Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Wal-Mart settles w/suspected shoplifter's family

who's talking here?

FirePrincess 1
JDB2 4
RRay 1
buzzingo 1
Danabug(BCM) 13
txsweetpotato 2
Anderson 1
kjones0125 1
girlsRus 1
CyberSage 4
AtascaMom 1
qpc 3
AuthorMan 2
cowboyswife 1
auraofpeace 23
lonesophist 12
Clown Vomit 7
Mabbers 20
Reality is good 4
CleverName 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

kjones0125 --- 19 years ago -

The nation’s largest retailer will pay $750,000 to the family of a suspected shoplifter who suffocated as employees held him down in a parking lot outside a northeast Harris County store. Stacy Clay Driver, 29, died Aug. 7, 2005, in a Wal-Mart parking lot as someone sat on him while he was face-down and handcuffed, said Brad Frye, an attorney for the family. “One or more people were on his body and he couldn’t breathe,” Frye said Thursday. “This was a senseless, senseless death.” The case went to mediation before being settled in March, he said. An autopsy showed that Driver had methamphetamine in his system when he was chased into the parking lot by a “loss prevention” employee at the store in Atascocita, where he was wrestled to the hot pavement. He was suspected of exchanging stolen items to get $94 worth of store credit on a gift certificate, police said. His death was ruled a homicide caused by asphyxia from neck and chest compression. The autopsy report listed a contributing factor as overheating with methamphetamine toxicity. Frye said the methamphetamine may have contributed to Driver’s death, but didn’t cause it. A Harris County grand jury in July 2006 declined to indict anyone in the case. According to court documents, an initial sum of $550,000 will go to Driver’s wife, Wendy, their son, Ashton, and Driver’s father, H.C. Driver. The son also will receive payments from a trust, which will disburse $25,000 on his 25th birthday, almost $70,000 on his 30th and $100,000 on his 35th birthday, court papers show. Driver’s stepmother, Pat Driver, said the money “doesn’t bring him back, it doesn’t help the pain, it doesn’t end anything.” She said Driver’s son will turn 2 in July. At the time of his death, Driver was on probation for a theft case related to a similar gift?card scam the previous year at a Wal-Mart in Polk County. He had signed an agreement to never enter another Wal-Mart store. Wal-Mart’s Houston lawyer, John Ramirez, referred questions about the Driver lawsuit to company headquarters. Calls to that office were not returned Thursday. Wal-Mart is commonly said in legal circles to be the most sued company in America and the second-most sued entity in the world, behind the U.S. government. James Paulsen, a South Texas College of Law professor, said that would be hard to prove, but is believable simply because of the number of stores and employees the company has and the number of customers and transactions it deals with every day. 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

Frye said the methamphetamine may have contributed to Driver’s death, but didn’t cause it. Would Mr. Driver have died had he NOT had methamphetamines in his system? If you get in a car wreck and you have no insurance whose fault is the wreck? Yours. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

$750,000 passed on to us because their dishonest relative stole. He wouldn't have had any of that happen if he stayed off drugs and didn't steal. JMO. 

Reality is good --- 19 years ago -

True, if a robber breaks into your house and breaks his leg, you get sued and will have to pay. What a wonderful country this is. So righteous and fair to it's citizens, so willing to stand up for the criminal and all the rights that are bequeathed unto them. 

girlsRus --- 19 years ago -

That is why you shoot them dead in your home 

FirePrincess --- 19 years ago -

That is why you shoot them dead in your home Yeah. You drag them to the street for that. 

Clown Vomit --- 19 years ago -

I think the ruling was fair, although I think $750K is overkill. Wal-Mart should be held liable because it didn't better train its employees. A Wal-Mart employee is NOT allowed to aprehend a suspect. Period. I was employed there back in the early 1990's. We were allowed to follow suspected shoplifters out to the parking lot, but that was it. They even told us we weren't allowed to say anything to them, because if you wrongly accused someone of shoplifting, they could sue Wal-Mart for slander. The rules were very clear on this. That $94 turned into $750K because someone wanted to be a hero. 

AtascaMom --- 19 years ago -

He had signed an agreement to never enter another Wal-Mart store. He shouldnt have been in the store anyways. This is ridiculous. The grand jury didnt indict Walmart. They shouldnt have paid them anything. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Wal-Mart should be held liable because it didn't better train its employees. Mr. Driver should be held liable because he didn't keep himself from stealing or doing drugs. It never would have happened in the first place if he was not a thief and a drug addict and had stayed out of Wal-Mart like he was legally bound to do! 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

The thief is an idiot, but I am not sure when petty theft at a retail store became a capital crime. I am trying to figure out if some of you parents would be as quick to condemn the settlement against Wallyworld if you had YOUR kids come into MY shop and try to steal something, and I made them lie face down in the hot asphalt driveway in July until the cops got here, which is about a 45 minute response time. Of course, I would be holding them at gunpoint, and if one made a move that made me nervous, I would probably kick the sh-t out of them with steel toe boots until they slowed that action down. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

So your nickname "auraofpeace" is kinda like a war tactic. Misdirection? 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

auraofpeace do you have a permit for that gun? There is nothing wrong with those employees apprehending a CRIMINAL as long as it was safe for them to do so. If the guy hadn't been breaking laws there would be no settlement, law suit or anything else. BOTTOM LINE IS HE WAS A CRIMINAL. 

Clown Vomit --- 19 years ago -

Mr. Driver should be held liable because he didn't keep himself from stealing or doing drugs. Thats irrelevant now. A Wal-Mart employee killed him, now the blame rests solely on Wal-Mart. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

I don't think he deserved to die though. Okay, he's drug addict and a thief. Those are things he can overcome if he so desired. But, I also don't think Wallyworld needed to pay the family. What was done would have been done by anyone. If a drug addict cannot survive a routine arrest, why is it anyone's fault? 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

no, the executives didn't kill him, an individual did. if it wasn't all about $$$$$ (which just goes to show what wonderful people they are) then they would have sued the individual not the corporation. 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

I LOVE this country. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Exactly BCM. If I died in a parking lot being stopped from stealing to support my habit, I can tell you my family would NOT sue. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

Mine either, in fact they would probably be sitting there saying we told ya so. haha 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

So your nickname "auraofpeace" is kinda like a war tactic. Misdirection? not really. I would not likely do any of those things for petty theft. Neither should have WalMart. auraofpeace do you have a permit for that gun? there is no such thing as a "gun permit" in the State of Texas. ---- Basically, in terms of self defense as a civilian, the use of deadly force is only justified when in fear for your own life, defending the life of another, defending property in your home, defending yourself or another party against rape, kidnapping, and the like, and a few other specific "crimes". In terms of WalMart using "deadly force", I can think of no cicrumstance it would be reasonable for theft. I can also think of no reason to hold someone face down in a hot parking lot until they were injured for property that you recovered once you apprehended him/her. If he would have been ijured during the apprehension (say a fall or a minor injury) it was no big deal. Once he was apprehended and the property recovered, WalMart had no more reasonable duty to do anything else but to try to corral him til the cops arrived. If he hauled buns, it isn't like he would be a threat to anyone or hard to find with about 15 descriptions and a few dozen camera pics taken of the entire incident. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Absolutely BCM. These lawsuits really get me going. And it kinda takes a lot these days. I've settled into complacency, but there are people out there that I just don't understand. For the life of me, I can't see how anyone could sleep at night trying to squeeze every last penny out of every last person they come in contact with. That's all you'd have time for. Planning and schemeing your next "haul." Unbelievable. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

again, imagine your teenage kids getting a buzz on and trying to "wahoo" a 12 pack of beer out of Stop and Rob. The clerk beats the crap out of your child to the point of hospitalization. You are not going to sue? Yeah, right. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

auraofpeace, you keep saying WALMART, the WALMART is not a person. An employee did this. They are were money hungry bottom line, anyone who trys to capitalize on losing a loved one is SICK IMO. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

No I wouldn't SUE, I would mourn my child and pick up the pieces of having to deal with the loss of said child and move on. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Thats irrelevant now. A Wal-Mart employee killed him, now the blame rests solely on Wal-Mart. It's totally relavant. There would never have been the incident and he would still be alive except for his very own actions. HE is the one responsible. Do I think he deserved death? No, but HE made the decision to do drugs and to steal. HE made the decision to deal with the consequences of his actions or that stealing and doing drugs were more important than those consequences. If he placed great value on his life, he would have made different decisions. And yes, if one of my kids were in the same situation, I would not hold others responsible for the consequences of MY CHILD'S actions. Would it break my heart...yes....absolutely! Is it the store owners fault that my child stole from them? Absolutely not! I highly doubt that my kids will be multiple-time shoplifter though. We allow our children to accept consequences now, as unpleasant as the consequences may be, so that they learn at a young age that they are responsible for their actions and that there ARE consequences. To do otherwise would teach them that consequences are irrelevant and would do them much more harm than good. Even my 6 year old could tell you that bad things happen if you steal and do drugs. Too bad that a father of a young child couldn't tell that or just didn't care. Unfortunately, his son has to reap the consequences of his father's poor choices. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

They are were money hungry bottom line, anyone who trys to capitalize on losing a loved one is SICK IMO. Thats the bottom line right there BCM!! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

I think, qpc, you right in the sense that we allow our kids consequences, but I do not, however, believe others do. I think there are parents who shelter their children, parents who try to use their children, and frankly, parents who just don't give a damn. Discipline's a tricky thing these days, but you can certainly tell those kids who have boundaries and those that don't. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

auraofpeace, you keep saying WALMART, the WALMART is not a person. An employee did this. They are were money hungry bottom line, anyone who trys to capitalize on losing a loved one is SICK IMO. If an employee at Walmart waxed the floor and did not put up safety signs, and you slipped and broke your hip... Would you go after WalMart to pay your bills or the person who mopped the floor? "WalMart" did not create the safety hazard. But it happened in a WalMart store. WalMart is liable as a result. If you sued WalMart for your injury (or even the person who mopped) would you be "capitalizing" on your injury? You can't assume that the parents are "capitalzing" on anything. And even if they are, it does not lessen WalMarts liability in the situation. WalMart hired the people involved, gave them training, and employed them. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

People like you are the reason we are where we are today. It is all about sueing. PEOPLE TAKE RESPOSIBLITY FOR YOUR OWN DAMNED ACTIONS. GEEZ!!!!!!!!!!! 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

You are right about that aura. It did happen at WalMart, so yes, they play a part in this fiasco. The difference here is, someone didn't fall down, or slip on a wet floor. They were subdued trying to flee a crime. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

It's premises liability. An employer is liable for the actions of its employees. A thief does not deserve to die just because he's a thief and shoplifted from Wal-Mart. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

People like you are the reason we are where we are today. It is all about sueing. PEOPLE TAKE RESPOSIBLITY FOR YOUR OWN DAMNED ACTIONS. GEEZ!!!!!!!!!!! people like me? I have never sued anyone for anything. I have been "rear ended" in my vehcile twice, and only tried to get what it costs for repairs on my truck(s). Not for "whiplash" or any nonsense like that. Certainly some folks are litigous, but by suing someone it is not that you are "litigous" by default. WalMart employees are responsible for killing someone. That the deceased commited a crime prior to his death is irrelevant in that his crime was not one that reasonably allows WalMart to kill him for it. In other words, if he would have ran out of WalMart with a stereo, no police officer, armed guard, or concrned citizen would have been justfied in killing him on the spot with a gun or whatever. When he was caught by the WalMart employees, their duty to the store was complete when they recovered the merchandise. Nobody working for WalMart is a law enforcment officer. There only legal rights in petty theft are in recovering merchandise. They can't shoot you, beat you up, or punish you for anything. At best they can detain you, but only if you basically comply with such. If you run, they are not allowed to trip you, run over you with carts in the lot, or tazer you. WalMart employees stepped over their legal boundaries with his guy. Him being a thief oes not justify their actions. If they will act in ways that endanger the lives of a petty thief, you can only assume they will do so with anyone they "assume" is a thief. So, it can be assumed that if you leave and the "bonger" goes off and you resist because you "know" it isn't you that set it off, they can and will detain you, hold you face down in the lot, and ignore any signs you ahve of injury or life threatening actions on their part. All to "recover" merchandise of unknown value. Since WalMart has to be held responsible for this, and you cannot bring the guy back to life, the only hold you can place on WalMart as an entity is a financial burden. They will pay for the mistkaes, and pay "to" the only people left who have any justification in claiming it, and that is his relatives. 

Clown Vomit --- 19 years ago -

It's totally relavant. There would never have been the incident and he would still be alive except for his very own actions. HE is the one responsible. Do I think he deserved death? No, but HE made the decision to do drugs and to steal. HE made the decision to deal with the consequences of his actions or that stealing and doing drugs were more important than those consequences. If he placed great value on his life, he would have made different decisions. I disagree. In that same vein, he would have never been tempted to steal had Wal-Mart not built a store there. OR...He would have not been tempted to steal had he not been high on meth...so do you blame the meth dealer that sold him the drugs, too? Where does it end? The Wal-Mart employee is not an authorized police officer. He was not authorized nor trained to aprehend a suspect. In doing so, he contributed to the suspect's death. Boom. Wal-Mart is liable. End of story. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Thank you lone. I couldn't seem to get out what I wanted to say. Although that person did what he did, he didn't deserve to die. On that note, I'm not sure it was the employee responsible for that death. If you're holding someone down, waiting for the police, that will not kill you. It would however kill someone who's having a heart attack because they're "methed out." 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Is the death really that employee's responsibility? If that is the case, then there is something inherently wrong with our system. When criminals become victims....it's enough to make me puke. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

If you're holding someone down, waiting for the police, that will not kill you. It would however kill someone who's having a heart attack because they're "methed out." and that is the slippery slope when you take on that responsibility. Certainly there are certain, viable, and real justifications for doing everything from detaining someone to basically shooting them dead on the spot. But not every situation is the same as the nxt, even though they look very simielar. I have no sympathy for him as a thief, a meth head, or being a blight on society. More than likely he has commited many more crimes, some more serious in nature, than the one that he ended up dying as a result of. But, I cannot think of any theft against WalMart, in anything that WalMart has in any store, that is worth killing someone over in the parking lot, even if it is by actions that were not "deadly in intent" but were deadly in their premeditated commision. Think about it like this. If your house is being constantly burglarized at night, you are justified in shooting the criminal in your house if you catch him. But lets say you are a heavy sleeper and so you can't rely on your waking up. So you create a trap, and you amke a "set gun" out of a shotgun and a pice of strong tied to a doorknob. You go to sleep and are awaked by a BOOM!, and you go out to your living room to find the crook as a bloddy splat on the floor, having set off the trap. When the police arrive, you will go to jail. Why? Because that "trap" was indiscriminate. Suppose your house would ahve been on fire and a fireman set it off? Suppose a child would have gotten up at night and set it off? What if a policeman followed that crook into the house after seeing him in the yard, and the cop set it off? WalMart employees acted in a way that was alos indiscriminate. They used excessive force, and unlawfully. Someone acting "out of the law" never gives you the right to do the same. 

txsweetpotato --- 19 years ago -

SAdly, I bet the family of the dead drug addict thief still shop at walmart. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Are we really sure that the employee killed him? That's my question. No, nothing at WalMart is worth running someone down for, but okay, so he decided to go get the guy, you really think that that's what killed him? I doubt it. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

When criminals become victims....it's enough to make me puke. he is a victim. But not in the way you imply. He deserved to go to jail. If he would have been injured in the lawful apprehension of him, there would be no issue. But this is no different than having a WalMart employee run him over with a car to stop him, or shoot him with a gun. The actions appear to be different, but the outcome was the same. That WalMart didn't "mean to kill him" means very little in terms of their actions being excessive for the crime commited. Again, if some kids try to steal some beer out of the Stop and Rob, they deserve to go to jail. They do not deserve to be beaten with bats and kicked in the head in the parking lot when they try to run away. 

Mabbers --- 19 years ago -

Of course txsweetpotato! They're angry with WalMart! They're just pretending to win the lawsuit! 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground