Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Car Seats

who's talking here?

Keystone 1
Paige 1
Momoftwo 2
MomofTwins 3
H and J 2
Mygirl01 2
addipie 3
Pampered Chel 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Pampered Chel --- 18 years ago -

Speaking of car seats... We are trying to decide on what additional car seat to get. We have the Britax marathon for dd that is about 3. Baby dd needs to get out of her infant carrier. We don't know if we should buy another Marathon or a Roundabout for the baby. Or give the Marathon to the baby and get the Regent Booster car seat for our older dd. Any suggestions?  

MomofTwins --- 18 years ago -

Give the Marathon to the baby and buy a Regent for dd. I offer this advice based on past experience. We bought our twins Marathons at age 3.5 (we had Roundabouts which they outgrew.) By age 5 they didn't want to sit in the Marathons anymore, even though they fit in them, because they look like 'baby seats' per the kids. I think Marathons are more comfortable for car sleepers from age 3 to 4, but you won't get as much life out of them as you would a Regent. Make sure the Marathon fits rear facing in your car before you make a decision. Some people lose their front passenger seat when they put the Marathon behind it, as the seat is pushed too far forward. 

Pampered Chel --- 18 years ago -

I am looking right now and I am trying to figure out what the difference is between the Regent Car Seat and the REgent Booster Car Seat. 

Pampered Chel --- 18 years ago -

 

Paige --- 18 years ago -

Get the one w/ the 5 pt. harness... 

Pampered Chel --- 18 years ago -

Yes, I will. They all have 5 point harness that I am looking at. My husband just suggested the Graco booster. I checked it out and said no way! It does not have a five point harness. I think we are going with the Regent. 

Pampered Chel --- 18 years ago -

Some people lose their front passenger seat when they put the Marathon behind it, as the seat is pushed too far forward. This will probably happen in my car. It should not be a big deal since no one rides in the front seat. Baby dd already meets the weight requirement and will be 1 in April. I dh's car we already have a Roundabout and a Marathon. I really wish we would not have bought that 2nd Marathon ...dh was in such a hurry! 

MomofTwins --- 18 years ago -

If you don't want to take up all of the room that a Regent takes, I highly recommend this one: Hybrid Booster Safe Guard The Hybrid Booster is not so huge to move around as a Regent is.... our neighbor has one and her 6yo is in it still. The Hybrid Booster is cheaper than the marathon. The true SafeGuard seat is great as well, but is $$$$$. 

Mygirl01 --- 18 years ago -

Please keep in mind that all of these expensive car seats are rated based on the fact that they are anchored and or tethered to the vehicle while using the 5 point harness. Now before you go out and spend $$$ on them the question you need to ask is... What is the weight limit on my cars anchor's?? Believe it or not, most vehicles anchors can ONLY hold a 40 pound child, making all of the extra money you spend to keep a 60 pound child in a 5 point harness that is anchored to your car's frame, useless because your car may not be able to support that weight using that system. Now if you can use the seat belt to hold the car seat in place then you can use the extra weight for that harness system but their safety ratings are when that child seat is anchored to your vehicle not seat belted in. 

Mygirl01 --- 18 years ago -

www.saferidenews.com/pdfs/pg_126_max_wt_07.pdf I never get the link correct but here is a list and some weights and I will bump the old thread that this is from, I think it is titled Anyone have this... 

H and J --- 18 years ago -

We are dealing with the same issues... www.elitecarseats.com has some good feedback and prices while www.car-seat.org has some great forums/advice. Rumor has it that some states will be required to have all children in a 5 pt harness until the age of 8 by 2012. That will force car seat makers to finally come up with some better alternatives. We bought the Regent and loved it but it was so huge that the driver could not put the seat all the back without squishing our child's legs (we returned it). We are now looking at the Recaro Signo. Some people really like the new Graco Nautilus and I do think there will be a general movement toward better 5 pt harness boosters. Good luck! 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

britax also makes a car seat for fisher price that is exactly the same as the marathon but half the price 

MomofTwins --- 18 years ago -

Rumor has it that some states will be required to have all children in a 5 pt harness until the age of 8 by 2012. Where did you hear that rumor? I find that VERY hard to believe. I would understand if they made kids be in a booster seat until age 8 (which they should be anyway if they are average sized), but no way will they make that 5-point harness rule until 8. addipie - yes, the Fisher Price one is made by Britax. It is not "exactly" the same (comfort, padding, cover, etc), but holds the same height/weight requirements. 

H and J --- 18 years ago -

Where did you hear that rumor? The car seat guru at Baby's 1st Furniture - she also said not all states will require it at first and every state will have different regulations... she did not go into detail so I am not sure of the specifics or the accuracy. She also talked about the huge increase in parents using a 5 pt harness instead of boosters until around 6 years of age. Hopefully there will be a car seat/booster introduced soon that will incorporate the comfort of the Regent without being quite so large and have a little more side impact protection. Recaro is on the right track with some of there boosters already - they look "cool" for older kids - now they just need to add the 5 pt harness for mroe than 40 pounds. 

Momoftwo --- 18 years ago -

I agree about buying the Regent for the oldest child. I moved my dd out of it this year at 5.5 b/c I needed the Regent for ds who was 2.5. I moved my oldest to a seat belted booster (Compass B550). I really like my Britax regent and if you have space for it, I think you will find your child will use it longer than another Marathon. At 5.5 my dd had no complaints with the Regent. It was very roomy and comfortable for her and she's tall. 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

addipie - yes, the Fisher Price one is made by Britax. It is not "exactly" the same (comfort, padding, cover, etc), but holds the same height/weight requirements. I have the marathon in my car and the FP one in my mom's car. She seemes just as happy in it as the marathon. The cover is definatley not as cute though:) 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

is the regent made by britax? 

Keystone --- 18 years ago -

We have Marathons for our 4- and 6-year olds. They like them since they sit up high and are so comfortable. They have never said anything abou them being a "baby" seat. You know your own child--I'm just saying it doesn't bother our kids. 

Momoftwo --- 18 years ago -

Yes, the Regent is made by Britax. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
recommendations


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground