone else should be...our safety depends on it. Too many people make excuses. 

notreallyhere --- 18 years ago -

This is what is wrong with people. Kids are taught not to take blame for anything. I don't care if you are 10 or 110. You know right from wrong unless you have been taught that you are the exception to the rules. Everyone looks for others to blame when the person that is responsible is standing in front of them. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

everything is dangerous and should be banned...your car, your bicycle, your utensils in your home, your sporting equipment.... First of all, guns are designed to kill or harm someone else. That's their purpose. Driving while drunk is a crime. Is it a crime to carry a gun while you are drunk? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

health
news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground