Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

thoughts on a new KYS feature?

who's talking here?

adam 5
barb 1
Frozen Margarita 2
Paige 4
love4bdd 1
Tedelady 2
Fancy 13
3s Enuff 1
My 3 and Me 1
khshops!! 7
♥Blessed 4 Ever♥ 1
MAR 1
crrc 1
browneyes 1
Gotcats 1
proudmomoftwo 1
Cicero 8
Nana 1
Rachel 1
KBM'SMOM 1
★ † 12 Stones † ★ 1
Gemini~on~the~Run 2
I'm here...Ur there! 1
*ANN* 1
Lil J 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

we've received a constant stream of comments over the years about "no shows" for expected appointments. many of you have recommended various feedback systems, but we haven't figured out how to keep people from abusing. but i finally had a thought.... :-) what if you could set up appointments with a seller on the site. once an appointment is agreed on, then the seller and buyer can provide feedback on each other on the nature of the exchange. "showed up right on time! A+++++". "seller wasn't home. F----" the control would be that both parties would agree on the time before any feedback could be provided. this would mean you have to manage appointments through the site, which might be more formal than phone calls/emails, which some people may prefer. anyway, it's a brainstorm. what do you think? 

proudmomoftwo --- 19 years ago -

sounds logical to me, I say go for it. 

KBM'SMOM --- 19 years ago -

I think its a good idea 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

It sounds very similar to e-bay and even Amazon.com. I think it's a nice idea. 

barb (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

"showed up right on time! A+++++". "seller wasn't home. F----" Did I just see adam drop the F-bomb??? Ice him!!! 

Gemini~on~the~Run --- 19 years ago -

I like it Adam, it will help in a lot of ways. The only thing is, if both have to agree before the other posts anything on feedback, what happens if the "f" who did not show up does not ever approve? 

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

could it be abused? how? is it too much to manage? is there a way to make it better? 

Tedelady --- 19 years ago -

Maybe not a time, but instead a date. I am notorious for being late, but I show up if I say I will. ~ Thanks = ) 

*ANN* --- 19 years ago -

Sounds like a great idea to me. 

Gotcats --- 19 years ago -

JUST DO IT!!! Great idea 

Tedelady --- 19 years ago -

I also like the idea of being able to post a comment rather than just a "grade" or star system. Maybe the seller was late but did show up. Maybe the weather kept them from coming. Or did they just flake on you? 

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

what happens if the "f" who did not show up does not ever approve? both parties would "agree" on a time. only then could they give feedback on each other. 

browneyes --- 19 years ago -

would this rating follow the customer/seller....like if that person were to consistantly no show and had a failing grade...would it show up when they inquired about an item? Or would the seller have to look their grade up? 

Gemini~on~the~Run --- 19 years ago -

Great idea. I,too, like the idea of the comment thing, but that would increase a chance for "Moderator Needed" areas. 

crrc --- 19 years ago -

I think what Adam means is F (minus minus minus etc) 

love4bdd --- 19 years ago -

Any thoughts on the thread I started below? The " Hey Adam" thread.....can it be done easily? 

My 3 and Me --- 19 years ago -

I think that would be great! 

MAR --- 19 years ago -

Just my 2 cents...How about ratings on both sides of the coin? A+..Buyer picked up item promptly, A+ item was just as described. 

khshops!! --- 19 years ago -

......that would increase a chance for "Moderator Needed" areas. I agree Also, I question how many bad buyers would just create new e-mail adresses to contact sellers. 

3s Enuff --- 19 years ago -

I was hopeing that their would be a rating system so this sounds great! 

khshops!! --- 19 years ago -

and if the buyer/seller is a no show, will their feedback option be disabled (and the one that did show could still leave it)? (and how will you decide if someone is being malicous or truthful that the other was a no show -so their feedback option is disabled?) (does that make sense?) Also, would their be a "disputing" option? (like if a buyer was 10 minutes late and the seller leaves - feedback) (or if a seller doesn't accept an "offer" and the buyer takes it personally, and leaves a buyer - feedback). How much time will you (adam) have to spend on the maintence (monitoring/disputes/etc)? 

Fancy --- 19 years ago -

I think a rating system would be better, such as "thumbs up" and "thumbs down"; for the seller meaning "showed-no showed" and the buyer meaning "item was available-non selling seller". I personally think leaving comments on a site such as KYS is NOT a good idea. I can see some of the comments already, lol. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

In order for that type of system to work, the buyer and seller must agree to use the KYS feature to schedule their appointment. I don't use KYS very often. I've sold a couple of things there. If I find an item for sale then I'm going to call the seller and setup an appointment. I wouldn't use the online 'schedule' feature. If they insist that I use it before they will meet with me then I will won't buy from them. 

Fancy --- 19 years ago -

Also, would their be a "disputing" option? (like if a buyer was 10 minutes late and the seller leaves - feedback) (or if a seller doesn't accept an "offer" and the buyer takes it personally, and leaves a buyer - feedback). the control would be that both parties would agree on the time before any feedback could be provided. they would need to agree on time AND PRICE. So they negotiate on site, and then buyer confirms appt, and then 24 hours after scheduled appt. they would be able to leave feedback, or the thumbs rating I suggested (please no comments...EEEKKK) I really hate when a buyer wants an item and then tries to negotiate at the door. Not cool! 

Fancy --- 19 years ago -

I wouldn't use the online 'schedule' feature. If they insist that I use it before they will meet with me then I will won't buy from them. I love the idea of confirming appts. and if a buyer wouldn't agree to confirm, I wouldn't waste my time selling to them. If a buyer can't commit, they probably won't show anyway. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

If a buyer can't commit, they probably won't show anyway. What about the people that aren't even registered users of KYS? Do you expect them to create a user ID just so that they can buy something from a classified Ad? Nobody wants to buy something so badly that they're gonna go through all that trouble. It's the sellers loss, the buyer will go elsewhere. 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

I love the idea of confirming appts. and if a buyer wouldn't agree to confirm, I wouldn't waste my time selling to them. If a buyer can't commit, they probably won't show anyway Absolutely! I agree! I never give out my phone number for buyers to call me unless they are on their way and get lost or it is a big item. I love KYS because I don't have to mess w/ taking calls. I love the online idea. 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

Nobody wants to buy something so badly that they're gonna go through all that trouble. Sure they do! Or they wouldn't waste their time scrolling through the hundreds of KYS pages. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Sure they do! Or they wouldn't waste their time scrolling through the hundreds of KYS pages. There's a search feature on KYS, no need to scroll through hundreds of pages. 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

Very true... 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

I always forget about the search feature. People call things so many different names I always scroll through it all. 

khshops!! --- 19 years ago -

the control would be that both parties would agree on the time before any feedback could be provided. and??? so, they agree on the time (activating the feedback system), then the buyer is still late or the seller doesn't want to negotiate prices at the door. that is when they go home, and leave - feedback. ~that is where the dispute comes in; the buyer DID show (late, but showed), or the seller DID have a quality item for sale (just not wanting to take 50% off at the door). Therefore, a dispute would be e-mailed to Adam, by either 1 or both parties, causing Adam to have to go through each e-mail/case individually. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Here's a scenario: Currently there's a lot of sippy cups for sale on KYS for $5. It's on the front page. Someone notices the ad and is interested. They click 'contact seller' then enter their email address, etc. At this point the seller is going to demand that the buyer create a KYS account and setup an appointment before the will sell their Sippy cups to them? The sellers who do this will be losing out on lots of sales. I'm not sure what the market is. Are the majority of KYS users people who browse ads for small items then run from seller to seller buying things or are they casual users who don't have accounts? 

Fancy --- 19 years ago -

Nobody wants to buy something so badly that they're gonna go through all that trouble. It's the sellers loss, the buyer will go elsewhere. either you haven't sold much on KYS, or you are the most laid back seller ever with nothing but time on your hands. No shows are a HUGE problem here. They waste everyones time with total disregard. I think I'd rather lose a few sales than have to keep dealing with the no-shows. It is that huge of a problem. 

Fancy --- 19 years ago -

so, they agree on the time (activating the feedback system), then the buyer is still late or the seller doesn't want to negotiate prices at the door. that is when they go home, and leave - feedback. ~that is where the dispute comes in; the buyer DID show (late, but showed), or the seller DID have a quality item for sale (just not wanting to take 50% off at the door). I suggest that the feedback option initiate 24 hours after the scheduled appt. That way no one can just blast anyone with immediate feedback, and either party has 24 hrs. to make it right. 

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

At this point the seller is going to demand that the buyer create a KYS account and setup an appointment before the will sell their Sippy cups to them? in my head, setting up a schedule would be an OPTION....you could still email them or chat with them directly. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

either you haven't sold much on KYS, or you are the most laid back seller ever with nothing but time on your hands. No shows are a HUGE problem here. They waste everyones time with total disregard. I think I'd rather lose a few sales than have to keep dealing with the no-shows. It is that huge of a problem. I've sold a few items ranging from $100-$900. I made arrangements by phone to meet the buyers in person. Most of them showed up within 30 minutes of the 'appointment'. Communication is key. 

Fancy --- 19 years ago -

I've always had buyers for higher priced items show as well, because they know they are getting a deal. I communicate as well. It's thebuyers of lower priced items that I have ALOT of problems with. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

in my head, setting up a schedule would be an OPTION....you could still email them or chat with them directly. If the system was optional then I think it's a good idea. Then it's up to the seller if they want to 'chance it' or lose out on a sale. Again, just brainstorming here. I have no idea what the majority's buying/selling behaviour is on KYS. 

Fancy --- 19 years ago -

additionally, I have not sold "a few items", I have sold a ton of items, and no shows are a huge problem. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

kys


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground