Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Age of the Earth: Science, Religion, & Perception [& the Bard of Avon briefly abused]

who's talking here?

Unichic 16
bbjones 62
Justwatching72 42
gking 1
XCPuff 4
CyberSage 2
cowboyswife 1
NoNameNoLastName 3
bluesky 2
Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen 3
ChezML 6
Clown Vomit 1
accent_ 11
Cicero 7
cyber-bullyvictim 3
haroldoftherocks 1
Meteor 2
yahootoo 2
MomofKU 1
bruiserbetty 1
ZoomZoom 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

THE AGE OF THE EARTH: SCIENCE, RELIGION, AND PERCEPTION for the Shell Distinguished Lecture Series, Shell E&P Technology Company, Bellaire Technology Center Lecture Hall, 3737 Bellaire Blvd., 10:30 AM, Thursday, May 21, 1998 by John H. Lienhard Mechanical Engineering Department University of Houston Houston, TX 77204-4792 jhl@uh.edu Geology is a huge part of your business. You have a greater intimacy with the structure of Earth's crust than any group I normally meet. So maybe it's worth our while to talk about how we formed our perception of ourselves-in-God's-universe by studying that fragile crust. Let's talk about how we calculated Earth's age and some of the stuff that went with the unfolding of revelations that followed as we pursued that calculation. The old Biblical begats first came under serious assault after medieval miners began digging deeper than they had before. The history of the age-of-the-earth question is wedded to the history of mining (which, in a sense, is your business today). The problem is, the history of mining didn't exist a century ago. We did have Georgius Agricola's marvelous book, De Re Metallica, but modern scholars didn't know how to read it. Agricola lived through the early 1500s, and his masterpiece came out just after he died in 1556. Agricola, who started out as a physician in the mining region of Bohemia, was drawn to mining and metallurgy. He gave up medicine and devoted his life to mining engineering. De Re Metallica is quite a modern book. Agricola avoided the methods of the alchemists. He wrote straightforward and accurate accounts of observed facts. He was a shrewd observer. The book was sweepingly comprehensive. It was still the bible of mining engineers on the eve of the Industrial Revolution, 200 years later. And I mean Bible. Mining-district churches chained copies to their altars. That way, the clergy could translate parts of its Latin text for the miners in their congregations. Now enter a most unexpected couple: Before President Herbert Hoover entered politics, he was the outstanding mining engineer of his time. In 1905 his wife, Lou, wrote to the Stanford Professor who'd taught geology to them both. Lou had run across a copy of De Re Metallica in London, and she wondered if there was an English translation. If there wasn't, she wanted to use her knowledge of Latin to create one. Then the fun began: Lou and Herbert Hoover undertook the job together. They worked every spare hour from 1907 until 1912. What they produced was no mere translation. Their introduction, footnotes, and appendices, by themselves, made up the first comprehensive history of mining ever written. Agricola had invented most of his Latin technical terms, and the previous German translators had butchered them. Now, with extraordinary care, the Hoovers figured out Agricola's intent. They made a whole study of Latin and Medieval units of measure. Herbert did laboratory experiments to check Agricola's statements. Together, the Hoovers took us on a guided tour through the complete mining literature before Agricola and much of what followed. These two amateur historians set down the origins of the field of mining engineering with brilliant scholarly work. This lovely book, with its 289 fine woodcuts, tells us just what mining was like and how it was done. It presents a microcosm of late Medieval and early Renaissance life. The Hoovers' work stands today as the single classic in the history of mining. Now: De Re Metallica was not a book on the secrets of nature. It was a practical tract on how to extract Earth's wealth. Agricola didn't presume to know God's intentions the way earlier writers did. Nor did he try to divine them the way philosophers would after his death. As we dug deeper into the earth, we did trip across the question of God's intentions. Earth's contents were complex and laden with riddle. For example, come forward 150 years and meet Nicolaus Steno. Steno was born in Denmark in 1638. He studied medicine and did fine anatomical work while he was young. At 27 he became physician to the Grand Duke of Florence and also converted to Catholicism. Twelve years later he became bishop to the Catholics in the Protestant North. Just after he came to Florence, he wrote a book on geology. The title was Introduction to a Dissertation on a Solid Body Contained Within a Solid. Then he joined the Church and never wrote the full dissertation. He left scholars confused. They credit him with pointing out that angles between crystal faces are constant. But that was just an offhand remark in a figure caption. Steno had really been dealing with other matters entirely. The new observational science had begun with people like Agricola. Steno was one of the new breed who brought that kind of thinking to fruition. He was fascinated by stony inclusions -- one rock inside another. And stony inclusions were raising a lot of questions about God's intentions. Steno looked at inclusions with an artist's eye. He realized that there were two entirely different kinds of inclusion. In one, a hard inner substance fills a cavity in an outer rock. In the other, the outer rock shapes itself around an inner one. Crystal inclusions and veins of metal fill rocks in. But sediment forms itself around fossils. The trouble is, no one knew about fossils in Steno's day. One inclusion looked like a seashell. Another, a vein of quartz, might be shaped like the letter Z. God had just as mystically left a seashell in one and the letter Z in another. Steno changed all that. He saw that the two things had to have been put there by different means. He saw that the image of a seashell wasn't an image at all. It was the vestige of a real shell. He saw that sedimentary rock had formed around it. So the world we knew began to change. Steno's Earth couldn't have been formed in one sidereal day. It was made by long sequences of events. We remember Steno for a chance remark about crystal angles. But his great contribution was putting us on the road to creating a history for Earth. Stephen Jay Gould laments the way we read Steno today. Twentieth-century readers miss his question: "Of the two rocks -- inner and outer -- which formed itself to the other?" We grasp for direct insights like the one about crystal angles. What Steno really gave us was a whole new way of looking at geological formation. After I recently found that the Catholic Church had declared Bishop Steno a saint, I began to wonder if they hadn't sainted him for the wrong reasons. (Certainly the crystallographers have.) But, in any case, I don't suppose that's an honor that many geologists look forward to. Of course Gould writes a lot about the great lurch in perception that stretched Earth's age from a few thousand years to several billion. He calls it the discovery of deep time. One of Gould's favorite characters was a geological theorist named Thomas Burnet, whom textbook writers have treated badly. Technical textbook writers all too often take a pretty facile view of history. It's all too easy to make yesterday look like nothing more than ignorance of today's knowledge. During Steno's lifetime -- in the 1680s -- Burnet wrote an important geological treatise. He called it Sacred Theory of the Earth. His Bible-based Earth begins as a chaotic void. He shows how it congealed into a perfect sphere -- the home of Eden. He details rational means by which the Great Flood ruined that perfect earth when it left in its wake continents, mountains, seas, and disorder. Then he predicts what will happen. At the second coming, Burnet's earth is to be burned by fire. It is to revert to spherical perfection, and it will finally be made into a star at judgment day. That's hard for us to take seriously. So we paint Burnet as a misguided biblical literalist. Writers have spoken of his "romantic and unprofitable labors," of "wild fancies that deserve to be called travesties!" One writer even said flatly that his writings were the sort of stuff we sweep out of stables. In fact, Burnet exchanged long letters with Isaac Newton. They agreed on the substance of Burnet's Sacred Theory. They argued only over details. It was Newton -- not Burnet -- who suggested that we get around logical problems by assuming that God kept changing the rules of natural law during the Creation. Burnet stayed away from that sort of thing. Here's what he said: 'Tis a dangerous thing to engage the authority of scripture in disputes about the natural world, in opposition to reason; lest time, which brings all things to light, should [reveal that what we] made scripture to assert [was false]. A new observational science had grown up around Burnet. Now scientists had to go where the non-technical language of the Old Testament was never meant to go. They had to accommodate hard observations. That's what Burnet and Newton tried to do. A century later, scientists realized that the Bible gave them a different kind of information altogether. They went on to face the fact that Earth was almost incomprehensibly old. When modern scientists finally reached that point, they overlooked the pioneering nature of Burnet's attempts to model geological time. They rewrote history to match knowledge they never had to question. We really dishonor the inventive minds of an earlier age when we forget the process it took to get us where we are. And, with that in mind, we jump forward another century. This time, meet the Scottish geologist James Hutton. He published his Theory of the Earth in 1795. In 1795 scientists were still trying to fit geological evidence into Biblical chronology. Now Hutton put forth a theory that was far less friendly to Genesis than anything science claims today. Hutton didn't extend the origins of Earth to millions or billions of years. He eliminated origins entirely. Hutton was part of a remarkable intellectual circle. He met regularly with people like Adam Smith, David Hume, and Joseph Black at Edinburgh's Oyster Club. Hutton and Black would go off together into the Scottish wilds. Black unraveled the mysteries of heat and cold in that forbidding northern land. He set the stage for the science of thermodynamics. Hutton also gazed at the Scottish glens and crags -- at the eerie world that was, even then, moving Walter Scott to write, O Caledonia! stern and wild, Meet nurse for a poetic child! What Hutton saw was evidence for his theory. He found formations he called unconformities -- substrata of rock standing at right angles to the surface strata. And those strata, in turn, were perpendicular to the next stratum below. Hutton decided that Earth had been shaped by cyclic deposits of silt, formed into rock, and followed by upheaval -- the drama repeated over and over. There is "no vestige of beginning, no prospect of an end," he said. Gould calls Hutton's earth "a machine without a history." Hutton himself likened Earth to a cyclic mechanism. So Hutton banished all history, Biblical or otherwise. Maybe he should have gone back and read Steno more carefully. He failed to see that fossils progress from one unconforming layer to the next. Hutton's prose was so turgid that he would surely have been forgotten. But he had a powerful prophet in John Playfair, another member of the Oyster Club. Playfair wrote brilliantly about Hutton's theories. He toned down the rigid claims. Playfair forged Hutton's work into a powerful influence on future geology. It was Hutton who first opened our eyes to the idea that time reaches back far beyond Biblical family trees. But he did it by echoing the Newtonian vision of a clockwork universe. Clockwork and clockwork thinking ruled science right up to the time of Hutton, and then it abruptly died. A few years later, thermodynamics would tell us that nothing can ever cycle along like that forever. Modern thermodynamics was only just taking shape under the hands of Hutton's friend Black. The Second Law of thermodynamics wouldn't mature until the 1850s, but it would bring back time's utter unidirectionality. Meanwhile, we have a facsimile set of Hutton's original watercolors at the UH Library. They show the wild, beautiful images of Scotland that fueled his vision of an eternally recurring present. When I look at those pictures I hear Walter Scott's lines: Mountains divide us, and the waste of seas ... And we in dreams behold the Hebrides! I won't try to sort through the 19th-century history of weaving fossil evidence into the issue of geological time. I'll go instead to a strange sidelight on the Alpha-Omega questions that Burnett and Hutton raised. For Gould the issue is, how did geologists come to terms with time that runs far older than the Biblical begats? By the early 1800s scientists had squared off over our ancient past. Some thought Earth had taken its shape progressively over eons. Some believed, with Hutton, that Earth is shaped by cyclic action without beginning or end. Earth is both things, says Gould. To underscore the point he shows us two strange works of art. First, the frontispiece of Thomas Burnet's book: Remember, Burnet showed Earth after each catastrophic Biblical event since the beginning. Then he closed the circle. He showed Earth going through a matching set of future events that finally return it to perfection. He endowed history with a fearful symmetry. I've already argued that Burnet was a serious scientist. He simply labored to square observation with the Biblical account. Earth evolves, he said; but it also moves in a great looping cycle. He set the stage for both parts of the debate that followed. So Gould tells about James Hampton, a barely literate janitor. God spoke to Hampton in a vision and told him to build a throne room for the Second Coming. For 33 years he did just that. Each night after work he shaped it from bits and pieces -- old furniture, light bulbs, beer cans. He saw beauty that we overlook. The world found Hampton's masterpiece when he died in 1964. It's a glittering array of symbolic furniture. One hundred and seventy-seven ornate pieces are all wrought in perfect bilateral symmetry. He poured enormous creative energy into his secret room. He transmuted junk into works of strange grace and balance. Gould first saw all this in the National Museum of American Art, and he was stunned. Hampton's throne room was just like Burnett's frontispiece. Both tell of Earth's progressive, symmetrical cycle. Hampton's pieces do tell of Alpha and Omega. He formed them in a circle that begins and ends at the top. Like Burnet, they retell the past on the right. On the left they prophesy a future that will replay past events in reverse. With eerie clarity, James Hampton saw what scientists had struggled to see ever since Burnet. He saw that events cycle in time. Things repeat. Day follows night. Nature displays symmetry. But he also saw that time is directional and irreversible. It takes us from one place to another. If science tells of reproducible, or cyclic, events, it also recites our history. It tells the story of our trek through time. Science tells of things that begin and which, someday, must also end. In any case, 19th-century Biblical scholars didn't stop using Biblical exegesis to estimate Earth's age. By 1860 a hundred or so estimates were extant. They put Earth's age anywhere from 5400 to almost 9000 years. Meantime, geologists had started insisting that Earth was, in fact, much older. But they didn't yet have any basis for making their own estimates. By now Joseph Fourier had written a theory of heat conduction. It was based on avant-garde math that not many people could accept. Then, in 1862, Lord Kelvin used Fourier's theory to calculate Earth's age. And his calculation was based on a fact that'd come out of all that mining-- all that digging into Earth's crust. Kelvin knew that Earth's temperature increases one degree Fahrenheit for each 50 feet we go into the ground. He also guessed that Earth began as molten rock at 7000 oF. He solved Fourier's equation for heat conduction into a semi-infinite region. He found that it would've taken a hundred million years for the temperature gradient at Earth's surface to flatten out at one degree every 50 feet. Now the fat was in the fire! The deeply religious and anti-evolutionist Kelvin had given an age that was far too young to satisfy geologists and Darwinists. But it was plenty old enough to waken the ire of Biblical literalists. The problem with Kelvin's estimate was that he didn't know about radioactivity. Now we know that radioactive decay sustains Earth's surface temperature gradient when simple cooling would've have made it far more flat than it is. Kelvin's cooling calculation was worthless for telling us the age of our planet. It's real value lay in the intellectual stimulus it created. The great Victorian scientists and mathematicians knew something was wrong. So they formed ranks to fight over questions of mathematical method and Biblical exegesis. The debate went on until the 20th century. It drew in Darwin, Huxley, Heaviside, and more. When they were through fighting, at least the mathematics of semi-infinite regions had found a solid footing. Today, modern chemical analysis tells us that Earth is 4½ billion years old. But the debate over Kelvin's calculation helped set up techniques that let today's students solve far nastier heat flow problems than he ever could: techniques for determining everything from how long it takes to refrigerate fruit to how to cool a brake shoe. But, in a odd way, the nub of the debate with Biblical literalists was the person of Adam. If Earth was old beyond our ability to calculate, when did Adam really enter the picture? Gould talks about the problem early artists faced when they painted Adam and Eve. Should they portray them with or without navels? Adam was molded from spit and clay and Eve from Adam's rib. Neither was born of a woman, so how could they have navels? Yet they'd look pretty silly without them. Artists often dodged the question by extending fig leaves over the lower belly. That may sound foolish, but it took on huge significance just before Darwin -- as geologists began seeing so much history written in the rocks. Navels suggested only that Adam had a history before his creation. Now geologic remains were suggesting that Earth itself existed, alive and changing, long before the Biblical creation. In 1857 a fundamentalist scientist, Philip Henry Gosse, addressed the matter. He published a great treatise: Ompholos: An Attempt to Untie the Geological Knot. (That was only two years before Darwin completely changed the conversation about Biblical literalism with his Origin of the Species.) Gould calls Gosse "the finest descriptive naturalist of his day." And Ompholos, of course, is Greek for navel. Did Adam have a navel, asked Gosse? Sure he did. Gosse went on to list other figurative navels. The teeth of an adult hippopotamus, for example, are worn down to a chisel shape. Hippos aren't born that way, but they'd be in serious trouble if they didn't get there as they matured. They wouldn't even be able to close their mouths. So did God create adult hippos with fresh unground teeth? No, of course not. Gosse looked very carefully at the fossil record, and it proclaimed a world with a very long history -- much older than hippos' teeth, much older than Adam and Eve. Gosse said that God had created a world with a built-in history -- just plopped it down, history and all. But it was history that hadn't really happened. Still, Gosse said, that history is worth studying and understanding nevertheless, because God put it there. Naturally, logic like that cooked Gosse's goose. He left us with a huge looping tautology. He really bought it when he wrote that the question of history made no practical difference. Gosse said plainly that a created world and an evolved world would both look exactly the same. When he did that, he made the scientific search for reality into a great cosmic joke. His readers filled in the obvious conclusion: It that were so, then, at best, God had deceived us. At worst, nothing was worth knowing anyway. After that, we were ready to quit messing with specious logic and to take the fossil record seriously. We were ready to allow that Adam had a navel after all, along with all his forbears. After Gosse, we were ready for Darwin. And so we learn. It's hard and it's step by step. Learning never occurs without our having to break down old knowledge in some way or another. One last story to underscore that point: This one centers on the night before Christmas Eve, 1856 -- three years before The Origin of the Species came out. Fifty-four year old Hugh Miller, an important Scottish geologist, went to his study with a blinding pain in his head and wrote an agonized letter: Dearest Lydia, -- My brain burns ... and a fearful dream rises upon me. I cannot bear the horrible thought. God ... have mercy upon me. Dearest Lydia, dear children, farewell. My brain burns as the recollection burns. My dear, dear wife, farewell. Then he shot himself. That same day he'd finished correcting proofs of his last book, The Testimony of the Rocks. That was a lovely, ponderous old work, thoughtful, well-illustrated, with paragraphs that run to five pages in length. Hugh Miller was raised in the 19th-century fundamentalism of the Scottish Presbyterian Church. He took up geology and, throughout his life, struggled with the account in Genesis. In that last book he made six epochs of the six days of Biblical creation. He detailed each one with his vast knowledge of geologic and fossil formations. It was conservative stuff by our lights: no hint of evolution and no question about the Biblical flood. Still, Miller was seen as dangerously liberal for stretching 24-hour days into geologic epochs. He studied the size of Noah's ark and decided it wasn't big enough to hold all the species. So the flood couldn't have been world-wide. He ended this ceremony of compromise by saying, "I know not of a single truth that militates against the minutest [details of Genesis]." He also said something that showed profound good sense. He said of people who "have sought to deduce from [the Bible] what it was not intended to teach -- the truths of physical science: they [fall] into extravagant error." But this night Hugh Miller suffered another attack of some terrible mental illness. He suffered soul-curdling nightmares and imagined his brain was being eaten away. So he wrote that wrenching note and shot himself. Then, with the publication of Darwin, the late-19th-century science-religion wars went into high gear, and Miller was brushed aside. Also brushed aside was creationist Hugh Miller's perfectly sane reminder that we have no business trying to turn the Bible into a science textbook. Meanwhile, all of you have played counterpoint to this. In 1829, two years before Darwin sailed on the Beagle, Kentucky petroleum went on the market as American Medicinal Oil. In 1859, two years after Hugh Miller shot himself and the same year Darwin finally published Origin of The Species, E. L. Drake drilled the first oil well off in Pennsylvania. In the first year he took 2000 barrels of oil from it. In 1869, while people were fighting over Kelvin's predicted age of the earth, America's annual oil production had quickly risen from 2000 barrels to four million barrels. In 1906, while the Hoovers were still thinking about translating Agricola, production was up to 126 million barrels. And my 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica includes lengthy articles on petroleum and petrology. No more trying to make the underground record fit one preconception or another of God's word. Now understanding the world beneath our feet was a market-driven enterprise. Now, at last, whatever truths Earth's crust held had to be dealt with at face value. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SOME SOURCES Agricola, G., de re Metallica, (tr. by Hoover, H.C. and Hoover L.H.) New York: Dover Publications, Inc., 1950. (reprint of the original 1912 edition.) Gould, S. J., Time's Arrow, Time's Cycle, Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1987. Gould, S. J., Hen's Teeth and Horse's Toes, New York: W.W. Norton and Company, 1983, Chapter 5, "The Titular Bishop of Titiopolis." By the way, Steno's actual title was De Solido intra Solidum naturaliter Contento Dissertationis Prodromus. I've translated the word "Prodromus" as "Introduction" for simplicity's sake. It is a more technical term that means something like "Introductory Discourse." Steno's book was meant to set the stage for a really heavy work. Nahin, P.J., "Kelvin's Cooling Sphere: Heat Transfer Theory in the 19th Century Debate over the Age-of-the-Earth," History of Heat Transfer: Essays in Honor of the 50th Anniversary of the ASME Heat Transfer Division, (E. T. Layton and J.H. Lien-hard, eds.) New York: ASME, 1988, pp. 65-85. Gould, S. J., The Flamingo's Smile. New York: W. W. Norton & Com-pany, 1985. Miller, H., The Testimony of the Rocks, Boston: Gould and Lincoln, 1867 (first edition, 1857.) (See also, various encyclopaedia ar-ticles on Hugh Miller. The Testimony of the Rocks was published repeatedly until 1897. A modern edition came out in 1980.)  

Meteor --- 19 years ago -

Finally, a voice of reason. From a scientist, THANK YOU. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

And it is false reasoning. 

yahootoo --- 19 years ago -

Ultimately, the age of the earth cannot be proven. Whether 6,000 years or 4.6 billion years – both viewpoints (and everything in between) rests on faith and assumptions. Those who hold to 4.6 billion years trust that methods such as radiometric dating are reliable, and that nothing has occurred in history that may have disrupted the normal decay of radio-isotopes. Those who hold to 6,000 years trust that the Bible is true, and that other factors explain the “apparent” age of the earth, such as the global flood, or God creating the universe in a state that “appears” to give it an very long age. As an example, God created Adam and Eve as fully-grown adult human beings. If a doctor were to have examined Adam and Eve on the day of their creation, the doctor would have estimated their age at 20 years (or whatever age they appeared to be) - when, in fact, Adam and Eve were less than one day old. Whatever the case, there is always good reason to trust the Word of God over the words of atheistic scientists with an evolutionary agenda. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Whatever the case, there is always good reason to trust the Word of God over the words of atheistic scientists with an evolutionary agenda. Yeah, that has done mankind GREAT so far... 

yahootoo --- 19 years ago -

Yeah, that has done mankind GREAT so far...  that is why we have free will, it's your choice to believe or not. No one said mankind is very smart. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

my point was, the people that follow the word of the god, more often than not are the ones that has helped to bring this world to the state of chaos it is in now..not completely all their doing, but a good part of it. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Evidence for a Young World by Dr. Russell Humphreys, Ph.D., Here are fourteen natural phenomena which conflict with the evolutionary idea that the universe is billions of years old. The numbers listed below in bold print (usually in the millions of years) are often maximum possible ages set by each process, not the actual ages. The numbers in italics are the ages required by evolutionary theory for each item. The point is that the maximum possible ages are always much less than the required evolutionary ages, while the Biblical age (6,000 years) always fits comfortably within the maximum possible ages. Thus, the following items are evidence against the evolutionary time scale and for the Biblical time scale. Much more young-world evidence exists, but I have chosen these items for brevity and simplicity. Some of the items on this list can be reconciled with the old-age view only by making a series of improbable and unproven assumptions; others can fit in only with a recent creation. 1. Galaxies wind themselves up too fast. The stars of our own galaxy, the Milky Way, rotate about the galactic center with different speeds, the inner ones rotating faster than the outer ones. The observed rotation speeds are so fast that if our galaxy were more than a few hundred million years old, it would be a featureless disc of stars instead of its present spiral shape.1 Yet our galaxy is supposed to be at least 10 billion years old. Evolutionists call this “the winding-up dilemma,” which they have known about for fifty years. They have devised many theories to try to explain it, each one failing after a brief period of popularity. The same “winding-up” dilemma also applies to other galaxies. For the last few decades the favored attempt to resolve the puzzle has been a complex theory called “density waves.”1 The theory has conceptual problems, has to be arbitrarily and very finely tuned, and has been called into serious question by the Hubble Space Telescope’s discovery of very detailed spiral structure in the central hub of the “Whirlpool” galaxy, M51. 2 2. Too few supernova remnants. According to astronomical observations, galaxies like our own experience about one supernova (a violently-exploding star) every 25 years. The gas and dust remnants from such explosions (like the Crab Nebula) expand outward rapidly and should remain visible for over a million years. Yet the nearby parts of our galaxy in which we could observe such gas and dust shells contain only about 200 supernova remnants. That number is consistent with only about 7,000 years worth of supernovas.3 3. Comets disintegrate too quickly. According to evolutionary theory, comets are supposed to be the same age as the solar system, about five billion years. Yet each time a comet orbits close to the sun, it loses so much of its material that it could not survive much longer than about 100,000 years. Many comets have typical ages of less than 10,000 years.4 Evolutionists explain this discrepancy by assuming that (a) comets come from an unobserved spherical “Oort cloud” well beyond the orbit of Pluto, (b) improbable gravitational interactions with infrequently passing stars often knock comets into the solar system, and (c) other improbable interactions with planets slow down the incoming comets often enough to account for the hundreds of comets observed.5 So far, none of these assumptions has been substantiated either by observations or realistic calculations. Lately, there has been much talk of the “Kuiper Belt,” a disc of supposed comet sources lying in the plane of the solar system just outside the orbit of Pluto. Some asteroid-sized bodies of ice exist in that location, but they do not solve the evolutionists’ problem, since according to evolutionary theory, the Kuiper Belt would quickly become exhausted if there were no Oort cloud to supply it. 4. Not enough mud on the sea floor. Rivers and dust storms dump mud into the sea much faster than plate tectonic subduction can remove it. Each year, water and winds erode about 20 billion tons of dirt and rock from the continents and deposit it in the ocean.6 This material accumulates as loose sediment on the hard basaltic (lava-formed) rock of the ocean floor. The average depth of all the sediment in the whole ocean is less than 400 meters.7 The main way known to remove the sediment from the ocean floor is by plate tectonic subduction. That is, sea floor slides slowly (a few cm/year) beneath the continents, taking some sediment with it. According to secular scientific literature, that process presently removes only 1 billion tons per year.7 As far as anyone knows, the other 19 billion tons per year simply accumulate. At that rate, erosion would deposit the present mass of sediment in less than 12 million years. Yet according to evolutionary theory, erosion and plate subduction have been going on as long as the oceans have existed, an alleged three billion years. If that were so, the rates above imply that the oceans would be massively choked with sediment dozens of kilometers deep. An alternative (creationist) explanation is that erosion from the waters of the Genesis flood running off the continents deposited the present amount of sediment within a short time about 5,000 years ago. 5. Not enough sodium in the sea. Every year, rivers8 and other sources9 dump over 450 million tons of sodium into the ocean. Only 27% of this sodium manages to get back out of the sea each year.9,10 As far as anyone knows, the remainder simply accumulates in the ocean. If the sea had no sodium to start with, it would have accumulated its present amount in less than 42 million years at today’s input and output rates.10 This is much less than the evolutionary age of the ocean, three billion years. The usual reply to this discrepancy is that past sodium inputs must have been less and outputs greater. However, calculations that are as generous as possible to evolutionary scenarios still give a maximum age of only 62 million years.10 Calculations11 for many other seawater elements give much younger ages for the ocean. 6. The earth’s magnetic field is decaying too fast. Electrical resistance in the earth’s core wears down the electrical current which produces the earth’s magnetic field. That causes the field to lose energy rapidly. The total energy stored in the earth’s magnetic field (“dipole” and “non-dipole”) is decreasing with a half-life of 1,465 (± 165) years.12 Evolutionary theories explaining this rapid decrease, as well as how the earth could have maintained its magnetic field for billions of years are very complex and inadequate. A much better creationist theory exists. It is straightforward, based on sound physics, and explains many features of the field: its creation, rapid reversals during the Genesis flood, surface intensity decreases and increases until the time of Christ, and a steady decay since then.13 This theory matches paleomagnetic, historic, and present data, most startlingly with evidence for rapid changes.14 The main result is that the field’s total energy (not surface intensity) has always decayed at least as fast as now. At that rate the field could not be more than 20,000 years old.15 7. Many strata are too tightly bent. In many mountainous areas, strata thousands of feet thick are bent and folded into hairpin shapes. The conventional geologic time scale says these formations were deeply buried and solidified for hundreds of millions of years before they were bent. Yet the folding occurred without cracking, with radii so small that the entire formation had to be still wet and unsolidified when the bending occurred. This implies that the folding occurred less than thousands of years after deposition.16 8. Biological material decays too fast. Natural radioactivity, mutations, and decay degrade DNA and other biological material rapidly. Measurements of the mutation rate of mitochondrial DNA recently forced researchers to revise the age of “mitochondrial Eve” from a theorized 200,000 years down to possibly as low as 6,000 years.17 DNA experts insist that DNA cannot exist in natural environments longer than 10,000 years, yet intact strands of DNA appear to have been recovered from fossils allegedly much older: Neandertal bones, insects in amber, and even from dinosaur fossils.18 Bacteria allegedly 250 million years old apparently have been revived with no DNA damage.19 Soft tissue and blood cells from a dinosaur have astonished experts.20 9. Fossil radioactivity shortens geologic “ages” to a few years. Radiohalos are rings of color formed around microscopic bits of radioactive minerals in rock crystals. They are fossil evidence of radioactive decay.21 “Squashed” Polonium-210 radiohalos indicate that Jurassic, Triassic, and Eocene formations in the Colorado plateau were deposited within months of one another, not hundreds of millions of years apart as required by the conventional time scale.22 “Orphan” Polonium-218 radiohalos, having no evidence of their mother elements, imply accelerated nuclear decay and very rapid formation of associated minerals.23,24 10. Too much helium in minerals. Uranium and thorium generate helium atoms as they decay to lead. A study published in the Journal of Geophysical Research showed that such helium produced in zircon crystals in deep, hot Precambrian granitic rock has not had time to escape.25 Though the rocks contain 1.5 billion years worth of nuclear decay products, newly-measured rates of helium loss from zircon show that the helium has been leaking for only 6,000 (± 2000) years.26 This is not only evidence for the youth of the earth, but also for episodes of greatly accelerated decay rates of long half-life nuclei within thousands of years ago, compressing radioisotope timescales enormously. 11. Too much carbon 14 in deep geologic strata. With their short 5,700-year half-life, no carbon 14 atoms should exist in any carbon older than 250,000 years. Yet it has proven impossible to find any natural source of carbon below Pleistocene (Ice Age) strata that does not contain significant amounts of carbon 14, even though such strata are supposed to be millions or billions of years old. Conventional carbon 14 laboratories have been aware of this anomaly since the early 1980s, have striven to eliminate it, and are unable to account for it. Lately the world’s best such laboratory which has learned during two decades of low-C14 measurements how not to contaminate specimens externally, under contract to creationists, confirmed such observations for coal samples and even for a dozen diamonds, which cannot be contaminated in situ with recent carbon.27 These constitute very strong evidence that the earth is only thousands, not billions, of years old. 12. Not enough Stone Age skeletons. Evolutionary anthropologists now say that Homo sapiens existed for at least 185,000 years before agriculture began,28 during which time the world population of humans was roughly constant, between one and ten million. All that time they were burying their dead, often with artifacts. By that scenario, they would have buried at least eight billion bodies.29 If the evolutionary time scale is correct, buried bones should be able to last for much longer than 200,000 years, so many of the supposed eight billion stone age skeletons should still be around (and certainly the buried artifacts). Yet only a few thousand have been found. This implies that the Stone Age was much shorter than evolutionists think, perhaps only a few hundred years in many areas. 13. Agriculture is too recent. The usual evolutionary picture has men existing as hunters and gatherers for 185,000 years during the Stone Age before discovering agriculture less than 10,000 years ago.29 Yet the archaeological evidence shows that Stone Age men were as intelligent as we are. It is very improbable that none of the eight billion people mentioned in item 12 should discover that plants grow from seeds. It is more likely that men were without agriculture for a very short time after the Flood, if at all.31 14. History is too short. According to evolutionists, Stone Age Homo sapiens existed for 190,000 years before beginning to make written records about 4,000 to 5,000 years ago. Prehistoric man built megalithic monuments, made beautiful cave paintings, and kept records of lunar phases.30 Why would he wait two thousand centuries before using the same skills to record history? The Biblical time scale is much more likely.31 References 1.Scheffler, H. and Elsasser, H., Physics of the Galaxy and Interstellar Matter, Springer-Verlag (1987) Berlin, pp. 352–353, 401–413. 2. D. Zaritsky, H-W. Rix, and M. Rieke, Inner spiral structure of the galaxy M51, Nature 364:313–315 (July 22, 1993). 3. Davies, K., Distribution of supernova remnants in the galaxy, Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Creationism, vol. II, Creation Science Fellowship (1994), Pittsburgh, PA, pp. 175–184, order from http://www.icc03.org/proceedings.htm. 4. Steidl, P. F., Planets, comets, and asteroids, Design and Origins in Astronomy, pp. 73-106, G. Mulfinger, ed., Creation Research Society Books (1983), order from http://www.creationresearch.org/. 5. Whipple, F. L., Background of modern comet theory, Nature 263:15–19 (2 September 1976). Levison, H. F. et al. See also: The mass disruption of Oort Cloud comets, Science 296:2212–2215 (21 June 2002). 6. Milliman, John D. and James P. M. Syvitski, Geomorphic/tectonic control of sediment discharge to the ocean: the importance of small mountainous rivers, The Journal of Geology, vol. 100, pp. 525–544 (1992). 7. Hay, W. W., et al., Mass/age distribution and composition of sediments on the ocean floor and the global rate of sediment subduction, Journal of Geophysical Research, 93(B12):14,933–14,940 (10 December 1988). 8. Meybeck, M., Concentrations des eaux fluviales en elements majeurs et apports en solution aux oceans, Revue de Géologie Dynamique et de Géographie Physique 21(3):215 (1979). 9. Sayles, F. L. and P. C. Mangelsdorf, Cation-exchange characteristics of Amazon River suspended sediment and its reaction with seawater, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 43:767–779 (1979). 10. Austin, S. A. and D. R. Humphreys, The sea’s missing salt: a dilemma for evolutionists, Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Creationism, vol. II, Creation Science Fellowship (1991), Pittsburgh, PA, pp. 17–33, order from http://www.icc03.org/proceedings.htm. 11. Nevins, S., [Austin, S. A.], Evolution: the oceans say no!, Impact No. 8 (Nov. 1973) Institute for Creation Research. 12. Humphreys, D. R., The earth’s magnetic field is still losing energy, Creation Research Society Quarterly, 39(1):3–13, June 2002. http://www.creationresearch.org/crsq/articles/39/39_1/GeoMag.htm. 13. Humphreys, D. R., Reversals of the earth’s magnetic field during the Genesis flood, Proceedings of the First International Conference on Creationism, vol. II, Creation Science Fellowship (1986), Pittsburgh, PA, pp. 113–126, out of print but contact http://www.icc03.org/proceedings.htm for help in locating copies. 14. Coe, R. S., M. Prévot, and P. Camps, New evidence for extraordinarily rapid change of the geomagnetic field during a reversal, Nature 374:687–92 (20 April 1995). 15. Humphreys, D. R., Physical mechanism for reversals of the earth’s magnetic field during the flood, Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Creationism, vol. II, Creation Science Fellowship (1991), Pittsburgh, PA, pp. 129–142, order from http://www.icc03.org/proceedings.htm. 16. Austin, S. A. and J. D. Morris, Tight folds and clastic dikes as evidence for rapid deposition and deformation of two very thick stratigraphic sequences, Proceedings of the First International Conference on Creationism, vol. II, Creation Science Fellowship (1986), Pittsburgh, PA, pp. 3–15, out of print, contact http://www.icc03.org/proceedings.htm for help in locating copies. 17. Gibbons A., Calibrating the mitochondrial clock, Science 279:28–29 (2 January 1998). 18. Cherfas, J., Ancient DNA: still busy after death, Science 253:1354–1356 (20 September 1991). Cano, R. J., H. N. Poinar, N. J. Pieniazek, A. Acra, and G. O. Poinar, Jr. Amplification and sequencing of DNA from a 120-135-million-year-old weevil, Nature 363:536–8 (10 June 1993). Krings, M., A. Stone, R. W. Schmitz, H. Krainitzki, M. Stoneking, and S. Pääbo, Neandertal DNA sequences and the origin of modern humans, Cell 90:19–30 (Jul 11, 1997). Lindahl, T, Unlocking nature’s ancient secrets, Nature 413:358–359 (27 September 2001). 19. Vreeland, R. H.,W. D. Rosenzweig, and D. W. Powers, Isolation of a 250 million-year-old halotolerant bacterium from a primary salt crystal, Nature 407:897–900 (19 October 2000). 20. Schweitzer, M., J. L. Wittmeyer, J. R. Horner, and J. K. Toporski, Soft-Tissue vessels and cellular preservation in Tyrannosaurus rex, Science 207:1952–1955 (25 March 2005). 21. Gentry, R. V., Radioactive halos, Annual Review of Nuclear Science 23:347–362 (1973). 22. Gentry, R. V. , W. H. Christie, D. H. Smith, J. F. Emery, S. A. Reynolds, R. Walker, S. S. Christy, and P. A. Gentry, Radiohalos in coalified wood: new evidence relating to time of uranium introduction and coalification, Science 194:315–318 (15 October 1976). 23. Gentry, R. V., Radiohalos in a radiochronological and cosmological perspective, Science 184:62–66 (5 April 1974). 24. Snelling, A. A. and M. H. Armitage, Radiohalos—a tale of three granitic plutons, Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Creationism, vol. II, Creation Science Fellowship (2003), Pittsburgh, PA, pp. 243–267, order from http://www.icc03.org/proceedings.htm. Also archived on the ICR website at ICCRADIOHALOS-AASandMA.pdf. 25. Gentry, R. V., G. L. Glish, and E. H. McBay, Differential helium retention in zircons: implications for nuclear waste containment, Geophysical Research Letters 9(10):1129–1130 (October 1982). 26. Humphreys, D. R, et al., Helium diffusion age of 6,000 years supports accelerated nuclear decay, Creation Research Society Quarterly 41(1):1–16 (June 2004). See archived article on following page of the CRS website: http://www.creationresearch.org/crsq/articles/41/41_1/Helium.htm. 27. Baumgardner, J. R., et al., Measurable 14C in fossilized organic materials: confirming the young earth creation-flood model, Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Creationism, vol. II, Creation Science Fellowship (2003), Pittsburgh, PA, pp. 127–142. Archived at http://www.icr.org/pdf/research/RATE_ICC_Baumgardner.pdf. See poster presented to American Geophysical Union, Dec. 2003, AGUC-14_Poster_Baumgardner.pdf. 28. McDougall, I., F. H. Brown, and J. G. Fleagle, Stratigraphic placement and age of modern humans from Kibish, Ethiopia, Nature 433(7027):733–736 (17 February 2005). 29. Deevey, E. S., The human population, Scientific American 203:194–204 (September 1960). 30. Marshack, A., Exploring the mind of Ice Age man, National Geographic 147:64–89 (January 1975). 31. Dritt, J. O., Man’s earliest beginnings: discrepancies in evolutionary timetables, Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Creationism, vol. II, Creation Science Fellowship (1991), Pittsburgh, PA, pp. 73–78, order from http://www.icc03.org/proceedings.htm. Additional resources for items 9–11. DeYoung, D., Thousands … Not Billions, Master Books (2005) Green Forest, AR. Vardiman, L., Snelling, A. A., and Chaffin E. F., editors, Radioisotopes and the Age of the Earth, Vol. II, Institute for Creation Research and Creation Research Society (2005) El Cajon, CA and Chino Valley, AZ. (Technical). 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

my point was, the people that follow the word of the god, more often than not are the ones that has helped to bring this world to the state of chaos it is in now..not completely all their doing, but a good part of it. Sorry JW, but that is not true. It is people who DID NOT follow the Word of God who has brought chaos to this world. 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 19 years ago -

Man, hasn't THIS topic been rehashed before several times? I think the end result was teeth gnashing, ice box puttin', name calling, non concluding, arguments. To each his own. Christians and non Christians have a hard time seeing eye to eye. Best often to go separate ways. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Sorry JW, but that is not true. It is people who DID NOT follow the Word of God who has brought chaos to this world. You can't prove that bb, just like i cannot prove my statement, they are both opinions. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

It is people who DID NOT follow the Word of God who has brought chaos to this world. Let's put things in proper perspective here. You mean people who did not follow another people's "word" of their God - according to their religious beliefs. Seems to me, the most strife, chaos and bloodshed in this world's history has not been between believers and non-believers, it has been between different factions of very passionate believers - fighting over who's "word" is THE word. Yes - I know what you would say - there's only one word, one God. Well, therein lies the rub. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

"Creation Physicist" D. Russell Humphreys, and his Questionable "Evidence for a Young World" (1485 total words in this text) (1378 Reads) Printer-friendly page David E. Thomas version of January 16, 1998 Self-styled "creation physicist" D. Russell Humphreys, an adjunct faculty member of the Institute for Creation Research, often lectures on "Evidence for a Young World" at creationist seminars and fundamentalist churches around America and the world. He claims to provide evidence that the Earth is not billions of years old, but just a few thousand years old, as required by some Biblical literalists. Humphreys says that if the universe and Earth are as old as scientists think, then spiral galaxies would be wound up into balls, there would be no comets, the sea floors would be choked with sediments, the ocean would be much saltier, and there would be billions of tombs of dead cavemen. In his lectures and brochures, Humphreys tells his audience that he will show how various processes provide maximum ages for the Earth. Some of these `maximum ages' can be as long as 100 million years, but they are invariably less than the scientifically-determined age. Humphreys claims that the true age of the Earth is set by the smallest such maximum age, which conveniently turns out to be just a few thousand years. That is, he looks at several very dubious age estimates, and declares the youngest such "estimate" to be correct. It's like looking at three estimates of the "maximum" distance from Albuquerque to Los Angeles: a thousand miles, 100 miles, and 10 feet. By Humphreys' logic, the smallest "maximum" distance (10 feet) is the best, most accurate value, because it "fits comfortably within the maximum possible" values! When Humphreys talks at churches or creationism seminars, he is introduced as a physicist at Sandia National Laboratories, a respected federal science institution. But Humphreys' conclusions on the age of the Earth are not supported by Sandia. His work in an engineering group responsible for designing bomb fuses is completely unrelated to his creationist activities. And Humphreys doesn't present his young-earth arguments to Sandia colleagues, even though many Sandia programs involve radiometric dating and the age of the Earth. In fact, when a Sandia colleague recently requested his data on problems with radiocarbon dating, Humphreys refused to supply it because it was "non-work related." Humphreys' employment at Sandia certainly does not mean that this prestigious institution endorses his radical views on the age of the Earth. Here are brief discussions of Humphreys' five favorite young-earth arguments, and of his attack on radiocarbon dating. (1) Galaxies wind themselves up too fast (maximum age: a few hundred million years). Humphreys shows off a computer simulation in which a very simple "galaxy," a line of stars about a center point, develops a spiral shape. This spiral then winds up and disappears in just a few hundred million years. In this way, Humphreys claims to "prove" that galaxies can not be billions of years old. In his super-simple simulation, however, the stars are attracted to a "galactic center" - but not to each other! As a result, more distant stars move more slowly about the "galactic center," just as planets do around our Sun. But Humphreys fails to mention that the situation in real galaxies is far more complex than this: for one, real stars attract each other with large gravitational fields. Only the outermost stars of real galaxies have the "Keplerian" orbits he assumes, while the inner stars of a galaxy can move very differently, often almost as a rigid disk. Humphreys dismisses one of the modern theories of spiral formation, "density wave theory," as too complex, but it's really his ideas that are far too simple. Humphreys' strawman galaxy does not prove that galaxies are young. (2) Comets disintegrate too quickly (maximum age: 100,000 years). Humphreys notes that comets lose some mass with every trip around the sun, claims that there is no source of new comets in the solar system, and then concludes that comet lifetimes (10 to 100 thousand years) provide an upper limit to the age of the solar system. But Humphreys' comet theory fell apart recently because a source for new comets, the Kuiper Belt (predicted by astronomer Gerard Kuiper in 1951), has been actually photographed and confirmed by several teams of astronomers. Humphreys responds to these discoveries by saying that the supposed "Kuyper Belt" [sic] doesn't help scientists because it must be supplied by the unproven Oort Cloud; and that even if what he calls the "Kuyper Belt" existed, it would exhaust itself of comets in a short time (say, a million years). But he has his astronomy backwards - the Kuiper Belt contains the remains of the "volatile" (icy) planetesimals that were left over from the formation of the solar system - numbering in the hundreds of millions. If anything, it is the Kuiper Belt that supplies the more remote Oort Cloud, as some icy chunks are occasionally flung far away by interactions with large planets. There is a source for new comets, and the fact that we still see comets does not prove the solar system is young. (3) Not enough mud on the sea floor (maximum age: 12 million years). Humphreys mentions reports that 25 billion tons of sediment erode from the continents each year, and that plate tectonic subduction removes only 1 billion tons of sediment from the ocean floor per year. He then claims that it would only take 12 million years at most for the excess 24 billion tons per year to produce the current amount of sediment - at an average depth of about 400 meters. But once again, Humphreys' model is far too simple. The depth of sediments on the ocean bottoms is not a uniform 400 meters, but varies considerably. And much sediment never gets to the oceanic floor, but is trapped instead on continental slopes and shelves, or in huge river deltas. Over the years, some of these continental slopes can accumulate several kilometers of sediment, while others can even become part of mountain ranges in continental plate-to-plate collisions. Neither erosion nor subduction are expected to be constant processes over millions of years, and they are simply not very good clocks. Humphreys' strawman ocean floor does not prove the Earth is young. (4) Not enough sodium in the sea (maximum age: 62 million years). This is another example of processes which vary greatly being used as "constant-rate" processes for dating the Earth. Humphreys finds estimates of oceanic salt accumulation and deposition that provide him the data to "set" an upper limit of 62 million years. But modern geologists do not use erratic processes like these for clocks. It's like someone noticing that (A) it's snowing at an inch per hour, (B) the snow outside is 4 feet deep, and then concluding that (C) the Earth is just 48 hours, or two days, in age. Snowfall is erratic; some snow can melt; and so on. The Earth is older than 2 days, so there must be a flaw with the "snow" dating method, just as there is with the "salt" method. (Several other creationist "proofs" of a young Earth involve similar extrapolations.) (5) Not enough stone age skeletons (Upper limit for duration of Stone Age: 500 years). Humphreys assumes that the Stone Age had a constant population of about 1 million, with 25 years average between generations. Thus, if the Stone Age lasted for 100,000 years (like those "evolutionists" think), then there should be 4,000 generations, times one million people per generation, for a total of 4 billion buried bodies to be found. Humphreys notes that only a few thousand have been found, and concludes that the actual duration of the Stone Age is only 500 years. He provides no justification for his model of grave discovery rates as a "clock." Perhaps, in a thousand centuries, some of those burial sites might just have been eroded away, or covered with tons of soil or debris. Predators or vandals might have disturbed some of the graves, and subsequent generations of cavemen may have even re-used some of the same traditional burial sites. In any event, it is clear that the number of discovered Stone Age graves does not provide a very accurate "clock" for finding the age of the Earth. Finally, Dr. Humphreys rejects scientifically-accepted methods for determination of the Earth's age, such as radioactive dating. He often shows a slide indicating that carbon-14 (C-14) radioactive dating methods are inaccurate because "the ratio of radioactive (C-14) to normal (C-12) carbon was at least 16 times smaller before the flood [of Noah]," and therefore that "Evolutionists overestimate C-14 ages." Humphreys' statement on carbon ratios is based on a short piece in the journal Nature (C. J. Yapp and H. Poths, Vol 355, p. 342, 23 Jan. 1992), which refers to a 16-fold increase in atmospheric carbon in rocks from the Ordovician Period. These rocks are actually about 440 million years old. Now, the relatively rapid decay of carbon-14 prevents its use as a clock on anything older than about 50,000 years. Using C-14 to find the age of a rock which is millions of years old is a lot like trying to look at Mars with a microscope instead of a telescope; it's simply not the right tool for the job. Humphreys has presented this "analysis" of radiocarbon dating for years, even though he cannot point to even one age estimate which has been incorrect because of the "pre-flood" carbon dioxide levels. Humphreys creates a slick, scientific-sounding argument for a "young" Earth, but in the process seriously misrepresents modern consensus. All serious dating methods (radiometric age dating, dendrochronology, ice core analysis, varve deposition, and more) yield ages far older than Humphreys' methods. D. Russell Humphreys breaks all the rules of science. He uses flawed logic, overly simple models, and twisted data to sell his young Earth. Caveat Emptor! 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Finally, a voice of reason. From a scientist, THANK YOU. The science is there. Don't let the smoke blowers get you down. 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 19 years ago -

Either way, for the earth, life begins at 40 million. I just don't know why someone doesn't put a sign in a yard on Earth day reading: Over The Hill, By 4.6 Bill. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Evidence for a Young World by Dr. Russell Humphreys, Ph.D., Yeah , and this nutcase claims that he has successfully developed a new solution to Einstein's equation of general relativity to prove creationism. LOLOLOLOL. ROTF Laughing Our ass off. Next time BBJ, please quote someone reputable. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

To each his own. Christians and non Christians have a hard time seeing eye to eye. Best often to go separate ways. But it does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods or no God. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg. -Thomas Jefferson, Notes on Virginia, 1782 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

The error is in the accusation that this debate is Christian vs non-Christion, religious vs non-religious. The science is not in conflict with Christianity, religion, or the Bible, and those claiming such a conflict don't represent all, of either view. 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 19 years ago -

The error is in the accusation that this debate is Christian vs non-Christion, religious vs non-religious. The science is not in conflict with Christianity, religion, or the Bible, and those claiming such a conflict don't represent all, of either view. May be true, but guess where THIS thread is headed. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

You can't prove that bb, just like i cannot prove my statement, they are both opinions. Yes, I can prove it. Just look at any group or person that has caused chaos in the world and they WERE NOT following the Word of God. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

May be true, but guess where THIS thread is headed. Most of the usual suspects have arrived on the crime scene, quantity and length of posts is increasing. There is a certain sado-masochistic aspect to it all, isn't there? But think of the profound effect that what happens on this thread will have on our sleep this night and our labors tomorrow... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

D. Russell Humphreys breaks all the rules of science. He uses flawed logic, overly simple models, and twisted data to sell his young Earth. Caveat Emptor! No, he does not. It is his detractors who do that. Who is David E. Thomas? Not a PhD physicist like D. Russell Humphreys. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Yeah , and this nutcase claims that he has successfully developed a new solution to Einstein's equation of general relativity to prove creationism. How would you know Chez? You would not recognize whether he had or not. He has a PhD in physics from LSU. Do you? LOLOLOLOL. LOL. There you are with that stupid echo again. Next time BBJ, please quote someone reputable. Hahahahahahahahaha!!! How would you know what or who is reputable? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Most of the usual suspects have arrived on the crime scene, That is because the usual crime was committed by the original posting of nonsense written by a Mechanical Engineer. Of course, he would know more about physics than a PhD. Physicist. 

Meteor --- 19 years ago -

The guy's a quack. If it walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck..well, you get the picture. Well, the rest of us do. Quack, quack. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The guy's a quack. If it walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck..well, you get the picture. Well, the rest of us do. Quack, quack. Is that why you are quacking? 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

If it walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck Yes, most of the usual suspects have arrived on the scene, and, suddenly, the first evidence of fowl play... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

When Humphreys talks at churches or creationism seminars, he is introduced as a physicist at Sandia National Laboratories, a respected federal science institution. But Humphreys' conclusions on the age of the Earth are not supported by Sandia. He never claimed that it did. Finally, Dr. Humphreys rejects scientifically-accepted methods for determination of the Earth's age, such as radioactive dating. He often shows a slide indicating that carbon-14 (C-14) radioactive dating methods are inaccurate because "the ratio of radioactive (C-14) to normal (C-12) carbon was at least 16 times smaller before the flood [of Noah]," and therefore that "Evolutionists overestimate C-14 ages." Humphreys' statement on carbon ratios is based on a short piece in the journal Nature (C. J. Yapp and H. Poths, Vol 355, p. 342, 23 Jan. 1992), which refers to a 16-fold increase in atmospheric carbon in rocks from the Ordovician Period. These rocks are actually about 440 million years old. Now, the relatively rapid decay of carbon-14 prevents its use as a clock on anything older than about 50,000 years. Using C-14 to find the age of a rock which is millions of years old is a lot like trying to look at Mars with a microscope instead of a telescope; it's simply not the right tool for the job. Humphreys has presented this "analysis" of radiocarbon dating for years, even though he cannot point to even one age estimate which has been incorrect because of the "pre-flood" carbon dioxide levels. JW, that statement by David E. Thomas is one big lie. I have read what Humphrey's says about radiocarbon dating, and Thomas is confusing radiocarbon dating with radiometric dating. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Yeah , and this nutcase claims that he has successfully developed a new solution to Einstein's equation of general relativity to prove creationism. Next time BBJ, please quote someone reputable. Look at his credentials and then look at Thomas' credentials. Looks like it is pretty obvious that Humphrey's credentials in radioactive materials are MUCH more reputable than Thomas' are. I am sure that he has forgotten more than you will ever know. The guy's a quack If he's a quack, what does that make you? D. Russell Humphreys Award-winning physicist, involved in physics research and development in geophysics, optics, nuclear physics, high energy physics, electricity, magnetism, and theoretical physics B.S. in Physics from Duke University Ph.D. in Physics from Louisiana State University. His dissertation: cosmic rays and ultrahigh energy nucleon-nucleon interactions. Worked six years for General Electric in the High Voltage Laboratory where he received a US patent and one of Industrial Research Magazine's IR-100 awards. He received another US patent and two awards from Sandia, including an Award for excellence for contributions to light ion-fusion target theory. Former researcher at Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, New Mexico starting in 1979 - in nuclear physics, geophysics, pulsed power research, theoretical atomic and nuclear physics, and the Particle Beam Fusion Project Helped design particle accelerators used in fusion energy and Strategic Defense research. Co-inventor of laser-triggered "Rimfire" high-voltage switches. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

D. Russell Humphreys Co-inventor of laser-triggered "Rimfire" high-voltage switches. The thread is temporarily diverted to a discussion of what one of the parties cited plans to have inscribed on his tombstone 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

I know bb, you are right no matter how much proof is shoved in your face. ( i do love how you skipped over other aspects of what he said, what about the other types of dating bb? dendrochronology, ice core analysis, varve deposition those are all wrong to i suppose.) have a good nite. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I know bb, you are right no matter how much proof is shoved in your face. What proof JW? I could say the same thing about you now couldn't I. i do love how you skipped over other aspects of what he said I did not skip over anything. I just am not going to take the time to refute every point that Thomas made. It would take too long. I have already spent a lot of time discussing the "other" types of dating. The bottom line is, any of the radiometric dating processes are flawed without reference points and you cannot have reference points without someone being there to record them. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

who was thereto see the things written in your book bb? thats right, inspired by an imaginary friend... What proof JW? you dont show me proof bb, your entire belief system is based on FAITH that there is a god, you have NO PROOF god exists.. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I think the end result was teeth gnashing, ice box puttin', name calling, non concluding, arguments. We few, we happy few, we band of brothers; For he to-day that types his posts with me Shall be my brother; be he ne'er so vile, This day shall gentle his condition; And gentlemen in Kingwood now-a-bed Shall think themselves accurs'd they were not here, And hold their manhoods cheap whiles any types That posted with us upon this Sunday [apologies to the Bard, but: Hey! He'd understand.] [and I worried that the "And gentlemen... now-a-bed... Shall... hold their manhoods cheap... " bit might mean what it sounds like it means and get the topic flagged as dangerous or get me iceboxed or both, but I decided to live dangerously this once and throw caution to the wind.] 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

any of the radiometric dating processes are flawed without reference points and you cannot have reference points without someone being there to record them. what the hell are you talking about? out of three dating process i mentioned at least two of them do not use radiometric dating...nice try...do your research next time before you go spouting off.. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

you dont show me proof bb, your entire belief system is based on FAITH that there is a god, you have NO PROOF god exists.. JW, you know I love ya..... The BIBLE is our proof. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

I know cbw, and like i said before, if i am refuting he bible, you cannot use the bible to prove the bible is true, that's called circular reasoning and it doesn't play out. It's not proof....it's faith. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Often those with little education often believe anything which is written by someone with a doctorate must be true. Because of their lack of knowledge and understanding of the subject material at hand, and/or because of their need on a psychological level to reinforce their beliefs, they try to pass the information of as fact to the rest of us, witness tonight. A simple background check by BBJ of Humphreys who have shown that the claims of this so called scientist been disavowed by 32 of his Sandia colleagues. They also state that Humphreys has never even attempted to publish any evidence contrary to the prevailing views on radiometric dating, and that Humphries admitted in an e0mail that he had not published his rejection of radiometric dating methods because he had not even analyzed them. Furtheremore, Humphreys is no longer employed at Sandia. He’s now 'retired' ;-) 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

you dont show me proof bb, Regardless of whether you believe in God or not, I have shown you plenty of scientific proof that the world is not billions of years old. Nothing that I posted had any reference to the Bible. what the hell are you talking about? out of three dating process i mentioned at least two of them do not use radiometric dating...nice try...do your research next time before you go spouting off.. I specifically did not mention the other methods of dating because Thomas' statement about them is false. Tree ring dating and varve deposition, yield ages that are only in the thousands of years. Ice core dating has just as many assumptions as radiometric dating - one of the methods uses radioactive isotopes which would put it in the category of radiometric dating. Maybe you should take some time to research those methods before you believe their writings. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Often those with little education often believe anything which is written by someone with a doctorate must be true. Because of their lack of knowledge and understanding of the subject material at hand, and/or because of their need on a psychological level to reinforce their beliefs, they try to pass the information of as fact to the rest of us, witness tonight. Chez, that statement you made describes you to a tea. How nice of you to post autobiographical material about yourself. It is very certain that you lack knowledge and understanding of the subject material at hand, otherwise, you would not make the ridiculous comments that you make as proved by the statements made in your post. The same request that I made earlier goes out to you pertaining to your understanding of radiometric dating. Please show us how much you think you know by explaining how radiometric dating works. Explain to us how you would determine the age of a rock using radiometric dating without making any assumptions. By the way, there are many writings by people with a doctorate that I do not agree with, specifically because I do have knowledge pertaining to this subject. Another ridiculous claim made by you. A simple background check by BBJ of Humphreys who have shown that the claims of this so called scientist been disavowed by 32 of his Sandia colleagues. They also state that Humphreys has never even attempted to publish any evidence contrary to the prevailing views on radiometric dating, and that Humphries admitted in an e0mail that he had not published his rejection of radiometric dating methods because he had not even analyzed them. Talk about not knowing the subject material. A simple check by Chez would have revealed that the letter signed by his 32 colleagues DID NOT disavow Humphreys' work, in fact, the letter had nothing to do with D. Russell Humphreys. Their letter was in response to a letter written to Skeptical Inquirer where the writer referred to Bishop Ussher's proclamation that the Earth was six thousand years old. The letter writer asserted that "many top scientists agree with Ussher, including many of the top scientists at Sandia Labs." Chez also forgot to mention that Sandia's workforce of 7,540 includes 1,350 technical staff members with PhDs. So clearly, 32 members is not a very large percentage of Humphreys' colleagues. Additionally, it is very clear that you either do not even take the time to read what you are trying to post a rebuttal to, or you just do not comprehend what you read. Not one of D. Russell Humphreys' fourteen natural phenomena, which conflict with the evolutionary idea that the universe is billions of years old posted on this thread, had anything to do with radiometric dating. Furtheremore, Humphreys is no longer employed at Sandia. He’s now 'retired' ;-) Really? Don't you think that when I posted "Former researcher at Sandia National Laboratories" that the word "former" just might be a tip off that he no longer works there? Again, just another indication that either you do not read what is posted or you do not comprehend what you read. 

page 1 2 3 4 5
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground