Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

for you bb... confirmation thread

who's talking here?

JerseyGirl 1
cmi 1
bbjones 21
karenact 5
GHYC 3
XCPuff 6
Hardshell 1
Going off air 2
ChezML 4
SugarCookie 1
Setta-Don-Naw 1
Dane 11
bethiepoo01 14

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

karenact --- 19 years ago -

It is basically instruction in the church and faith BEFORE allowing communion. Communion is a sacred privilege and confirmation was done in order to be sure the child was ready for it. It would be similar to CCE at the catholic church. It is not usually required that the parents be a member, however the child will most likely be a member after completion.... 4X4 it is way different Confirmation is received after first communion in our church (Catholic Church)  

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I look at both of those "different" definitions or understandings (Did God tell us two different things?) and have to repeat my questions: Can someone please show me where God instructs this practice in the Bible? Where does God call a Communion ritual a sacred privilege? 

karenact --- 19 years ago -

I did couple of months back and you and your gang had my non offensive comments kindly deleted. Remember? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I did couple of months back and you and your gang had my non offensive comments kindly deleted. Remember? I do not have a gang and I do not flag debates, therefore, I did not flag your response nor did I ask anyone to flag it. My questions still stand. 

karenact --- 19 years ago -

Well I apologize then I thought you did. I can't imagine why the definition of catholic confirmation was kindly deleted ... oh well ... when I have time to repost I will. This time I will make a back up of it so I don't have to re type it again. 

JerseyGirl --- 19 years ago -

Yes, I remember that bb started stuff after I mentioned that my son was just confirmed in the catholic church. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Yes, I remember that bb started stuff after I mentioned that my son was just confirmed in the catholic church. I do not want to cause hard feelings, but what did I start? Telling people the truth of God's Word is me starting something? If that is your criteria for "starting something", then it could be said that you "started something" by posting unbiblical practices. I know that you do not agree, but your practices come form a doctrine created by men and are contrary to what God tells us in the Bible. That is why I asked "Can someone please show me where God instructs this practice in the Bible?". Can you do that for me? 

Dane --- 19 years ago -

All BB is saying is back it up with scripture. Please do. Before this one gets really ugly, remember each religion does interpret somethings different ways. From Methodist(don't drink in front of fellow church members), Baptist(no dancing) Catholics (gotta love a Polish wedding) to the JW's (my biological father turned into one of them, just a really strange experience as a kid). You may not agree, as a Methodist, with a Catholic, but that's what this country was founded on. BB is a VERY knowledgable person. Not shutting you down, karen, just saying "Show me". 

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

"Can someone please show me where God instructs this practice in the Bible?". Can you do that for me? No one can.....it's not there...... 

karenact --- 19 years ago -

I have other things I am working on this morning and no time to type it all out again... perhaps folks should think before they flag ... what I typed in the past was directly from the catechism and the catholic encyclopedia. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

what I typed in the past was directly from the catechism and the catholic encyclopedia. And NEITHER of them is God's Word. Both were authored by men, NOT God. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

I'm not getting into this, but a simple online search produced the following interpretations: Acts 8:14-17 - the people of Samaria were baptized in Christ, but did not receive the fullness of the Spirit until they were confirmed by the elders. Confirmation is a sacrament that Jesus Christ instituted within His Catholic Church to further strengthen those who have reached adulthood. Acts 19:5-6 - the people of Ephesus were baptized in Christ, but Paul laid hands on them to seal them with the Holy Spirit. This sealing refers to the sacrament of confirmation. Eph. 1:13 - Paul writes that the baptized Ephesians were sealed with the promised Holy Spirit, in reference to confirmation. Eph. 4:30 - Paul says the Ephesians were sealed in the Holy Spirit of God, in reference to the sealing of confirmation. Heb. 6:2 - Paul gives instruction to the Hebrews about the laying on of hands, in reference to confirmation, not ordination. The early Church laid hands upon the confirmand to administer the sacrament of confirmation. Heb. 6:2 - this verse also refers to the cycle of life and its relationship to the sacraments - baptism, confirmation, death and judgment - which apply to all people. John 6:27 - Jesus says the Father has set His seal on Him. As the Father sets His seal on Jesus, so Jesus sets His seal on us on the sacrament of baptism, and later, in the sacrament of confirmation. Rev. 9:4 - the locusts could not harm those with the seal of God upon their foreheads. See also Rev. 14:1 and 22:4. 

Dane --- 19 years ago -

what I typed in the past was directly from the catechism and the catholic encyclopedia It may be based on the Catholic Church's interpretation. That's exactly what I meant. Every religion has some sort of "man" who started it all. Who is to say the jews are wrong or the muslims (not the terrorists type)? Were any of us around when all of these religions were started? We worship God in our own way, try to be good people. That's the bottom line. Will the best Catholic or the best Methodist get into heaven? I'm sure if they both try to be good-hearted, God-fearing people, there will be room for both. We all have our beliefs, you will not sway someone who truely believes their religions teachings. My whole step-family is Catholic, I was raised in the UMC. My best friend for 25 years is a Baptist. The over all end result is what matters. He loves us all. 

karenact --- 19 years ago -

there is biblical support of confirmation but like I said I am working on other things right now. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I'm not getting into this, but a simple online search produced the following interpretations: cmi, Those are Catholic explanations of Scripture that have been taken out of context. None of those verses have the word "confirmation" in them, nor do they convey a "concept" of a confirmation process. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

We worship God in our own way, try to be good people. That's the bottom line. Will the best Catholic or the best Methodist get into heaven? I'm sure if they both try to be good-hearted, God-fearing people, there will be room for both. I am sorry Dane, but for people to "try to be good-hearted, God-fearing people" will accomplish nothing towards eternal life. We can do NOTHING because God has already done EVERYTHING for our deliverance from the wages of sin. All we have to do is to BELIEVE that Jesus Christ's sacrifice on the cross was the complete and perfect payment for our sin - for ALL sin. 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

Matt 9:20 And, behold, a woman, which was diseased with an issue of blood twelve years, came behind him, and touched the hem of his garment: Touching Jesus is all that really matters. and Your life...it will never be the same All ya gotta do is reach out and touch him. and BELIEVE when you call on his NAME! Pretty simple if ya ask me. 

bethiepoo01 --- 19 years ago -

I am kindly deleting myself! 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

I am kindly deleting myself! but then where would you go? 

bethiepoo01 --- 19 years ago -

I am kindly deleting myself! but then where would you go? lolol I believe in God, born into a Catholic Family and now non denominational. I have done much research and it is so exausting to venture back into a topic like this. There is no common ground for these debates! 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

Telling people the truth of God's Word is me starting something? I think you mean your opinion of God's Word. Those are Catholic explanations of Scripture that have been taken out of context. None of those verses have the word "confirmation" in them, nor do they convey a "concept" of a confirmation process.  A word does not have to appear in the bible for the spirit of the word to be there. The bible is not black and white in what is says, it calls to each of us in different ways. In finding fault with that is was all this back and forth is all about. It is a battle that will never have a clear winner, because it is not meant too. 

bethiepoo01 --- 19 years ago -

I think you mean your opinion of God's Word.The bible is not black and white in what is says, it calls to each of us in different ways and to find fault with that is was all this back and forth is all about. Could not have said it better myself! 

Dane --- 19 years ago -

We can do NOTHING because God has already done EVERYTHING for our deliverance from the wages of sin. All we have to do is to BELIEVE that Jesus Christ's sacrifice on the cross was the complete and perfect payment for our sin - for ALL sin. So we don't be good people, and instead be mean, hurtful people. It's all good because we are forgiven. I, no matter what religion or Bible says so, have never been able to accept that fact that you can be the worst sinner on earth as long as you accept Jesus. I could go on a killing spree, but it's ok because I'm forgiven. I disagree. We HAVE To and MUST try to be good people in life. I have been baptized but I refuse to stop at that. This is my own personal belief. For so long I have had a huge problem with all organized relion for just that reason. That's where the Sunday hypocrits come in. "Bless you, Brother, Bless you, Sister" all day on Sunday. But the other six days of the week, they are just jerks (not everyone). And that's ok, because they have been given frogiveness? I am pretty sure He doesn't work that way. We have to try. That's my philosophy on the matter. If I am wrong then oh well. I'll be a better person for it. 

Setta-Don-Naw --- 19 years ago -

Once saved always saved...can you not go back to the same river that someone saved you from drowning in and begin to drown again?...you can always go back...hense the name "backsliders" (not biblical name)... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I think you mean your opinion of God's Word. No, I DO NOT mean my opinion of God's Word. God's Word is very clear, especially to the Christian that listens to the teachings of the Holy Spirit. God's Word speaks for itself. A word does not have to appear in the bible for the spirit of the word to be there. I know, that is why I wrote "nor do they convey a "concept" of a confirmation process." The bible is not black and white in what is says, it calls to each of us in different ways. You are wrong about that. The Bible and its Scripture passages have only ONE meaning because they were authored by ONLY one God. The Bible tells us: "But the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost, whom the Father will send in my name, he shall teach you all things, and bring all things to your remembrance, whatsoever I have said unto you." (John 14:26) There is only ONE Holy Sprit that indwells ALL Christians and that Holy Spirit will TEACH every Christian the same thing. Only when the Christian ignores the teachings of the Holy Spirit, do they understand something in a different way that is CONTRADICTORY to God's Word. In finding fault with that is was all this back and forth is all about. It is a battle that will never have a clear winner, because it is not meant too. Which Bible are you reading? There is a clear winner. Jesus Christ has overcome this world that adheres to satan's views. The Word of Jesus Christ is the TRUTH, the ONLY TRUTH because THERE IS ONLY ONE WORD! 

XCPuff --- 19 years ago -

lol I love these threads. Baptist > Catholicism Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket 

Dane --- 19 years ago -

out 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

So we don't be good people, and instead be mean, hurtful people. It's all good because we are forgiven. I, no matter what religion or Bible says so, have never been able to accept that fact that you can be the worst sinner on earth as long as you accept Jesus. I could go on a killing spree, but it's ok because I'm forgiven. I disagree. We HAVE To and MUST try to be good people in life. No, WE do not have to TRY. ALL we have to do is to submit to the Holy Spirit that indwells us, in other words - do nothing on our own, and let God do good works through us. If we try, we can not do good works. "This I say then, Walk in the Spirit, and ye shall not fulfill the lust of the flesh. For the flesh lusteth against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh: and these are contrary the one to the other: so that ye cannot do the things that ye would. But if ye be led of the Spirit, ye are not under the law. Now the works of the flesh are manifest, which are these; Adultery, fornication, uncleanness, lasciviousness, Idolatry, witchcraft, hatred, variance, emulations, wrath, strife, seditions, heresies, Envyings, murders, drunkenness, revellings, and such like: of the which I tell you before, as I have also told you in time past, that they which do such things shall not inherit the kingdom of God." (Galatians 5:16-21) To "Walk in the Spirit" means for us to allow Jesus Christ to guide our lives. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Once saved always saved...can you not go back to the same river that someone saved you from drowning in and begin to drown again?...you can always go back...hense the name "backsliders" (not biblical name)... YES Setta, once a person has received salvation, they cannot lose it nor will it be taken from them! 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

An opinion. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Chez, it IS NOT an opinion. It is what God clearly tells us. His Word is not an opinion. It is the truth of how things will be done! 

Dane --- 19 years ago -

This is great, if we were all perfect Christians. There was only one of those. That's why I say this requires effort on our part. Don't try, go on letting the Holy Spirit guide us. Theoretically, that would be ideal. I, personally, have to give myself a jolt every now and then. A wake up call, to remind me of what's going on in my life and how to deal with it. I try to put it in His hands, but I don't always get an answer fast enough or if I do, I don't see it. I would love to coast along being guided through life and never make the wrong decisions about anything. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

lol I love these threads. Baptist > Catholicism XCPuff, this thread is not about Baptist vs Catholic. It is about God's views vs man's views. 

XCPuff --- 19 years ago -

XCPuff, this thread is not about Baptist vs Catholic. It is about God's views vs man's views. So... Your views vs Gods Views 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

You are wrong about that. The Bible and its Scripture passages have only ONE meaning because they were authored by ONLY one God. The Bible tells us: And as usually that is your opinion, where in the bible does it say cut and dry that their is only one meaning exactly those words that because it does not appear in the bible. No one is saying your wrong just that you have an opinion that you are stating. YES Setta, once a person has received salvation, they cannot lose it nor will it be taken from them! Also an opinion because the bible does not state that word for word anywhere. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I would love to coast along being guided through life and never make the wrong decisions about anything. You would never make wrong decisions if you will make the decisions that God wants you to make. Everything is in His time, not when you think that it is not "fast enough". 

GHYC --- 19 years ago -

It is about God's views vs man's views.  You mean God's views vs man's opinions of God's views. 

XCPuff --- 19 years ago -

Also an opinion because the bible does not state that word for word anywhere. I agree. I was once proclaimed "saved" and was very devout, however these days... well you probably saw my thread from a while back. I'm sure if I died today and I was face to face with God, he would not consider me saved. 

Dane --- 19 years ago -

BB have you ever had to make a split second decision and it absolutely, without a doubt turned out to be the wrong one? I have. I am full aware that everything is in His own time. I know that some people say no answer is an answer. To me, that starts to leave alot of gray area in the matter. I know we are having a debate, and I am sooooo proud that this thread has not gone the way of the others. I guess I have alot of internal conflict with this issue because of all I have gone through and seen in my life. We can't debate that away. I will continue to approach things the best way I know how. I try to further my education in these matters. I want to learn. I want to be a good person. I pray for these, but most of all, I pray for wisdom constantly. I believe by doing that, I am guided in the right direction. I find it strange the more I pray for wisdom, the more of a philosophical delemma I find myself in. I guess, we should all pray for each other, I'll continue to pray for wisdom, and we will see how this all turns out at a latter date. 

bethiepoo01 --- 19 years ago -

Chez, it IS NOT an opinion. It is what God clearly tells us. His Word is not an opinion. It is the truth of how things will be done! If this were true there would not be different religions right? Everyone takes what they want from the words that they read! So you are saying that YOUR opinion is the truth? What if your opinion is not the way it should be taken or given and you have given a false meaning, isn;t that a sin? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground