Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Day After We Bomb Iran - sobering analysis

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 16
GCan 4
Mary C 2
Fallon 3
WhoHoo 3
bbjones 1
planemom 3
Justwatching72 10
SS (SmilingSurvivor) 1
letsbargain 6
qpc 4
rose8304 1
NoNameNoLastName 1
Going off air 2
Superfantastik 2
stacy99 2
irt339 1
Cicero 34
Lynn 2
mamajulie 1
ZITA 1
laurabehindthebush 2
BMD004 1
get_the_lead_out! 24

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

The Day After We Bomb Iran Chris Weigant Mon Oct 1, 10:57 PM ET There's a raging debate within the Bush administration, the punditocracy, and the blogosphere about whether or not it is time to bomb Iran. While this conversation scares small children (and other sane people), most of the focus has been on (1) whether President... oh, excuse me... Vice President Cheney truly is moonbat-crazy enough to do so, and (2) whether anyone else in America (including the military) would go along with the idea. But not enough attention is being paid to what happens after we rain death from the skies down on Iran. Which is a shame, because that's what we ignored during the ramp-up to war with Iraq. And we all know how that turned out. Let's assume, for the sake of argument, that the United States actually does go ahead and bomb Iran. There are a lot of different scenarios which could lead to this point, of course -- a "false flag" operation (think: Gulf of Tonkin Incident); Iranian military captives the United States swears were killing Americans in Iraq being paraded before the television cameras; provoking the Iranian Navy and swearing we were in international waters and not Iranian waters -- there are many ways to make the case for war before the eyes of the world, so it's not very productive to worry about which method it may take. But let's assume George Bush presents some sort of a casus belli to the world, which is immediately followed by the United States military dropping bombs and cruise missiles on Iran. Now the actual method of the attack (as opposed to the rationale) may influence later events, so it is worth breaking down the possibilities. The old plan was to destroy both Iran's nuclear sites and enough infrastructure that rebuilding them would take the Iranians years to accomplish (while bombing all the military sites and radar installations we see along the way, of course). The new plan (according to Seymour Hersh in his explosive new article in the New Yorker) is to take out the Revolutionary Guard (and to ignore the nuke sites), merely as hot-pursuit retaliation for Iranian involvement in Iraq (while also bombing all the radar installations we see along the way, of course). Rumors abound that Israel is also thinking seriously about taking out the Iranian nuke sites. Perhaps a combination of the two is what is envisioned? An American raid which conveniently takes down the Iranian radar net would make it awfully tempting for Israeli jets to use the opportunity of such cover to achieve their main objective, it would seem. This is all pure speculation on my part, I must admit. Whether our justification for the bombing is "hot pursuit" or whether it is to set Iranian nuclear progress back a decade will not matter a whole lot to whoever's under the bombs as they fall. But it may matter in the response Iran makes. The neo-cons thinking: "They'll greet us with flowers, II" So far, the Iranian response has seemingly been addressed by the neo-conservative think tank "The Iraqis Will Greet Us With Flowers Institute," which is fully as dangerous and deluded as it sounds. Their basic argument is the Iranians will see the errors of their ways (after we bomb them), throw out the Mullahs in Tehran, and beg the United States' forgiveness. Or that they're just too scared of our awesome military might ("Shock And Awe II," you might call it) to retaliate in any way, because they'd be terrified of losing a war with us. That this is divorced from both reality and the history of the United States and Iran for the past 60 years or so seems to escape the proponents of this view. But then again, they sold the Bush White House on the "we'll be greeted as liberators, with flowers" line, so there's no guarantee it won't work a second time. Here are some chilling quotes from Hersh's article on the subject of "what happens next?" after the bombs stop falling. "They're moving everybody to the Iran desk," one recently retired C.I.A. official said. "They're dragging in a lot of analysts and ramping up everything. It's just like the fall of 2002" -- the months before the invasion of Iraq, when the Iraqi Operations Group became the most important in the agency. He added, "The guys now running the Iranian program have limited direct experience with Iran. In the event of an attack, how will the Iranians react? They will react, and the Administration has not thought it all the way through." That theme was echoed by Zbigniew Brzezinski, the former national-security adviser, who said that he had heard discussions of the White House's more limited bombing plans for Iran. Brzezinski said that Iran would likely react to an American attack "by intensifying the conflict in Iraq and also in Afghanistan, their neighbors, and that could draw in Pakistan. We will be stuck in a regional war for twenty years." . . . A senior European diplomat, who works closely with American intelligence, told me that there is evidence that Iran has been making extensive preparation for an American bombing attack. "We know that the Iranians are strengthening their air-defense capabilities," he said, "and we believe they will react asymmetrically -- hitting targets in Europe and in Latin America." There is also specific intelligence suggesting that Iran will be aided in these attacks by Hezbollah. "Hezbollah is capable, and they can do it," the diplomat said. The article does quote one unnamed "senior European official" (most likely British) who has drunk deep of the neo-con Kool-Aid: The European official continued, "A major air strike against Iran could well lead to a rallying around the flag there, but a very careful targeting of terrorist training camps might not." His view, he said, was that "once the Iranians get a bloody nose they rethink things." For example, Ali Akbar Rafsanjani and Ali Larijani, two of Iran's most influential political figures, "might go to the Supreme Leader and say, 'The hard-line policies have got us into this mess. We must change our approach for the sake of the regime.' " This is rebutted with a quote from an unnamed "former [American] senior intelligence official": "Do you think those crazies in Tehran are going to say, 'Uncle Sam is here! We'd better stand down'? " the former senior intelligence official said. "The reality is an attack will make things ten times warmer." War-gaming the Iranian response The Iranians have missiles. They also have a shadowy world-wide terror network that, from all accounts, is quite competent and deadly. And geography gave Iran a chokepoint that could cut off roughly 20% of the world's oil supplies. Put all of these together, and you have quite a range of options for the Iranians to take. Let's assume that they would use these on an escalating scale, with proportionate responses by the U.S. The very first thing the Iranians would do is bomb the MEK camps in Iraq. This would be on a "tit-for-tat" level and they could make a good case before the world for doing so. The MEK ("Mujahedeen-e-Khalq") is an Iranian dissident group who have been trying to overthrow the government of Iran for quite some time now. They used to operate out of Saddam's Iraq, in cross-border raids into Iran. When we invaded, we kind of institutionalized a stalemate with them -- we accepted their surrender, told them we would protect the safety of their camps, but we allowed them to stay. The only problem is, they're a terrorist group. Which we're protecting with the American military. You can easily see the parallels with what we would be claiming Iran is doing -- supporting outlaw groups from within their own territory who cross the border and perform terrorist actions. Which is why they would be target number one for Iranian retaliation if we used the "hot pursuit" rationale. Iran would loudly proclaim American hypocrisy and attempt to convince the world of the justification of their actions. They might even succeed in doing so. If America kept attacking Iran, the options get much grimmer much quicker. Iranian missiles may start targeting the Green Zone in Baghdad with a passion. They may start targeting those sprawling US bases out in the desert in Iraq. Remember the Kuwaiti war with Saddam? America kept saying "oh, we've taken care of all of Saddam's missiles" while the SCUDs kept raining down, proving us wrong. Imagine that scenario coming from Iran. Iran may also unleash the terrorists it sponsors. Hezbollah, in particular, may begin spectacular terrorist attacks within Europe. They could even conceivably (unlike Bush's bugaboo "Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia") successfully attack the United States mainland. So not only are missiles raining down on the Green Zone, but shopping malls and train stations and power plants are getting blown up all over Europe and the United States, or (failing to reach America) U.S. Embassies worldwide. But these nightmare scenarios aren't the worst weapon. Iran's real leverage comes from sitting on top of the Straits of Hormuz (some use the singular Strait of Hormuz). Check out a map of it on Wikipedia, and notice that Iran surrounds this tight bottleneck on three sides. Twenty percent of the world's oil moves through these straits every day, on supertankers. Imagine Iranian mines, torpedoes and missiles taking out oil tankers here. They'd really just have to successfully take out one, or maybe two to prove they could do it whenever they felt like. What would happen after the first of these successful attacks would be oil trading at astronomical highs: $150 to $200 a barrel. Or roughly two to three times what is has been trading at during the Iraq war. Six to nine dollars a gallon at your local pump. If this went on for a short period of time, it could cause a devastating recession on the American economy. If it went on for a long period of time, it could cause a worldwide economic depression. If the American economy crumbles, it's going to be harder and harder to find the money to continue three wars at once. Remember, we essentially outspent the Soviet Union in the arms race. It'd be awfully ironic if it happened to us, since it would be almost impossible to pour the amount of money we have been into the Middle East if our economy was on its knees. And really, what would the eventual end to the American military escalation of an Iranian war? A military draft here at home, for one thing, since the Army just could not withstand to supply a ground invasion at its current level of soldiers. Or we could escalate bombing on a level not seen since Vietnam -- carpet bombing from B-52s, not "smart" bombs in pinprick raids. Or the Bush White House might even be tempted to test out those nuclear penetrator bombs we've been working on -- to take out "deeply buried Iranian nuclear sites," no doubt. My point is that the consequences for an Iranian adventure would be severe. In all the arguments swirling around Iran currently inside the Beltway, not enough attention is being paid to the likely outcome of such military action. If you're a neo-con and are arguing that Iran needs to be taken out because they're the world's biggest state sponsor of terrorism, then fine -- make your case. But be sure to realistically address what the costs of such rash action would be for America. Because last time around, we ignored that part of the equation with "we'll be greeted as liberators" -- and we just can't afford a second mistake of that magnitude.  

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

My point is that the consequences for an Iranian adventure would be severe. and my point is that little midget psycho already said he had nuclear weapons and he already said he would use the on Israel and us in order to bring about Armageddon as laid out in his Quoran....... Nuke the bastards before they nuke us. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

Nuke the bastards before they nuke us.  Ditto! 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

I'm with y'all 100%! nuke 'em! 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

Bomb Bomb bomb Bomb bomb Iran Barbra Annn 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

beach boys 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

He stood on a stage in NY at Columbia and TOLD US that he plans on bringing about the return of the Mahdi, which means (to him) that the US must be destroyed. He OPENED with this remark, and just a few months ago in his address to the UN he closed with the remark. When he was elected a couple of years ago, he laid out exactly what he wanted to do to the US. Why does no one take these crazy lunatics at their word? No one took Hitler or Stalin at their word either and look what happened. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

And if we do not defend Isreal we will be the next to fall. No doubt about that. 

Lynn --- 19 years ago -

We know this is coming..it's a matter of who is gonna do it first..them or us? 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

There's a raging debate within the Bush administration, the punditocracy, and the blogosphere about whether or not it is time to bomb Iran. And WHY are we even considering this type of action? It's time for impeachment. I don't want to hear the WMD argument all over again. It worked once, but it won't work twice. Fool me once ..... fool me .... you can't get fooled again. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

And WHY are we even considering this type of action? Any President who does not consider it is a traitor to this country. Period. When do you want action? After NY is vaporized? 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Any President who does not consider it is a traitor to this country. Period. When do you want action? After NY is vaporized? Nobody is going to launch a nuclear attack against the USA. Won't happen. No way, no how. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Fool me once ..... fool me .... you can't get fooled again. Can I quote you when we sit here and do nothing and you are glowing in the dark? Nobody is going to launch a nuclear attack against the USA. Won't happen. No way, no how. And you know this how? I don't want to hear the WMD argument all over again. Even when the little prick said that he will nuke us? or did you miss that speech of his? 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

No "country" perhaps but a nifty little black market package sponsored by said country. The plans have been drawn up it is a matter of the perps thinking they have a place to run and hide after the fact. When they think they can get away with it, it WILL happen. Sure. I can see it now: A terrorist attack occurs on US soil and immediately we know who is to blame and where they are hiding. (*wink*) Oh wait, that already happened ... they called it 9/11. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

Oh wait, that already happened ... they called it 9/11. If the government would have paid attention then, we would have known it was going to happen...and now when the governmant pays attention, the people say an attack would never happen? 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

The same people that attacked on 9/11 had already bombed other US properties 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

If the government would have paid attention then, we would have known it was going to happen...and now when the governmant pays attention, the people say an attack would never happen? You missed the sarcasm in my post. The gov. was certainly paying attention before 9/11. No question about that. Alas, that's the topic of another discussion. As for Iran nuking the US - what would this accomplish for Iran??? Anyone with common sense knows that in this day and age a nuclear attack would mean the end of the world. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

As for Iran nuking the US - what would this accomplish for Iran??? Anyone with common sense knows that in this day and age a nuclear attack would mean the end of the world. Sorry I missed the sarcasm. My bad. But it sounds like the Iranian President IS trying to bring about the end of the world. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

"Iranian missle parts are showing up in Iraq and Afgahnistan" would lead you to think they do not sponsor terrorism, most especially in light of Ah-midget-dad's own on air confessions? Or so we would be led to believe. How exactly does a country sponsor 'terrorism'? 'Terrorism' is a difficult term to define. Why do you think that it's such a popular buzzword with the US government? It can be easliy argued that ANY act of aggression is 'terrorism'. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Anyone with common sense knows that in this day and age a nuclear attack would mean the end of the world. No shit sherlock..and that is exactly what that little piece of crap said he wanted....truly Cicero...quit watching CNN.... 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

No shit sherlock..and that is exactly what that little piece of crap said he wanted....truly Cicero...quit watching CNN.... I don't watch CNN. You guys believe everything that you read, don't you? Did y'all vote in the 'sheep' poll that I started yesterday? You might want to rethink your votes ... or your honesty. ;) 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

READ??? how about hearing him say it from his own lips......think he is just making idle threats about nuking us and Israel? really cicero....really.....id make a bet with you, but when i win, you will be a crispy critter as will i and I won't be able to collect. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

I don't watch CNN. You guys believe everything that you read, don't you? So we can't take the Iranian midget's word on what he has been quoted on video saying? Wow! What a two-face liar! He really wants to be our friend! 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

READ??? how about hearing him say it from his own lips......think he is just making idle threats about nuking us and Israel? really cicero....really.....id make a bet with you, but when i win, you will be a crispy critter as will i and I won't be able to collect. It's BS, JW. You'll never see a nuclear attack. Back to the 'terrorism' thing. Anyone remember the 'Bay of Pigs'? In case you're not up on your history ... it was a US sponsored attempt to overthrow Fidel Castro. How is that NOT sponsoring 'terrorism'? 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

according the the Iranian midget, it's either them or us and I vote for us. Maybe we can meet with the Iranian midget at a starbucks but I don't think that is what he wants 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

like I said before, nobody believed we could have an attack on our soil previously and it happened and now you say a nuclear attack will never happen, even though the Iranian President doesn't care if the world will end? 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

like I said before, nobody believed we could have an attack on our soil previously and it happened and now you say a nuclear attack will never happen, even though the Iranian President doesn't care if the world will end? *IF* 9/11 was really an attack on the US (over 1/3rd of the people in the country and most of world do not believe this) - that still is not an excuse to bomb every country that the average citizen feels is a 'threat'. Stop living in fear. What you're witnessing is propaganda. 

whatchamacallit --- 19 years ago -

As for Iran nuking the US - what would this accomplish for Iran??? Anyone with common sense knows that in this day and age a nuclear attack would mean the end of the world. Yes, you are right anyone with common sense would not, but we are not dealing with a people with common sense. They are more interested in fulfilling a proficey of doom that they have been taught is the way it should be for MANY MANY generations, if not forever! They don't think or reason or believe as we do. Self-preservation has nothing to do with their decision making on this matter. WAKE UP! 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

cicero....you are one of the reasons that we WILL get attacked again....YOU are the one listening to and following propaganda... what makes you think that iran is willing to be all nice nice with us? they have been caught sending guns and such to iraq to help KILL our men... 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

*IF* 9/11 was really an attack on the US (over 1/3rd of the people in the country and most of world do not believe this) 9/11 wasn't an attack on the U.S.? 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Ah-Wanna-jihad has stated over and over that he is going to be the one that will bring and end to the world as we know it according to his Quoran... When a leader of a country makes that threat and has nuclear weapons, we are to just blow him off, not do anything to protect ourselves? 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

Did anyone read the story on Drudge Report about Obama wanting everyone to give up nuclear weapons?? Who does not know that we would be the only ones to play by that rule if it were ever made! Every other country would still have theirs. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Yes, you are right anyone with common sense would not, but we are not dealing with a people with common sense. They are tryin to fulfill a proficy of doom that they have been taught is the way it should be for MANY MANY generations, if not forever! They don't think or reason or believe as we do. Self preservation has nothin to do with their decision making on this matter. Quite honestly, only a fool would believe that everyone in Iran is on a suicide mission against the US. You can't possibly believe this, do you? Look, we're not talking about a schoolyard fight here. The US needs to rethink it's Foreign Policy. You don't threaten military action everytime another country disagrees with you. IMO that shows weakness. If we keep invading and bombing all of these countries around the world it will only be a matter of time until it backfires on us. Eventually people around the world will get sick of it and we won't have anyone on our side. Think about it. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Yes, lets just talk to them...everyone hug and it will be a ok....how's that working for ya? 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

9/11 wasn't an attack on the U.S.? Just head back to the flock, you'll be ok - we'll take care of it. 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

Just head back to the flock, you'll be ok - we'll take care of it. Way to respond to the question. 

whatchamacallit --- 19 years ago -

It doesn't have to be the everyday people! They are quite expendable in their governments eyes. You know collateral damage, don't be fooled, these nut jobs that are in power will do whatever it takes to make themselves appear to be right, even if it kills them and lots of innocent people. Oh and OBAMA, that is just too convenient, with his religious background! 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Way to respond to the question. No, that was my answer. If you have to ask that question then you might as well head back to the flock. Sorry, brutal truth. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 19 years ago -

Quite honestly, only a fool would believe that everyone in Iran is on a suicide mission against the US. You can't possibly believe this, do you? We don't need everyone on a suicide mission, just an idiot few. But the Iranian government supports these idiots and uses them to promote the Iranian Presidents agenda and beliefs, which is to bring about armaggedon 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

They are quite expendable in their governments eyes. You know collateral damage, don't be fooled, these nut jobs that are in power will do whatever it takes to make themselves appear to be right, even if it kills them and lots of innocent people. But you and I aren't? What about 3,000 New Yorkers - are they?? 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground