Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Ionic Breeze Towers?

who's talking here?

~grandma again~ 5
Lilteapot 1
Fallon 1
likeke27 1
gking 2
lilmommy 1
TheWiffy 1
Loblolly 3
lonesophist 1
I Kissed Frogs 2
Reality is good 4
Beach 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Loblolly --- 19 years ago -

my husband watches too many infomercials. Anyone have the ionic towers for cleaning air? Like the Breeze, they don't require filters to help clean the air in the room. He's wanting to get one and I was curious.  

Loblolly --- 19 years ago -

See I wondered if they really worked or not. thanks for the tip on the outlet, I was looking on ebay. 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

The 'Seals' that endorse the ionic breeze are given money from Sharper image to tout the 'benefits' of their tower. They are a waste of money and some of them have been known to release harmful ozone into the air. Air cleaners: The truth behind the accolades Ads for air cleaners from Sharper Image and Oreck include a Seal of Truth from the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America (AAFA), a Washington, D.C.-based group. Sharper Image ads also display a Seal of Approval from the British Allergy Foundation, now known as Allergy UK, and refer to university studies claimed to support Sharper Image's air-cleaner claims. As we found, some university studies were funded by the manufacturer. We also found that another seal on some air cleaners addresses the volume of clean air those machines deliver, though it doesn't tell the whole story. Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America seal. NO ENDORSEMENT The AAFA says its Seal of Truth isn't an endorse-ment, but its laudatory tone suggests otherwise. What seals don't tell you. The AAFA's Seal of Truth program is open to manufacturers who submit a $5,000 application fee. According to the AAFA, companies are asked to submit “independent” research for review by a panel of experts, who determine whether a product's performance meets its claims. If the panel says it does, manufacturers can apply the seal to that product for two years. Fewer than 12 allergy-related products, including vacuums and cleaning products, have the seal; Sharper Image's Ionic Breeze and Oreck's XL are the only air cleaners with it. The AAFA states on its Web site that its expert panel includes M.D.s, Ph.D.s, and Masters of Public Health. Michael Tringale, an AAFA spokesman, would not identify its experts, citing confidentiality concerns. Nor would Tringale or Sharper Image show us research submitted as part of the seal program. But the AAFA's literature discloses two points that the air-cleaner ads don't mention. One is that its seal is not an endorsement or statement of clinical efficacy. Yet the words on the seal for Sharper Image's Ionic Breeze, above, imply otherwise. The other is that its program isn't a comparison but, rather, “helps consumers distinguish truthful product claims relating to asthma and allergies, regardless of how products compare to each other.” In an interview, Tringale said that AAFA panel members saw a Consumer Reports air-cleaners report that found the Ionic Breeze ineffective, but granted the seal anyway. “Because we aren't rating in comparison,” Tringale said, “we asked, does the research stand up? And indeed it did.” But when Sharper Image submitted studies to Consumers Union, the nonprofit publisher of Consumer Reports, they didn't stand up. Allergy UK's Seal of Approval program is somewhat like the AAFA's, though it says its seal is an endorsement. A manufacturer submits a fee for new testing by an “independent scientific consultant” at the University College Worcester or a review of its own independent tests. According to the British group, a 39-member panel of experts sets specific protocols for each product. Allergy UK would not disclose detailed information about its review protocol. What's more, the foundation states on its Web site that its endorsement does not mean that a product will necessarily reduce an allergy sufferer's symptoms. Endorsement programs between business and nonprofit groups raise ethical concerns. A 1994 study commissioned by the American Cancer Society concluded that the use of its logo is seen as endorsement. In 1997 the American Medical Association withdrew from an agreement allowing its logo to be used on Sunbeam blood-pressure monitors and other devices amid conflict-of-interest concerns. That withdrawal resulted in a nearly $10 million breach-of-contract settlement with Sunbeam. By 1999 such programs led 16 state attorneys general to issue a report warning that their implied product endorsements could “mislead, deceive or confuse the public.” Such programs remain numerous. But some organizations acknowledge concerns. The American Lung Association says its national board comprises physicians and others who agree to its conflict-of-interest policy, which excludes directors from companies with which it has partnerships. At the time this report was written, the AAFA's Web site showed that its board included representatives of pharmaceutical, medical-device, and air-filter manufacturers. What the studies don't say. Studies touted in Sharper Image ads came under scrutiny last year in the company's lawsuit against Consumers Union. Court testimony and documents revealed information absent from the ads. For one, documents showed that a researcher had been receiving a $6,000 monthly retainer from Sharper Image for research used by the company to support the sale of its Ionic Breeze. The company also provided research grants to a university professor and author of two reports about the Ionic Breeze prepared at Sharper Image's request, and compensated others whose research was cited. One study was deemed irrelevant by Consumers Union because the Ionic Breeze was used as a particle collector, not as an air-cleaning device. To put that difference into perspective, you can collect the dust particles that settle out of the air and onto a tabletop in a room, but that doesn't make the table an air cleaner. In November 2004 federal Judge Maxine Chesney dismissed Sharper Image's suit, holding that there was no reasonable probability that Consumers Union's findings were false and that Sharper Image's studies provided no basis for challenging those findings. (See Sharper Image lawsuit ends.) What's in the numbers. Many models, including the Friedrich and Whirlpool, have clean-air delivery-rate (CADR) certifications. Seals are issued by the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers (AHAM). A manufacturer must submit its line to independent lab tests or have its results verified by an AHAM-designated lab. The seal lists CADR results and the room size that a model can effectively clean. It also notes that a higher CADR is better. While the numbers are a good guide to an air cleaner's effectiveness, you must check one of AHAM's Web sites (www.cadr.org) to compare models. What's a good rating? You'll see numbers from 10 to 450. Generally, we judge CADR values above 350 excellent and those below 75 poor. Air cleaners with a CADR of 10 or less are barely distinguishable from gravity at removing airborne particles. If you know someone who has a online subscription to Consumer Reports, have them look up the findings that CR gave the Ionic breeze. 

~grandma again~ --- 19 years ago -

I have 2 ionic breezes and love them! It is amazing the gunk that gets taken out of the air. You have no filters to buy and i like that. The filter i was using before cost me $20 a month at least just for filters. I clean them at least once a week, usually on Wednesday and Sunday though. I clean them with isopropyl alcohol. I did buy two that were reconditioned and paid about half price for them but they were just like new. 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

You're welcome. Sharper Image is a rip-off with these Ionic breeze towers. Be careful. 

Loblolly --- 19 years ago -

our neighbor has one and it does smell "fresh" 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

We've had those in our office before and they do nothing. They ended up in the storage closet. 

~grandma again~ --- 19 years ago -

by the way, my daughter has 2 and she likes hers. and i also know Lilteapot has one. 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

Consumer Reports calls air purifier ‘unhealthy’ Sharper Image's Ionic Breeze fails to clean air, magazine says. SAN FRANCISCO - Consumer Reports magazine is taking renewed aim at a popular air purifier made by The Sharper Image two months after it fended off a libel lawsuit filed by the machine’s retailer. The magazine reports in its latest issue hitting newsstands Tuesday that Sharper Image’s Ionic Breeze Quadra Silent Air Purifier and four other similar machines fail to significantly clean the air — but also release potentially unhealthy levels of ozone. The article is being published two months after San Francisco-based Sharper Image agreed to pay the magazine’s publisher, Consumers Union, $525,000 in legal costs after a judge dismissed its libel suit. The failed lawsuit alleged that earlier magazine articles highly critical of the Ionic Breeze’s ability to reduce airborne particles were false and malicious. Story continues below ↓advertisement 2 million sold Company lawyer E. Robert Wallach said Sharper Image was evaluating how to respond to the article, which advised against buying the machines. More than 2 million of the $350 units have been sold. “It is astonishing that Consumers Union would continue its misguided efforts to attack the judgment and experience of millions of Americans who are satisfied with the performance of the Ionic Breeze products,” Wallach said in a statement. In a statement of its own, Consumer Reports said the magazine’s latest article is accurate and that the nonprofit organization had called on federal regulators to look at the advertising claims being made by sellers of the five air purifiers it examined. “All of these ’not recommended’ products did a poor job in our tests of removing dust, smoke and pollen from the air,” the statement said. “In addition, all five of these products failed in Consumer Reports’ labs the standard industry test for ozone generation.” Consumers Union is based in Yonkers, N.Y. Shares of Sharper Image Corp. fell 4 percent, or 67 cents, to close at $15.68 Monday on the Nasdaq Stock Market, near their 52-week low of $14.08. 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

The ozone generation is what you really want to be careful with. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

to each is their own 

~grandma again~ --- 19 years ago -

maybe it is just in our imagination that it works? hmmmmmm....heck, i think it is even pulling dust from my attic. 

TheWiffy --- 19 years ago -

I do not that the beds I sell come with a recommendation to not use the Ionic air cleaners because it will breakdown bed components over time. Not sure about other air purifiers.. that is just on the ionic kind. 

~grandma again~ --- 19 years ago -

beds? how can it break down bed components...maybe removing the bed bugs? 

gking --- 19 years ago -

our neighbor has one and it does smell "fresh" That's the smell of the ozone. Sharper Image's latest models have a new feature they call OzoneGuard™ on the front grill that supposedly converts by-product ozone to oxygen before adding it back into your atmosphere - thus addressing the ozone concern. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I can honestly say that when Rita was coming in we went to Shreveport to stay with my in laws. They have them all over the house. Their house is an older home. I had always wondered if they really work. But considering I came home with pneumonia.... First time to ever get it... And had many many problems breathing while in their house that I wouldn't put them in my home. And my MIL's house is very clean so I'm not sure what the problem was but every time I sat beside those things I would have something close to an asthma attack. And I don't have asthma. And yes, we cleaned those filters as well. So that wasn't the problem. 

Lilteapot --- 19 years ago -

We have 2. Dh bought them home from sharper image one day and I nearly killed him, $800! Buy one get one free. He swears by them, I dont. I am the one that cleans them though, (I use any orange cleaner goes right through the thick tar that builds up), and then windex them after. I can say the gunk is pretty impressive that gets built up on them, but weather or not they work....I still dont know. Aurthorman knows of a SUPER PROVEN air cleaner, and he swears by his. 

Beach --- 19 years ago -

Hey everyone! This is Yankee Rose posting under Beach~! I bought the copycat one at Walmart for about 150 and I like mine. And I worked in a office that had the real Ionic Breeze and they swore by it. It was an old moldy office and they said it really improved their health working there. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 19 years ago -

I have the one from Shaper Image and it makes me sick if I let it run long enough to cause ozone. It burns my nose and throat and if I stay in the area I get either a sinus infection or have a hard time breathing. So if I use it I only run it for a short period of time and move it to other areas quickly. Most of the time it just sits in the corner not on. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

I Kissed Frogs... Is your model one of the later ones with the OzoneGuard™ feature? Curious to know if it's doing what they claim it should...or not. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

Before you buy one call your allergist. Mine told me not to use one in our house. He said, that because my youngest has asthma they will make asthma worse. And he said he sees lots of cases of broncitous and pneumonia with folks who have one in thier home. So we bought some regular airfilters with hepa filters in them. And no doubt they do get some stuff out of the air! THe filters get unreal dirty. That is my .02 worth! lol 

I Kissed Frogs --- 19 years ago -

Yes it is older - probably 4-5 years old. I don't like the smell of the ozone either. My husband can't smell it like I can so I guess I am super sensitive to it. 

~grandma again~ --- 19 years ago -

hmmmm.....wonder if this is why i can not get rid of my bronchitis? could be. i will talk with my doctor when i go back and see him. (like he will know anything about them) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground