Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

When was Jesus born?

who's talking here?

Lilteapot 1
Fallon 2
bbjones 4
Danabug(BCM) 1
CyberSage 3
4babygirls 1
Zionist NightOwl 6
Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen 1
Going off air 1
Superfantastik 1
Clown Vomit 3
accent_ 3
donottreadonme 1
Mark 2
Angela 1
Donkey Hodie 7
partyboy 1
peeches 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Donkey Hodie --- 18 years ago -

When was Jesus born? 1)Before 4 BCE. Matthew 2:1 Now when Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judaea in the days of Herod the king. Luke 1:5 There was in the days of Herod, the king of Judaea, a certain priest named Zacharias, of the course of Abia: and his wife was of the daughters of Aaron, and her name was Elisabeth. Note: Herod the Great died in 4 BCE. Wikipedia: Herod the Great http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herod_the_Great ========== 2) After 6 CE. Luke 2:1-2 And it came to pass in those days, that there went out a decree from Caesar Augustus that all the world should be taxed. (And this taxing was first made when Cyrenius was governor of Syria.) Note: Quirinius (in Greek, Cyrenius) became governer of Syria in 6 CE, ten years after king Herod's death. Wikipedia: Quirinius http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quirinius The Gospel of Luke mentions the census taken by Quirinius when he was governor of Syria, as part of a census of the "whole world", in connection with the birth of Jesus. However Luke and the Gospel of Matthew date the birth to the reign of Herod the Great, who died in 4 BC, nearly ten years before Quirinius became governor. ========== So, was it 4 BCE, or 6 CE? That's a ten year difference? Is the Bible truly without error? 

partyboy --- 18 years ago -

Nobody knows for sure...lets just celebrate it on December 25th. 

peeches --- 18 years ago -

On the 4th of July. 

Mark --- 18 years ago -

There are some theologians and historian who say that Jesus was actually born in the Spring. Their basis for this is that, in the Bible it says that the Shepards are tending their flocks. According to historians and Agriculturalists sheep would have been tended during the Spring not the Winter. However, it doesn't really matter when Jesus was actually born, it just matters that he was... 

Danabug(BCM) --- 18 years ago -

He was born on his birthday :) 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

Actually, it is the fall, probably late September to early October. True, the winter in Israel is their rainy season, so no shepards would have been tending their flocks. Additionally, one can use the timeline of Elizabeth's pregnancy relevant to Mary's, and the fact that Elizabeth's husband was a priest serving at a set time of the year in the temple. (Luke 1:5: a certain priest named Zacharias, of the course of Abijah ) The division of Abijah served as priests during the second half of the fourth month (I Chronicles 24:10). According to Luke 1:24-26, Mary conceived Jesus in the sixth month of Elizabeth's pregnancy. Jesus would have been born 15 months after Gabriel appeared to Liz's husband. That would be the seventh month of the Jewish calendar, late September or early October. 

Mark --- 18 years ago -

Wow, NightOwl...Interesting theory... 

Donkey Hodie --- 18 years ago -

Spring, summer, fall, winter, July 4th, December 25th - that is less important to me than having a conflicting year in the same Gospel. What is bb's answer to this? 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

Cooler than that--you know the passage where the Word "dwelt among us" (John 1:14). Dwelt there is the Greek word "skenoo" which literally means "to tabernacle". And what happens during the seventh month of the Jewish calendar? Why, the Feast of Tabernacles, of course! 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

Donkey, I remember reading an explanation for that somewhere, but I'll have to research it later and see if I can find the answer for you--gotta run out the door right now. 

Superfantastik --- 18 years ago -

ask bbjones 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

My, my, my. Have you read any of Luke's writings? Do you think he would be off on the date by 10 years, and wouldn't know who was governor of Syria? Luke's accuracy as a historian is impeccable. Let us delve a little deeper to find the answer... 

peeches --- 18 years ago -

Have you read any of Luke's writings? Luke Skywalker? Why yes I have. 

Angela --- 18 years ago -

I think you are mixing up the Herod’s. There were two or three of them, note that one is listed as Herod the king and the other Herod the Great. I would have to research it. The setting of December 25th as Jesus’ birth date was implemented by the Roman Catholic church. They usually had the winter solstice around December 21st, which was a big festival with the giving of gifts. The church felt that this was paganistic and wanted to outlaw the festival. But the people continued to celebrate it, so the church decided to just label the date as Jesus’ birthday. Then they had a problem with the gift giving, because that was also a pagan ritual. The people got upset about this and rebelled against the church. So they decided that gift giving was okay, because the wise men gave gifts, and people do give gifts on birthdays. When the Puritans moved to America, the gift giving stopped for a while, because of the pagan insinuation. But then industries needed cash during the winter months, so they decided that it would be okay to start giving gifts again. 

Clown Vomit --- 18 years ago -

Yesterday. 

Donkey Hodie --- 18 years ago -

Why is it so hard to admit that the Bible may contain small factual errors? The value of the Bible is in it's moral lessons and philosophical teachings, not it's incorrect literal history. It's not the end of the world to admit that, unless you're bbjones. 

Clown Vomit --- 18 years ago -

If he admits that, he'll turn into a pillar of salt. 

Going off air --- 18 years ago -

Myth became Fact when God became Man The person of Jesus was the bankrupting of Logic Jesus was born in the Fullness of Time Therefore the Bible is true and without error 

Donkey Hodie --- 18 years ago -

The setting of December 25th as Jesus’ birth date was implemented by the Roman Catholic church. Actually, Saturnalia was started by the Romans before Jesus was born. Although some people think Christmas on Dec 25th was actually the morph of the celebration of Sol Invictus. But Sol Invictus was the morph of Saturnalia, so it's all basically the same thing. A pre-Jesus Roman celebration in late December. Whoo! 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Why is it so hard to admit that the Bible may contain small factual errors? The value of the Bible is in it's moral lessons and philosophical teachings, not it's incorrect literal history. Yes, it's only when some try to make the Bible into something that it is not, something that it never claims to be, that the question of errancy is raised. It does not claim to be a science text, for example. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

It really is not known for sure. Some say Jan, and others say Sept. Spring, May. No one can actually determine for sure. Google it, there is some interesting reading on it. 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

On Christmas Day on Christmas Day on Christmas Day in the morning! :) 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

Why is it so hard to admit that the Bible may contain small factual errors? Because it doesn't, and it can't. If I had written a complex computer program that was brilliantly flawless, but so above your or anyone else's understanding that you were constantly harping to me that "it must not work right here", why would I say, "Well, maybe you're right; it may have flaws", when I knew for a fact that it didn't? Wouldn't I say, "No, you just don't comprehend its complexity." There are parts of God's Word that we may not grasp entirely yet in our limited understanding, but that doesn't mean we can say that it has flaws. The Bible is the ONE thing that I have in this world that I can have absolute trust in. It is the ONE thing that I know is TRUTH, and it is the ONE thing that I know will stand the test of time in accuracy. Preachers may get its message wrong; scientists may be blinded to its truths; husband and friends may turn out to be untrue; my own understanding of what the Bible says may be in error. But as the STANDARD, it is not in error. By definition, Truth cannot be in error. Heaven and earth may pass away, but God's Word remains forever. It is HOLY and good, not flawed. 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 18 years ago -

Amen, NightOwl. 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

NIght Owl you ROCK!!! Happy Hanuikka (I know it is misspelled, spell check is having a hissy fit! lol) 

donottreadonme --- 18 years ago -

There are parts of God's Word that we may not grasp entirely yet in our limited understanding, but that doesn't mean we can say that it has flaws. Very well said God Word's is never wrong. We just don't grasp it properly most of the time. 

Donkey Hodie --- 18 years ago -

OK, if "God's Word" (I'm assuming you mean the Bible - oh, and which translation?) is never wrong, when was Jesus born? 4 BCE or 6 CE? 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Spring, summer, fall, winter, July 4th, December 25th - that is less important to me than having a conflicting year in the same Gospel. What is bb's answer to this? There is debate by historians over the exact duties and/or titles of Quirinius during the period of time before he became Governor of Syria in 6 AD. It is historically known that when Quirinius became governor in 6 AD, he did order a census for taxation and that this caused an uprising in Judea. Luke mentions this in his second book, The Acts of the Apostles in 5:37. From the reading of Scripture, we can see that Luke makes no attempt to link this census with what he describes as the "first census" in his gospel account of Jesus' birth. In 1912, an inscription was discovered at Antioch that establishes Quirinius as the military governor of Cilicia prior to his becoming the governor of Syria in 6 AD. This is backed up by the historian Tacitus who recorded that Quirinius led a military campaign in Cilicia against the Homonaedenses between 12 and 6 BC. Cilicia was annexed to Syria around the time of the birth of Jesus. This means that Quirinius would now be called a governor, by definition, of Syria since Cilicia was now a province of Syria. It was customary for a census to be taken upon an annexation. In Quirinius' position as governor of Cicilia, he would have been responsible for the census mentioned by Luke. This census that was requisitioned in approximately 6 BC would, therefore, have been the "first" census taken when Cyrenius was governor as recorded in Luke 2:2 and the historically documented census of 6 AD by Josephus was really a second one. Now let's look at the Scriptures in conjunction with the recorded history. Jesus was born while Herod the Great was alive as recorded in Matthew 2:1. Wise men appeared in Jerusalem asking about "one who has been born king of the Jews?" This upset Herod, who had been given the title "King of the Jews" by the Roman Senate. We are told in Matthew 2:7 that Herod talked to the wise men secretly and found out from them the exact time the star had appeared. Herod asked them to return to him and report after they had found the child. The wise men then journeyed to Bethlehem and found Jesus, Mary, and Joseph in a house as recorded in Matthew 2:11. They "fell down, and worshipped him... And being warned of God in a dream that they should not return to Herod, they departed into their own country another way." When the wise men did not return to give Herod a report, "Then Herod, when he saw that he was mocked of the wise men, was exceeding wroth, and sent forth, and slew all the children that were in Bethlehem, and in all the coasts thereof, from two years old and under, according to the time which he had diligently inquired of the wise men." (Matthew 2:16). This Biblical account tells us that Jesus may have been born approximately two years before the appearance of the wise men and the death of Herod. According to the Jewish historian, Josephus, Herod died the spring of 4 BC. It was their custom to count the years of one's age from the date of conception. In other words, when a child is born he is one year old until his first birthday. Therefore, Herod actually killed the children one year old and under according to the way that we calculate age today. According to the way they calculated ages, Jesus would have possibly been born in about 5 BC. The Bible also tells us that Jesus was "about thirty years old" when He began his ministry. "And Jesus himself began to be about thirty years of age, being (as was supposed) the son of Joseph, which was the son of Heli," (Luke 3:23). From information revealed to us in John 2:20 about the construction of the temple, it has been determined that Jesus' ministry began 26 AD. So, if we count forward from 5 B.C. to A.D. 26, subtracting one year because there is no year zero, that would make Jesus 30 years old when he began his ministry. If Jesus was born around 5 BC this would also fit with what historian's believe is the date of the crucifixion - somewhere around 29 or 30 AD. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Yes, it's only when some try to make the Bible into something that it is not, something that it never claims to be, that the question of errancy is raised. It does not claim to be a science text, for example. You and some of your supporters are the only ones who are trying to say that the Bible is a science book. It is not, BUT, the science contained within the Bible is true. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

OK, if "God's Word" (I'm assuming you mean the Bible - oh, and which translation?) is never wrong, when was Jesus born? 4 BCE or 6 CE? I'm going with the 4 - 1 BCE era, as that is what the majority of theologians seem to think. In just one quick google, I immediately found 2 different, plausible explanations for your "discrepancy". I am sure that there are more, but these are just the first two I stumbled across. First, there is a strong probability that there were multiple censuses, so that the one mentioned in Luke was not the one that occurred in 6 CE, but the one that occurred in 2 BCE. Copied and pasted from comereason.org's website: . . . we have at least three censuses in the area of Judea - one in 8 B.C., one starting around 2 B.C. and one in 6 A.D. . . . The first point is the terminology Luke uses when writing about Quirinius' governorship over Syria. In stating that Quirinius controlled the Syrian area, Luke doesn't use the official political title of "Governor" ("legatus"), but the broader term "hegemon" which is a ruling officer or procurator. This means that Quirinius may not have been the official governor of Judea, but he was in charge of the census because he was a more capable and trusted servant of Rome than the more inept Saturninus. Justin Martyr's Apology supports this view, writing that Quirinius was a "procurator", not a governor of the area of Judea. ComeReason.org This seems to be the consensus of most scholars whose writings I read from, (including the second source below.) A second explanation is that it wasn't Herod the Great in the Matthew 2:1 verse. Copied and pasted from home.teleport.com's website: Herod the Great was near 70 years old by the time he died in 4 BC. . . . it's not Herod the Great Matthew was talking about in the verse above. Herod the Great did though have 3 sons that were made joint kings of the region: Herod Archelaus: ruled Judaea, Samaria, and Idumea Herod Antipas: ruled Galilee and Perea (and later had John beheaded) Herod Phillip: ruled lands east of Jordan Herod Archelaus ruled from 4 BC to 6 AD, he had direct control over Bethlehem at the time of Jesus's birth, and he is the one mentioned a few verses down in Matthew: Mat 2:22 But when he heard that Archelaus did reign in Judaea in place of his father Herod, he was afraid to go there: nevertheless, being commanded by God in a dream, he returned into the parts of Galilee. See Archelaus? That's Herod Archelaus, the king of Judaea, Sumaria, and Idumea at the time that the order went out to kill the newborns in Bethlehem. Herod Archelaus was 18 years old in 4 BC, and was the principal heir of his father's kingdom. He was described as being cruel and tyrannical, a hypocrite and a plotter. He killed thousands and his reign ended in 6 AD. There is little doubt that he would have been the one to give the order to kill all newborns in Bethlehem. . . . home.teleport.com With all due respect, I question your motive here. You seemed so gleeful to point out some "discrepancy" you read about. Do you really think that you're going to find some new revelation, some new "discrepancy" that Biblical scholars the world over haven't already dissected and offered a half-dozen plausible explanations for? But keep digging, because you are at least becoming more familiar with the Holy Word of God, which is a good thing, IMO. 

4babygirls --- 18 years ago -

He was born on his birthday :) that's exactly what i thought when i read the question! i guess we're both very clever!! i know it's not december 25, but it's never mattered to me enough to research it out. i'm just glad He was born and that He died for our sins, blameless and without sin Himself. merry Christmas, everyone!! 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

You and some of your supporters Me and my "supporters"? What a very funny thing to say! Does that fit into some role play thing that you have concocted? The role play might explain much, I suppose. I really can't imagine a venue much more randomly anarchic and leaderless than a board like this, though, with individuals, most of whom have no other contact with each other, happening to agree, wholly or in part, on one thread, disagreeing on another, having no view at all on still another, on most. There are posters with whom I agree in substance, but heartily disagree in method, and vice versa, all blissfully uncoordinated. Some of the posters for whom I have greatest respect happen also to be posters with whom I've had strong disagreement. Some with whom I share some views irritate me, frequently. I'm not aware of any supporters, or leaders. It's a madhouse. 

Clown Vomit --- 18 years ago -

You and some of your supporters are the only ones who are trying to say that the Bible is a science book. I say it's a comic book, only without all the cool pictures. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

Happy Hanukkah Thanks, Fallon! Back at 'ya. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

bb, Man, you gotta post sources for stuff! Before the article, after, whatever - I don't really care. But please, don't ruin a good post my leading us to believe that you wrote it all yourself. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

My point about Luke is that there are a lot better texts to argue if you want to point out errors in the Bible. Luke not knowing when Cyrenius was governor, or when the census occurred, would be like us missing the date of the Challenger explosion or the year WWII ended by 10 years. Luke obviously had a good reason for writing what he wrote. Your argument against inerrancy in our extant manuscripts would be better served by picking on a different portion of the texts. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Nobody knows for sure...lets just celebrate it on December 25th. Yes! The reason for the season Merry Christmas to all! 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

CyberSage, for your information, I typed every word in that post except for the quotes from the Bible. I spent a long time doing so. I could care less whether you think that I wrote that myself or not. I took the time to look up the information from several locations, took notes and then put the material together to answer a direct question that was proposed to me. I was concerned with getting the answer as accurate as possible and not concerning myself with whether YOU think that I ruined the answer because YOU are unclear as to whether I wrote it myself or not. If you do not like how it was presented, then get over yourself and don't read it. Isn't it very obvious to you that I got my information on the dates and the people from history books? Do you actually think that I just made up those dates and those names on my own? Do you actually think that I expect others to think that I did? I did reference some of my sources, such as Josephus. I actually have the book of his complete works, titled "Josephus - Complete Works" and I personally looked up that information. His works include "Life of Flavius Josephus"; The Antiquities of the Jews"; the Wars of the Jews"; Discourse Concerning Hades"; and Seven Dissertations. Also included in the works is tables of Jewish weights and measures and texts of the Old Testament parallel to Josephus' histories. Now, does that make you feel any better? ANY information that YOU, or anyone else, have in YOUR mind that did not come from a direct experience, came from learning what someone else said or told you. Do you cite all of those sources every time you write? No? Why not? How come others, such as CleverName, make post after post containing information that they got from reference material and I never see you telling them to cite their sources? You and others need to start paying attention TO THE MESSAGE and forget about the messenger. IF you think that what I posted was wrong, then say so and give the reasons for saying so. Otherwise, concentrate on your own style of writing and let ME worry about mine. 

Donkey Hodie --- 18 years ago -

Your argument against inerrancy in our extant manuscripts would be better served by picking on a different portion of the texts.  I know. Besides all of the wacky stuff in the OT that would probably merit an NC-17 rating if it were made into a movie, if you only look at the Gospels you can find plenty of contradictory stories. I only brought up the year of Jesus' birth since it's the Christmas season right now. I think biblical literalists like bbjones ultimately do Christianity a disservice. By insisting on inerrancy in an obviously flawed book, (and again, I ask those of bbjones' ilk, which translation are you even talking about?) and by flawed, I mean in a literal sense, in that many so-called "facts" in it are demonstrably incorrect, that by asserting divine authority in this hodge-podge collection of stories, myths, allegories, etc., collected over several hundred years by many different writers, they are ruining the potential wisdom that could be gleaned from it by a mature reading and understanding. They take the wisdom, the rich cultural store and collective knowledge and turn it into a legalistic policy manual. It is bbjones and those of his kind who ruin Christianity more than any atheist ever could. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

if you only look at the Gospels you can find plenty of contradictory stories. There are no contradictions in the Bible. I think biblical literalists like bbjones ultimately do Christianity a disservice. By insisting on inerrancy in an obviously flawed book, I do Christianity a disservice by saying that the Word of God is Holy and inerrant? What nonsense. It is the people, like yourself, that use the Bible's use of figurative speech to imply that God is a liar and that his Word is flawed, that are the disservice to Christianity and to ALL humanity. A literal understanding allows for purely figurative language, but such cases are evident from the context in which it is used. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground