Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Earth is Flat (So what else is new?)

who's talking here?

bbjones 3
accent_ 15
CleverName 9
RootBeerBelly 2
ffup 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

The Flat Earth Society "Deprogramming the masses since 1547" Why a Flat Earth? Ever since the official signing of the Flat Earth Society's charter, one of our most difficult goals was to understand the mindset of those we were trying to save. The complexities of Efimovich's theory, that theory's convoluted nature and dependence on flawed logic and the omission of obstructions make it nearly impossible to understand at all, let alone understand why anyone would believe such dribble. Although we have, through the years, made significant progress towards understanding the viewpoint of Efimovich's followers, we still recognize the holes in the intricate web Efimovich wove. Ours is the truth, the truth of the world's flatness, and ours is also the burden of proof. We are the minority, the followers of lies being the majority, and we gladly accept our burden, if in the end that acceptance means ridding the world of the foul half-truths spread by Grigori Efimovich and his brood of vipers. We present the following five arguments, each completely logical and to some degree building off of the arguments before it. We hope that, after carefully considering what we say here, you will look a with a little less ridicule on the Flat Earth Society and its members. Argument One - Experimental confirmation of the Earth's rigidity in space 1) The ether factor In classical physics, ether was assumed to be a ephemeral substance which permeated all matter. This omnipresent medium was that through which visible light and other electromagnetic waves were supposed to have traveled. It was assumed to have qualities which now seem rather bizarre - too bizarre, in fact, to be allowed to exist, by Efimovich's teachings. So in 1887, two American scientists, operating under the Efimovich-based assumption that the Earth was moving through outer space and not the fixed center of the Universe, conducted an experiment to "prove" whether or not ether actually existed. In this experiment, the general idea was to try to calculate the absolute speed of the earth relative to the fixed ether. In a sense, they would emit a light pulse, and calculate how far it "trailed" behind the earth, much like tossing a napkin out the window of a moving car to calculate the car's speed. It was assumed that, if ether existed, the light pulse would fall back in one direction, giving the physicists a tangible "absolute" speed of the earth. Their calculated speed: Zero. Yes, scientists Albert A. Michelson and Edward W. Morley were baffled by this, wondering how the Earth could be sitting in one spot, while every aspect of the teachings of Grigori Efimovich indicated that the planet must be orbiting its own sun, and therefore must be moving at least with a critical orbital velocity. Moving quickly to avoid having to admit that they were wrong, they were able to instead "infer" from their results that the ether must not exist, and that light must propagate through no medium at all (impossible for a wave by the very definition of a wave). Their inference was generally accepted by the scientific community (save a few notable exceptions, including Hendrik A. Lorentz) and the "ridiculous" notion of ether was thrown out. But light waves would still require a medium for transmission, and the actual purpose of the experiment was to determine the existence of that medium. The results speak for themselves: the Earth does not move. And even if the Earth did, the problems inherent in keeping it moving through this light medium called ether are overwhelmingly supportive of "Flat-Earth" theory. Argument Two - Difficulties with the model: incorporating an Efimovich-type model with the known Universe 1) Maintaining speed In the Efimovich model, the planet Earth is supposed to be a large, spherical shaped ball of rock flying through space at hundreds of thousands of miles per hour. But how could the Earth continue to move at the same speed for as long a time as the "round Earthers" say that it has existed for; namely, several billion years. If outer space were a vacuum, then there would be no problem. But space is not a vacuum, it is instead filled with ether. The earth would have to have been pushing its way through the ether for all those billions of years. Shouldn't it have slowed somewhere along the line? What would keep the Earth from grinding down to a stop at some point on the Efimovichian timeline? 2) An accelerating world A second critical piece to the Efimovich model is that the Earth is not the center of the solar system either. It is, according to "round Earth" theory, orbiting the sun at a radius of around five-hundred million kilometers. Were this the case, the Earth would be an accelerated object in circular motion around its sun. And thereby are the problems introduced. The Earth accelerating in circular motion would behave no differently than would a car taking a corner: loose objects (humans and animals would act like loose change or a cup of coffee on the dashboard) would slide around, or be thrown off completely. There would be an apparent centrifugal force on everything. During the day, when things would be facing the sun and therefore on the inside of the "orbit", buildings would be crushed and humans beings squashed like grasshoppers in a centrifuge. And at night, when everything would be at the outside, trees and buildings would be ripped from the ground and flung into outer space, and humans wouldn't stand a chance. Obviously, there is a flaw in Efimovich's "orbit" theory. Argument Three - The impossibilities of holding unsecured objects in place on a curved surface 1) Staying on top Once again, picture in your mind a round world. Now imagine that there are two people on this world, one at each pole. For the person at the top of the world, (the North Pole), gravity is pulling him down, towards the South Pole. But for the person at the South Pole, shouldn't gravity pull him down as well? What keeps our person at the South Pole from falling completely off the face of the "globe"? 2) Falling off As we begin to make this argument, we acknowledge beforehand that we are aware of the property of matter known as friction. Yes, we realize that whenever two surfaces are held together by any force there will be a static frictional force that will resist any motion by either surface in any direction other than parallel to the force. The example we are using is an extreme situation, and would involve the object in question to travel a considerable distance (tens of degrees of latitude) from the "top" of the planet. Using the "round Earth" theory, setting an object on the earth would be like setting grains of sand on a beach ball. Certainly a few grains would stay - right around the top, the surface is nearly horizontal - but when you stray too far from the absolute top of the ball, the grains of sand start sliding off and falling onto the ground. The Earth, if round, should behave in exactly the same fashion. Because the top is a very localized region on a sphere, if the Earth were in fact round, there would be only a very small area of land that would be at all inhabitable. Stray to the outside fringes of the "safe zone", and you start walking at a tilt. The further out you go, the more you slant, until your very survival is determined by the tread on your boots. Reach a certain point, and you slide off the face of the planet entirely. Obviously, something is wrong. In order to avoid the aforementioned scenario, (which obviously is inaccurate, as you very rarely hear of people falling off the face of the planet) we are forced to assume that, in the "round Earth" theory, there would be a gravitational field radiating from the center of the planet. All objects, be they rocks, insects, humans, or other planets would have, under Efimovich's theory, have a gravitational "charge" that would, under a certain alignment, cause them to be attracted to the center of the Earth. Unfortunately, like a magnet in a stronger magnetic field, it would undoubtedly require a long time to re-align an object's gravitational charge, were this the case. And so we go to argument four, which deals with difficulties in having different "downs" for different people. Argument Four - Paradoxes associated with an inconsistent down direction 1) Negotiating long-distance travel Now imagine, if only for the sake of argument, that the person on top and the person on bottom can both manage to remain attracted to the ground "below" them. What would happen if the person on one side decided to visit the other? Since the man at the North Pole has a different idea of what is down and up (and in fact experiences an opposite pull from the Earth's gravity) than the person at the South Pole does, when the denizen of the frozen Arctic visits his Antarctic counterpart, they will experience gravitational pulls exactly opposite of each other! The human from the North Pole will "fall up", never returning to the ground, and will continue falling forever into the deep void of outer space! Looking at the feasibility of Efimovich's teachings cannot remain limited to examining small, solid objects such as human beings. A true analysis of his work must incorporate natural phenomena and how their existence is either explained or made difficult by each of the theories. In the next argument against the "round-Earth" theory, we will be analyzing the existence of two extremely commonplace (yet altogether unfeasible under the ramifications of having a round planet) non-solids: the atmosphere and the oceans. Argument Five - Difficulties in maintaining a functional Earth-bound atmosphere and ocean 1) The fluid problem Water. Regardless of which train of thought you follow, it covers over seventy-five percent of our planet's surface. And the atmosphere, also a fluid, covers the entire surface. The difference is why. While flat-Earthers know that the ocean is really just a large bowl, (with great sheets of ice around the edges to hold the ocean back), and the atmosphere is contained by a large dome, the backwards "round-Earth" way of thinking would have you believe that all those trillions of gallons of water and air just "stick" to the planet's surface. Conventional thinking would suggest that the water would just run down the sides of the Earth (to use the analogy again, like droplets running down the sides of a beach ball) and fall into outer space, while the air would dissipate. Using the earlier mentioned idea of "gravitational charge" gives some credibility to the theory. If the fluids were static, then exposure to the gravitational field for a long enough period of time would allow their molecules to align themselves with and be pulled in by the field. But fluids are not static, especially not in the atmosphere and oceans. Great ocean currents run both at the surface and deep below, carrying water across huge basins, keeping the solution far from stagnant. Jet streams of air travel at hundreds of miles per hour through the atmosphere. And windblown rainclouds carry vast quantities of evaporated seawater across miles of ground, releasing their load far from its starting point. Water or air that (according to "round-Earth" theory) starts on one side of the planet could end up completely on the other side in a matter of only a few days. With all this turbulence and motion, if the world were round, the oceans should all fall "down" into the sky, leaving the planet dry and barren, and the atmosphere would simply float away. Why, just look at the moon. It is round, like a ball, and yet it has no atmosphere at all. 2) Thermodynamic complications Taking into account the "gravitational charge" analogy once more, and assuming that for some reason the atmosphere was able to align itself with the new direction of the theoretical "gravitational field", we are faced with a new problem involving another branch of physics known as thermodynamics. Obviously, the world is static, the fixed center of the Universe. The sun, planets and stars all revolve around it (although not necessarily in circular paths), in a plane level with the flat Earth.  

CleverName --- 18 years ago -

Did anyone receive the color brochure titled "Have Scientiss Been Wrong?[sic.] For 400 Years?" by the Geocentric Bible Foundation, Inc. of Wichita, Kansas, advertising a free copy of the Geocentricity Primer and the Geocentric Bible 6. I am ordering my copy. How about you? Anyone? Anyone? I am curious about whether anyone here believes the following: 1. The Earth does not revolve. 2. The Earth does not orbit the Sun. 3. The Sun orbits the Earth. 4. The Planets and Stars orbit the Earth. 5. The Earth is the center of the Universe. So how about it. Five simple yes/no answers. There had to be a reason this was mailed to the "Current Resident" at my address. Who here has a problem with Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler, Newton, et al.? Am I part of a minority in Kingwood that thinks Copernicus, Galileo and Kepler were right about the Earth, Planets, Comets and Asteroids orbiting the Sun? 

ffup --- 18 years ago -

No, but I did receive the National Geographic. :) 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Obviously, the world is static, the fixed center of the Universe. The sun, planets and stars all revolve around it (although not necessarily in circular paths), in a plane level with the flat Earth. Why would you believe this nonsense and post it? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Who here has a problem with Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler, Newton, et al.? Am I part of a minority in Kingwood that thinks Copernicus, Galileo and Kepler were right about the Earth, Planets, Comets and Asteroids orbiting the Sun? I figured that there would be a much more positive reception on KU to the Flat Earth Society Post. After all, if you can believe the earth is only about 6,000 years old, what can't you believe? As to that material going to your address, CN: what have you not been telling us, and why are you being so defensive about it, and why is this 9 day old post active now? After all, things like that don't just happen. There's something fishy going on here, and it isn't only that old tuna that I just removed from the refrigerator. 

CleverName --- 18 years ago -

Obviously, the world is static, the fixed center of the Universe. The sun, planets and stars all revolve around it (although not necessarily in circular paths), in a plane level with the flat Earth. Why would you believe this nonsense and post it? Bb, I know you contend that the earth is approximately 6,000 years old. However, I believe I remember you agreeing that the Earth and planets orbit around the Sun. What I don't remember is if you believe that the Earth is the center of the universe. I know your boy D. Russell Humphreys claims our galaxy is the center of the universe, but not the Earth itself. I was just wondering what your take on the the Geocentric Bible Foundation's claims, since you seem to be the most biblically versed of all the posters. 

RootBeerBelly --- 18 years ago -

If you multiply the vector of the Earth by how many shots are in a bottle of patron tequila....when you wake up the next day on the concrete floor in jail you will plainly see that the Earth is flat. Bunch of geniuses in here....duh. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

If you multiply the vector of the Earth by how many shots are in a bottle of patron tequila....when you wake up the next day on the concrete floor in jail you will plainly see that the Earth is flat. Bunch of geniuses in here....duh. Yeah, you and I know that, but it is way above th heads of most on this thread. 

RootBeerBelly --- 18 years ago -

All they have to do is multiply the Patron ...it's simple really :) 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Who here has a problem with Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler, Newton, et al.? and what if I say that I've no problem with Copernicus and Galileo and Kepler, and Newton, but, in et al, you throw in some scientiss who is into Intelligent Design or something? 

CleverName --- 18 years ago -

There's something fishy going on here, and it isn't only that old tuna that I just removed from the refrigerator. All I have in my fridge is Turkey. As to that material going to your address, CN: what have you not been telling us, and why are you being so defensive about it, and why is this 9 day old post active now? After all, things like that don't just happen. It's a Festivus miracle! No, really, I saw this brochure in the mail and throught I would search to see if anyone else had received it. I picked your post to pose this question because the Geocentric Bible Foundation also spent time dealing with the question of whether the Bible teaches the Earth is flat. As to the material going to my address, I suddenly got the feeling that my zip code may not have been chosen at random. I was wondering if I was an old fashion "shunning" was in my future if I kept speaking my mind. :) 

CleverName --- 18 years ago -

All they have to do is multiply the Patron ...it's simple really :) I forgot to carry the 6 (pack). Gotta check my math. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I was wondering if I was an old fashion "shunning" was in my future if I kept speaking my mind. You should only be so lucky. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I forgot to carry the 6 (pack). Gotta check my math. mas Cerveza, por favor 

CleverName --- 18 years ago -

and what if I say that I've no problem with Copernicus and Galileo and Kepler, and Newton, but, in et al, you throw in some scientiss who is into Intelligent Design or something? You're too slick for me. I'll have to try another lawyer trick on you. For now, I'll confine the inquiry to Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler, Newton and Einstein, since Special and General Relativity do modify Newtonian mechanics on a large scale but not significantly on the scale of our solar system. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

and now I'm worried that, since I don't like shopping at Wal-mart, someone will get the wrong idea, so can we change the topic to football and hunting and Nascar? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

but not significantly on the scale of our solar system. Care to explain exactly what you mean by "not significantly" in that context? I don't want you trivializing something that may be very important to me. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

What I don't remember is if you believe that the Earth is the center of the universe. The Earth is the center of the universe because God created it specifically for man, His greatest creation. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

mas cerveza, por favor 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

and what if I say that I've no problem with Copernicus and Galileo and Kepler, and Newton, but, in et al, you throw in some scientiss who is into Intelligent Design or something? Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler, and Newton did believe in God, the Intelligent Designer and Creator of the universe. 

CleverName --- 18 years ago -

but not significantly on the scale of our solar system. Care to explain exactly what you mean by "not significantly" in that context? I don't want you trivializing something that may be very important to me. The observable effects of Newtonian mechanics and of General Relativity are not very distinguishable on a small scale such as our solar system without instruments with significant precision and sensativity that were not available in Galileo's time. If you do the calculations, you should get the same or similar answers. If memory serves me, for bodies in the solar system, you have to look at the Sun and Mercury to find a gravitational field warped enought to show a difference between Newtonian Mechanics and Relativity. I believe there is a slight precession or wobble affecting Mercury that cannot be explained by Newtonian mechanics, but this is not really observable without satellites orbiting Mercury. The biggest observational proof that made Einstein a rock star among theoretical physicists was the 1911 solar eclipse that showed a shift of the light waves from a distant constellation that came close to the sun and caused a particular constellation to appear in a different place that it really was. This proved that light was affected by gravity. An observer using the technology available in 1758, the year that the church withdrew its prohibition against preaching heliocentrism, probably would not be able to see any phenomena which would have different results depending on whether you applied Newtons or Einstein's theories. Accordingly, arguing that Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler or Newton got it wrong because Einstein has proven to be more correct would miss the point when considering what was available in 1758. Thus, I'll include all five, even though Einstein was not born yet. All five had a greater grasp than the Roman Inquisition. 

CleverName --- 18 years ago -

Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler, and Newton did believe in God, the Intelligent Designer and Creator of the universe. Sure they did. And so do I. However, I do believe that the Earth rotates around its axis, and I do not believe that the Sun orbits the Earth. I believe the Earth orbits the Sun. Does that make me a heretic or apostate? 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

but not significantly on the scale of our solar system. Care to explain exactly what you mean by "not significantly" in that context? I don't want you trivializing something that may be very important to me. The observable effects of Newtonian mechanics and of General Relativity are not very distinguishable on a small scale such as our planet. If you do the calculations, you should get the same or similar answers. If memory serves me, for bodies in the solar system, you have to look at the Sun and Mercury to find a gravitational field SEE, SMARTASS? You ran into a problem with Newtonian Mechanics and Relativity before you got past the first flipping planet, didn't you? Wait until this gets around KU, CN, and I'm going to make it my special task to see that it does. How are you going to rebuild your credibility now? You'll rue the day that you awakened this sleeping thread, mister uppity know-it-all... sorry, the tuna thing may have me out of sorts 

CleverName --- 18 years ago -

Wait until this gets around KU I'm ruined! Please don't tell anyone. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

I'm ruined! Please don't tell anyone. It's too late, CN! This thread has already been viewed more than 120 times, although 103 of those are me thinking that I'd post a response to something and changing my mind. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

Does that make me a heretic or apostate? and besides that, you'll have to rephrase that question. The rules of the thread*, clearly state that multiple choice questions are not allowed * sent to the current occupant at your address at the time of the initiating post. 

CleverName --- 18 years ago -

I'm ruined! Please don't tell anyone. It's too late, CN! This thread has already been viewed more than 120 times, although 103 of those are me thinking that I'd post a response to something and changing my mind. That's ok. The other 17 were me trying to think of a witty retort. It looks like my secret is still safe. Does that make me a heretic or apostate? and besides that, you'll have to rephrase that question. The rules of the thread*, clearly state that multiple choice questions are not allowed * sent to the current occupant at your address at the time of the initiating post. Damn that compound question rule. You caught me on another lawyer trick. I'll get you yet! :) 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

It's too late, CN! This thread has already been viewed more than 120 times, although 103 of those are me thinking that I'd post a response to something and changing my mind. That's ok. The other 17 were me trying to think of a witty retort. It looks like my secret is still safe. Don't celebrate prematurely, wiseguy! During the SIXTEEN HOURS in which you were trying to think of a witty retort, the thread was viewed another 50 times, and I, assuming it dead, again, had ignored it. Just when you thought it was safe to go back in the welter... 

ffup --- 18 years ago -

 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

All of this rainwater is flowing away! Perhaps I was hasty in assuming the earth flat... nevermind... 

ffup --- 18 years ago -

You've a little obsession with this don't you? lol Flat or round, it's all the same to me. 

accent_ --- 18 years ago -

You've a little obsession with this don't you? Yes, of course, but I was aiming for a neurotic sort of little obsession, Woody Allenish, perhaps, though not nearly as intelligent 

ffup --- 18 years ago -

You're getting there. :) You may be tarred and feathered for it on this board though. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground