Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Dyslexia 'is just a middle-class way to hide stupidity'

who's talking here?

poodle_lover 1
stampin' gal 2
I Love Horses 3
Danabug(BCM) 1
Sandyr9111 2
Hardshell 2
CyberSage 1
movedagain 2
Deltadawn 1
Going off air 1
lonesophist 5
Mr Mark 1
Mabbers 5
iwaveatcows 1
Cicero 1
Beach 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

Dyslexia 'is just a middle-class way to hide stupidity' By REBECCA CAMBER. The Daily Mail. ©2007 Associated Newspapers Ltd Dyslexia is a social fig leaf used by middle-class parents who fear their children will be labelled as low achievers, a professor has claimed. Julian Elliott, a leading educational psychologist at Durham University, says he has found no evidence to identify dyslexia as a medical condition after more than 30 years of research. "There is a huge stigma attached to low intelligence," he said. "After years of working with parents, I have seen how they don't want their child to be considered lazy, thick or stupid. "If they get called this medically diagnosed term, dyslexic, then it is a signal to all that it's not to do with intelligence." He added: "There are all sorts of reasons why people don't read well but we can't determine why that is. Dyslexia, as a term, is becoming meaningless." One in ten people in the UK - including 375,000 schoolchildren - has been diagnosed with dyslexia. The condition is said to impair short-term memory and the ability to read, write, spell and do maths. Supporters of the condition argue that dyslexics are intelligent people who have difficulties processing information and need extra help and time than others who are poor readers. But Professor Elliott has claimed that the symptoms of dyslexia - such as clumsiness and letter reversal - are similar to those seen in those who simply cannot read. He argues that the condition should be rediagnosed as a reading difficulty. His comments provoked fury among dyslexia campaigners. John Rack, head of research and development at the charity Dyslexia Action, denied that the disability was a middle-class phenomenon. He told The Times: "There is ample evidence that dyslexia exists across the spectrum and the argument that there is no consistent means of identifying it is one cited by people who don't know enough about the subject." However, other experts have suggested that parents are putting their children forward for reading ability assessments to "get them off the hook". Dr Michael Rice, a dyslexia and literacy expert at Cambridge University, said: "There is a sense of justification when children are diagnosed. "It gets them off the hook of great embarrassment and personal inadequacy." According to Professor Elliott, dyslexic university students are gaining an unfair advantage by getting extra time for their studies and many are getting diagnosed simply to get up to £10,000 worth of equipment including laptops and extra books. University lecturers have complained about students "milking the system" by pretending they have the condition. One lecturer who teaches in the South-East said: "On one degree course I teach, about one quarter of the students get help with their coursework and other assistance because they have this label. You become quite cynical." The number of students who receive disability allowances at university has risen to a record 35,500 at a cost of £78.4million a year.  

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

Did ya hear about the dyslexic on the Atkins' Diet Plan? He couldn't lose any weight even though he stopped eating crabs! 

iwaveatcows --- 19 years ago -

i wish i knew how to the get the disability allowance for a child who REALLY has dyslexia -- it ain't no bed of roses 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

This article was done based on info from the UK. Over here they would be whining about kids diagnosed ADHD. Yeah some kids do have it, it is real. And some parents use it as an excuse to medicate their children. 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

Julian Elliott, a leading educational psychologist at Durham University, says he has found no evidence to identify dyslexia as a medical condition after more than 30 years of research. Maybe Julian Elliott is the stupid one. I have not overcome dyslexia, but last time I checked I had a 124 iq. I design oil rigs for a living. I do not consider myself to be an execption to the rule. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

One in ten people in the UK - including 375,000 schoolchildren - has been diagnosed with dyslexia. I understand the sentiment, considering how abused the diagnosis is. 

Beach --- 19 years ago -

I know we have at least one teacher on here I'd love to hear her views of this..Freshell your thoughts? BTW this isn't Beach..its Yankee Rose posting under her name! Beach will be on here later to reply.... 

stampin' gal --- 19 years ago -

I used to be a teacher, and I'll weigh in on this one. Dyslexia and ADD are way misdiagnosed. Too many parents are looking for a 'reason' why their 4 year old can't sit still, or why their 10 year old isn't as smart as his friend. Instead of realizing that a 4 year old CANNOT sit still for hours at a time, or that SOME KIDS ARE JUST SMARTER THAN OTHERS, these parents need an excuse; a diagnosis; something to blame. Thus all the ADD and Dyslexia diagnoses. And, yes.....you do see MORE of it in upper middle class/upper class families. I saw it with my own eyes. Now, before those of you that have kids with these diagnoses tear me a new one, hear me out. IF YOUR CHILD REALLY HAS ONE OF THESE PROBLEMS, you should be as mad about the mis-diagnoses as I am!!! All these people that are looking for an 'easy label' are making those with a REAL problem look bad! They take away from the significance of the disorder, and I DO believe ADD and dyslexia are VERY real problems. But, I think at least 50% (i would guess closer to 80%) of kids that are diagnosed are MISdiagnosed. Again....just my little opinion based on what I have seen (and my degree in education). 

Deltadawn --- 19 years ago -

There is something wrong with the guys research, it is real. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

Thank you for saying that, stampin' gal. I have struggled for so many years with a system of misdiagnosing ADD and ADHD and everyone wanting to slap a band-aid on problems children are having by giving it the pop psychology diagnosis of the month. While my son truly does struggle with ADHD, I have fought long and hard with the school system, the administrators, teachers, counselors, and his own father to get them to TEACH him and HELP him and work on making sure he learns what he needs to learn and not just giving it a name and thinking that resolves the issue. I agree with the article in some ways, I do not think that it's a way to hide stupidity, but I do think that people do not want to take the time and do the work necessary to make sure their children get to where they need to be and learn what they need to learn. It's too easy to blame everyone else and claim they have some "problem." Sorry for the rant. It amazes me that they spend money to hold studies when it all just seems logical to me. There are children out there who do need help and medication DOES work for them. It's insulting to parents who struggle with these learning disabilities in their children to see it abused this way. 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

It's insulting to parents who struggle with these learning disabilities in their children to see it abused this way. I agree. And Stampin I totally agree with you.....alot of kids are misdiagnosed. Ive paid out the BUTT to make sure of what my childs problem is with extensive testing, therapy, etc. You cant look at a kid and just diagnose them even though lots of Drs do nowdays. 

poodle_lover --- 19 years ago -

My oldest daughter was diagnosed with this in 2nd grade. it is real and It was a struggle with her to learn to read but she is very smart. She finished 4 years of college in 2 1/2 and is the only person I know who can do calculus in her head. 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

I dont know about the mis diagnosis coming from the parents all the time. I have had teachers tell me i need to medicate my kid because he is a active child (hell any 6 year old boy is a active child) and he is nowhere close to some of the kids i have seen that really do have ADD/ADHD. 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

I'm gonna have to ponder this one awhile Not sure which way i swing on this one Opposing opinions make us have to think 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

I think alot of teachers self diagnose so they dont have to deal with a active child and pressure parents to put their kids on meds. My son is very smart and reads very well so i dont see a need to medicate him to make the teachers life a little easier. Sorry this is a touchy subject with me. 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

Heck iam dyslexic sometimes when iam typing. I will Type the end of the sentence first and have to backtrack. My brother was diagnosed with dyslexia and he definantly had a problem reading for a while but is extreamly smart. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

Ive paid out the BUTT to make sure of what my childs problem is with extensive testing, therapy, etc. I think a true diagnosis of any learning disability takes years, not days, to diagnose. I don't like the tone of that article anyway, because I do not believe that any child is stupid. I know what the author is attempting to say, but it probably needs to be reworded to say that the parents are stupid for wanting to find a buzz word to make sure their child isn't DIFFERENT from all their buddies. Children learn in different ways. The key is finding the right way your child learns and do everything you can to make sure their teachers know it, too. 

stampin' gal --- 19 years ago -

I'm glad no one is mad at me for my post, lol. It is a VERY real problem, but I suspect if you take 10 kids that are 'labeled as add/adhd, probably only 1 of them REALLY has it. Just a guess, but that is pretty much what I saw. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Ha ha ha!!! If that's true, then guess what????? TOM CRUISE IS S-T-U-P-I-D!! Of course I already knew that with or without a learning disability. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

Humble Pediatrics used to have the following recording: Thank you for calling Humble Pediatrics. If this is an emergency, press 1. If you are calling for a Ritalin refill, press 2. If you need an appointment, press 3. If you need a nurse, press 4. If you need billing, press 5. I think that about sums up the problem. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Morning Lone!!!! My oldest used to take those ADD medications. I hated it, but his teachers, his doctor, his father were all breathing down my neck. So I acquiesced...reluctantly. When I'd take his pills to the school nurse, you would NOT believe the cabinet I saw. Literally hundreds of medicine bottles. Ritilin, concerta...blah, blah, blah. It was sooo depressing. Thank GOD he's not on anything right now. I swear. Everyone basically pushed those meds on me and my ds. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

While my son truly does struggle with ADHD, I have fought long and hard with the school system, the administrators, teachers, counselors, and his own father to get them to TEACH him and HELP him and work on making sure he learns what he needs to learn and not just giving it a name and thinking that resolves the issue. I hope the school system is getting better about this. In my day if there was a child who needed a little more help they'd just push him aside and say that he didn't want to learn or was lazy. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Talk about your ultimate peer pressure! 

movedagain --- 19 years ago -

As a teacher I can tell you that there are children with both LD (learning different) problems and ADHD... Can they be solved--- yes! Does it take a lot of work and effort-- YES Do most parents put enough time and effort into the children with these problems to help them-- some do and some do not. I had a young boy with a tested IQ of 167 but in 6th grade he could not read. Finally one day sitting across the table from me I figured out he was a mirror reader--he read upside down and backwards. It was amazing and opened up so many doors for him. The brain is an amazing tool. It takes time, effort and a lot of hard work to deal with children that learn differently. The schools do not teach well to children that do not learn in a standard way, this hurts many children. On the same side many parents drop children off at the school and expect the teachers to do everything for them. They are not working at home with the child and wonder why the child is not doing well. Being a parent is hard work! I had one mom actually ask my why her child could not multiply. I asked her if she went over the facts at home, she said 'why should she, that is the school's job"... ... So there are many sides to this situation. Children that really struggle with each thing they learn, schools that do not accommodate all learning styles, parents that do over the top with children and then parents that do nothing, doctors that write a script to please the parents and then those doctors that frustrate the parents and demand more answers... 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

I agree movedagain. Good post. I am thankful for the few teachers my son has had who have recognized some of his struggles and helped him overcome them. He tests high on all his intelligence tests as well, but cannot pass standardized tests like the TAKS without a struggle. The school system has turned into a little box where everyone is expected to sit quietly, do exactly as you're told, at the pace the teacher chooses for you, and anything that ventures outside that box is slapped with a label and considered a problem. All participants have become lazy, including teachers AND parents. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Thanks movedagain. Yes. There are kids who benefit immensely from these types of medications. They may have helped my ds through a "rough" patch of not being able to focus and retain anything. I just see that there's something wrong when the school nurse's cabinet is nothing but ADD and ADHD meds. She saw it too. So instead of dyslexia being middle class stupidty....the correct statement should be medicating students....middle class laziness. Because if more people took the time to properly diagnose, there would be less medicating and more disciplining. Those who really need it would benefit and those who simply need to learn to behave themselves would get their "medication!" 

movedagain --- 19 years ago -

It is not just middle class. I have had all income levels force medication. Those that had higher incomes with both parents working were just as guilty as those without a job! It is just easier when the meds are free. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

Being a parent is hard work! I had one mom actually ask my why her child could not multiply. I asked her if she went over the facts at home, she said 'why should she, that is the school's job"... ... We had a few issues this year with my son in kindergarten. we stayed consistant with the teacher, principal, and counselor, we still weren't getting a good response from them. We ended up contacting the assistant super intendent for the district and finally got the results we wanted. The principal kept telling us he was amazed at the lengths we went to to get the result we wanted for our son. He said so many parents just don't care enough. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

We had a few issues this year with my son in kindergarten. we stayed consistant with the teacher, principal, and counselor, we still weren't getting a good response from them. We ended up contacting the assistant super intendent for the district and finally got the results we wanted. The principal kept telling us he was amazed at the lengths we went to to get the result we wanted for our son. He said so many parents just don't care enough. Good for you, BCM. That's what it takes sometimes, even when you continue to hit brick walls. You know what's best for your son, even if people continue to disagree with you. I think people give in too easily to what they're told by "experts" and not realizing that every kid is different and you have to listen to your instincts about your own children. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

It is not just middle class. You're absolutely right...didn't mean to stereotype. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground