Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Legal Rights

who's talking here?

outermaga 1
jimmy 1
Going off air 1
auraofpeace 1
ChezML 1
lonesophist 5
Mr Mark 1
Mabbers 1
CleverName 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

With everyone discussing the Wal-Mart lawsuit, it reminded me of an issue that has always bothered me and came up again today. I spent the morning at the courthouse trying to get some documents signed, and I watched the criminal trial docket while I waited. I saw so many people who were arrested and had been brought over from the jail in shackles and handcuffs sit in the courtroom and not even ask for a lawyer. Yes, they committed a crime, yes, they will be punished, but we all have the right to an attorney when accused of a crime. It bothers me that so many people become so defeated that they don't even try to protect their civil rights. Everyone deserves the right to an attorney and a fair trial. That really bothered me. Do people not realize that they SHOULD ask for a lawyer and it's what they're supposed to do? It baffles me.  

outermaga --- 19 years ago -

Do people not realize that they SHOULD ask for a lawyer and it's what they're supposed to do? I think they do but some of the lawyers they give you are so horrible that they get discouraged. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

A lot of court appointed lawyers are horrible, but when you waive your right to an attorney, you have basically lost your right to appeal anything that happens to you. It just bothered me today to see so many people sitting there at the mercy of the judge's mood and the prosecutor's good will. 

Mr Mark --- 19 years ago -

Back in the day, I used to get tickets for things like "expired inspection sticker, or expired tags". After a while I was issued a warrent for my arrest. After a night in jail, I could plead my case. Guilty, Not Guilty. If I pleaded not Guilty, I would go back to jail until the trial. If the officer that cited me for the ticket did not show. I went free. Chances are what you saw, was a little bit of people pleading a case. Some things never change. (trying to beat the system). 

ChezML --- 19 years ago -

I'm assuming that they were coming in for araingment hearings? Doesn't the judge ask them at that time if they have an attorney, and if they don't and can't afford one, he kets them know that the court will appoint one. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

No, these were people charged with a crime. Also, anyone who wants to cop a plea should also ask for a lawyer to get the best deal possible. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

In most cases, especially on drug related crimes, having a C.A.A. is like playing offense using the other teams QB. No District Attorney is going to allow a lawyer getting paid by the County to tie up his docket fighting case after case when the evidence is basically overwhelming. So the C.A.A, at best, will cop you a decent plea. At worst, will play you right into the hands of a max sentence. As you say, it is stupid, but it is an attitude bred from a lot of cynicism of the system from folks who play it, as well as see it played, first hand. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

I'm assuming that they were coming in for araingment hearings? Doesn't the judge ask them at that time if they have an attorney, and if they don't and can't afford one, he kets them know that the court will appoint one. Yes, Chez, that's true. What I'm saying is all of them waived their right to an attorney. That's what bothers me. I don't understand why they did that. They asked who over here wants an attorney, raise your hand? No one did. 

jimmy --- 19 years ago -

It is proable that the people you saw were there for an arraignment-a hearing where the judge looks at why they were arrested, charged, etc. (probable cause). Bail is set and they are given a court date 2-3 weeks in the future. They are also told what court etc. If they do not have an attorney one is be appointed, or they are told to get one by their next court date. Some of these people know how the system/game is played and will plead guilty and get a lighter sentence than what they would get if they went to trial... 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

Jimmy, they were not being bonded out. They were waiving their right to an attorney and being sentenced. That was the point of my post. 

CleverName --- 19 years ago -

lonesophist --- 1 days ago A lot of court appointed lawyers are horrible, but when you waive your right to an attorney, you have basically lost your right to appeal anything that happens to you. It just bothered me today to see so many people sitting there at the mercy of the judge's mood and the prosecutor's good will. auraofpeace --- 1 days ago In most cases, especially on drug related crimes, having a C.A.A. is like playing offense using the other teams QB. No District Attorney is going to allow a lawyer getting paid by the County to tie up his docket fighting case after case when the evidence is basically overwhelming. So the C.A.A, at best, will cop you a decent plea. At worst, will play you right into the hands of a max sentence. As you say, it is stupid, but it is an attitude bred from a lot of cynicism of the system from folks who play it, as well as see it played, first hand. While I am not familiar with the court appointment systems in other jurisdictions, I can say that in Harris County a court appointed lawyer is really up to a luck of the draw. I have seen and heard of many instances where people have fired their court appointed lawyer to hire a less qualified "free world" lawyer. If you have, by the luck of the draw, had some truly brilliant attorneys such as Jim Mount, Pat Stallings, Jim Lightener, David Cunningham or Jon Munier, the stupidest thing you could do is fire them and pay some "free world" lawyer $ 5,000 to defend you. To hire one of these guys privately, or someone on the same level of competence, you could easily spend $25,000 or more, depending on the crime. However, there are stories of lawyers who are appointed who are sadly deficient in their representation. As for the idea that the DA is going to somehow control whether a defense attorney gets paid, they have no say in that matter. The judge is the one who appoints the attorneys and decides the fee and expense reimbursement amounts. If any pressure is placed on a court appointed lawyer, it would have to come from the judge. For the record, I have not accepted criminal defense clients for years and obviously do not solicit or accept court appointments. As for pleading out on the arraignment setting without a lawyer. Such a move would be ill advised in most cases. However, there are times when a lawyer advises his or her client to take first day deal. For instance, if a client was picked up for a fifth DWI, which is a felony, but the state does not have the criminal history at its disposal on the first setting because any deal is a misdemeanor which will be less than the minimum in district court when the DA figures out the problem and obtains an indictment for the felony. 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

Lonesophist if you really want to see injustice in circus form go to a Patton Village court room. It's totally laugh-able All they care about is their money It's a real Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

I think many just want to get the hell out. Most times, when you request a court-appointed attorney, you have to wait and/or stay in jail. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground