Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Shoot 1st & worry about the rest later?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
GCan 1
love4bdd 1
Lilteapot 3
buddercup 1
duflochy 1
Holly 1
Rusty Shackleford 1
lLackCreativity 1
amb07 1
Puppy again 3
mykidsmom 1
blondeitalian 1
ChezML 1
Mr Mark 1
*emily 2
proudmomoftwo 4
Mabbers 1
Cicero 2
Lynn 1
CleverName 3
mamajulie 1
~Shannon~ 1
D'Hat Lady 1
riley 1
partyboy 3
Mike 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Shoot 1st & worry about the rest later?

Most of us have heard about the guy that called 911 and shot two people robbing the next door neighbor. I think hes going to do time. What do you think? Would you do it. Do you think you would get away w/it?

He's going to do time. Vote
 
 23.2% (13)
He's not going to do time. Vote
 
 19.6% (11)
I'd shoot to kill Vote
 
 21.4% (12)
I'd shoot to wound (then add salt just to be mean) Vote
 
 35.7% (20)
Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

Most of us have heard about the guy that called 911 and shot two people robbing the next door neighbor. I think hes going to do time. What do you think? Would you do it. Do you think you would get away w/it? 

Lilteapot --- 19 years ago -

His problem is, the 911 have been aired, and he was clearly warned by the 911 operater, police were on their way, and to stay put. 

blondeitalian --- 19 years ago -

 

partyboy --- 19 years ago -

if he felt he should have gotten involved, he should have gotten license plate numbers and photos, not hunted them down like deer 

Lilteapot --- 19 years ago -

As much as I would protect and want my neigbor to protect my property, he DID the right thing by making the 911 call. But then he totally ignored the authorities and took the law into his own hands, and shot and KILLED two people. While I do belive everyone has a right to protect their property and neigborhod, this guy was clearly trigger happy. 

partyboy --- 19 years ago -

The two guys that died, their families will probably sue him because the dead cannot steal to support their family anymore. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

It all depends on whether the shooter thinks he thinks the property cannot be protected or recovered by any other means. See Tex. Pen. Code § 9.42(3)(A). I think he may have a problem since the dispatcher told him to stay inside and that the police were on the way. The good news is that if he is justified in killing the criminals under criminal law, he is immune from civil liability under Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 83.001. The legislature expanded the coverage of the immunity to all lawful uses of force, not just self defense. 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

I think he will do time. In this case he was urged to stay inside... He had plenty of time to decide to kill the two robbers. 

whatchamacallit --- 19 years ago -

I think he will do time for this. He had already called 911 and they had given him intructions, which he ignored. 

amb07 --- 19 years ago -

I am proud of him and believe he should not do time, he instead should be rewarded. 

partyboy --- 19 years ago -

I am proud of him and believe he should not do time, he instead should be rewarded i agree....he should. but hes not. the ACLU will get him some really slick lawyers to prove that the puerto ricans who were probably illegals, were violated of their civil rights and the shooter and homeowner will have to bear financial ruin because of this. 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

I say if a few more robbers get shot maybe people will think twice before breaking in. This is Texas I dont think he will do time.. Just My Opinion 

Puppy again --- 19 years ago -

He will do time. My uncle owned a gas station and saw someone inside one night. He called the police and they told him they were on thier way. Then he went in and shoot the guy. He is now serving life! 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

puppy again, when was that, things change and you know how texans are when it comes to there home... I dont think charges have been pressed at least thats the last I heard. 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

The news station was reporting that if the the neighbors had an agreement to look out for each others property, the a saavy lawyer could argue from that perspective and quite possibly keep him out of jail. 

Puppy again --- 19 years ago -

It was about 15 yr ago in Waller. And the same guy that he shot had robbed him twice before and been caught! Times may have changed but I can tell you after working in the prison system, he will do time! 

duflochy --- 19 years ago -

Kill them, pile them up, let God sort them out....... 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

From what I saw yesterday on the news, he shot them for burglary. He said something about not wanting them to get away with his stuff...this does not constitute protection in my book. He sounded trigger happy. 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

it wasnt his stuff it was his neighbors, if I heard the story right. 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

I think it also has to do with you adrenaline pumping. I think he acted in the heat of it all.. I guess only time will tell.. I admit it does sound bad on the tape.. I just dont have any sympathy for crooks, and he did try to call 1st.. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

It all depends on whether the shooter thinks he thinks the property cannot be protected or recovered by any other means. Even if that property isn't his? 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

Even if that property isn't his? Yes. You can use deadly force to protect the property of a third party if you meet the requirements of Texas Penal Code § 9.43. My cite to § 9.42 above arises from the fact that § 9.43 incorporates all of the requirmenets of imposed upon a person who uses deadly force to defend his own property which is found at Texas Penal Code § 9.42. 

Lilteapot --- 19 years ago -

He screwed himself IMO. He called the authorities and they told no once but several times, DO NOT go outside, DO NOT take your gun. He ignored them. He did call, he knew the police were on there way. (He could of gone and sorted them out first...then called cops). 

Holly --- 19 years ago -

I dont know if the law changed since then, but way back I had a friend that shot some one climbing in through thier window. The man was 1/2 in and 1/2 out. They ended up doing time even though it was obvious the man was breaking in... But since he wasn't ALL the way in.. they said there was a chance he might have changed his mind. UGH! They said, if you would have dragged him the rest of the way in before calling us it wouldn't have been a problem! Yeaah.. it's ok if he had lied. I think the person will do time. But I think he did the right thing. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

He'll walk. He did nothing illegal. If you listen to the call you'll hear him tell the 911 operator that they came in his yard. Also they had a crowbar which they used to break into the house. These were career criminals. I won't shed a tear for them. 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

Thats what I though to Cicero. I heard they came into his yard. Thats going to be his best defense I think. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Thats what I though to Cicero. I heard they came into his yard. Thats going to be his best defense I think. The man sounded really scared too. It's possible that the criminals had cased the neighborhood for awhile. How did he know they weren't coming for his house next? 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

If someone broke into my neighbors house in broad daylight and came into my yard next I would probably shoot too! 

Puppy again --- 19 years ago -

I would love to see him do no time... I wish him luck, all the luck in the world. But I have seen it before, do not be surprised when he is convicted of murder! 

Lynn --- 19 years ago -

The news just said that the home owner went outside with his gun to see where the two guys were and they were in his yard..he told them to stop and one jumped for him..which they just said is self defense..the man feared for his life..I don't think he should do any time..if anything he should get a reward..When the owners get more power from the police to shoot to kill maybe robberies will go way down. 

buddercup --- 19 years ago -

f anything he should get a reward..When the owners get more power from the police to shoot to kill maybe robberies will go way down. I totally agree! 

riley --- 19 years ago -

With all of the robberies going on in broad daylight lately, and the robbers getting more and more bold I'd shoot without hesitation. They would have to be robbing my house though. I'm also a girl and have two small children to protect. Before they were born I'd probably just try to scare off the burgulars. Now I wouldn't take a chance on them taking my weapon from me and harming myself or my children. I'd have no choice but to shoot to kill. I've also been taught not to draw a weapon unless I had full intention of using deadly force. Guns are not a game. Texas born of coarse! 

lLackCreativity --- 19 years ago -

I never wanted to own a gun until I became a mother. As a woman, I have a deep urge to protect and care for all life...even that of humans I don't know. But I am not just a woman anymore, I'm a mother. And in my book that means my baby comes before all. If a person was in my yard, I would call the cops hide the kid and wait. Once they enter the sanctuary of my home, my place of safety and security...it's a whole new ball game. 

~Shannon~ --- 19 years ago -

I never wanted to own a gun until I became a mother. As a woman, I have a deep urge to protect and care for all life...even that of humans I don't know. But I am not just a woman anymore, I'm a mother. And in my book that means my baby comes before all. If a person was in my yard, I would call the cops hide the kid and wait. Once they enter the sanctuary of my home, my place of safety and security...it's a whole new ball game exactly what I would do. If they were at my neighbors then I would try to take a picture after I called 911. Stay in my house and hide with my kids phone gun 

D'Hat Lady --- 19 years ago -

He was on the phone for the whole time that they went in, grabbed things then came out with bags filled... thats plenty of time for A- the police to come or B- for the robbers to "change their minds" and stop stealing, he told them twice to stop! I think he went through all the steps that I would have, nevertheless, knowing most robberies always go unsolved, he stopped it from happening again. Now I probably would have aimed for the legs or something so they would be here to serve their time and take the punishment due.... but then again, my aim is not that good :) 

Mike --- 19 years ago -

I agree that the man is going to probbably going to be doing some time. Although he did do the right thing, but he had plenty of time to think twice and was told not to act. He offered way too much recordable and admissible information and that is what is going to hang him. He told the dispatcher that he was going to KILL THEM. He premeditated the act. Had he acted within one or two minutes rather than six he would have a chance at falling under the new self defense and protection of property law. 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

I would like him as my good buddy neighbor :) 

Rusty Shackleford --- 19 years ago -

I think we should throw him a party and send him on his way. 

mamajulie --- 19 years ago -

As i read the law cited here and elsewhere, it seems to me that it clearly states that you may use force to "prevent" a robbery. Now these guys were making multiple trips in and out of the house. Seems to me that he was acting within the law. Hopefully the grand jury will see it that way also, if it even gets that far. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

As i read the law cited here and elsewhere, it seems to me that it clearly states that you may use force to "prevent" a robbery. Now these guys were making multiple trips in and out of the house. Seems to me that he was acting within the law. Hopefully the grand jury will see it that way also, if it even gets that far. Actually, this is a buglary of a habitation, not a robbery. The law says you can use deadly force to the extent you reasonably believe deadly force is necessary to prevent the imminent commission of burglary or to prevent a person who is fleeing immediately after the committing a burglary, but only if you reasonably believe the burgled property cannot be recovered by any other means or using less than deadly force would expose you to substantial risk of serious bodlily injury or death. See Tex. Pen. Code § 9.42. DISCLAIMER: DO NOT GO SHOOT SOMEONE BASED UPON THIS POSTING. This posting is for informational purposes only and is not intended to be legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. You should not act, or refrain from acting, based upon any information at this posting. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground