Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Tell Congress To Pass the Birthright Citizenship Act

who's talking here?

MissT 3
bbjones 29
Sandyr9111 1
Anderson 4
lilmommy 2
NoNameNoLastName 1
Vicman 1
stacy99 3
ChezML 8
accent_ 14
irt339 4
Lynn 2
CleverName 23
lifeisgood 2
ZITA 3
Louisiana Proud 1
Meteor 2
~peanut~ 5
the dog 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

It's time to push for some SERIOUS reform -- starting with ending the abuse of the 14th Amendment to the Constitution that is currently being used to allow children of illegal aliens to be born American citizens. Present U.S. anchor baby "policy" is an abuse of the 14th Amendment. This amendment was ratified in 1868 to protect the civil rights of native-born black Americans, who had recently been freed from slavery and whose rights were being denied. The clear, original intent of the 14th Amendment was spelled out in 1866 by Senator Jacob Howard, co-author of its citizenship clause, who wrote "Every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons." Thankfully, we now have the chance to put a stop to that. Rep. Nathan Deal (R-GA), has introduced H.R. 1940, the "Birthright Citizenship Act," to end the practice of abuse of birthright citizenship. It currently has 57 cosponsors -- but it needs a LOT more to pass! To Take Action Go Here 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

This definitely needs to be enforced properly. I sent emails on both. Hopefully it will do some good. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

"Every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons." I think you highlighted the wrong part: "Every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I think you highlighted the wrong part: I think you highlighted the wrong part: "Every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States..." by P.A. Madison "Sen. Trumbull and Sen. Howard then settled upon a construction for “subject to the jurisdiction thereof,” with Trumbull declaring: The provision is, that 'all persons born in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens.' That means 'subject to the complete jurisdiction thereof.' What do we mean by 'complete jurisdiction thereof?' Not owing allegiance to anybody else. That is what it means. Sen. Trumbull further added, “It cannot be said of any Indian who owes allegiance, partial allegiance if you please, to some other Government that he is 'subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.'” Sen. Jacob Howard agreed: [I] concur entirely with the honorable Senator from Illinois [Trumbull], in holding that the word "jurisdiction," as here employed, ought to be construed so as to imply a full and complete jurisdiction on the part of the United States, whether exercised by Congress, by the executive, or by the judicial department; that is to say, the same jurisdiction in extent and quality as applies to every citizen of the United States now. The above statements by Howard and Trumbull give us a good idea of what “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” as employed under the Fourteenth Amendment means: Absence of owing any allegiance to any other foreign power, which in return allows the United States to exercise full and complete jurisdiction over the person. To understand how an alien might not owe allegiance to some other sovereignty upon arrival to this country, one need to look no further then the naturalization laws of the United States. Under United States law, an alien was required to make a declaration of his intention to become a citizen, and renounce all allegiance to his former government two years before he could make a final application. Therefore, it does not require a leap of faith to understand what persons, other than citizens themselves, under the Fourteenth Amendment are citizens of the United States by birth: Those aliens who have come with the intent to become U.S. citizens, who had first compiled with the laws of naturalization in declaring their intent and renounce all prior allegiances. Sen. Trumbull further restates the the goal of the language: "It is only those persons who come completely within our jurisdiction, who are subject to our laws, that we think of making citizens..." He could only be referring to the laws of naturalization and consent to expatriation by the immigrant in order for him to come completely within the jurisdiction of the United States and its laws, i.e., he cannot be a subject of another nation. A citizen owes the same quality of allegiance to their nation of origin as does their country's ambassador and foreign ministers while within the limits of another nation unless they freely decide to renounce their allegiance in accordance to law. In other words, it would be preposterous to consider under the meaning given to “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” that a French subject visiting the United States was not a subject of France, but completely subject to the will of the United States while within the limits of the nation without first consenting to expatriation." 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

A statute does not trump the plain meaning of a provision in the Constitution. You can't go to legislative history for original intent when the plain meaning is clear from the text. What part of "[a]ll persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside" is ambiguous? Jurisdiction? Are you really claiming that if an illegal alien stabs me, in Texas, the State of Texas has no jurisdiction to prosecute him? Are you claiming my personal injury suit against an illegal alien who stabs me in Texas could not be heard because the Texas court would not have jurisdiction over an alien living here illegally? How would the United States have less jurisdiction over a child born in the United States living here than an alien illegally living here? Come on, people, the Fourteenth Amendment is clear on this point. If you have a problem with it, amend the Constitution; don't pass unconstitutional acts which will only be overturned. This issue was settled in 1898. See United States v. Wong Kim Ark, 169 U.S. 649 (1898). 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

You can't go to legislative history for original intent That is what the Supreme Court does when reviewing constitutionality. Jurisdiction? Are you really claiming that if an illegal alien stabs me, in Texas, the State of Texas has no jurisdiction to prosecute him? Are you serious? There is a BIG difference between the requirements for citizenship and the prosecution of criminal activity. 

Louisiana Proud --- 19 years ago -

Just like everything else. We have an EXISTING law not being enforced to the letter and looholed to death. What makes ANYONE think that a new law would be enforced. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Come on, people, the Fourteenth Amendment is clear on this point. If you have a problem with it, amend the Constitution; don't pass unconstitutional acts which will only be overturned. IMO, the Fourteenth Amendment is probably one of the most important of the Constitution. It has been instrumental in making sure that all people who are born here --no matter to whom – share the same equal rights. It prevents any group from being disenfranchised. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

What makes ANYONE think that a new law would be enforced. This proposed law is clearly unconstitutional. As Clevername pointed out, the illegality was settled over one hundred years ago. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

The intent of the "Birthright Citizenship Act" is to restore the same sort of discrimination that the 14th Amendment was enacted to eliminate. It is promoted for precisely the same reasons that the 14th Amendment was originally opposed. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

Isn't birthright citizenship the same in most countries? My oldest dd was born in another country, and she is a citizen of both USA and where she was born. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Isn't birthright citizenship the same in most countries? My oldest dd was born in another country, and she is a citizen of both USA and where she was born. No, it varies from country to country. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Some 380,000 children are born in the United States each year to illegal-alien mothers, according to U.S. Census data. A large portion of those births are illegitimate...which means the mother collects all sorts of tax payer funded programs. Illegitimacy and Immigration Study 2007 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Out of the 194 countries in the WORLD, the following allow for automatic citizenship upon birth regardless of parents status...I only found the follwing: Argentina Barbados Brazil Canada Colombia Jamaica Mexico Pakistan Peru Romania United States Uruguay 

irt339 --- 19 years ago -

So what's your point other than to lament? Legislation in violation of the 14th Amendment has been unconstitutional for a century. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Com'on....like the constitution can't be changed?? It's always changing to fit the "times". 

irt339 --- 19 years ago -

You need a HS government class if you believe that to be the case. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

Out of the 194 countries in the WORLD, the following allow for automatic citizenship upon birth regardless of parents status...I only found the follwing: Argentina Barbados Brazil Canada Colombia Jamaica Mexico Pakistan Peru Romania United States Uruguay Obviously an incomplete list since Costa Rica is not even listed. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

IMO, the Fourteenth Amendment is probably one of the most important of the Constitution. It has been instrumental in making sure that all people who are born here --no matter to whom – share the same equal rights. It prevents any group from being disenfranchised. "The phrase "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" was intended to exclude from automatic citizenship American-born persons whose allegiance to the United States was not complete. In the case of illegal aliens who are temporarily or unlawfully in the United States, because their native country has a claim of allegiance on the child, the completeness of the allegiance to the United States is impaired and logically precludes automatic citizenship." Why does the United States continue to allow a practice subject to widespread abuse? The answer lies in how American courts have interpreted the 14th Amendment to the Constitution. The 14th Amendment was added to the Constitution as part of the post-Civil War reforms aimed at addressing injustices to African Americans. It states that "all persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof are citizens of the United States" and was crafted so that state governments could never deny citizenship to blacks born in the United States. But at the time, the United States had no immigration policy, and thus the authors saw no need to state that explicitly. That is why the Birthright Citizenship Act needs to be passed. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

This issue was settled in 1898. See United States v. Wong Kim Ark, 169 U.S. 649 (1898). This proposed law is clearly African-Americunconstitutional. As Clevername pointed out, the illegality was settled over one hundred years ago. Maybe someone should do a little research first. "In United States v. Wong Kim Ark, 169 U.S. 649 (1898), the Supreme Court extended (re-affirmed) U.S. jurisdiction to include all aliens LAWFULLY residing within the United States, who were not explicitly protected from its jurisdiction by treaty." Notice the word LAWFULLY. That WOULD NOT include ILLEGAL aliens. "There have been several subsequent cases involving the citizenship status of people born to aliens legally within the United States, but the Supreme Court has never explicitly ruled whether or not the Fourteenth Amendment grants children of illegal immigrants automatic citizenship. The actual application of Wong Kim Ark to the domestically born children of illegal aliens originates from the use of birth certificates as proof of citizenship." The 14th Amendment was only meant to apply to any person of African ancestry in the wake of the Civil War. The Dred Scott case of 1857 had ruled that blacks at that time, whether slave or free, were not citizens of the United States. The 14th Amendment basically overturned that Supreme Court ruling. It was never meant to extend citizenship to every person born in the United States. That is why Indians were made citizens in the 1920s by an act of Congress. They were born here, but yet they were not citizens. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

bb, when you quote me, use the complete sentence. I said "[y]ou can't go to legislative history for original intent when the plain meaning is clear from the text." Cutting out the phrase "when the plain meaning is clear from the text" completely changes the meaining of the sentence and does violence to the thought I was expressing. Of course you can go to the legislative intent when the passage is ambiguous. I just argue that the actual words of section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment are not ambiguous. It says "[a]ll persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside." I find it interesting that the conservatives who are advocating the Birthright Citizenship Act are essentially hijacking a tactic used by liberals in the 1970's, judicial activism. Some want to rewrite the constitution to create some "double double secret" jurisdiction for the Fourteenth Amendment only which applies to the children born of citizens, as if the United States is impotent to regulate or control infants born in its borders to aliens. bb, you go even further when you state "The 14th Amendment was only meant to apply to any person of African ancestry in the wake of the Civil War. The Dred Scott case of 1857 had ruled that blacks at that time, whether slave or free, were not citizens of the United States. The 14th Amendment basically overturned that Supreme Court ruling. It was never meant to extend citizenship to every person born in the United States. That is why Indians were made citizens in the 1920s by an act of Congress. They were born here, but yet they were not citizens." Where does the text talk about blacks? So let me get this straight. The Fourteenth Amendment applies only to blacks? White babies have no citizenship absent some benevolent grant from Congress? You know, your Native American argument might be compelling save one forgotten fact. The United States negotiated treaties with the Native American nations. Of course, the United States promptly ignored the treates and violated them, yet there were treaties on the books which excluded Native Americans from the jurisdiction of the United States and allowed their nations to remain sovereign within our borders had the United States had the honor of following the treaty terms (other than the ones which benefited the United States). By the 1920's, Congress accepted the reality, in part at least, that we had violated our treaties and extended citizenship to Native Americans regardless of unhonored treaty provisions. So lets take this a step further. How is my white daughter a citizen? She was born here. Are you saying that absent some provision in the Immigration and Nationality Act, the government could exclude her from citizenship because she is white? bb, to my jurisdiction question, you said, "Are you serious? There is a BIG difference between the requirements for citizenship and the prosecution of criminal activity." [notice the complete quotation, without truncation :) ] Yes, I am serious. If we have the power to incarcerate or execute someone, they are subject to our jursidiction, unless you are making the farcical argument that the United States should not have the power to punish crimes within its borders. (Of course, we have tripple secret jurisdiction in Guantanamo ;) Finally, exactly how is a child (not the child's parents) born inside the United States committing a crime? What crime did the infant commit? Give me a US Code citation, please. I am curious. Even more puzzling, what crime did a child conceived in the United States commit? Anyone? Anyone? Beuller? Beuller? My point here is not whether immigration is bad or whether we should amend the Constitution to prevent "anchor babies." I am just saying, we need to "dance with the one that brung us." Our Constitution is clear on this issue. Engaging in syllogistic original intent semantics to get around a provision we find inconvenient is an end run around our freedoms. When you chip away at freedoms you might be next. Just wait until President Hillary Clinton decides the patriot act allows her to surveil churches as hate terrorist groups. Then you might not be so quick to gut the plain meaning of the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

bb, when you quote me, use the complete sentence. I said "[y]ou can't go to legislative history for original intent when the plain meaning is clear from the text." Cutting out the phrase "when the plain meaning is clear from the text" completely changes the meaining of the sentence and does violence to the thought I was expressing. I did not include it because it was not pertinent to my point and because I do not always include the whole quote since the person that wrote it knows what they posted. There IS controversy over this, so apparently the meaning IS NOT clear. You should ALWAYS go to the legislative history to determine intent whenever there is controversy over the meaning of a law or statute. Where does the text talk about blacks? It does not specifically state that it was only for blacks, but that was the reason it was written. That is why you have to go to the legislative history to determine the reason for the law. Yes, I am serious. If we have the power to incarcerate or execute someone, they are subject to our jursidiction, unless you are making the farcical argument that the United States should not have the power to punish crimes within its borders. The United States ONLY has jurisdiction over that person WHEN he/she violates our laws. Finally, exactly how is a child (not the child's parents) born inside the United States committing a crime? The parents are committing a crime by being here illegally, therefore, the children are part of the crime by proxy. The children are here illegally also and should not be GIVEN citizenship. They should have the same citizenship of their parents who have jurisdiction over them. The 14th amendment to the Constitution was written to ensure that the children of former slaves would be given automatic U.S. citizenship upon birth and to provide automatic citizenship of children of LEGAL immigrants. There are no children of former slaves living in the United States today, therfore the 14th amendment now only applies to children of LEGAL immigrants. While LEGAL immigrants were pursuing naturalization, it allowed them to start having a family without placing upon them the burden of naturalizing their children as well. Its intent was not to allow someone to illegally step across the border and give birth to an "American Citizen". LEGAL immigrants are those aliens who have come with the intent to become U.S. citizens, who had first compiled with the laws of naturalization in declaring their intent and renounce all prior allegiances. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

I did not include it because it was not pertinent to my point and because I do not always include the whole quote since the person that wrote it knows what they posted. Yes, it was pertinent. The point was that legislative history is not appropriate HERE IN THIS INSTANCE because the clause is clear. You falsely made it appear I said that legislative history was never appropriate. Can I at least get an agreement that I limited the prior statement to ambiguous language? It does not specifically state that it was only for blacks, but that was the reason it was written. That is why you have to go to the legislative history to determine the reason for the law. You did not answer my question. Do you apply the Fourteenth Amendment only to blacks? Is my white daughter a citizen only by the benign grace of Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reed? bbjones wrote: The United States ONLY has jurisdiction over that person WHEN he/she violates our laws. Actually no. In fact, you might be committing a crime in violation of 26 U.S.C. §§ 7201, 7202, 7203, if you actually were advocating that statement. You statement could be encouraging people to refuse to file their income tax returns or pay their income tax if they are here illegally. I think you will find that the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, is quite clear that non-citizens present in the United States for more than 183 days out of the year ARE subject to the taxation of their world-wide income tax from whatever source derived, regardless of whether they are legal or illegal aliens. Now that's what I call jurisdiction. Surely you don't suggest that the United States only has jurisdiction to tax an alien "WHEN he/she violates our laws." The United States has jurisdiction over anyone within its territory unless there is a specific treaty excluding jurisdiction, such as the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations (1961), 500 U.N.T.S. 95, with respect to diplomatic immunity. Of course, I know you did not mean to violate the Federal criminal tax law. Accordingly, for the Internal Revenue Special Agents who may be monitoring this board under the Patriot Act, bb does NOT advocate illegal aliens shirking their income tax liablity or obligations to file returns. The parents are committing a crime by being here illegally, therefore, the children are part of the crime by proxy. The children are here illegally also and should not be GIVEN citizenship. They should have the same citizenship of their parents who have jurisdiction over them. Objection, non-responsive. You have failed to cite a single statute under which a jury could legally convict the infant. The reason is because the infant has committed no crime. The infant did not voluntarily move across the border (assuming conception happened outside the United States; your argument is even weaker for children of illegal aliens conceived within the United States). In the United States, we have no "crimes by proxy," whatever that means. You can't punish someone because their parents did something. The infant has no duty to supervise and control his parent. Congress cannot impose a crime of "failing to compel his parents to leave the United States" on a 1 day old baby. What you are trying to do is create a status crime of which to covict the baby. Status crimes are unconstitutionally cruel and unusual. See Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962). Unlike the jurisdictional argument you are making concerning citizenship, due process rights (and thus the right to be free from crimes of cruel and unusual punishment) attach to anyone within the borders of the United States, regardless of their citizenship. U.S. Const. Amend. XIV, § 1, s. 2, cl. 2 ("nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law"). You cannot create a cruel and unusual crime in violation of the Eighth Amendment specifically to apply to infants born to illegal aliens in the United States without violating the infant's due process rights. Citizenship is irrelevant for due process purposes. So creating a new crime to make the infant illegal as well will not work. Of course this entire discussion of why a crime applicable to infants of illegal aliens is academic. THERE IS NO CRIME OF WHICH THE INFANT IS GUILTY. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Excellent post explaining the legal aspects CN! 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

I got to ask, what does NFNNLN mean? My daughter (who is a citizen by the benign benevolence of Congress) is not old enough to explain the internet to me. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Citizenship is irrelevant for due process purposes. So creating a new crime to make the infant illegal as well will not work. Now, if we can only convince the Defense and Justice Departments to uphold the Constitution, there might be some trials for some folks who have been held for awhile and who have been denied due process. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

Oh, I forgot the last paragraph from bb. LEGAL immigrants are those aliens who have come with the intent to become U.S. citizens, who had first compiled with the laws of naturalization in declaring their intent and renounce all prior allegiances. Actually legal immigrants can be permanent residents without declaring their intent to renounce all prior allegiances. The oath to "absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereignty of whom or which [the immigrant] have heretofore been a subject or citizen" comes in the oath of citizenship at the end of the process to become a citizen, not the beginning of the process to become a permanent resident. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

I got to ask, what does NFNNLN mean? My mistake. I got you confused with the other person NoFirstNameNoLastName. I fixed it ;-) 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The point was that legislative history is not appropriate HERE IN THIS INSTANCE because the clause is clear. Apparently the clause is not clear because YOU do not understand it. You did not answer my question. Do you apply the Fourteenth Amendment only to blacks? Is my white daughter a citizen only by the benign grace of Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reed? Yes, I did answer your question. Just read what I posted. Did I not post "The 14th amendment to the Constitution was written to ensure that the children of former slaves would be given automatic U.S. citizenship upon birth and to provide automatic citizenship of children of LEGAL immigrants." For the children of former slaves AND LEGAL immigrants. Your question about your white child was ridiculous and you know it. White children born to citizens of the U.S. were already considered to be citizens. That is WHY the 14th amendment was needed - so that black children and children of LEGAL immigrants would have citizenship rights like white children had. Actually no. In fact, you might be committing a crime in violation of 26 U.S.C. §§ 7201, 7202, 7203, if you actually were advocating that statement. Actually YES! The United States ONLY has jurisdiction over that person WHEN he/she violates our laws. Now pay attention here. When a person is ILLEGALLY here, then they have already violated our laws and, therefore, are under the jurisdiction of the United States. BUT, this jurisdiction DOES NOT meet the requirements of of the 14th admendment BECAUSE coming here ILLEGALLY does not meet requirements of the naturalization laws of the United States. To become a naturalized citizen of the United States, a person has to enter the United States LEGALLY, having made a declaration of his intention to become a citizen, and renounce all allegiance to his former government two years before he could make a final application. Tax laws are not applicable here. Objection, non-responsive. You have failed to cite a single statute under which a jury could legally convict the infant. The reason is because the infant has committed no crime. Again, you either did not read what I wrote or you just did not understand. Where did I say that the baby had committed a crime that they would be found guilty of? I WROTE that the parents committed the crime and that the child was a part of that crime by proxy. A proxy is a person authorized to act for another. Wouldn't you say that a parent has authorization to act for their children? Regardless of how you feel about that, and no matter HOW the child arrived here, the children are here ILLEGALLY and should not be GIVEN citizenship. I DID NOT SAY THAT THERE WAS A CRIME THAT THE CHILD WAS GUILTY OF INTENTIONALLY COMMITTING, BUT ONCE THEY ARE BORN, THEY ARE HERE ILLEGALLY ACCORDING TO THE 14TH ADMENDMENT. Actually legal immigrants can be permanent residents without declaring their intent to renounce all prior allegiances. Premanent residency and citizenship ARE TWO DIFFERENT THINGS. You can be a permanent resident of the United States and NEVER become a naturalized citizen. The 14th admendment DOES NOT apply to permanent residency. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Excellent post explaining the legal aspects CN! You are as confused about that as you are about the identity of the poster. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Any legislation passed along these lines would be declared unconstitutional so it's a moot point. If you want to take citizenship away from the children of illegals, then you're going to have to amend the Constitution. This is what the Fourteenth Amendment states: Section. 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.  

the dog --- 19 years ago -

i think we need to attend to our "own" u.s. citizens born here and "legally" here. we need to stop all the "panty a** liberal attitudes toward illegal aliens! they need to bild that wall asap and make it not 15 ft high but 25 ft high with barbed wire and a 30,000 volt cable on top. sorry but i have no respect nor pity for illegal aliens. remember the alamo!!! if you know anything about it!! 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Any legislation passed along these lines would be declared unconstitutional so it's a moot point. If you want to take citizenship away from the children of illegals, then you're going to have to amend the Constitution. Not if you follow the 14th amendment as written. "All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof" "That means 'subject to the complete jurisdiction thereof.' What do we mean by 'complete jurisdiction thereof?' Not owing allegiance to anybody else. That is what it means." Those words came from one of the authors of the 14th amendment. Do you think that you know more than he did about the INTENT and the MEANINGS of the statutes within? 

Meteor --- 19 years ago -

So lets take this a step further. How is my white daughter a citizen? She was born here. Are you saying that absent some provision in the Immigration and Nationality Act, the government could exclude her from citizenship Can you imagine being born here, living here all your life, going to high school and college here, serving in the army, then getting married and starting a family of your own. Then all of a sudden you find out you're not really a citizen because one or both of your parents weren't here legally? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Can you imagine being born here, living here all your life, going to high school and college here, serving in the army, then getting married and starting a family of your own. Then all of a sudden you find out you're not really a citizen because one or both of your parents weren't here legally? It would be a shame that the parents did not tell the child the truth. 

Lynn --- 19 years ago -

No presidential candidate can truthfully say he cares about low taxes, welfare reform, improving education, reducing the federal deficit, and solving problems of healthcare and Social Security if he does not support banning automatic citizenship for children of illegal immigrants. Everything associated with illegal immigration including birthright citizenship goes against conservative values of being tough on crime, fiscally responsible, protecting America’s sovereignty, keeping taxes low and the bureaucracy in tow. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

I'm done with this thread as CleverName has explained it exceptionally well. Besides, it's a non-issue. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I'm done with this thread as CleverName has explained it exceptionally well. You're done with this thread because you cannot refute the truth. 

ZITA --- 19 years ago -

You're done with this thread because you cannot refute the truth. Always the loud mouth bully, eh SportyNuts. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

You're done with this thread because you cannot refute the truth. You're done to a crisp - stick a fork in it time -- because you have posted nothing other than your opinion. If you want to be taken seriously, then cite the case law. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground