Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

ADHD Son and Punishment

who's talking here?

adam 1
ms_mm 8
MissT 2
Fallon 2
txsweetpotato 1
Sandyr9111 3
girlsRus 1
mykidsmom 1
qpc 2
myself 1
*Sunny* 1
lonesophist 1
I Kissed Frogs 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

I Kissed Frogs --- 19 years ago -

My son 9 y.o. has some medical issues that making being a parent a challenge at times but I wouldn't trade it for the world. However, I get frustrated and punish sometimes more than I should. Well he out and out lied to me yesterday about doing his spelling words practice. So today I told him he had to write me an essay using his spelling words about not lying to me again and how he can help around the house more and be more self sufficient. He has been working at the letter for over 1-1/2 hours and just gave it to me. It only has 2 of his 15 spelling words in it. Should I just let it go or make him try again? I had even given him examples of sentences to write and not one example is there but he did work a really long time.  

myself --- 19 years ago -

but he did work a really long time. or did he play? i would send my child back to the drawing board...just so they know they cant run one by me!! 

girlsRus --- 19 years ago -

I bet the spelling words are in the first paragraph, he then got so into what he was writing he forgot about the rest of the spelling words. Sounds like my 8 year old nephew who is ADHD also. I think your punishment was appropriate for the crime, we use essay writing often for our punishment. I would probably let the spelling words slide if it was me, but I would offer to study them with him. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

Ditto what girl said, unfortuanly that will be the best way to get it done, sit down with him. It will keep him focused. It is tough with ADHD, it take so much patience, and often you are punished too because you will have to sit with him many time to keep him on task. But the consistency is so worth it in the long run! You are doing great:) 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

He has been working at the letter for over 1-1/2 hours and just gave it to me. It only has 2 of his 15 spelling words in it. tell him it's not acceptable, he didn't follow directions (i'm so mean...) 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

His attention span was not there the first time, so it will not be there now. The behavoir will be worse, because he will get so frustrated. Sit with him and redirect as needed, that will work. And no doubt he will be happy to have you sit with him anyway:) 

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

coach him through it. sometimes we assume our kids understand more or are more capable than they really are. and sometimes we underestimate them. :-) 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

i'd give him another chance to do it on his own now that he understands you will not just accept anything.... i bet he won't want to do it a third time. (i've had to do this with mine before) 

*Sunny* --- 19 years ago -

and for heaven's sake if you make him "redo" it use the same strategies teachers are supposed to do in class: modify the work. It is overwhelming to an ADHD child to see 15 words on a page at once. It is overwhelming. Take it down to 5 words, tell him to put those into sentences. Then when that much has been done, let him take a break, then pull out 5 more...get what I'm saying? He honestly can't help it... 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

ADHD kids are a challenge to say the least. My dd is 10 and suffers with it. You need to think too he has been cooped up at school all day being forced to focus and coming home to have to do it again is hard. I used to make my daughter write her spelling words 3x a day....she always struggled. I quit making her write them and now she makes 80-98 on every spelling test now. Had I known that I would have quit a long time ago. Does he take medication?? Do you allow him "down time" when he gets home so he can unwind before homework is started? Let him go out and run for 20-30 mins THEN start on homework. It helps alot. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

My son also has ADHD and he cannot be left alone to do homework independently. I literally have to sit beside him to make sure he does it, especially something monotonous and repetitive like spelling words. The other people commenting here are right, it has to be broken down into smaller tasks so they don't get overwhelmed. I also let him take breaks and play and then direct him back to the task. 

ms_mm --- 19 years ago -

My COLLEGE son did not take his Adderall for TWO OF HIS FINALS this week. Is Momma mad??? HELL YES. 

ms_mm --- 19 years ago -

I used to make my daughter write her spelling words 3x a day Sandy - have you tried letting her use Scrabble tiles? I have found that with some kids it works wonders. They can easily move the letters around - and since it is something different they don't mind it as much. I have even let some kids do the words with tiles before writing it for the test. 

txsweetpotato --- 19 years ago -

scrabble tiles!! That is a wonderful and fun idea!!!!! thank you! 

ms_mm --- 19 years ago -

It is also WAY LESS intimidating if they make a mistake since it is so easy to correct. 

ms_mm --- 19 years ago -

I am pretty passionate about spelling - don't know why... BUT...most of the time it is not taught correctly. The word list should not be just random words but a list that teaches a pattern or rule. Given a choice, would you rather learn less than 20 spelling rules or 10 words a week for every week of the school year? 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Sandy - have you tried letting her use Scrabble tiles? I have found that with some kids it works wonders. They can easily move the letters around - and since it is something different they don't mind it as much. I have even let some kids do the words with tiles before writing it for the test. That is an AWESOME idea! My son, a 10 year old with ADHD, has the worst time with spelling too! He loves to write though, and writing something with his spelling words is actually the best way we've found to get him work on spelling. I think the scrabble tiles would work even better though! 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

BUT...most of the time it is not taught correctly. The word list should not be just random words but a list that teaches a pattern or rule. Given a choice, would you rather learn less than 20 spelling rules or 10 words a week for every week of the school year? My kids are using the A Beka curriculum, and it follows this. There is one or two "rules" that words fall under and then some "harder to spell" (because they don't fall in a rule) words and some vocab words. They are pretty tough words too. 

ms_mm --- 19 years ago -

Scholastic's teacher page will let you make a word search and/or a word scramble with spelling words. 

ms_mm --- 19 years ago -

Last spelling tip - told you I was a lunatic about it - having them write the word in the air is good too - making big letters moving from the shoulders. That helps to put it in muscle memory (where it is more easily remembered). 

I Kissed Frogs --- 19 years ago -

Just got back from his baseball game... thanks for all the suggestions. We talked about it and he handed me the wrong draft - goof ball. He did much better on the second one. He used more than half the words and then explained he couldn't think how to work the word "purple", October, November, etc into the essay. I joked and told him he could have said "and my hinny will be purple from all the spankings if I lie to my Mom again". And "If I lie to my Mom again I will be grounded until October or November". In regards to the question about meds. Yes he is on them. I fought it for years because of the side affects but we found one that works great but he metabolises it so fast it wears off before homework. In regards to spelling our doctor also suggested Sky Writing but I keep forgetting to use it. That is where they write it really big in the air right in front of them. Doc says the exaggerated motion helps. And yes I forget because I am a little ADD too, ha! 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

I fought it for years because of the side affects but we found one that works great but he metabolises it so fast it wears off before homework. I have the same problem. We had a VERY small dose focalin we had to use if my dd had alot of homework just to get her through. Weve now had to go to Ritalin 2x a day because her metabolism would burn a 12 hour pill in about 4-6 hours. No wonder she can eat like a horse...lol 

ms_mm --- 19 years ago -

I blow through my meds fast too. Then I forget to take my afternoon pill... When are they going to invent a pump??? 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

LOL @ Ms_MM 

ms_mm --- 19 years ago -

Wouldn't it be great? You have a big test or meeting...open the line wide. You want to just sit around and watch tv...close it. It would be there - you wouldn't be - OH NO, I forgot to take my pills and they are at home. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 19 years ago -

My son is on Focalin too. He takes the XR in the morning but has to take immediate release at 1 in the afternoon because he has already metabolised the XR that fast. I can't give him something too late because he has abnormal brain activity when he is in stage 2 & 3 sleep that manifest as extremely bad nightmares and if he isn't really sleepy when going to be he fights it because he doesn't want to dream. So meds for homework would keep him up. 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

Frizz - My DS is also ADHD, but he is only 5... I am sure we will have the same types of battles, but to answer your question, maybe you should find a different form of punishment all together.... Homework in itself is a challenge to any child, much less one with ADHD... And, as you already know, punishment is also a challenge, because ADHD kids react differently to "normal" punishment, compared to kids who do not have ADHD.... I find that punishement which isolates and confines my DS is the most effective, like timeout in his room against a wall, or in his room on his bed with no toys, books, TV, etc... not laying down, or playing, but being perfectly still, alone, isolated from the rest of the family... My DS hates it and it is very effective.. JMO, good luck. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground