Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should law enforcement be confronted when they break the law?

who's talking here?

Keystone 4
JDB2 1
hdavidson 1
Fancy 1
Justwatching72 5
Sandyr9111 1
likeke27 3
jimmy 1
Joybell 1
ChezML 1
Mr Mark 5
proudmomoftwo 2
irt339 1
Cicero 10
Strait♥lover 1
CleverName 3
Duke 2
txdaddy 3
Vedette 1
WHO'syourdaddy 5
get_the_lead_out! 2
Spartacus 1
carmineskeeper 1
partyboy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should law enforcement be confronted when they break the law?

I have a great deal of respect for all law enforcement. Sherriffs, H.P.D. State Troopers. No exceptions to the men and women that protect us. Thank you for your service. However when I see law enforcement commiting a minor traffic violation I am compelled to confront and question autority. This morning I saw a Sherriff's truck enter the H.O.V. I got close enough to see this person was alone. As my temper was climing I got ready to pass on the ramp entering the H.O.V. As I made my pass I saw the sherriff was in fact alone. I held up one(index)finger and then two, as if the sherriff could read my sign language. To the confusion of the sherriff the window went down. She was good lookin, down right pretty. Just the same I shouted.Isnt there supposed to be two people in there? Are you above the law? She just dismissed me w/ a passing wave of her hand. So I am inclined to ask my fellow Houstonians What do you think?

Yes law enforcement should be held to the same traffic standards as all of us. Vote
 
 89.1% (41)
No. law enforcement does not deserve special privalge when it comes to traffic violations, H.O.V. occupancy. Vote
 
 10.9% (5)
Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

I have a great deal of respect for all law enforcement. Sherriffs, H.P.D. State Troopers. No exceptions to the men and women that protect us. Thank you for your service. However when I see law enforcement commiting a minor traffic violation I am compelled to confront and question autority. This morning I saw a Sherriff's truck enter the H.O.V. I got close enough to see this person was alone. As my temper was climing I got ready to pass on the ramp entering the H.O.V. As I made my pass I saw the sherriff was in fact alone. I held up one(index)finger and then two, as if the sherriff could read my sign language. To the confusion of the sherriff the window went down. She was good lookin, down right pretty. Just the same I shouted.Isnt there supposed to be two people in there? Are you above the law? She just dismissed me w/ a passing wave of her hand. So I am inclined to ask my fellow Houstonians What do you think? 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

both answers are the same 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

metro cops are allowed touse the hov lane with only one person in the car. 

Strait♥lover --- 19 years ago -

yes yes yes yes 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

Your right. damn... ok. 2nd question is supposed to read law enforcement deserves special privalages. Thanks likeke27 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

OF course they should get special traffic treatment.. They are enforcing TRAFFIC laws...in order to enforce them they may have to circumvent those laws in order to uphold them. No biggie...so what if they use the HOV lane or don't use a turn signal..They put their life on the line every time the pull someone over. So what if they get a fringe traffic benefit or two. (She rolled down the window and smiled at ya, that was your opening to ask her out for a cup o' joe') ;-) 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

I think they should wear seatbelts, use turn signals, get off their cell phones when driving....when I grew up you respected any officer of the law. Sometimes I think they forget that the uniform isn't supposed to be what is respected, but the person in the uniform. We all know you have to earn respect but I'm afraid things have changed. 

Vedette --- 19 years ago -

I agree with JW. If she was checking the HOV lane for some reason, she shouldn't be required to drag someone else with her. Except for the turn signal thing. Everyone *should* use their turn signal. Although I'm not sure people around here actually know how to operate theirs... 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Only METRO enforces laws on the HOV lane. The Sheriff's dept. has no business on the HOV lane. If they were enforcing traffic laws then they would need to be on the main lanes where 99.9% of the violations are occurring. I take the HOV everyday on the MC. I've seen plenty of off-duty cops driving solo. Some Sheriffs cars too. The badge doesn't raise you above the law. If anything they should be setting an example and following the laws to the 'T'. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

What ticks me off is when the I see sheriffs or constables turn their lights on to get through a light and as soon as they make it past the light, they shut theirs off! Almost got hit once because the lead cop didn't turn his lights on when he was coming towards me and I was making a left hand turn and I had the green light. I saw two constable cars coming at me a little too fast so I stopped before the turn and the first one went right through the light and the second constable turned his lights on for about 3 seconds to go through the light. PO'd me just a little bit!! 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

The badge doesn't raise you above the law. Of course it does...it has always been this way...why change now? 

WHO'syourdaddy --- 19 years ago -

For petes sake it just the HOV lane. As for cop cars running lights, i believe cops respond to calls 3 different ways CODE 1,2, or 3 Code 1 is lights and sirens at 100mph Code 2 is hurry and get there maybe use lights and siren to get around traffic Code 3 take your damn time, hours sometimes 

partyboy --- 19 years ago -

of course they should be confronted, unless its me in my cop outfit! 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

For petes sake it just the HOV lane. Its not so much the H.O.V. as much as it is; law enforcement has a duty to the people. When a law enforcement offical dis-respects the law, what does that say about the law? That duty is not upheld to the standard that I am held to account to. Of course it does...it has always been this way...why change now? If not now, when? What line will have to be crossed b4 you say something to the contrary of what your saying now? 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

What line will have to be crossed b4 you say something to the contrary of what your saying now? None, all the lines have already been crossed in the past by crooked cops, murder, fraud, rape, abuse... why would it change now? And no, one person CANNOT make a difference. This is just the way it has and always will be with people in positions of power. There is ALWAYS corruption, otherwise it would not be called POWER, it would be called something else. 

WHO'syourdaddy --- 19 years ago -

you should of forced her off the road and TASERED THAT ASS 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

W.Y.D. She was in a truck... Im on a bike. She has a gun........ Im on a bike. She can call back up. Im on a bike. I confronted her. w.w.y.d. 

WHO'syourdaddy --- 19 years ago -

I drove a fire truck last night and got to break all kinds of laws twice. Man it was fun 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

I confronted her. w.w.y.d. Asked her out.... 

WHO'syourdaddy --- 19 years ago -

i would have gave her my "O" face lol 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

Asked her out.... J.W. You need a date huh? 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Need a date no..but c'mon, a hot woman, in a cop uniform..From what I recall you are single...if it was me I would have gotten over the frustration of her HOV debacle and asked her out, especially if she rolled down the window and smiled at ya. But that's just me. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

And no, one person CANNOT make a difference. Not neccesarily true. Filing complaints with the PD actually does work. Even if your complaint cannot be substantiated it goes in the officer's file. 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

OK, is it me or are the two choices basically the same??? 

Keystone --- 19 years ago -

ALL law enforcement officials are allowed to use the HOV lane. DH is a police officer (non-uniform) and works for DA's office. He uses the HOV alone every day. Quite legal. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

ALL law enforcement officials are allowed to use the HOV lane. Not exactly true. They must be in a marked vehicle with rooftop lights. If your DH is using the HOV lane in a vehicle that does not meet these requirements then he's breaking the law. http://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/exemptvehicleshov/chapter4.htm 

Fancy --- 19 years ago -

They take the HOV lane to go to the downtown jail and couthouses. This cop may have had to appear in court, or whatever, they are allowed to use it. Even if it wasn't for anything important, and we don't know that, I would consider it a job perk and forget about it. 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

Code 1 is lights and sirens at 100mph Code 2 is hurry and get there maybe use lights and siren to get around traffic Code 3 take your damn time, hours sometimes Actually this is backwards. Code 3 is running hot with lights and siren. And to be quite honest it is against the law to run lights and no siren. Learned that in EMT school many years ago. Alot of them do it but they arent supposed too. 

WHO'syourdaddy --- 19 years ago -

sorry your right it is against the texas state law to run lights with no siren, however you are wrong about a code 1 call. It is the priority call for HPD and has lights and sirens. Code3 or priority 3 calls are taken as needed 

Duke --- 19 years ago -

What about instead of getting all in a fret over this and recommending filing complaints on officers, why not contact the police department and arrange for a ride-along with an officer. Get in the car with one of those guys and see firsthand what they get to deal with. I think it will change your mind. Try doing that balancing act of getting to a call and dealing with traffic. You can wait it out or try and get through traffic in order to get to the call a little quicker, knowing that folks are waiting for you to arrive in order to provide the service that has been requested. It can be an interesting ordeal. Of course folks always want to know what took you so long to get there. 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

Of course they can skirt traffic laws, kinda hard to chatch someone if you can only do 55.... I have bigger things to worry about.. I may be partial, I have police officers in my family so I know the kind of crap they deal with. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

Before running off and confronting an officer, make sure he really did violate the law. Emergency service vehicles and police vehicles are exempt from the High Occupancy Vehicle passenger requirements can use a high occupancy vehicle lane with only one officer. See Tex. Transp. Code § 224.1542. The exemption does not limit police vehicles to marked vehicles or vehicles with lights. See id. Likewise, those lawfully operating authorized emergency vehicles may (1) park or stand, irrespective of another provision of the Texas Transportation Code or any city or county ordinance, (2) proceed past a red or stop signal or stop sign, after slowing as necessary for safe operation, (3) exceed a maximum speed limit, except as provided by an ordinance adopted under Texas Transportation Code § 545.365 regulating emergency meducal service vehicles and ambulances NOT responding to emergency calls, blood and tissue bank vehicles, as long as the operator does not endanger life or property, or (4) disregard a regulation governing the direction of movement or turning in specified directions. Id. § 546.001. This traffic law exemption (not the HOV exemption which is unlimited) applies when responding to emergency calls, id. § 546.002(b)(1), pursuing an actual or suspected violator of the law, id. § 546.002(b)(2), responding to but not returning from a fire alarm, id. § 546.002(b)(3), directing or diverting traffic for public safety purposes, id. § 546.002(b)(4), or conducting a police escort, id. § 546.002(b)(5). Police vehicles are not required to have their sirens or lights on when relying on the traffic law exception (such as speeding or running red lights) in certain circumstances when responding to emergency calls. See id. § 546.004(c). 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

What about instead of getting all in a fret over this and recommending filing complaints on officers, why not contact the police department and arrange for a ride-along with an officer. Get in the car with one of those guys and see firsthand what they get to deal with. I think it will change your mind. I am of the mindset - if a cop is behind me, let them by. They're working; I'm greatful. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

I am of the mindset - if a cop is behind me, let them by. They're working; I'm greatful. Definitely true for me also. 

Joybell --- 19 years ago -

Hey Cicero, by the way - the US Department of Transportation site does not contain statute (law) - just guidelines (that's why the guide you cited did not contain a legal citation referring to the U.S. Code). These cops are NOT breaking the law. There have been memos put out to the law enforcement agencies in the area by Metro stating the same. As long as they are in their department vehicle (marked or not) it is allowed. And CleverName has got it right. 

Spartacus --- 19 years ago -

The police have my total respect. If they want to be in the HOV lane, no problem. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

These cops are NOT breaking the law. I emailed a cop that I know. This is the response that I got: '(The exception to single occupants includes on-duty law enforcement vehicles; METRO/TxDOT operational or maintenance vehicles; and motorcycles.' If a cop is driving TO work in his POV, solo, on the HOV, then he's breaking the law. Here's the statute: § 224.1542. POLICE AND EMERGENCY VEHICLES. A restriction imposed on a restricted lane under this subchapter does not apply to a police vehicle or an authorized emergency vehicle as defined by Section 541.201 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

"If a cop is driving TO work in his POV, solo, on the HOV, then he's breaking the law. Here's the statute: § 224.1542. POLICE AND EMERGENCY VEHICLES. A restriction imposed on a restricted lane under this subchapter does not apply to a police vehicle or an authorized emergency vehicle as defined by Section 541.201" What in § 224.1542 says the officer has to be on duty? I agree that the officer needs to be in a police vehicle. I was responding to a post that said: "They must be in a marked vehicle with rooftop lights. If your DH is using the HOV lane in a vehicle that does not meet these requirements then he's breaking the law." Police vehicles don't have to be marked. See Tex. Transp. Code § 721.005(a)(1), (b)(1). Likewise, they don't even have to have "exempt" plates. See id. § 501.159. Most are marked and have exempt plates, but technically, one could drive an unmarked alias car on the HOV and still have a defense to the HOV ticket. For that matter, even if a peace officer is not on his shift, he is still a peace officer. In fact, one of the reasons that peace officers are allowed to drive marked patrol cars home is because they can intervene when an offense is committed in their presence, even if they are "off duty." In fact, for sheriffs, constables, city police officers and DA/county attorney investigators, they don't even have to be in their employers' jurisdictions if the offense is not a traffic offense. See Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 14.03(g). A city officer can even respond to traffic offenses outside of his city provided he is within a county in which the city is situated. See id. art. 14.03(g)(2). So when exactly is a police officer off duty? If Officer Friendly is driving home from his shift and spots a drunk driving down the road does he stop him or let the drunk kill someone because he is off duty? The Code of Criminal Procedure makes no distinction whether the officer clocked out for he day. He still has a duty to pull the guy over. 

Duke --- 19 years ago -

Go do a ride-along and quit bickering about it. See what the real deal is. Become involved. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

What in § 224.1542 says the officer has to be on duty? It explicitly states 'Police Vehicle'. This is the State Law. Whether or not HPD/METRO policy has extended that law to 'On-Duty only', I don't know. I'm going by what the officer told me in his email not an assumption based on something that I found on the internet. You know what 'off-duty' means. No need to waste bandwidth. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground