Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Limpbaugh's "Phony Soldiers" Slur

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 1
JDB2 3
bbjones 28
GHYC 5
croxt 1
Hardshell 1
qpc 1
NoNameNoLastName 1
Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen 1
BaylorMom 5
ChezML 9
accent_ 22
Jasmine 1
WHO'syourdaddy 1
Meteor 1
bruiserbetty 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Limbaugh's "Phony Soldiers" Slur Joe Conason Thu Oct 4, 3:00 AM ET The controversy over what Rush Limbaugh meant when he uttered the phrase "phony soldiers" last week isn't just another broadcast sideshow. As the political power of conservatism declines, the symbolic authority of figures such as Limbaugh is likewise shrinking. That is why he backs away from his own words, rips them from context by selectively editing his program's transcript, and insists he didn't demean soldiers and veterans who dissent from the Bush White House war policy — as he and his fellow partisans have done so many times before. This revealing episode began on Sept. 26 during a conversation between Limbaugh and "Mike," a caller who identified himself as an active-duty soldier and supporter of the Iraq war, who warned against the consequences of withdrawing U.S. troops "because Iraq itself would collapse and we'd have to go right back over there within a year or so." At that point the host interjected, "There's a lot more than that that they don't understand. They can't even — if — the next guy that calls here, I'm gonna ask him: Why should we pull — what is the imperative for pulling out? What's in it for the United States to pull out? . . . I don't think they have an answer for that other than, 'Well, we just gotta bring the troops home. Save the — keep the troops safe,' or whatever. It's not possible, intellectually, to follow these people." Replied Mike, "No, it's not, and what's really funny is, they never talk to real soldiers. They like to pull these soldiers that come up out of the blue and talk to the media." Limbaugh agreed: "The phony soldiers." Two days later, under heavy critical fire for using those words, he claimed to be the victim of a "smear." He served up a neatly trimmed transcript of the Sept. 26 program, omitting more than a minute and a half to make it seem as if his "phony soldiers" reference was intended solely for an anti-war activist who had allegedly masqueraded as an Army vet. That falsified transcript has provided fodder for Limbaugh's defenders, a motley assortment of bloggers, Fox News personalities, and a Republican congressman from Georgia who has actually introduced a resolution commending him. Not content with insulting the troops, the Limbaugh clones seem to think any soldier who examines the transcript will be too dumb to figure out how they have tampered with it. It is equally telling that both he and his defenders change the original phrase "phony soldiers" and say "phony soldier" instead — because the plural belies his alibi and emphasizes his nasty intention. While today he whines because Media Matters for America, the progressive watchdog group, caught and publicized his slur, he cannot escape what the audio proves. Only in a media environment where conservatives have long felt exempt from scrutiny would Limbaugh still feel free to mock the military service of those who disagree with him. He is, after all, a certified chicken-hawk who cheered on the Vietnam War as it ground up tens of thousands of young Americans, but saw no reason why he should serve. His local draft board in a Missouri county, where his family enjoyed political influence, granted him a 1-Y deferment after he dropped out of college and forfeited his student deferment. Explaining how he escaped the draft, he has cited both a "bad knee" and a cyst on his backside that supposedly rendered him medically unfit. Despite that undistinguished record, however, he has never hesitated to denigrate the service of Sen. John Kerry, former Sen. Tom Daschle and other Democrats who volunteered to wear the nation's uniform. He spent hours repeating the "Swift boat" lies when Kerry ran for president in 2004. And now he insinuates that the troops and vets who question this war are "phony soldiers." What really worries Limbaugh and his right-wing comrades is that more and more of those who bravely serve America abroad, from foot soldiers to flag officers, have begun to voice their anger at the reckless policies that have cost them so dearly. Leaders of VoteVets, a group of Iraq and Afghanistan veterans organized in support of smarter security policy, have angrily challenged Limbaugh to repeat his slur to their faces — something he is most unlikely to do. Thanks to all the veterans with the courage to speak out — no matter what their opinion — it is no longer so easy for the Limbaugh crowd to claim the military and the flag as their exclusive property. That illegitimate seizure of everyone's patriotic heritage is coming to an ignominious end. Joe Conason writes for the New York Observer (www.observer.com). To find out more about Joe Conason, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com. COPYRIGHT 2007 CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

He was actually specifically referring to Jesse MacBeth, a war critic who falsely claimed to be an Iraq veteran. His previous dialogs before the call in question had been about Mr. MacBeth, who made up all sorts of lies about what he expeirenced in Iraq, the cruelties that the troops were committing, etc and he had never even served in Iraq. He flunked out of boot camp. It was Mr. MacBeth and those like him that Limbaugh was referring to. It's fine if you don't like what Rush has to say, but at least listen to what he REALLY said before criticizing it. In this case, it WAS taken totally out of context. The guy really WAS a "phony soldier". Media Matters omits that fact. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

He was actually specifically referring to Jesse MacBeth, a war critic who falsely claimed to be an Iraq veteran. His previous dialogs before the call in question had been about Mr. MacBeth, who made up all sorts of lies about what he expeirenced in Iraq, the cruelties that the troops were committing, etc and he had never even served in Iraq. He flunked out of boot camp. Actually, Rush came up with that story on a show a week later. During the September 26 broadcast, Limbaugh discussed with a caller a conversation he had with a previous caller, "Mike from Chicago," who said he "used to be military," and "believe[s] that we should pull out of Iraq." The second caller, whom Limbaugh identified as "Mike, this one from Olympia, Washington," asserted that he had "a retort to Mike in Chicago, because I am a serving American military, in the Army." Here is a transcript from that show: The actual conversation went as follows: LIMBAUGH: Another Mike, this one in Olympia, Washington. Welcome to the EIB Network. Hello. CALLER: Hi Rush, thanks for taking my call. LIMBAUGH: You bet. CALLER: I have a retort to Mike in Chicago, because I am a serving American military, in the Army. I've been serving for 14 years, very proudly. LIMBAUGH: Thank you, sir. CALLER: And, you know, I'm one of the few that joined the Army to serve my country, I'm proud to say, not for the money or anything like that. What I would like to retort to is that, if we pull -- what these people don't understand is if we pull out of Iraq right now, which is about impossible because of all the stuff that's over there, it'd take us at least a year to pull everything back out of Iraq, then Iraq itself would collapse, and we'd have to go right back over there within a year or so. And - LIMBAUGH: There's a lot more than that that they don't understand. They can't even -- if -- the next guy that calls here, I'm gonna ask him: Why should we pull -- what is the imperative for pulling out? What's in it for the United States to pull out? They can't -- I don't think they have an answer for that other than, "Well, we just gotta bring the troops home." CALLER: Yeah, and, you know what - LIMBAUGH: "Save the -- keep the troops safe" or whatever. I -- it's not possible, intellectually, to follow these people. CALLER: No, it's not, and what's really funny is, they never talk to real soldiers. They like to pull these soldiers that come up out of the blue and talk to the media. LIMBAUGH: The phony soldiers. CALLER: The phony soldiers. If you talk to a real soldier, they are proud to serve. They want to be over in Iraq. They understand their sacrifice, and they're willing to sacrifice for their country. LIMBAUGH: They joined to be in Iraq. They joined -- 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Not content with insulting the troops, the Limbaugh clones seem to think any soldier who examines the transcript will be too dumb to figure out how they have tampered with it. It is equally telling that both he and his defenders change the original phrase "phony soldiers" and say "phony soldier" instead — because the plural belies his alibi and emphasizes his nasty intention. Rush spoke on Hannity and Colmes. "COLMES: Let me talk to you for a second about the phony soldiers comment, because those who criticize you have pointed out you said "soldier-s" plural. And then when you played it back a couple of days later, you edited out about a minute and 35 seconds of time. So it wasn't clear initially you were talking about one particular soldier. RUSH: I did not edit -- here's what we edited out, for the purposes of my Web site. You know, Alan, "Brevity is the soul of wit." That is what Shakespeare said. The second caller, after discussing the phony soldiers, went into a discussion of weapons of mass destruction. At the time he's doing that, I am talking to my producer on the other side of the glass of the IFB, I'm saying, "Find the commentary I did yesterday morning on Jesse MacBeth," who, by the way, whose birth name is Jesse Al-Zaid. Find me that commentary. This guy is going on. He's got diarrhea of the mouth about weapons of mass destruction. I'm asking people to find this commentary so I can illustrate what I mean by phony soldiers. We edited -- that was about a minute and a half, or a minute and 45. When we put the transcript up -- and I finally told this guy, I said (summarized), "Look, weapons of mass destruction is a moot point now. Whether they're there or weren't there, it's not relevant because the situation in Iraq has gone way beyond that." We just edited that out. It had nothing to do -- there was nothing hidden. There was nothing I was trying to cover up. You've got to stop listening to these partisans and these propagandists at Media Matters for America. They are nothing but a bunch of hacks who are producing the primetime at MSNBC. If they ever went dark, Media Matters, MSNBC would have nothing to say. They do -- Alan, you have a radio show, and I have a radio show. You have a website. I have a website. All you have to do is turn on the radio to listen to each of us, or go to our websites. The Drive-By Media does not listen to my show, does not go to my website. They take for granted whatever Media Matters says about what I said is true. It is irresponsible. It's journalistic malpractice, and it's silly. We edited that out simply for the sake of brevity and to stay on point. When we got to the -- when I found the commentary, when they printed it out to my printer behind me, that's when I got rid of the call, and that's when I started in repeating the commentary on Jesse MacBeth that I had aired the previous morning." Rush Limbaugh's ORIGINAL comments regarding the "phony soldier" (Jesse MacBeth). This was the original posting (his "Morning Update" which airs on radio stations the morning of Sept 25th). A follow-up discussion on-air with listenners has generated significant media hype, with accusations of Rush holding soldiers on contempt. Read the full transcript of the two phone calls that pertained to the "phony soldiers" comment here. I am sure the soldiers will be "smart" enough to know what was being discussed. It is equally telling that both he and his defenders change the original phrase "phony soldiers" and say "phony soldier" instead — because the plural belies his alibi and emphasizes his nasty intention. Rush's Use of "Soldier(s)," Not "Soldier" Rush responds by citing the US Attorney's Office Western District of Washington's "Operation Stolen Valor" targeted multiple "phony" soldiers like Jesse MacBeth. Rush posts video of the ABC News report "Phony Heroes." He also cites the liberal New Republic's "Baghdad Diarist," anti-war soldier Pvt. Scott Thomas Beauchamp, who "signed a sworn statement admitting that all three articles he published in the New Republic were exaggerations and falsehoods." 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

It's fine if you don't like what Rush has to say, but at least listen to what he REALLY said before criticizing it. In this case, it WAS taken totally out of context. The guy really WAS a "phony soldier". Media Matters omits that fact. I was listening to Limbaugh on the days in question [I'm a masochist, have listened to him since the very early 90s] and, no, his "phony soldiers" remark was clearly more general, but his loyal listeners and fans prefer to believe his heavily edited transcript. But, then, Limbaugh frequently omits the facts. MacBeth was a convenient nail on which Limbaugh could try to hang his slur. Had Limbaugh originally intended to refer only to MacBeth, I wouldn't fault him, as MacBeth has clearly misrepresented his own service, made himself vulnerable. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

rushlimbaugh.com is hardly the best source for the facts in this. That site would be as self-serving as Limpbaugh's loyal listeners are unwilling to expose themselves to the facts 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

but his loyal listeners and fans prefer to believe his heavily edited transcript. What was "heavily edited" from his transcript? rushlimbaugh.com is hardly the best source for the facts in this. That site would be as self-serving as Limpbaugh's loyal listeners are unwilling to expose themselves to the facts The full "unedited" programs are located there. What better place to get to the truth than to hear the "entire" broadcast. 

WHO'syourdaddy --- 19 years ago -

hey bb Jesus says hi 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

Welcome back bbj! Oh and Rush is an idiot. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Rush is an idiot. But, at least, he's a well medicated idiot. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Actually, Rush came up with that story on a show a week later. Actually, your timeline is incorrect. The broadcast was on September 26, 2007 and Rush responded on September 28, 2007 to the lies that were being told on September 27, 2007. From September 28, 2007, Rush Limbaugh respondes to the smear tactics of the Left regarding phony soldiers: In what universe does two days equal one week? 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

But, at least, he's a well medicated idiot.  LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yes, he has good health insurance! ;) He can afford to be. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

CALLER: No, it's not, and what's really funny is, they never talk to real soldiers. They like to pull these soldiers that come up out of the blue and talk to the media. LIMBAUGH: The phony soldiers.  

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

But, at least, he's a well medicated idiot. When you are in pain, do you take medication? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The phony soldiers. He is correct, there are phony soldiers. They are the "soldiers" that the liberal media display, not the "real" soldiers that the caller refered to. Rush responds by citing the US Attorney's Office Western District of Washington's "Operation Stolen Valor" targeted multiple "phony" soldiers like Jesse MacBeth. Rush posts video of the ABC News report "Phony Heroes." He also cites the liberal New Republic's "Baghdad Diarist," anti-war soldier Pvt. Scott Thomas Beauchamp, who "signed a sworn statement admitting that all three articles he published in the New Republic were exaggerations and falsehoods." 

Meteor --- 19 years ago -

Rush said he would have served in 'Nam but he had an anal cyst. Wait a minute - he is an anal cyst. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Rush has such staunch defenders on KU! I only regret that they are cluttering up the thread with images of Limpbaugh, who, for good reasons, confines himself to radio 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I only regret that they are cluttering up the thread with images of Limpbaugh, who, for good reasons, confines himself to radio Rush does not confine himself to radio. He makes TV and public appearances. Do you? 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

But, at least, he's a well medicated idiot. Hillbilly heroin, and least anyone forget, also a Viagra smuggler ;-) 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

... and Limpbaugh's staunchest defenders on KU seem to be among BushCheney's staunchest defenders on KU . If Limpbaugh, by his own accounting this very day, has about 22 million listeners, many of whom probably buy into his line, and if that line, with few exceptions, coincides with BushCheney's line, and if many of those listener/supporters happen also to be voters, then is it any wonder that we find ourselves overextended and underrespected in the world and in greater debt, with less to show for it at home? I've always resisted buying into the mind-numbed robots accusation, but I can understand, especially this evening, why some have made it. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

also a Viagra smuggler ;-) When you are in pain, Chez, do you not take medication? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

This thread reminds me of a book. "If Democrats Had Any Brains, They'd Be Republicans" 

Jasmine --- 19 years ago -

"If Democrats Had Any Brains, They'd Be Republicans" I concur. 

bruiserbetty --- 19 years ago -

That is not nice. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

also a Viagra smuggler Rush Limbaugh was not smuggling Viagra. It belonged to him and the prescription was in his doctor's name - a common practice among many well known celebrities. But of course, some people do not want to know the truth. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

That is not nice. It's a cruel thread, bb, with no winners, only bearers of scars, visible and invisible. If you value your sanity, you'll leave while you still can! 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

not smuggling Viagra. It belonged to him He was in pain and was taking medication. 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

"If Democrats Had Any Brains, They'd Be Republicans"  I don't think anyone one who is a Democrat, Republican or Independent would appreciate you ongoing attacks of a group of people who vote Democrat. How can you call an entire group of people lacking in brains, just because they don't vote like you. To judge an entire group of people is not only wrong, but not very Christian. Your words are not always as Christian you claim to profess so often on KU. Maybe you need to practice what you preach. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

How can you call an entire group of people lacking in brains, just because they don't vote like you. Are you serious? All I wrote was "This thread reminds me of a book". Then I quoted the title of a book that I did not write. If you will look at what I wrote, I was not speaking about an individual person, unlike some others, I was speaking about this thread. Let's talk about being Christian. It is not wrong to judge people who clearly indicate who they are, nor are Christians commanded not to judge. By the way, who was it that wrote "Oh and Rush is an idiot." I do practice what I preach. I judge by what the Bible tells us is wrong. That is how a Christian is to judge. That is what a Christian is called to do. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

He was in pain and was taking medication. Typical liberal spin of taking words out of context unless, of course, you think that Viagra is pain medication. 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

I said do not judge entire groups of people, calling one person an idiot is not the same. Are you serious? Darn skippy I'm am you are judging an entire group of people, by the innuendo of a title of that book. And it's not like this is the first time you have attacked this group. Now your trying to spin your way out of it. Good night 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

you are judging an entire group of people, by the innuendo of a title of that book It is a good thing that you are a mind reader. You are the only one doing the spinning here. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

you are judging an entire group of people, by the innuendo of a title of that book. And it's not like this is the first time you have attacked this group. It looks like to me that you, Chez and especially accent were doing the heavy attacking on this thread. 

Shutterman 7.5 + Keygen --- 19 years ago -

As a former serviceman, let's first dispense with violently and vehemently defending the term "Phony Soldier". Here we go with a public outcry and outrage over a misused and out of context group of words. But let's get to a realness... There is a minority of "phony soldiers" who whisper under their breath how they would be eager to leave their post to return home and be ripped out of the nightmare of war. It's a reality. I even whispered that to myself during the Gulf War many times. Was I a phony soldier? At times yes. Holistically, no. *However, these servicemen earn their right to choose how they feel about war so I don't undermine their emotional latitudes. War is Hell. Phony soldier or not. Second, I support the servicemen around the globe. It's not their fault gutless turds called politicians can't get things on the right track. I'm a Republican but am inclined now to think outside the box. What the media portrays is NOT THE TRUTH. And the servicemen are not the "phony soldiers" the media cattle herds to skew a story. It's the media's fault. Politics are Hell. Thirdly, I used to be a newscast director for a small market tv station. The media lies and spins stories. Truth is boring. Spinning is exciting and increases ratings. You wouldn't believe what some news directors tell their reporters to do. The "story" you see on air (4-5 minutes) does not come close to the bigger picture. However, the honest reporters bust their humps to get the REAL story out there and are left at the mercies of dramatists. Broadcasting is Hell. Funny. I can walk down the street and say something controversial without much consequence but when a celebrity does it, they are crucified and forced into making a strong public plea for mercy. Celebrity is Hell. 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

Again, by Limbaugh's accounting yesterday, he has 22 million or so listeners and I've no reason to doubt the figure. He is influential and, with skill and instincts and talent, took a small niche and customized it, made it the model for spin talk radio, made it a juggernaut, and the envy of conservative spinners less skilled at the trade. Nothing should detract from that. His career is based on spin, spinning the Conservative and Republican message, and spinning it as fact, spinning it as patriotism, spinning it as good for the country, despite all evidence to the contrary, spinning the opposition as unpatriotic, and spinning his critics as tormentors. Rush manages to spin himself, Conservatives, and the religious right as underdogs, again, ignoring the facts. I doubt that more than a tiny percentage of that 22 million constitute Limbaugh groupies, individuals who, in their effusive adulation, if their idol is "attacked" or criticized or exposed for what he is, rush, in frantic panic, to rushlimbaugh.com to find ammunition with which to respond to Rush's tormenting demons, and post, from his site, edited transcripts, clips, or pithy quotes that seem, to the worshipful, supportive of Limbaugh's spin on his own gaffs, his own arrogance, his own bigotry. If Limbaugh is addicted to pain killers, his groupies feel his pain. Limbaugh groupies have kept up with the details of his spin on the prosecution on those drug charges, his spin on his probation, and can spout his spin on that, or his doctor's Viagra that he carried on his return from the Dominican Republic, where cigars were the main entertainment, or so Rush had spun. Limbaugh wants the microphone, wants to continue to be the loudest voice Clear Channeling the airwaves, wants the resulting audience. Just because Rush groupies spin criticism of him as crucifiction, doesn't make it so. He's no underdog, and his groupies are underdogs by inclination rather than circumstance. Gee, what would groupies do without celebrities? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Gee, what would some people do if they told the truth instead of accusing others of spinning the truth? 

BaylorMom --- 19 years ago -

I think accent just put this up to slur Rush, yet he talks about Rush liking to omit the facts, when he does the same thing. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

I spent three years in the 82d Airborne as an infantryman. When I think of phoney soldiers, there are many "soldiers" that are not really soldiers in my opinion. Sure everyone contributes, but there are plenty of whiners that are in the service soley for their own interests. Plenty of them that find the easiest job and do it haphazardly. They are usually the first ones to try to get to the media. They are sometimes the first ones to make policy recommendations. They are almost always the loudest. Then there are those that do the job they signed up to do. I didn't always agree with what we were doing. I didn't always understand what we were doing, but I did recognize that I had a job to do and I did it to the best of my ability. Anything less would have been phoney. Frankly, there are phoney soldiers. Those that lie about being servicemen and servicewomen when they aren't/weren't even in the service and those that embellish their role. The topic has nothing to do with Rush Limbaugh. Many folks here are simply trying to bash him. You should find something better than the use of a real term. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

I think accent just put this up to slur Rush you are right Green Eyes - look at her spelling of his name on the title. Doesn't seem like the sensitive person she'd like us to think she is... 

accent_ --- 19 years ago -

I had a job to do and I did it to the best of my ability. Thanks, jdb and Shutterman, for your service. There's nothing phony about either of you. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground