Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Gore gets a cold shoulder

who's talking here?

Lydia Erb 1
bbjones 17
planemom 1
GHYC 4
Aviator 1
NoNameNoLastName 4
Going off air 1
Superfantastik 1
BaylorMom 1
stacy99 3
ChezML 2
Brian 1
irt339 1
Cicero 1
ZITA 2
Goddess 1
Meteor 2
Bosko 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Steve Lytte October 14, 2007 ONE of the world's foremost meteorologists has called the theory that helped Al Gore share the Nobel Peace Prize "ridiculous" and the product of "people who don't understand how the atmosphere works". Dr William Gray, a pioneer in the science of seasonal hurricane forecasts, told a packed lecture hall at the University of North Carolina that humans were not responsible for the warming of the earth. His comments came on the same day that the Nobel committee honoured Mr Gore for his work in support of the link between humans and global warming. "We're brainwashing our children," said Dr Gray, 78, a long-time professor at Colorado State University. "They're going to the Gore movie [An Inconvenient Truth] and being fed all this. It's ridiculous." At his first appearance since the award was announced in Oslo, Mr Gore said: "We have to quickly find a way to change the world's consciousness about exactly what we're facing." Mr Gore shared the Nobel prize with the United Nations climate panel for their work in helping to galvanise international action against global warming. But Dr Gray, whose annual forecasts of the number of tropical storms and hurricanes are widely publicised, said a natural cycle of ocean water temperatures - related to the amount of salt in ocean water - was responsible for the global warming that he acknowledges has taken place. However, he said, that same cycle meant a period of cooling would begin soon and last for several years. "We'll look back on all of this in 10 or 15 years and realise how foolish it was," Dr Gray said. During his speech to a crowd of about 300 that included meteorology students and a host of professional meteorologists, Dr Gray also said those who had linked global warming to the increased number of hurricanes in recent years were in error. He cited statistics showing there were 101 hurricanes from 1900 to 1949, in a period of cooler global temperatures, compared to 83 from 1957 to 2006 when the earth warmed. "The human impact on the atmosphere is simply too small to have a major effect on global temperatures," Dr Gray said. He said his beliefs had made him an outsider in popular science. "It bothers me that my fellow scientists are not speaking out against something they know is wrong," he said. "But they also know that they'd never get any grants if they spoke out. I don't care about grants."  

Aviator --- 19 years ago -

Gore is a "bore" ... 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Gray and Muddy Thinking about Global Warming Anybody who has followed press reporting on global warming, and particularly on its effects on hurricanes, has surely encountered various contrarian pronouncements by William Gray, of Colorado State University. A meeting paper that Gray provided in advance of the 2006 27th Conference on Hurricanes and Tropical Meteorology (taking place this week in Monterey California, and covered here by CNN), provides an illuminating window into Gray's thinking on the subject. Our discussion is not a point-by-point rebuttal of Gray's claims; there is far more wrong with the paper than we have the patience to detail. Gray will have plenty of opportunities to hear more about the work's shortcomings if it is ever subjected to the rigors of peer review. Here we will only highlight a few key points which illustrate the fundamental misconceptions on the physics of climate that underlie most of Gray's pronouncements on climate change and its causes. Gray's paper begins with a quote from Senator Inhofe calling global warming a hoax perpetrated on the American people, and ends with a quote by a representive of the Society of Petroleum Geologists stating that Crichton's State of Fear has "the absolute ring of truth." It is the gaping flaws in the scientific argument sandwiched between these two statements that are our major concern. Claim: The Thermohaline Circulation causes Global Warming, Hurricane Cycles, etc For years, perhaps decades, Gray has been ascribing all sorts of climate changes and hurricane cycles to fluctuations in the Thermohaline Circulation (THC), an overturning circulation in the Atlantic ocean associated with formation of deep water in the North Atlantic. None of the assertions are based on rigorous statistical associations, oceanographic observations or physically based simulations; it is all seat-of -the-pants stuff of a sort that was common in the early days of climate studies, but which is difficult to evaluate when viewed as a scientific hypothesis. The THC is undoubtedly important to climate, because it transports heat from one place to another. However it cannot do magical things. It cannot created energy out of thin air (or thick water), nor can it make energy mysteriously disappear. Thus, Gray's statement that "The average THC circulation cools the ocean by about 3 W/m2" is a scientific absurdity. In the paper Gray makes many extravagant claims about how supposed changes in the THC accounted for various 20th century climate changes ("I judge our present global ocean circulation conditions to be similar to that of the period of the early 1940s when the globe had shown great warming since 1910, and there was concern as to whether this 1910-1940 global warming would continue. But beginning about 15 years following the onset of a strong THC circulation in 1926, in the early 1940s, the warming began to abate. A weak global cooling began from the mid-1940s to the mid-1970s.") but the reader would never guess that he in fact has no direct oceanographic evidence that the THC was doing anything of the sort. These are all subjective estimates based on Gray's conception of the relation of Atlantic temperatures to the THC state. In fact, it is exceedingly difficult to directly monitor the THC, and reliable results have only recently been obtained. We have reported recently on the "Decrease in Atlantic Circulation". For years prior to the publication of evidence that the THC was slowing down, Gray was testifying in Congress and writing widely that hurricane increases were due to Atlantic warming arising from a speed-up of the THC (see our article for some typical quotes). Confronted with evidence that the THC was in fact behaving in the opposite way to what he had been assuming, Gray did a flip-flop and came up with a new story that yields the same conclusions. There's no shame in a scientist changing his or her mind, or in seeking new theories in the face of new observations. However, if Gray's old theory was really testable, where were the tests to show that it was wrong in the years he was touting it? How is one to put any confidence in the new theory? The fact is that neither of Gray's story lines about the THC is sufficiently well formulated to allow any clear-cut test. Nonetheless, insofar as it can be understood at all, some aspects of Gray's new story line about the THC are demonstrably wrong. The heart of the problem with Gray's new version of the THC story is that he labors under the misconception that the THC primarily upwells in the tropics, so that any reduction in the THC cools the North Atlantic but warms the tropics. This conception is at least 50 years out of date. The tropical upwelling is a shallow wind-driven cell that does not connect to the THC. It is almost impossible for cold deep water to upwell in the tropics, because it takes too much energy to bring it up; the main THC connection is with the Southern Ocean, as described by Marotzke and references therein (for more general background, see also en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermohaline_circulation). There are only a few very limited regions where moderately deep water can upwell in the Tropics. Simulations by Vellinga and Wood (Climatic Change, 2002) in fact show that a THC shutdown causes a cooling right into the Northern Subtropical Atlantic (the birthplace of hurricanes), and in fact only very weak warming in a few spots elsewhere in the tropics. On a longer time scale, the classic study of Manabe and Stouffer (Paleoceanography 1997) shows virtually no impact of THC shutdown in the tropics, but a considerable remote impact in the Southern Ocean. No doubt, Gray would object that these are only models, but why should we believe that Gray's drawing of circles and arrows on a map yields a better prediction than a simulation embodying the best of what we know about the underlying physics? Note that Gray does not merely claim that THC changes are responsible for the observed hurricane cycles. He in fact claims that the entire 20th century warming signal is due to a slowdown of the THC, and that CO2 has nothing to do with it. He claims flatly and without supporting evidence that models cannot simulate the THC properly, neglecting the fact that the models employed in the IPCC reports yield a rather wide variety of different possible THC behaviors, and none of them, including ones known to have a sensitive THC, spontaneously generate a warming of the sort Gray claims. Insofar as we can follow Gray's reasoning, he appears to think of the THC as burying heat in the deep ocean, as if the heat were some kind of solid nuclear waste. Thus, weak THC = less heat removal = warming, in Gray's world view. In reality, everything known about the physics of the THC's effect on climate suggests the opposite. For example, Vellinga and Wood find that, owing to certain nonlinearities like sea ice formation, a shutdown of the THC leads to a reduction in the Northern Hemisphere mean temperature, and very little multidecadal scale effect on the Southern Hemisphere mean temperature. The other reasons Gray thinks that the THC could cause global warming are tied up with a number of additional misconceptions he has about the physics of climate. Claim: Evaporation changes cause global warming, hurricane cycles, etc. Gray's grand answer to the riddle of global warming is evaporation, presumably modulated by changes in the THC. Again, Gray simply doesn't seem to understand energy conservation. Evaporation does not create heat; it does not add any heat to the climate system or take it away. It is an energy transfer that moves heat from a moist surface (like the ocean's) into the atmosphere. That severely constrains what evaporation changes can do to climate. In contrast, changes in CO2 concentration affect the top of atmosphere radiation budget directly, and change the rate at which the whole climate system loses energy. Let's start with an atmosphere that is in equilibrium, both at the surface and top-of-atmosphere. Now reduce the evaporation (you could do it by reducing the surface wind). The surface is now receiving more energy than it loses, so it will begin to warm. However, the atmosphere is no longer receiving all the energy it used to obtain from the surface as evaporative heat transfer; hence the atmosphere will begin to cool. This adjustment will continue until balance is restored. The precise way the adjustment is divvied up between atmospheric cooling and surface warming depends on details like the net atmospheric infrared opacity, boundary layer relative humidity,and so forth. However that all shakes out, the net result is nothing at all like the observed pattern of warming, in which both troposphere and surface warm up. This reasoning can be confirmed in the simplest radiative-convective model, of the sort introduced by Manabe and Strickler in the 1960's. A more serious problem is that Gray doesn't even understand that the greenhouse effect works primarily through the effect of greenhouse gases on the top of atmosphere radiation budget, and only very indirectly through the surface budget (as explained in A busy week for water vapor). This compromises almost all of his analysis. For example, many of the supposed changes in surface budget he describes could in fact be due indirectly to changes in greenhouse gases, via their affect on low level atmospheric temperature. By balancing a 4 W/m2 (top of atmosphere) CO2 radiative forcing against changes in evaporation, Gray concludes that the warming from doubling CO2 would be a mere two tenths of a degree C.. He ascribes the weak warming to the lack of water vapor feedback in his calculation, but in fact it is simply due to an incorrect calculation of the energy balance. Standard radiative physics based on a correct treatment of the top-of-atmosphere balance– physics going back at least to Arrhenius– yields a surface warming of about 1C in response to a doubling of CO2, when water vapor feedback is neglected. Gray has committed the major blunder of applying that 4 W/m2 top of atmosphere forcing at the surface. In reality, when that radiative forcing is properly applied at the top of the atmosphere, it leads to a warming of the entire atmospheric column which, at the surface, yields a far larger perturbation in the surface energy budget, as we have explained in the above-referenced article. By the way, Gray discounts water vapor feedback, based on what seems to be a gut feeling on weather systems, plus some unspecified analysis of the NCEP reanalysis dataset (which is completely unsuitable for studying trends in mid tropospheric water vapor); more reliable satellite based studies (e.g. Soden's study described in A busy week for water vapor ) support a positive water vapor feedback, and even Lindzen seems to be no longer arguing against this feedback. Claim: Ocean heat storage is inconsistent with CO2 as a cause of warming Gray also made a mess of an attempt to analyze the mid-twentieth century ocean heat storage. "… the globe underwent a weak cooling between 1950 and 1975 during which CO2 amounts were rising and causing a continuous mean energy gain over this 25 year period of about 0.4 W/m2. If all of this energy went into an accumulation of temperature in the upper 100 m of the global oceans, we would see an upper mean 100 m global ocean temperature increase of 1.1oC. " We are not sure where Gray gets the 0.4 W/m2 radiative forcing figure; the total radiative forcing increase from pre-industrial times to 1975 would be more like .95 W/m2 and it is not a trivial matter to figure out how much to subtract from that to account for the part compensated by ocean warming before 1950; the CO2 radiative forcing increase between 1950 to 1975, on the other hand, would be only .45 W/m2 and the mean new forcing over the period would be about half that. Be that as it may, Gray has not even done the arithmetic right, since .4 W/m2 going into a 100m mixed layer having specific heat of 4200 J/kg and density of about 1000 kg/m3 would only yield a warming of .75C . That's far from the worst flaw in his calculation, since his two biggest blunders are the neglect of the radiative cooling due to sulfate aerosols (known to be a critical factor in the period in question) and his neglect of the many links in the chain of physical effects needed to translate a top of atmosphere radiative imbalance to a change in net surface energy flux imbalance. In fact, the calculation has been done very carefully by Hansen and co-workers, taking all factors into consideration, and when compared with observations of ocean heat storage over a period long enough for the observed changes to be reliably assessed, models and observations agree extremely well (see this article and this article.). Concluding remarks The Wall Street Journal has insinuated that there is some ageism involved in the reaction to Gray's work ("Hurricane debate shatters civility of weather science," by Valerie Bauerlein, Feb.2, 2006). The problem is not Gray's age — we all revered Henry Stommel who did some of his finest work in his seventies. The problem is Gray's failure to adapt to a modern era of meteorology, which demands hypotheses soundly grounded in quantitative and consistent physical formulations, not seat-of-the-pants flying. The WSJ also made much of the withdrawal of an invitation for Gray to join a debate on hurricane trends at an Atlanta tropical meteorology conference. We can't speak for the organizers, but we find it easy to believe that their decision was guided more by the invalidity of Gray's scientific reasoning than by any political or personal considerations. 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

"It bothers me that my fellow scientists are not speaking out against something they know is wrong," Because they know Gray has been bought and paid for to be a mouth piece. 

BaylorMom --- 19 years ago -

Yea but it also could be the other way around, Gore being paid and bought off. Or the other scientists being paid to scare us. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

It all comes down to the money. There are very few orgainizations that want pure data. They want the data to say what they tell it say. Right now more money if available to the pro-man made global warming people. Therefore more scientists believe that theory. If society starts to disagree more money will be available to disprove man made global warming so it will appear that is the truth. 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

Yea but it also could be the other way around, Gore being paid and bought off. Or the other scientists being paid to scare us.  Or maybe it is just the inconvenient truth, that they want to discredit, because they know it will hurt the bottom dollar of corporate America. Look how long they lied to us that smoking was ok and had no health risks, finally the truth came out. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

The problem is Gray's failure to adapt to a modern era of meteorology, which demands hypotheses soundly grounded in quantitative and consistent physical formulations, not seat-of-the-pants flying. In science, one important measure of credibility is that one is actively puplishing in peer-reviewed journals. Gray has not been recently published, and certainly not in the field of climate science. 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

That's Gory! 

stacy99 --- 19 years ago -

Or the other scientists being paid to scare us.  You mean like the way the Bush Administration tried to scare everyone, so they could get approval to go to war with Iraq. The scientist have no oil to gain, what would be the purpose of scaring us? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Because they know Gray has been bought and paid for to be a mouth piece. No, it is the scientists that he is talking about thet have been bought and paid for. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

In science, one important measure of credibility is that one is actively puplishing in peer-reviewed journals. That is total nonsense. The peer reviewers are not going to give "credibility" to people who do not agree with them. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The scientist have no oil to gain, what would be the purpose of scaring us? So that they can get grant money. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Look how long they lied to us that smoking was ok and had no health risks, finally the truth came out. And that is exactly what the pro man-made global warming scientists are doing to us now. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Gray and Muddy Thinking about Global Warming Gray has been correct in the past. Have the people that wrote this article been correct in their modeling? Some of you people will believe any nonsense that the media put out there. As Joseph Goebbels knew when he drafted the Nazi campaign blaming the Jews for Germany’s failure to rise out of the ashes of the Great War, if you tell a lie often enough, it eventually becomes accepted as the truth. 

Bosko --- 19 years ago -

that a**hole is not even worth the print it takes to post the article 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

Peace be with you bbj, we will have to agree to disagree - yet again. 

irt339 --- 19 years ago -

Some of you people will believe any nonsense that the media put out there. As Joseph Goebbels knew when he drafted the Nazi campaign blaming the Jews for Germany’s failure to rise out of the ashes of the Great War, if you tell a lie often enough, it eventually becomes accepted as the truth. Please, defend your point with facts and their scientific references. If you can't do that, then spare us this sort of bullshit rhetoric.  

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Peace be with you bbj, we will have to agree to disagree - yet again. You don't even understand the science. Neither does NoName. The person(s) who wrote the article about Dr. Gray did not back up one of their assertions with data. It is very easy to say that someone is wrong when you are not held to the standard of substantiating your claims. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Please, defend your point with facts and their scientific references. If you can't do that, then spare us this sort of bullshit rhetoric. I have. If you don't take the time to read the history of what I have previously posted, then spare us YOUR nonsense. 

Meteor --- 19 years ago -

Just yesterday Jones was accusing anyone who didn't subscribe to his brand of climatology of being in effect bad Christians. What a special person. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Just yesterday Jones was accusing anyone who didn't subscribe to his brand of climatology of being in effect bad Christians. What a special person. Meteor, you are a liar. I said that it was sad when Christians did not believe God. If you are going to accuse someone of something, at least attribute to them what they have said CORRECTLY. 

Lydia Erb --- 19 years ago -

Just yesterday Jones was accusing anyone who didn't subscribe to his brand of climatology of being in effect bad Christians. What a special person. Thank you Meteor. Since science is obviously not his area of expertise, maybe Jones should just go back to preaching to everyone. At least that is a little less obnoxious. 

stacy99 --- 19 years ago -

then spare us YOUR nonsense. Yes would you please do that! Gray is not a climatologist, and his views are rejected by the field. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

You don't even understand the science. Neither does NoName. That, coming from the circular logic man, is indeed very funny... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

That, coming from the circular logic man, is indeed very funny... You do not even understand what circular logic is. However, you should, because it is YOU that practices it. But that still does not show your understanding of the science involved. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Thank you Meteor. Since science is obviously not his area of expertise, maybe Jones should just go back to preaching to everyone. Lydia, maybe YOU should know what you are talking about before you make stupid statements. I have degrees in Chemistry and Biology and have spent many years as an Environmental scientist. What science degrees do you have that give you the expertise to tell me that I do not know what I am talking about? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Gray is not a climatologist, and his views are rejected by the field. Talk about nonsense. Stacy, how can you blindly put out false statements like that. Don't you think that you should do some research first? Dr. Gray has a PhD in Geophysical Sciences and is Emeritus Professor of Atmospheric Science at Colorado State University (CSU), and head of the Tropical Meteorology Project at CSU's Department of Atmospheric Sciences. Gray is noted for his forecasts of Atlantic hurricane season activity. Professor Gray served as a weather forecaster for the United States Air Force, and as a research assistant in the University of Chicago Department of Meteorology. Gray pioneered the concept of "seasonal" hurricane forecasting — predicting months in advance the severity of the coming hurricane season. Gray's prognostications, issued since 1983, are used by insurance companies to calculate premiums. I believe that qualifies him as a climatologist. 

ZITA --- 19 years ago -

I believe that qualifies him as a climatologist. The dude is over the hill and out to lunch. No reputable scientists believe him any longer. 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

Just yesterday Jones was accusing anyone who didn't subscribe to his brand of climatology of being in effect bad Christians. What a special person. Typical of BBJ. And yes, I saw that comment too. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

You do not even understand what circular logic is. However, you should, because it is YOU that practices it. That coming from the man who says the Bible is true because the Bible was written under God's inspiration because the Bible says so is also funny. Gray and bbjones have something in common - The problem is Gray's failure to adapt to a modern era of meteorology, which demands hypotheses soundly grounded in quantitative and consistent physical formulations, not seat-of-the-pants flying. Replace "Gray" with "bbjones" and "meteorology" with "science", and there you go... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Typical of BBJ. And yes, I saw that comment too. If you say that you saw that comment, then you are a liar just like Meteor, which, by the way, you have already proven previously on this forum. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The dude is over the hill and out to lunch. No reputable scientists believe him any longer. That "dude" knows much more than you do. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The problem is Gray's failure to adapt to a modern era of meteorology, which demands hypotheses soundly grounded in quantitative and consistent physical formulations, not seat-of-the-pants flying. NoName, the problem is that you do not understand that the truth does not change, therefore, there is not adaptation needed. Only FALSE statements, theories, hypotheses, etc. need to be changed and adapted as new information is discovered. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

NoName, the problem is that you do not understand that the truth does not change, therefore, there is not adaptation needed. But circular logic is fine, right? The Bible is true because the Bible was written under God's inspiration because the Bible says so. Is this a true statement, bbjones? 

Goddess --- 19 years ago -

I've heard all this biblical stuff denying the obvious about trashing the earth resources and allowing endless pollution before. In fact, I had to live with this. They wish to force their religious beliefs, which are without scientific foundation, on everyone. If you don't believe, you are a bad Christian, the devils spawn. Anti-global warming is just one of their wingnut fantasies. All they can do is quote from less than reputable and outdated sources. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

All they can do is quote from less than reputable and outdated sources. And what is your reputable source? What is reputable is subjective. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Can we stop with the Global Warming debate now? It means nothing and will have virtually no impact on any of of lives. It's political fodder, see it for what it really is. 

ZITA --- 19 years ago -

I don't mind hearing about science, but the bible isn't science. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I don't mind hearing about science, but the bible isn't science. Goes to show what you know. The Bible contains much science. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground