Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Primerica

who's talking here?

JDB2 19
cmi 1
gking 6
rose8304 6
KWPlanner 9
browneyes 1
Mabbers 2
MeAndMyGang 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rose8304 --- 18 years ago -

Anyone ever heard of them or had any experience with them? What are your opinions of them? 

MeAndMyGang --- 18 years ago -

My parents have had life insurance with them forever. When they continued our policies, they were fine to work with. 

KWPlanner --- 18 years ago -

Rose, what types of services would you be contacting them for? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

They are expensive and I've only heard one good thing about their service (see MeAndMyGang above). 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

looks like they have improved their product line -- if they use the full line. 

rose8304 --- 18 years ago -

My brother just started selling for them and part of his training included him and his trainer doing “practice” presentations, so my dh and I agreed to let them do one for us. We liked a lot of what she told us, particularly the plan they have for paying off your mortgage in half the time and the life insurance. She said that she enjoyed being able to help families make their money work better for them. I had some reservations about some things she said though, and since I had never heard of them or anyone with experience with them, I wanted to see what some of you finance savvy people thought. 1. She kept talking about how they had such a proven track record but since I’ve never heard of them before, those are only words. She also kept saying that all these great facts she was throwing out were right there in black and white, but they were in black and white on paper that she brought over! Maybe that’s just a pet peeve of mine though. 2. While she said some great things about how they could lower this bill or save this much money or whatever and gave us examples, she didn’t actually explain how that was possible. For example, she told us that their special mortgage plan cuts your bill in half and you end up paying it off in nearly half the time, she didn’t actually explain how, just gave an example. 3. The last part of the presentation was where she explained how great it was to work for them and how much money we could make if we decided to do it too. The thing about that is that they get paid commission, so my thought was why wouldn’t she say whatever it took to get us to sign up for the services? She gets her money and who cares what happens to us afterwards? 

KWPlanner --- 18 years ago -

Rose, I'm sure your brother has good intentions. But everything they are pushing entails selling you insurance or other high-cost products. I'll give you an example of how #2 works: You will be pressured into buying a whole life or variable life insurance product. The claim is that over the years the policy will build up a cash value within the policy which you can then withdraw and pay off your mortgage early. (Believe me, I'm over-simplifying the whole process, but this is how it basically works). I know this because this is the exact sales tactic I was told to use when I first graduated from college and worked for Mutual of New York. The underlying costs of the insurance is incredibly high, and most likely not a good fit for you. It is for experiences like this that I only lasted in the commission-based side of financial planning for a mere two months. I've been providing fee-only planning ever since (15yrs). 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

This is just me, but I don't trust anyone that tries to sell me really hard. :) 

KWPlanner --- 18 years ago -

I don't trust anyone that tries to sell me really hard. That's why I got out of financial planning through sales and stuck with fee-only. Don't get me wrong, there are good honest people out there who are compensated by sales of financial products. It' just not for me, nor will it ever 

rose8304 --- 18 years ago -

Maybe I didn't explain the situation right. She wasn't trying to pressure us into anything. I believe the point was to teach my brother. In order to do that, she had to do the presentation and we liked what we heard. I used to work for a Kirby who does the same sort of training and it was completely reasonable to expect that some of the practice presentations would turn into sales, but I didn't get the impression she expected us to buy anything and I didn't feel any pressure to do so. 

KWPlanner --- 18 years ago -

Rose, feel free to PM me with any questions you have. I'd be more than happy to answer them for you and/or explain the concepts in more detail. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

I'll give you an example of how #2 works: You will be pressured into buying a whole life or variable life insurance product. The claim is that over the years the policy will build up a cash value within the policy which you can then withdraw and pay off your mortgage early. Wow - is this something new for them? In my experience with Primerica - they have been strictly offspring of the old A.L. Williams system - buy term and invest the difference. In fact, they set me up nicely back in the early 90's - a cheap, cheap term life policy and a couple of aggressive mutual funds. Primerica hawking cash value policies? Are you sure? I knew they have been adding to the "tool box", but that seems to go very deeply against their long standing philosophy (and sales pitch) regarding life insurance products. 

KWPlanner --- 18 years ago -

I didn't get the impression she expected us to buy anything and I didn't feel any pressure to do so. The pressure wasn't there most likely because of the training. However, that would be the end result if you were a cold-call prospect. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

their special mortgage plan cuts your bill in half and you end up paying it off in nearly half the time, she didn’t actually explain how, just gave an example This is a simple mathematical process. Additional principal payments will cut your mortgage term in half and you don't have to double your payments. However, these guys will charge you to do something you can do yourself without consideration for whether this is the best use of your financial resources. 1. She kept talking about how they had such a proven track record She is piggybacking off of Citibanks record. Primerica has been around for a while, but my understanding is that they were horrible and were therefore bought by Citi. how great it was to work for them and how much money we could make if we decided to do it too. The thing about that is that they get paid commission, so my thought was why wouldn’t she say whatever it took to get us to sign up for the services? She gets her money and who cares what happens to us afterwards? Commissions are not bad. You are paying for anything you are getting and the same argument can be made with any method of payment. However, are you getting a sufficient explanation of the compensation and are you being shown the alternatives? Are you being given options? 

cmi --- 18 years ago -

I'll give you an example of how #2 works: You will be pressured into buying a whole life or variable life insurance product. The claim is that over the years the policy will build up a cash value within the policy which you can then withdraw and pay off your mortgage early. (Believe me, I'm over-simplifying the whole process, but this is how it basically works). I signed up to sell for them years ago and it was the exact opposite. They wanted people to not do the whole life policies b/c you didn't need them. You needed to build up wealth through annuities and such and a term life would be suffice and cheaper. Therefore you could put your money towards "real" investments. On a negative note, I never sold for them b/c it was just selling. Noone really seemed to care about people behind the scenes. They just wanted to get everyone to be a rep under them and that was part of every presentation. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I only lasted in the commission-based side of financial planning for a mere two months. I've been providing fee-only planning ever since (15yrs). Be careful though. The same can be said for fee-only. You need to find a person that you can trust. In many ways, commissions are less expensive, they encourage a long-term relationship and there is incentive to perform. 

KWPlanner --- 18 years ago -

Gking, I'm hoping things have changed over the past 15 years, but that was my experience. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Or anyone pushing particular products (their company's). 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Primerica today is quite different from the AL Williams company from the 70's and 80's. 

KWPlanner --- 18 years ago -

commissions are less expensive, they encourage a long-term relationship and there is incentive to perform. jdb, you make it sound like we fee-only folk don't encourage long-term relationships and have no incentive to perform...lol. You know me better than that. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

You know me better than that. likewise. It's like anything else, there are several ways to look at it. Fee only has its advantages and so does commission based, right? 

gking --- 18 years ago -

Primerica today is quite different from the AL Williams company from the 70's and 80's. Oh - I'm quite aware of that, however - they still continued to build their business around the "buy term, invest the difference" concept. Which, by the way, I wholly agree with. I just don't believe that they would be pushing cash value policies for any reason. Not with all the other more financially sound ways to pay off a mortgage. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

they still continued to build their business around the "buy term, invest the difference" concept. Which, by the way, I wholly agree with. they are not even remotely close to the same company. They build their business using annuities, term, whole life, proprietary funds...they are completely different. The buy term philosophy can make more sense mathematically, but wouldn't you agree that it makes more sense to listen to the client and determine their needs? Some folks don't want to "feel" like they are wasting premiums on a policy that will expire. Some folks like cash value. Most folks don't qualify for low cost term unless they are young -- frankly, most of us do not fit the ideal height/weight guide. Additionally, term doesn't allow for the person that has hardships and cannot self insure. There are many downsides. Having said that, I am typically a term guy. I have term for my family and that is mathematically the best alternative. There is no such thing as a "one size fits all" insurance philosophy and my job is to help my clients, not myself. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I also sell insurance btw. I prefer term, but there are reasons to use other types. 

KWPlanner --- 18 years ago -

Fee only has its advantages and so does commission based, right? That's why I was careful to note that there are good people out there who are commission based. It's just not my cup of tea. I would be willing to bet you that beer that it wouldn't matter which office Joe Client came into (mine or yours); they would get the same level of service, attention, and dedication. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

I would be willing to bet you that beer that it wouldn't matter which office Joe Client came into (mine or yours); they would get the same level of service, attention, and dedication. that is a bet I won't take my friend...I'd enjoy the beer better if you bought it! 

gking --- 18 years ago -

wouldn't you agree that it makes more sense to listen to the client and determine their needs? Absolutely. But explain to me who would ever need an overpriced insurance premium married to an under-performing savings vehicle - benefits of which can never be gained simultaneously by the policy holder. I have yet to be sufficiently convinced that whole life policies are ever a good thing for the policy holder. They seem only to serve the insurer/salesman. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

who would ever need an overpriced insurance premium married to an under-performing savings vehicle - benefits of which can never be gained simultaneously by the policy holder. the person who will not be insurable at renewal would be one example. These policies are perpetual. Term isn't! I do not care for them either, but my needs and yours are not necessarily in the best interest of every consumer. Frankly, some folks want to make sure they have coverage 41 years from now. The longest term policy I've seen is 40 years. A proper blend of coverage can blend the cost and work well. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

the person who will not be insurable at renewal would be one example. These policies are perpetual. Term isn't! OK - what is your investment worth at the end of that term? As much or more than your policy payout? A payout that you only get if you die too! Who needs to renew! 

rose8304 --- 18 years ago -

I signed up to sell for them years ago and it was the exact opposite. They wanted people to not do the whole life policies b/c you didn't need them. You needed to build up wealth through annuities and such and a term life would be suffice and cheaper. Therefore you could put your money towards "real" investments. I think this is what she said. This is a simple mathematical process. Additional principal payments will cut your mortgage term in half and you don't have to double your payments. However, these guys will charge you to do something you can do yourself without consideration for whether this is the best use of your financial resources. She didn't say your payments would be doubled, she said the payments would be cut in half. Sorry, that's what I meant and why I don't understand how that's possible. Cut the monthly payments in half and pay off the loan sooner?? She is piggybacking off of Citibanks record. Primerica has been around for a while, but my understanding is that they were horrible and were therefore bought by Citi. I can believe that. She did mention how Citibank has been around for a long time as if that made Primerica better. She also mention a bunch of other finance related copmanies but said that they work for Primerica. In many ways, commissions are less expensive, they encourage a long-term relationship and there is incentive to perform. Good point. I hadn't been considering that they'd want to keep a good relationship because they would want to sell us more services. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

OK - what is your investment worth at the end of that term? As much or more than your policy payout? A payout that you only get if you die too! Who needs to renew! you have the death benefit in the meantime G! The products make sense for some people. It doesn't have to make sense to you. There are many services that make no sense to me. There is a demand and the whole life and annuity products have a very high demand. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

would be cut in half the number of payments would be cut in half, not the amount of the payment itself. I can do the same thing for you, but with no charge. You still have to determine if you should do that. It isn't usually the best use of resources in my opinion. If you have nothing else more important to spend you money on, then do that. Usually people with debt or people without fully funded retirement plans do this. Not a good idea usually. 

gking --- 18 years ago -

Frankly, some folks want to make sure they have coverage 41 years from now. Well, obviously the conscientious advisor would then need to educate the client as to how much more that difference in premium will grow under their control over those 40 years (e.g. mutual fund), rather than XYZ Insurance Co.'s control. And again - the only way the policy holder get's this "cash value" is to give up the insurance benefit. When they die - they get the face value of the policy, and the cash value "vanishes" (to the policy holder). How about - Mr or Mrs. client - you pay a fifth of the premium for a term policy, put the difference in other investment vehicles where you don't have to share the yield - AND, if you happen to kick the bucket while you're insured, your beneficiaries get the face value plus the investments. If you outlive your term, your investments will be more than sufficient - in all practicality negating the need for continuing a life insurance policy. Certainly comes down to proper planning doesn't it. Still - can't see how a cash value policy can ever be a prudent part of someone's plan - under any circumstance. 

KWPlanner --- 18 years ago -

The products make sense for some people. There comes an age when whole life premiums are cheaper than term. Don't quote me on it, but I'm thinking somewhere in the age 60-65 year old range. If for some reason a 70 year old needed insurance (and was insurable), THEN it may make sense for whole life. Other than that, I can't think of a time where I recommended whole life over term. (then again, it's almost midnight and I only had three hours of sleep last night...lol) 

gking --- 18 years ago -

There is a demand and the whole life and annuity products have a very high demand. For the uneducated. And those who are in the best position to do the educating - are not about to shoot their cash cow. You know as well as I do, those policies pay enormous commissions compared to the paltry term policies. To write someone a cash value policy is to take advantage of them - regardless of the demand. 

rose8304 --- 18 years ago -

Ok jdb. I think I remember the thing about the mortgage now. Say my mortgage is $1000 a month. Instead of paying that, I would pay $500 every two weeks and the interest rate would be recalculated every 15 days. I think she said the payments would go directly to the principle therefore, I would end up paying less over the (shorter) life of the loan. She also showed us another plan that cut the payment and the length of the loan somehow. And rather than having an escrow (which she said was somehow screwing me) they would set me up with some kind of account that would automatically (like direct debit or something) save the amount I needed for my taxes and stuff but I would get to keep the interest earned on that money which the bank is currently getting to keep. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

AND, if you happen to kick the bucket while you're insured, your beneficiaries get the face value plus the investments. and Mr. & Mrs. Client if you do what G says and for any reason in the entire world, you don't put away the ENTIRE 80%, and Mr. & Mrs. Client, if for any reason you get crappy performance in the markets, and Mr. & Mrs. Client, if for any reason I get out of the business and you have to find someone else to help you make investment decisions because you don't know how and don't want to know how.....you are absolutely hosed and have nothing now! And by the way Mr. & Mrs. Client, you are overweight, so your 20% is more like 40% now! And Mr. & Mrs. Client, I don't really care about what you are telling me...if you don't do it my way, you are a bonehead! I AM BEING FACITIOUS folks. GKing, you might not want to get into this side of the business. It's a relationship business and everything does not have to be done by the numbers nor does it all have to be done my way. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

For the uneducated. Gking - you sell pre-paid legal. Are you sure you want to go there? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

To write someone a cash value policy is to take advantage of them - regardless of the demand. Absolutely not true. You aren't paying attention and you don't seem to understand people very well. Additionally, what do you suppose an advisor makes when they handle the investment portion? I make more money selling the term and the investments if the client sticks with the investment portion and the insurance. By the way, I haven't yet recommended or sold whole life. I simply recognize that the reasons people purchase it are not all "uneducated" nor are these folks stupid. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

Ok jdb. I think I remember the thing about the mortgage now. Say my mortgage is $1000 a month. Instead of paying that, I would pay $500 every two weeks and the interest rate would be recalculated every 15 days. I think she said the payments would go directly to the principle therefore, I would end up paying less over the (shorter) life of the loan. that is basically how it works Rose. The problem is that they will charge a set up fee and then a monthly fee which can be flat or a percentage. They take a lot of your incentive. What happens is that you lower your priciple quicker, thus paying less interest. You also get an additional payment each year. There are things you can do to hedge some, but you should make sure that all non-deductible interest is paid off first and that any higher-interest items are paid off too. Then you need to consider taxes, retirement and any educational needs. Like the whole life, there are many ways to look at it and it depends on your situation. rather than having an escrow (which she said was somehow screwing me) they would set me up with some kind of account that would automatically (like direct debit or something) save the amount I needed for my taxes and stuff but I would get to keep the interest earned on that money which the bank is currently getting to keep. Escrow is prepaying your taxes and your insurance. You don't get interest on your funds. You can have your mortgage without escrow, then have your bank account drafted to a money market account. At the end of the year, the funds are there, so you write the checks and keep the difference. It doesn't allow for miscalculations or changes in insurance rates and/or taxes, but you can always increase or decrease it. You want to be careful with any of these things. I am not sure it applies to all mortgages, but we have a joint venture with Wells Fargo. Our mortgages have lower rates if you escrow because you are taking aways some risk from the lender. The lower rate is worth more in the long run than 3.5% on your escrow account. Again, determine what best fits your needs. If you tap into a self-funded escrow account and then don't have the funds available, you could end up with penalties. Ultimately, you could lose your house if you couldn't come up with the funds. That would be a long shot, but it has happened. As the taxes accumulate, the lender is on the hook for the taxes and the mortgage. It gets ugly. Remember, in all of these situations, we make many assumptions. One of the biggest assumptions is that people are rational. Another assumption we are making is that nothing changes for the worse in anyones life. These are important things to realize. Great thread Rose! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground