Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

2007 Child Safety Seat Ratings

who's talking here?

Paige 1
Unichic 5
MomofTwins 4
Scottie's Hottie 1
justmy2cents 1
likeke27 1
Valentine 4
mdawg 1
Mygirl01 18
Dentalgal 2
Kim 1
2girlygirls 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

To help you pick what car seat/booster is right for you, here is a website that has all the seat listed and what they offer, you may be surprised at what you find. Here is the site it is from the NHTSA, and if anyone knows how to get the link to work please do, I just don't know how. http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/CPS/CSSRating/Index.cfm 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

After reading this, I know my daughter is safe in her seat. I don't feel the need to rush out and buy some other high dollar seat that the media and internet has attempted to brain wash me into believing it is a safer seat. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

Car Seat Safety Report 

Unichic --- 19 years ago -

Well, it figures my seats are not listed lol. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

Well, it figures my seats are not listed lol. what seat do you have?? 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

Scottie's Hottie Thanks for the link! 

Kim --- 19 years ago -

Thanks for posting this MYgirl. I feel better about our seats after reading this. 

Valentine --- 19 years ago -

So this is only grading the convenience of the seats, not how they perform in an accident, right? I'd like to know how some perform in an accident. We've got 3 Cosco Alpha Omega Elite's in our back seat and it is SO crowded. I'm wondering how the Graco Highback Booster performs. I've been thinking about getting them for my big kids (who are just barely over 30 pounds). Anyone know where to get that info? Thanks for the link. You've got me thinking now! :) 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

I feel better about our seats after reading this That is why i posted it. You are welcome! Hopefully more people will read it and see that their child is in a safe seat afterall! 

Unichic --- 19 years ago -

I have the Cosco Apex seats in my car. They are forward facing up to 65 lbs. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

What you need to keep in mind is the securing your child section of the report. If your child is secure their chances of injury are lessened. You can not have a magic seat that is going to protect every child. What is important is that the child is sercured in a seat and if it is easy to meet that goal, then you child is safer. The "best" car seat will fail if you can not install it properly or or if you can not properly secure your child in the seat. So, I like knowing that I can easily install my seat and properly get my child in and out of it, because this is what makes a seat safe. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

And it tells you which seat have higher weight limits and what harness systems they have. I want people to know that there are other options for the features that they are wanting in a seat. 

Dentalgal --- 19 years ago -

The only reason I got the Regent was beacause it was one of the few carseats that my ds could be in a 5 point harness up to 80 lbs. I read in the Kyle Miller story as well as a friend, that the seat belt failed (which can happen) and the child was thrown from the car. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

I have the Cosco Apex seats in my car Is it manufactured under another name possibly? 

Unichic --- 19 years ago -

EW, I finally found mine. They are under Safety first Apex and my car seat is rated a B - HUM. I bought it because it is a forward facing 5-point harness seat up to 65 lbs. My taller 6.5 year old is using it, as well as my little girl who just turned 5. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

Most of the 5 point harness system have a 52-53 inche high limit, so they are not intended for a taller child. People need to look at all of the limits, not just the one for weight. I know my dd would exceed the height limit way before she got to the 65 pounds. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

If you have a child that is tall, they may need to be in the seat belt and not the harness because it can restrict them. Think of the build your child has, I hear moms say all the time that their seat is rated for 100 pounds, but if they checked the height requirement the child may not be able to use it for that entire time...they may outgrow the seat in height first. 

MomofTwins --- 19 years ago -

Everyone seems to be mad that Britax is expensive and taking over the car seat market. The simple truth is this: A 5-point harness that is holding your child in at the shoulders, waist and between the legs will out perform a 3-point seatbelt HANDS DOWN everytime. I don't care if it is Graco, Cosco, Britax, whatever. A five point harness is SAFER. A Graco is just as safe as a Britax (they are all crash-tested) until 40 pounds. The Britax seats are geared to those who want their kids harnessed after they reach 40 pounds. They are not safer, just can be used longer. More expensive, because it requires a certain technology to restrain an 80 pound kid in a 5-pt harness during a crash. Think about the old roller coasters you ride on - they just have a bar in front, right? The faster, newer ones have a harness that pulls down over your head. Which do you feel safer in? Mygirl01 - I agree with you; a car seat must be used correctly everytime to be safe. We all do the best we can for our kids. 

MomofTwins --- 19 years ago -

Valentine is right - the chart is geared towards Ease of Use, not necessarily how safe it is. A car seat that is easy to install is more likely to be used correctly and is therefore safer than an incorrectly installed car seat. European car seats are usually tested to a higher standard than the US seats, but I think the NHTSA is not going to put an unsafe seat out there. 

Unichic --- 19 years ago -

Well, he will probably have only another 6months to a year in the seat. Honestly, I bought one of these seats new off ebay for $95 including shipping (that is good) when my 4.5 year old's buckle casing cracked on her alpha omega. It was not a replaceable part and our seat was still covered, so they asked me what I would like to have in it's place and I picked the Apex only because it would allow my son to sit in a 5-point a little longer. YOu are right though, he will certainly outgrow the seat height-wise before weight. He is 49lbs and almost the max. height. 

MomofTwins --- 19 years ago -

Valentine - Booster seats are rated to 30 pounds, but some people recommend you don't use them until 40 pounds, as in a roll-over accident, they may slip out of the belt. Depends on how your kids are built, though. We used boosters when our kids travelled and were younger (age 3) - I wasn't crazy about it, but it worked fine. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

we use the little booster seat for my 6 year old sometimes depends on which car he is in. 

Dentalgal --- 19 years ago -

If you are in an accdident Britax will also replace you carseat. I didn't find that out until I bought it, which I thought says a lot. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

Everyone seems to be mad that Britax is expensive and taking over the car seat market. I don't know if anyone is mad about this. I just think parents should know that there are seats that are just as safe, without feeling bad for placing their child in that seat. A Graco is just as safe as a Britax (they are all crash-tested) until 40 pounds. Correct, They have no testing that proves that your child is safer in anything after 40 pounds, it is just speculated that they are safer. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

Valentine is right - the chart is geared towards Ease of Use, not necessarily how safe it is. A car seat that is easy to install is more likely to be used correctly and is therefore safer than an incorrectly installed car seat. If you can use the seat correctly, it is safer than a "better seat" that is being used incorrectly. This is from The Texas Childrens wedbsite. Children in car seats not always secure The number of children who travel in car seats has increased, according to the Greater Houston Safe Kids Coalition, but just because little ones are buckled up does not mean they are safe. “Of more than 1,200 seats we checked last year, greater than 90 percent were not installed correctly,” said Susan Hirtz, manager of the Texas Children’s Center for Childhood Injury Prevention and coalition coordinator. “If a car seat is not installed right, it cannot effectively protect the child. In an effort to teach parents how to properly install car seats, Texas Children’s Center for Childhood Injury Prevention coordinates the coalition’s free car seat check-ups at different locations around Houston. Certified instructors conduct the checks, which are scheduled throughout the year, to make sure car seats are appropriate for a child. If the seat does not fit well, inspectors show parents how to properly fit the seats. Each instructor has completed a 32-hour, four-day training course to learn to correctly install safety seats. “There are three easy tips parents need to remember,” said Javier Valdez, car passenger safety instructor with the Texas Children’s Center for Childhood Injury Prevention. “Parents should read the instructions for the child safety seat or booster seat, read the vehicle owner’s manual and test for a snug, secure fit.” A child safety seat must be held securely against the vehicle seat back, Valdez said. A safety seat should not move more than an inch from side to side or from front to back when parents pull the seat hard at the belt paths. Correctly installing the seat and securing the child in it are both important; however, using the right type of seat for the child’s age and weight is crucial. Car seats for infants Infants younger than 1 year who weigh 20 pounds or less must ride in rear-facing infant seats placed in the back seat of the vehicle. Bigger babies in the same age group may be placed in a convertible safety seat also facing the rear of the car until the child’s first birthday. Car safety for older children When a child weighs 20 to 40 pounds, a convertible seat may be used. A child who weighs more than 40 pounds or whose ears show over the top of the convertible seat should ride in a high-back booster seat with a safety harness. Once children can sit against the back of the seat and bend their legs over the seat edge, they safely may use seat belts. But Hirtz said 4 to 8 year olds less than 4 feet 9 inches tall are about four times safer in booster seats than in seatbelts. Children should continue to ride in the back seat until the age of 12, secured by the vehicle’s shoulder and lap belt. Airbags make riding in the front seat especially hazardous for children. Get more information on car seat safety and on free, car-seat safety checks 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

Protecting your most precious cargo: Texas Children’s shares best practices for keeping kids safe in the car HOUSTON (Feb. 13, 2006) – The birth of a new baby is reason to celebrate, but it also can cause great anxiety for the new parents. Installation of the car seat – for many – can be the greatest challenge, but one of the most critical of responsibilities for the new mom and dad. Child restraints, including car seats, child seats and booster seats – when installed correctly – save lives. “According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, four out of five children’s safety restraints are installed incorrectly,” said Susan Hirtz, manager of Texas Children’s Center for Injury Prevention. “Children are exposed to the risk of injury and death everyday when they are not properly restrained while riding in vehicles.” The most common mistakes parents and caregivers make in the installation of car seats include: Not using the right type of child safety seat according to the child’s weight and height. For instance, an infant under the age of 1, should be restrained in a rear-facing car seat. Infants require complete support for the head and neck. This is necessary because in comparison to the rest of the body, a baby’s head weighs so much more and the neck is weak. If a child is properly restrained in a rear-facing car seat during a crash, the crash forces will settle on the strongest part of the baby’s body – the shoulders and back. Installing the seat too loosely. The seat should not move more than an 1 inch when grabbing the seat at the belt path and moving side to side or forward. The parent should put weight on the seat and pull the safety belt as tight. Not using the correct belt path. Car seats can be cumbersome and a little confusing; parents need to make sure they are using the correct belt path when installing a child passenger seat. Not using the harness clip correctly. The harness clip snaps the vertical and horizontal straps together. It should be at armpit level – many parents have it at the child’s belly. That is too low. “Infants and children depend on adults to make safe decisions for them,” said Javier Valdez, a health educator with Texas Children’s Center for Childhood Injury Prevention. “If a parent has the slightest bit of doubt about how they’ve installed a car seat, I strongly encourage them to have a certified child passenger safety technician take a look at it. It could save your child’s life.” 

Valentine --- 19 years ago -

oh man... I just got our new Alpha Omega for the baby last week, now I don't know what to do. I'm thinking I should return it and get new seats for the big kids instead- the Radian, maybe; then the baby can use one of the old Alpha Omegas. Ugh... you people are making my brain work too much this morning! lol 

2girlygirls --- 19 years ago -

If you are in an accdident Britax will also replace you carseat. I didn't find that out until I bought it, which I thought says a lot. Your insurance should cover replacement of a carseat after an accident. When I called in my claim, the agent told me that the seat should be replaced and to give them the receipt and they reimbursed me for it. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

I'm thinking I should return it and get new seats for the big kids instead Keep your seat and just make sure it is installed properly. This is my point, there are people and websites that make us as parents question what we are doing for our kids. If you have yor child in a seat that is right for them (age, weight and height) and that seat is properly installed in your car, then you child is safe. You do not have to run out and buy some high dollar seat to protect your child, you just have to use the one you have correctly. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

Your insurance should cover replacement of a carseat after an accident True, but the person I know that this happened to didn't have to have a receipt, it was just added to the total of the damages. You should never reuse a seat that has been in any accident. This is the number one reason I feel that resale shops should not sell used car seats, you never know what that seat has had happen to it. 

Valentine --- 19 years ago -

You do not have to run out and buy some high dollar seat to protect your child, you just have to use the one you have correctly. Well, I realize that. I'm just thinking long term. I would prefer that my children ride in a large molded seat and 5 pt. harness for as long as possible- without even looking at crash test ratings, it just SEEMS like it would be safer. My twins are right at 30 pounds now, so they will outgrow the harness on the Omega probably in the next year. We're talking about a $160 seat here, so in a year I'll have 2 $160 seats we can't/ won't use anymore. ?? 

Unichic --- 19 years ago -

The alpha omega is a great seat. I am talking about a crack in the plastic that surrounds the buckle (red button part) on the 5-point harness. It probably would not affect anything, but I thought I could get that part replaced (I was nearing the end of my 7 year warranty). Instead they gave me a whole new seat - lucky me!! 

Valentine --- 19 years ago -

Not to mention, the Sunshine Radian is more narrow than the Omega, thus less for me to reach across to secure the baby in his seat. Ugh, it's killing me to reach across those dang Omegas to get that 20# baby in his seat! Okay, now I think we need new car seats AND a new car- a mini van!! lol 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

without even looking at crash test ratings, There are no ratings for these seats after 40 pounds, it is not required and the company wouldn't want to risk a bad outcome. You have to feel comfortable with the seats you are using. For me, my dd is very tall and very skinny. So the seats with the high pounds don't appeal to me...I would be surprised if my dd was 100 by the time she got to high school (I wasn't) so I tend to look at the seats that have a higher height requirement and those that are for taller kids use the regular seat belts not the harness systems. 

MomofTwins --- 19 years ago -

A harness is always safer than a seat belt, you cannot argue that. Correct, They have no testing that proves that your child is safer in anything after 40 pounds, it is just speculated that they are safer. Britax seats are crash tested to a higher weight limit - there is no speculation involved. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

Britax seats are crash tested to a higher weight limit - there is no speculation involved. Where do you find this information? I think that people who are in the market for these seats would like to see the crash results if they exsist and are public information. 

mdawg --- 19 years ago -

I had the Alpha Omega 7 1/2 years ago. Used it till I felt it was too much for the car. It was great! Now she is in my opinion to old for a seat. But her grandparents believe otherwise. So here when we are on vacation she rides in a Graco Booster. She likes it. I do have two of the same for her at home, but she doesn't like to use it there, says it's too babyish and she was made fun of from her friends. I guess it's not cool for a 3rd grader to be in! :P 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

What is the height on the Britax Regent? I know those suckers are built to last. My 4 (soon to be 5) year old is 45 in. and it still has plenty of clearance over his head. I see your point Mygirl and fully understand what you mean about your kid being safe in a properly installed car seat. Your right, you don't have to run out and buy an expensive car seat, but it sure made me feel better :-) Personally, I know my kids probably could have been safe in another seat, but I in the Britax I have the peace of mind knowing there is no doubt they are in one of the safer car seats for their height/size/build. Hands down, there is no way I would feel comfortable with them in a seat belt booster- no where, no how, no way. This is just my opinion and my choice for my kids :-)Doesn;t mean anyone else has to think that way :-) I think you just need to feel good w/ your personal choice and most importantly READ the manual. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

What is the height on the Britax Regent? Here you go, it is 53 inches for that seat. Britax Regent E9L39C5 (01-05-2006) 5-pt 22-80lbs/up to 53" I see your point Mygirl and fully understand what you mean about your kid being safe in a properly installed car seat. Your right, you don't have to run out and buy an expensive car seat That is all I want people to understand, if your seat is properly installed and you are using it correctly, then your child is safe. If there was this magic seat that could save every child's life in every situation then there would only be one seat availible to purchase. You need to know how to properly work the seat your child rides in, like I said before The "safest" seat out there is worthless if it is improperly installed or being used incorrectly. 

justmy2cents --- 19 years ago -

THAT REPORT DOES NOT RATE THEM IN CRASH TESTS!!!!!!!!!!! Crash ratings is all that matters! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
parenting


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground