Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Serious history question....

who's talking here?

JDB2 1
MissT 2
2131MR 1
Lilteapot 1
bbjones 2
planemom 1
lilmommy 6
amb07 1
jemezchick 2
cowboyswife 1
*harpo* 1
mamajulie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Ok I've got to go to bed but I have had this on my mind since my son asked me about it. My son is a huge history buff. He loves anything to do with history, especially American history. Today he starts telling me how the south is only republican and the north is only democrat. And then he drops the bomb on me. He tells me that his teacher told him this is the reason for the civil war. His teacher told him that we went to Africa and took slaves forcefully. Now, I'm not the biggest history buff but if my memory serves me correctly, didn't we purchase slaves from the African Govt.? I may be wrong. But I'm almost positive this is what we were taught up north. Do they teach it differently down south? Or am I all wrong? Oh, and I moved down south my senior year. I was kicked out of class for saying that the north won the war. He wouldn't allow that to be said in his class. So, I'm wondering how different the south and north teachings are? This is a serious question and I would like serious answers please. I know that's out of character for me, but humor me please. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

I must have slept through that one...:) 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Are you serious? I just don't want to start screaming at my child that his teacher is all wrong. And I also am wondering if it's just taught differently here than up north. 

Lilteapot --- 19 years ago -

link title this should help! 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

It has been awhile since I took US History I. So this is from a 10 year old memory. We purchased slaves from slave trading companies. Some were based out of the US other were based out of other places. I don't recall the African govt selling slaves. The north DID win the war! Today he starts telling me how the south is only republican and the north is only democrat. And then he drops the bomb on me. He tells me that his teacher told him this is the reason for the civil war. It sounds like his teacher needs to go back to school. 

mamajulie --- 19 years ago -

I am sure that some were purchased, but many were tracked down and captured, put in chains etc, The south was mainly democratic for many years, if I am remembering correctly the south started swinging to the republican side in the 80's with the Regan Republicans. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Thank you for clearing that up... I was seriously thinking I may need to check out these books and see if they were different from the northern ones. I know this is a touchy subject and my son always asks me why I get so upset talking about it. But I was seriously thinking that I might have to take him back up north to get an unbiased teaching if that is what they teach in the south. And yes, his teacher needs to go back to school. Heck, she's just a baby herself. She's 23. Barely old enough to wipe her own butt. LOL 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Maybe I should have clarified my previous post a little more. He thought that we invaded Africa and forcefully captured them. And I sure as heck didn't remember that happening. But I wanted to see if that is just what they teach down south before I tell him just how wrong his teacher is. 

*harpo* --- 19 years ago -

We need MissT, for this one. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

I just found this on wikipedia: African slave market Europeans usually bought slaves who were captured in wars between African kingdoms and chiefdoms, or from Africans who had made a business out of capturing Africans and selling them. Europeans provided a large new market for an already-existing trade, and while an African held in slavery in his own region of Africa might escape or be traded back to his own people, a person shipped away was sure never to return. People living around the Niger River were transported from these markets to the coast and sold at European trading ports in exchange for muskets and manufactured goods such as cloth or alcohol. Europeans rarely entered the interior of Africa, due to fear of disease and moreover fierce African resistance. They would be brought to coastal outposts where they would be traded for goods. Enslavement also became a major by-product of war in Africa as nation states expanded through military conflicts in many cases through deliberate sponsorship of benefiting European nations. During such periods of rapid state formation or expansion (Asante or Dahomey being good examples), slavery formed an important element of political life which the Europeans exploited: As Queen Sara's plea to the Portuguese courts revealed, the system became "sell to the Europeans or be sold to the Europeans". In Africa, convicted criminals could be punished by enslavement and with European demands for slaves, this punishment became more prevalent. Since most of these nations did not have a prison system, convicts were often sold or used in the scattered local domestic slave market. [9] The majority of European conquests occurred toward the end or after the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade. One exception to this is the conquest of Ndongo in Angola where warriors, citizens and even nobility were taken into slavery after the fall of the state. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

We need MissT, for this one. That's exactly what I was hoping for. I know slaves were sold as property after they were here. But for the life of me, I can't remember that we went into their country and took them against their will. Granted they were held against their will once here. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

The north wouldn't have a chance today!!! 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

The north wouldn't have a chance today!!! LOL. Thank you me... You answered my question perfectly. I can now tell my son that his teacher was wrong and that I was right. Well basically. I want my children to know the truth about slavery. It is a painful part of our past I know but it is better to have correct knowledge than false knowledge about such a disgusting and disgraceful time in history. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

If you've seen the movie "Amazing Grace" it tells alot. It's about the guy who wrote the hymn..... he was a slave trader (a private businessman) and he was haunted by all the souls that had died while on his ships. He became a monk and lived the rest of his days in a cathedral. Is there any truth in what the teacher said? Well.......Slaves WERE taken against their will. Was this the cause of the Civil War? Yes and No. If there had not been any slavery, there would have never been the issue of the South wanting to leave the Union. So it was also about the constitutional argument over whether or not a state had a right to leave the Union. Actually the majority of Southerners had little interest in slaves, slavery was a primary interest of Southern politicians, and consequently the underlying cause of the South's desire to seek independence and state rights. 

amb07 --- 19 years ago -

does it matter if they were "bought" or not? 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

So it was also about the constitutional argument over whether or not a state had a right to leave the Union. Actually the majority of Southerners had little interest in slaves, slavery was a primary interest of Southern politicians, and consequently the underlying cause of the South's desire to seek independence and state rights. It wasn't only about whether or not States could leave the union but how much control the Federal Gov't had over the states. I was in college before that was even mentioned in a history class. I also believe given more time slavery would have dispappeared in the South just like it did in the North. The large influx of immigrants made keeping slaves more expensive than paying an Irishman, or any other recent immigrant. That is why slavery went away in the North. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

I also believe given more time slavery would have dispappeared in the South just like it did in the North. right, the South just didn't want to wait it out.. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Slaves WERE taken against their will. But not by white people. They were captured and enslaved, as jemezchick pointed out, in wars between African kingdoms and chiefdoms, or from Africans who had made a business out of capturing Africans and selling them. They were purchased from Africans. 

2131MR --- 19 years ago -

Hello, I am Deltadawn's husband. Before we go and string up that teacher we need to examine a few things. First, by 1866, all of the former Confederate states were run by Republicans. This is because none of the former Confederate soldiers and supporters were allowed to vote, and African Americans were allowed to vote. This situation didn't last very long. By 1877, all of the former Confederate states were under Democratic contol and most had passed a series of Jim Crow laws that established legalized segregation or Aparthied. While the slave trade had existed in Africa long before the use of slavery in North America, the demand for slaves created by the North American market ripped apart West African society. A blow from which it has never completely recovered. For the most part, the captives were purchased from local leaders, often little more than bandits and kidnap gangs, sometimes from the legitimate rulers of a kingdom. Occassionally, the europeans did bother to get their hands dirty and take captives as well. In America, both northerners and southerners took part in the slave trade. Southerners used the labor, northerers financed the trade. Many of the major banks in the north built their fortunes by financing the slave trade. Many other northern industries produced the tools of the slave trade. No matter where you lived in the country, no one's hands were clean in regards to the slave trade. Anyway, before we go and hang this teacher, find out exactly what she said and why she said it. She may well have been inaccurate, it wouldn't be the first time that a teacher has misspoke, but it's also possible that she has been misquoted or taken out of context. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

While the slave trade had existed in Africa long before the use of slavery in North America, the demand for slaves created by the North American market ripped apart West African society. A blow from which it has never completely recovered. I disagree. That statements seems to be totally false. From the statistics that I found, "slaves were needed on plantations and for mines and the majority was shipped to Brazil, the Caribbean, and the Spanish Empire. Less than 5% travelled to the Northern American States formally held by the British." Brazil imported 8 times as many slaves as did North America. Read the full account here. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground