Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I'm so freakin' mad... Are you?

who's talking here?

Paige 1
GCan 4
nadine 2
MissT 6
eterry2 1
sarahandgarett 5
bbjones 6
planemom 1
kabbala 2
mdawg 1
lilmommy 14
amb07 1
WashingtonYankee 5
cowboyswife 3
Going off air 1
accent_ 1
m•t•v 1
Rachel 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I was reading the observer tonight. I found a section about schools. Splendora schools break down the TAKS tests into 3 categories. All schools do this and I personally think the entire state should be outraged. Basically our school is considered white, economically disadvantaged and hispanic. According to the states standards whites should score an average of 95, economically disadvantaged comes in lower, and hispanics are expected to score much lower than the others. Personally, if I was hispanic, I would be outraged. Being poor or of a different race has no bearing on how you score on the TAKS. From my mind, it appears that the State of Texas is lowering standards for both categories because they are basically insinuating that these kids are lower in intelligence. Which I do not believe to be true. So you tell me is that wrong in your eyes? I'm freakin' mad. It's just not right. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

Huh????....;) 

nadine --- 19 years ago -

I know a teacher told me about this a few years ago. Her school got a high rating only because of the way they rate low income and hispanics. Funding depends on this number aswell ~ from what I remember. 

amb07 --- 19 years ago -

That is so stupid. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Makes sense to me... Then when these schools claim they are excellent they really aren't. But my point is that these kids are being told that it's alright not to do as well as white children!!! I think that's insane. All children should be held to the same standards. Someones race or financial status has nothing what so ever to do with their minds. It's just crazy how the schools work. 

nadine --- 19 years ago -

I always say that the government is what keeps racism going. And this is a good example of it with our state. How will people see every one as the same if they do not. Just like with college funds, tv shows, etc… 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

My next question is why the isn't someone doing something about it? Why isn't the Hispanic community acting on it? Why not the economically disadvantaged? Do they not know what is going on? I've always heard of it being this way but until tonight wasn't sure it was true. So, why isn't someone doing something about it? 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

You really need to take a look at some of the studies done by the Civil Rights Project (out of Harvard). There truly is a difference and it's important for them to be separated so they can better see how to serve these kids. Here are some things: Every year, across the country, a dangerously high percentage of students—disproportionately poor and minority—disappear from the educational pipeline before graduating from high school. Nationally, only about 68 percent of all students who enter 9th grade will graduate “on time” with regular diplomas in 12th grade. While the graduation rate for white students is 75 percent, only approximately half of Black, Hispanic , and Native American students earn regular diplomas alongside their classmates. Graduation rates are even lower for minority males. Yet, because of misleading and inaccurate reporting of dropout and graduation rates, the public remains largely unaware of this educational and civil rights crisis. The nation’s dropout problem is concentrated in segregated high poverty schools. In our new book, Dropouts in America, we report that half of the nation’s African American and Latino students are dropping out of high school. The most severe problems are in segregated high poverty schools. For the high school class of 2002 almost a third of the high schools that were more than 50 percent minority graduated less than half of their class. Among schools that were 90 percent or more white, only one school in fifty had this kind of record. Half of the majority-minority schools had dropout rates over 40 percent as did two-thirds of the schools with less than a tenth white students. Nationally the gap in graduation rates between districts with high and low proportions of low income students was 18.4 percent in 2001, even higher than the gap between majority white and majority-minority districts. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

This one is especially important because children who fall into the economically disadvantaged category don't have the same opportunities (like preschool and educated parents) A comprehensive federal study of children across the country entering kindergarten shows very large differences in the acquisition of skills invaluable for school success long before the children ever enter a schoolhouse. Schools where almost all of the students come with these problems obviously face very different challenges than schools where some of the kindergarteners come better prepared. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I know all about the drop out rates. But if we don't expect all kids to excel how can we expect them to stay in school? In my eyes this is the same as telling these kids that they are not smart enough and then to add those articles we're further telling them that we have no faith in them. It's just wrong and I still don't believe we should keep them separate. 

sarahandgarett --- 19 years ago -

As a former teacher, I am going to try to explain the reasoning behind this as best I can. Each school is judged on how well their students do. If a school does poorly on the TAKS test a few years in a row, the school can get into major trouble from the state. Many teachers and schools complained because it is not fair for a school from inner city Houston to be compared to a school from let's say West U. It just isn't. If you pick a school from inner city Houston, where most of the people are economically disadvantaged, these kids have other things on their minds than the kids who come from great families. They just do. These kids could be worrying about about things like if they will have food for dinner, if they are safe at home, etc. These things do effect test scores. So, to help balance things out, the scores are divided. Does this make sense? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Blacks and hispanics have been made "slaves" to the government "dole" for many years. They now depend upon the government for their welfare and that is exactly how the Democrats like it. The less educated typically vote Democrat, so the Democrats have no incentive to raise expectations upon the blacks and hispanics. In fact, the effort is made in the opposite direction. It is amazing how other minorities, such as asians, who are also economically disadvantaged, can succeed when the blacks and hispanics cannot. For the most part, the asians are given no special help. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

This one is especially important because children who fall into the economically disadvantaged category don't have the same opportunities (like preschool They do though... Most areas that have high numbers of economically disadvantaged children have free Pre-K in the public school system. So that doesn't work. But to say the parents aren't educated enough may have a small degree of truth. But not everyone who is poor is low in intelligence. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

This one is especially important because children who fall into the economically disadvantaged category don't have the same opportunities (like preschool and educated parents) The asian kids do not have that either. Could it be they have a higher success rate because they learn respect and responsibility when they are young and therefore a more stable family unit? 

WashingtonYankee --- 19 years ago -

The less educated typically vote Democrat, so the Democrats have no incentive to raise expectations upon the blacks and hispanics. Ahhh yes, it must be the evil Democrats, not greedy Repubs that want a low wage serving class. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Does this make sense? To a point. I see the reasoning a little. But I just know that I would be outraged if someone expected less of my child because we weren't considered middle class or not poor or not of a minority. In my opinion they are short changing these children that do stay in school. And it's just not right. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

The asian kids do not have that either. Could it be they have a higher success rate because they learn respect and responsibility when they are young and therefore a more stable family unit? (hand goes up) YES! 

WashingtonYankee --- 19 years ago -

The asian kids do not have that either. Could it be they have a higher success rate because they learn respect and responsibility when they are young and therefore a more stable family unit? I believe you are correct on this. It has been my impression that these families exert a tighter family bond and higher expectations for all members within that unit. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

Agreed TY! 

WashingtonYankee --- 19 years ago -

The unfortunate truth is that if we lower standards for an economically disadvantaged group, we are effectively setting them back even further. Once they have to live by their performance in the workplace, they have been set up to fail compared to their new peer group. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Asian kids do have a tighter bond and are typically quieter than most other children... But come on... I'm mad here. Explain to me how this is right to do to these children who do stay in school? By saying that half of minorities drop out and then you have to lower the standard for those drop outs makes no sense to me. Because you are telling these kids that they are of lesser value than white kids. Oh, and my hubby is 3/4 native American so that still doesn't work for me. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

The unfortunate truth is that if we lower standards for an economically disadvantaged group, we are effectively setting them back even further. Once they have to live by their performance in the workplace, they have been set up to fail compared to their new peer group. Thank You!!!!!!! This is what I'm saying. 

WashingtonYankee --- 19 years ago -

Once they have to live by their performance in the workplace, they have been set up to fail compared to their new peer group. It has also been my ugly personal observation that those who far exceed the norm despite this are then viewed by some as entitlement recipients rathter than the high performers that they are. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Ahhh yes, it must be the evil Democrats, not greedy Repubs that want a low wage serving class. Republicans want people to succeed. Democrats want people with drive and ambition to have everyting taken from them to LOWER those people to the level of the slackers. 

sarahandgarett --- 19 years ago -

The unfortunate truth is that if we lower standards for an economically disadvantaged group, we are effectively setting them back even further. Or they could be told that they have to perform the same as someone who comes from an upperclass home, with two educated parents who have read to them every day of their lives and who are given every opportunity in the world. If a child feels like they cannot live up to someone's standards over and over, they will eventually give up. Why teach them to fail early on? Why not understand that they come from a different background, take that into account and work from there? We still expect a lot from them and still expect them to succeed, but we want to nuture them and teach them that they can overcome hardships. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Why teach them to fail early on? I don't see it that way. I see it as teaching them to strive to do better. Accepting that we all come from different backgrounds is great. Not expecting children to succeed just because they are poor is something entirely different. And no one has yet to explain how Hispanics fit into this category.. How are they rated lower? Actually the lowest of all at my school. Being Hispanic does not equal poor. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Or they could be told that they have to perform the same as someone who comes from an upperclass home, with two educated parents who have read to them every day of their lives and who are given every opportunity in the world. If a child feels like they cannot live up to someone's standards over and over, they will eventually give up. Why teach them to fail early on? There are MANY success stories of kids who succeed even though their parents were not well educated. Almost ALL kids could do that IF they would try, and even if their parents are not educated, they could instill work ethics into their kids. Not ALL white kids come from an upper class home, in fact, hardly any do. I sure did not. Hard work OVERCOMES hardships. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Republicans want people to succeed. Democrats want people with drive and ambition to have everyting taken from them to LOWER those people to the level of the slackers. And bb, don't start the liberal vs. conservative crap with me. LOL You know I'm a liberal but I believe strongly in teaching others to succeed. I've been told that I have republican views. But no, I have American views. 

WashingtonYankee --- 19 years ago -

Why not understand that they come from a different background, take that into account and work from there? We still expect a lot from them and still expect them to succeed, but we want to nuture them and teach them that they can overcome hardships. I think there is a vital difference between lowering standards and providing extra assistance. I think if we maintain the standards yet provide targeted assistance to families and students, both can be achieved, provided that the parents are willing to focus their children's efforts. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The facts are the facts lilmommy! 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

The facts are the facts lilmommy! Oh shut up!! LOL I think there is a vital difference between lowering standards and providing extra assistance. I think if we maintain the standards yet provide targeted assistance to families and students, both can be achieved, provided that the parents are willing to focus their children's efforts. Again I agree. If they need extra help then give it. That's nurturing their minds so that they do not have to face the same hardships as their parents do. Teaching them how to break the cycle of poverty. But no, we won't do that. Instead we expect less of them. It's just a crying shame. 

sarahandgarett --- 19 years ago -

I never said that all white kids come from those type of homes. I was using that as an example. I agree that hard word overcomes hardships, but you cannot tell a little third grader whose mother abuses drugs and has a different boyfriend every month that. As for the hispanic side of it, many of these children have parents who do not speak English. Once again, you have to give these kids time to catch up to the kids that have been read to every day of their life! I taught a complete ESL class for a year before I moved into a mainstream class. A child must take the TAKS test once they have been in the country for 2 years. There is no way that a child who did not speak a lick of English 2 years ago can be expected to do as well as a child who was born here. I don't think that y'all are looking at this from a child's perspective or an educator's perspective. We are not expecting these children to fail. We are giving them room to grow and NOT letting them fail! We work our buts off to make sure they succeed and give them EVERY SINGLE opportunity that the other kids get. 

sarahandgarett --- 19 years ago -

provided that the parents are willing to focus their children's efforts. That's the thing! Many parents are not willing to do this. What do you do then? If they need extra help then give it. That's nurturing their minds so that they do not have to face the same hardships as their parents do. Teaching them how to break the cycle of poverty. But no, we won't do that. Instead we expect less of them. It's just a crying shame. Are you willing to pay for that? As it is, many teachers spend UNPAID time helping these children after and before school. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I agree that hard word overcomes hardships, but you cannot tell a little third grader whose mother abuses drugs and has a different boyfriend every month that. Why not? In your way of thinking, you should not expect the middle class white kid to do as well as the upper class white kid either. There is no way that a child who did not speak a lick of English 2 years ago can be expected to do as well as a child who was born here. The asian kids learn English. No bilingual for them. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Are you willing to pay for that? Yep. I sure am. Get rid of welfare and then pay teachers more money. Make sure school systems have more resources and more staff. Yep. All for it. Please make no mistake about it, I respect teachers and think they are one of the most important, under appreciated worker in America. I have never griped when my school taxes have went up. Well when they go up to build new schools and just tear down old ones I do tend to gripe. But I would never gripe about teachers earning more money. I think they should get it. 

sarahandgarett --- 19 years ago -

Bbjones, my ESL class mostly contained Asian children. That was my favorite class of all time. They did work hard, their parents did not speak English, yet still they took some time to catch up to the English speaking children. That is to be expected. I expected all of my children to do well, not matter what class they were. I did take into account, though, other things that were going on in their lives. Since you are questioning why you can't tell a third grader who comes from a drug abuse home to buck up, work hard, and every thing will be fine, I'm taking it that you are not a teacher or have ever worked with these type of children. They need LOVE, and not the tough kind. They will work hard when they are shown that they will succeed. But, we have to show them that they can succeed first. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Going to bed. But just gotta say that I believe we are still short changing these children. It's just wrong. 

Going off air --- 19 years ago -

You have what it takes! Figure it out for yourself my lad. You’ve all that the greatest in life have had! Two arms, two hands, two legs, and two eyes: And a brain to use if you would be wise. With this equipment they all began, So start from the top and say, I can! Look them over the wise and the great They take their food from a common plate. And similar knives and forks they use With similar laces they tie their shoes The World considers them wise and smart, But you’ve all they had when they made their start. You can triumph and come to skill; You can be great if you only will. You’re well equipped for which fight you choose, You have arms and legs and a brain to use. And the man, who has risen great deeds to do, Began his life with no more than you. You are the handicap you must face; You are the one who must choose your place. You must say where you want to go, How much you will study the Truth to know. God has equipped you for life, but he, Lets you decide what you want to be. Courage must come from the soul within; The man must furnish the will to win. So figure it out for yourself my lad, You were born with all that the great have had. With your equipment they all began, Get hold of yourself and say, I Can! It’s true we can do all things through Christ! 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

We lived for many years in Splendora and I never noticed the discrepancy with regards to lower test scores for Hispanics. As a matter of fact, I recall distinctly that when my siblings were in school, my parents would get those scores and point out that the Hispanic scores were actually higher than the "white" scores. That being said...I'm not crazy about the TAKS test as being a measure of how well the kids are doing. As for ESL...I don't believe it is necessary either. I started kindergarten without speaking any English. There wasn't ESL at that time. I was just placed in the regular class and by the time I was finished, I spoke well if not better than some of my peers. To this day people are surprised to know that English wasn't my first language. My dad (who did speak English) and my mother who did not stressed the importance of speaking English and learning how to write and express ourselves. Dad would say that if we do this well, we would be successful at whatever we did. Unfortunately, Hispanics of today don't seem as anxious to assimilate fully into American culture and life. It's easy when many concessions are made for them (i.e., signs translated into Spanish). I understand older Hispanics who are perhaps settled in their ways and I don't have a problem with them needing things translated, etc. But when Hispanics that have been born in the U.S. still continue to pine for their supposedly homeland....and want their actual birthplace to become said homeland...then I have a problem. 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

You would be surprised at how many Asian kids languish in the system. If their parents do not speak the language these kids face the same challenges that the hispanic kids (whose parents do not speak English do). I sat in a forum where there was a level of alarm amongst the asians as there aren't enough people in the education system that can even communicate with all of the many different asian languages. Some Asians immigrate to the US, land in an area full of those who speak their language and rarely come out. I am the daughter of an immigrant and the greatest favor my dad did me is to learn our language before coming to the US to study. This is a highly sensitive subject to say the least and there is much more to take into consideration that we can even imagine. Praise God for the women and men who choose to teach! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground